SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Where does it say gates of hell not prevailing equals an infallilbe church? Where does it say that church means some separate entity apart from Christians for that is what it seems you insinuate? I can’t help but see you setting up what you deem to be the church as some kind of deity. No offense. Do you know that the church is people?
HELLO! Read Jurgans Faith of the Fathers. Know a little about the History of the Early Church. Before the 1500’s, to be a Christian or to be part of the Church was to be Catholic. The Church is people in one form of the meaning. But it is also a visible body that was instituted by Christ in which he gave the Keys to Peter.
 
Sorry, I can’t see it that way. The gates of hell not prevailing against the church means Satan cannot totally destroy the church, not that the church has infallibilty. Any part of the church (the church being Christians) could fall into error. If that weren’t so, why all the warnings to Christians (the church) in Scripture about false christs and false teachings? Paul was even having to correct errors in some of his letters to the various churches.

Acts 20
29 For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.
**30 Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. **
31 Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears.

I agree to disagree. 🙂

I’m merely pointing out the impression that Catholics can give and the impression that I’ve gotten from listening to them over a period of several years since I’ve been online.

I’m happy you got to use your emoticons.
If the HS is guiding His Church into All Truth, common sense screams infallibility. Let’s at least be honest here.
 
Sorry, I can’t see it that way. The gates of hell not prevailing against the church means Satan cannot totally destroy the church, not that the church has infallibilty. Any part of the church (the church being Christians) could fall into error. If that weren’t so, why all the warnings to Christians (the church) in Scripture about false christs and false teachings? Paul was even having to correct errors in some of his letters to the various churches.

Acts 20
29 For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.
**30 **Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. ****
31 Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears.

I agree to disagree. 🙂

I’m merely pointing out the impression that Catholics can give and the impression that I’ve gotten from listening to them over a period of several years since I’ve been online.

I’m happy you got to use your emoticons.
Yes, those men teaching perversely were Luther and Calvin.
 
So I should rely on someone else’s personal feelings about Scripture? Where does that leave me if they’re wrong? To my own Master I will stand or fall. If I’m going to be mistaken about something, I’d rather it be my mistaken than follow someone else’s.
Actually, the Bible is very clear when it says that personal interpretation is Wrong! We aren’t using our personal interpretations here WG. We are simply in accordance with the interpretation of the Magisterium of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church.
 
Actually, the Bible is very clear when it says that personal interpretation is Wrong! We aren’t using our personal interpretations here WG. We are simply in accordance with the interpretation of the Magisterium of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church.
Once again the Scripture you are referring to is being misinterpreted:

2 Peter 1:
We ourselves heard this voice come from heaven while we were with him on the holy mountain.
Moreover, we possess the prophetic message that is altogether reliable. You will do well to be attentive to it, as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts.
Know this first of all, that there is no prophecy of scripture that is a matter of personal interpretation,
for no prophecy ever came through human will
; but rather human beings moved by the holy Spirit spoke under the influence of God/B].

These verses state the the Scripture, given to us by the prophets and written down in what we call the Holy Bible, is the Word of God and not opinions of men.

Catholics interpret it ti fit their man-made doctrines.

Now my family has started to arrive for Christmas I will not have time to chat in CAF - at least not for awhile.

May you all have a Merry Christmas and a prosperous New Year!
 
Actually, the Bible is very clear when it says that personal interpretation is Wrong! We aren’t using our personal interpretations here WG. We are simply in accordance with the interpretation of the Magisterium of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church.
What Ginger says is true. That Scripture is about the validity of the Scriptures themselves and you misuse it to try and prove your doctrinre. In a way, you are using personal interpretation. You are using your personal interpetaton of things to choose to believe the things you do concerning Catholicism.
 
Catholic doctrine is infallible, made so by the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
We’re going to have do continue to disagree on that. We believe much of that doctrine contradicts the written word and anything that contradicts that can’t be infallible. Where did the idea come from that one has to be infallilbe to know or teach the truth? If that were true, then no one could not the truth.
 
Once again the Scripture you are referring to is being misinterpreted:

2 Peter 1:
We ourselves heard this voice come from heaven while we were with him on the holy mountain.
Moreover, we possess the prophetic message that is altogether reliable. You will do well to be attentive to it, as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts.
Know this first of all, that there is no prophecy of scripture that is a matter of personal interpretation,
for no prophecy ever came through human will
; but rather human beings moved by the holy Spirit spoke under the influence of God/B].

These verses state the the Scripture, given to us by the prophets and written down in what we call the Holy Bible, is the Word of God and not opinions of men.

Catholics interpret it ti fit their man-made doctrines.

Now my family has started to arrive for Christmas I will not have time to chat in CAF - at least not for awhile.

May you all have a Merry Christmas and a prosperous New Year!

Thanks for pointing that out, Ginger. 🙂
 
HELLO! Read Jurgans Faith of the Fathers. Know a little about the History of the Early Church. Before the 1500’s, to be a Christian or to be part of the Church was to be Catholic. The Church is people in one form of the meaning. But it is also a visible body that was instituted by Christ in which he gave the Keys to Peter.
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is. I do not believe the church was ever like the RCC of today. The term catholic means universal and Christ’s church is universal in that sense. Borrowing the term and turning it into an official church tital doesn’t make any one group alone Christ’s church for the Bible reveals His church to be believers.
I’m sorry WG, but that is just intellectual dishonesty. Clearly your view of the Church is flawed. Christ instituted a visible, authoritative Church so that when he could no longer physically be here with us, we would have a physical connection with him here on Earth. Matt 18 clearly describes the authoritative Church.
Obviously, I don’t believe my view to be flawed when the Bible reveals Christians to be the church. The Bible doesn’t say we will have a physical connection to Christ after His return to heaven. He’s there preparing a place for His bride aka Christians. He is with each and every Christian via the indwelling Holy Spirit.
 
We’re going to have do continue to disagree on that. We believe much of that doctrine contradicts the written word and anything that contradicts that can’t be infallible…
Here is a concept you should remember: When you say “much of that doctrine contradicts the written word”, what you are actually saying is that much of the doctrine contradicts your interpretation the written word, which is a very different thing. Considering that protestantism is self-contradictory by nature, with all its competing denominations and their contradictory teachings, I doubt that you are in a position to have the final say on what the Bible actually teaches.
 
Windgirl,
Refer back to your post 188. You agree with Ginger that the Holy Spirit can use men to interpret prophecy, yet you feel that He cannot likewise use men to forgive sins.

So, we also disagree on who these “men” are. We believe they are our priests, bishops, etc. who can trace their lineage, to a person, to the apostles. You believe it’s, well, you, and Ginger, and Billy Graham, I suppose.

Now let me ask you this. I don’t know if you know Ginger personally, but is there any chance that your interpretation is in any way different from hers on any matter of Scripture? So let me ask you this question:

If the Holy Spirit is guiding both of you in your interpretation of Scripture, how could your interpretations be in the slightest bit different from each other? The Holy Spirit cannot teach error, so one of you is not in fact guided by the Holy Spirit. One of you has been overlooked by God, I guess. There is no other explanation.

We know from Church history that as soon as the Church was founded by Christ, there began to be heresy. Slightly different or sometimes major different beliefs.
Every one of these heresies, and the ones that followed, continued to change it’s position of faith and morals. Your church, too, has changed it’s position on faith and morals, I can pretty much guarantee that.

I will say it again, there is one Church that has not changed. This is the Church that Christ founded.

Does it really make sense that God would start a Church, and knowing there would be heresy and false teaching, leave it to founder on it’s own, unguided?

Does it really make sense that He would trust the interpretation of his word to you and Ginger, or me or Broski? Doesn’t make sense to me.

Instead, if we just read Scripture we see that He left us a Church just as he promised. He has protected it against the gates of Hell, and the Holy Spirit guides it unto all truth.

So who is right? That Church’s interpretation, or yours? Or Ginger’s?

I also note a bit of “I don’t have time for this”, or “I’ll be around, but I don’t have time to answer much”. I’ve seen this before on this board. You are both facing some tough questions that you have never considered before, and you don’t have answers for. That’s a good thing. It’s something you need to work out. If you can answer these questions (and I mean honestly, to yourself) and you are still happy where you are, it will make you a stronger Christian. But, I believe if you keep searching our Church’s teaching (not Jack Chick’s opinion of our Church’s teaching), you may be in for a big surprise…
Or, you can do as others do, simply dismiss us without much thought.
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is.
Actually, your use of the word infallible in incorrect here. Infallible means unable to teach error in matters of faith and morals. The Bible does not teach. *People *teach. I think you mean to say the Bible is the inspired, inerrant Word of God. How do you know the Bible is the inspired, inerrant Word of God?
I do not believe the church was ever like the RCC of today.
I think you mean to say you do not *want *to believe the Church was ever like to RCC of today. What Church do you think it was like? The Baptist church? The Methodist church? The Lutheran Church? The Anglican church? The Presbyterian church? The Pentecostal church? The non-denominational church, etc., etc., etc., etc., …
The term catholic means universal and Christ’s church is universal in that sense.
Just what the Catholic Church teaches.
Borrowing the term…
From whom? St. Ignatius of Antioch? He was a Catholic!
and turning it into an official church tital doesn’t make any one group alone Christ’s church for the Bible reveals His church to be believers.
Again, it’s a both/and situation. It is true that we are all members of the body of Christ and we share in the hope that awaits us all, and in that sense we all belong to the universal body of believers. We also have to work towards unity as our Lord commanded.
Obviously, I don’t believe my view to be flawed when the Bible reveals Christians to be the church. The Bible doesn’t say we will have a physical connection to Christ after His return to heaven. He’s there preparing a place for His bride aka Christians. He is with each and every Christian via the indwelling Holy Spirit.
Of course you don’t believe your view is flawed. You are self-appointed Pope and Magisterium. I believe someone else in this thread already pointed this out.
Jesus said his Church would be “the light of the world.” He then noted that “a city set on a hill cannot be hid” (Matt. 5:14). This means his Church is a visible organization. It must have characteristics that clearly identify it and that distinguish it from other churches. Jesus promised, “I will build my Church and the gates of hell will not prevail against it” (Matt. 16:18). This means that his Church will never be destroyed and will never fall away from him. His Church will survive until his return.
Jesus established only one Church, not a collection of differing churches (Lutheran, Baptist, Anglican, and so on). The Bible says the Church is the bride of Christ (Eph. 5:23–32). Jesus can have but one spouse, and his spouse is the Catholic Church.
catholic.com/library/Pillar.asp
 
What Ginger says is true. That Scripture is about the validity of the Scriptures themselves and you misuse it to try and prove your doctrinre. In a way, you are using personal interpretation. You are using your personal interpetaton of things to choose to believe the things you do concerning Catholicism.
Well, why don’t we do a little research to see what the early church fathers believed about this verse. If you do, you will find it is in perfect agreement with the Catholic Church teaching. It is you who is making that fit your personal views. As a matter of fact, no one believed your views until the reformation. If the HS is guiding His Church into all truth, are you calling the HS a liar for 1500 yrs? Where were the protestants for the first 1500 yrs?
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is. I do not believe the church was ever like the RCC of today. The term catholic means universal and Christ’s church is universal in that sense. Borrowing the term and turning it into an official church tital doesn’t make any one group alone Christ’s church for the Bible reveals His church to be believers.

Obviously, I don’t believe my view to be flawed when the Bible reveals Christians to be the church. The Bible doesn’t say we will have a physical connection to Christ after His return to heaven. He’s there preparing a place for His bride aka Christians. He is with each and every Christian via the indwelling Holy Spirit.
Which Church is the universal (One and United) church then? The RCC is the same doctrinally today as it was then. If you don’t believe me, then I suggest you educate yourself by reading the early church fathers and the didache. Find out! The last chapter of John (the last two verses) tell you that not everything that Jesus taught is in the Bible. Remember, the bible is an expression of the tradition of the Church. The Church didn’t come out of the Bible. You still haven’t answered my question. If the HS is with you and it’s with me, why do we have conflicting views on the Church as well as other views?
 
WindGirls interpretation of John 20:23 -:

"Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained, but once you die, these powers are gone, and then the people can go back to confessing directly to God through me, because as soon as you my beloved Apostles die, that immediately makes space for direct access between me and the “elect.”

am i on the right track so far? 😉
 
WindGirls interpretation of John 20:23 -:

"Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained, but once you die, these powers are gone, and then the people can go back to confessing directly to God through me, because as soon as you my beloved Apostles die, that immediately makes space for direct access between me and the “elect.”

am i on the right track so far? 😉
Her anticipated response to this intrigues me.
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is.
This really is the crux of the matter.

While it’s impossible to prove that the Bible is inspired by God and therefore without error, could you convince an agnostic or atheist, of this beyond a reasonable doubt? How would you argue that?

The only good argument for the Bible that I’ve ever heard relies on the authority of the Church. I’d be interested in how you’d address that.
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is. I do not believe the church was ever like the RCC of today. The term catholic means universal and Christ’s church is universal in that sense. Borrowing the term and turning it into an official church tital doesn’t make any one group alone Christ’s church for the Bible reveals His church to be believers.

Obviously, I don’t believe my view to be flawed when the Bible reveals Christians to be the church. The Bible doesn’t say we will have a physical connection to Christ after His return to heaven. He’s there preparing a place for His bride aka Christians. He is with each and every Christian via the indwelling Holy Spirit.
An infallible book without an infallible interpreter is worse than useless.It is harmful-witness the thousands of protestant denominations who argue that ONLY their particular interpretation is correct.Each person becomes their own magisterium which does NOT point to Truth.Protestant tradition indicates that the Holy Spirit guarantees each reader easy and FAULTLESS interpretation.The sheer number of protestant denominations and their varying interpretations disproves the point.My interpretation of this infallible history book probably differs wildly from yours but thank God I have access to an Infallible Teaching Authority the Holy Catholic Church whom Christ has entrusted to the Advocate and guarantees freedom from error.I have the Body of Christ and we as Catholics have had it for 2000 years.Whether you believe the Catholic Church is not the orignal Church founded by Christ is completely irrelevant as it is mere opinion but it behooves you to reexamine this “feeling” of yours as it has implications for your eternal soul.Please read the early Church Fathers and you will indeed see how Catholic it was and is.Church Liturgies and customs have evolved but it is the same Church with the same Traditions and beliefs which were in existance for 300 years before this self-same Church produced and compiled Holy Scripture,The Bible.Please don’t wager your soul on “feelings”.I am not judging you or your salvation but please consider the Fullness of Truth rather than part of the truth,some error and your “feelings”,as your soul MAY be in the balance.Peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top