SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
WatchfulPilgrim made an insightful statement when he/she quoted
Galatians 1:8:

"But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.

Paul’s statement here definitely seems to dispel the idea that he is part of an infallible magisterium. If even Paul is capable of preaching “another gospel” in stands to reason that a lineage within a church organization is not a guarantee of infallibility" end quote.
 
WatchfulPilgrim made an insightful statement when he/she quoted
Galatians 1:8:

"But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.

Paul’s statement here definitely seems to dispel the idea that he is part of an infallible magisterium. If even Paul is capable of preaching “another gospel” in stands to reason that a lineage within a church organization is not a guarantee of infallibility" end quote.
Wrong again.

The members of the magisterium are not individually infallible. The magisterium is infallible even though its members individually are not.

Only the pope has the charism of individual infallibility, and even he is constrained by certain conditions that must be met.

The passage “proves” nothing; or rather, it does not prove what you want it to prove.
 
Wrong again.
Interesting you continue to ignore posts #205 & #239 🤷
The word used in 2 Peter 1:20 is “epilysis”.

It can refer to “an imaginary or fanciful interpretation”

On the other hand, “diermēneuō” means:
  1. to unfold the meaning of what is said, explain, expound
“hermēneuō” means:
  1. to explain in words, expound
    a. to explain; interpret.
  2. to interpret
    a) to translate what has been spoken or written in a foreign tongue into the using plain, everyday, ordinary language.
Are you suggesting the Apostles, under the inspiration of God, wrote an obscure, vague and uncertain passage to ensure Christians received a clear and correct interpretation of the Scriptures?
 
Interesting you continue to ignore posts #205 & #239 🤷
Ginger, you start off by telling us what the word epilysis can refer to and then you define 2 other words. Can you please tell me what these 3 words are in english? Are they all in the passage?

Thanks
 
I’m assuming epilysis is “interpretation”? What are the other 2 words you cited please, from 2 Peter 1:20?

Thanks
 
WatchfulPilgrim made an insightful statement when he/she quoted
Galatians 1:8:

"But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.

Paul’s statement here definitely seems to dispel the idea that he is part of an infallible magisterium. If even Paul is capable of preaching “another gospel” in stands to reason that a lineage within a church organization is not a guarantee of infallibility" end quote.
Actually that quote proves quite the opposite from what you claim. WatchfulPilgrim seems to have more of an open mind so perhaps he will see where you made this error. Paying close attention to the 2 WE’s, Lets looks at the 2 sentences again paraphrasing in a dialogue:

Me: St. Paul what did you just say?
St. Paul: " *If we, or an angel from heaven, preach a gospel *"
Me: Preach what kind of gospel?
St. Paul: Preach a gospel that’s differerent from the one **we **have preached to you.

Notice, St. Paul didn’t say, “If we preach a different gospel, than the one in the ‘Bible’”

Me: But how can **you **preach a different gospel that the one **you **have preached? Doesn’t that sound counter-intuitive?
St. Paul: Well i will repeat myself yet again, “As we said before, so now I say again: If any one preach to you a gospel, besides that which you have received, let him be anathema.”

Does this not point to an oral preaching? And how does oral teaching get transmitted? All that St. Paul preached to the Galatians, are not in that one letter to them. This letter shows he had preached to them previously with his own mouth, and he sent this letter out because some where “perverting the gospels”
 
Interesting you continue to ignore posts #205 & #239 🤷
Ginger-

I’m not ignoring them; I don’t have time to do them justice. It’s Christmas Day, and in an couple of hours, I’m loading the family into the van and driving four hours to spend several days with family.

So, no, I don’t have time to drag out my Strong’s and my Greek dictionaries, etc.

However, I also don’t hang my hat on exclusively on 2 Peter 1:20-21. There are ample scritptures to suggest that the promise of the Holy Spirit (with regard to leading into all truth) was to the Church and not to individual believers.

You and your co-religionist, WindGirl, have ignored my repeated questions about why Protestants who claim to be led by the one Spirit have come to contradictory conclusions about baptismal regeneration, infant baptism, the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist, etc.

My position is that Jesus promised the Spirit to the Church, and this never meant that each one of us would be lead individually into all truth. However, if you have the guidance of the Spirit as you appear to claim, then would it be fair to say that you consider yourself infallible in your interpretation of scripture? If not, could you please tell us what authority you would accept correction from (other than God, of course)?

FWIW, I did print out and read the article which attempted to offer explanations as to why Christians have so many different interpretations of scripture. To summarize, the excuses…er, reasons, offered are:
  1. Unbelief
  2. Lack of training
  3. Poor hermeneutics
  4. Ignorance of the whole word of God
  5. Selfishness and pride
  6. Failure to mature
  7. Undue emphasis on tradition
The author then spends time defending the unbiblical concept of “the essentials”. However, the weakness of these arguments, IMO, is that they are all failures of individual believers, and the author uses the word “individual” over and over in his explanations of each of these seven failures.

Exactly!

It is the individual who fails to interpret scripture properly. The Holy Spirit was not to promised to lead each individual into perfect understanding of the Word of God. Your misinterpretation of this promise is evidence of this fact.

However, it must also be painfully obvious to those who try to keep track of the thousands of Protestant denominations that have literally sprung up over the past few centuries, that the Holy Spirit is NOT actively leading these diverse groups toward any meaningful unity.

The reason for this is also obvious. The Holy Spirit was promised to the one Church that Jesus established: the Catholic Church.

The fullness of the Church of Christl subsists in the Catholic Church alone.

CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH
RESPONSES TO SOME QUESTIONS REGARDING CERTAIN ASPECTS
OF THE DOCTRINE ON THE CHURCH


The use of this expression, which indicates the full identity of the Church of Christ with the Catholic Church, does not change the doctrine on the Church. Rather, it comes from and brings out more clearly the fact that there are “numerous elements of sanctification and of truth” which are found outside her structure, but which “as gifts properly belonging to the Church of Christ, impel towards Catholic Unity”.[11]

“It follows that these separated churches and Communities, though we believe they suffer from defects, are deprived neither of significance nor importance in the mystery of salvation. In fact the Spirit of Christ has not refrained from using them as instruments of salvation, whose value derives from that fullness of grace and of truth which has been entrusted to the Catholic Church”[12].
 
To sum up:

As I stated above, it is understandable that individual Christians fail to agree on their respective interpretations of scripture since Jesus made no promise that the Holy Spirit would guide us into all truth individually.

But how is it that whole denominations have failed to come to consensus with one another regarding basic Christian doctrines after working on them for nearly 500 years?

Could it be that our Lord never promised these separated “ecclesial communities” the same protection that He promised to His own Church?

And is it not also evident that the unity, coherence and consistency of the Catholic Church’s doctrine for nearly 2,000 years could only be maintained by God’s own action and not the efforts of man?
 
The church is all Christians, not just an elite few.
No one has said it was not, however, to think that the Church is only the collection of Christians is also a deficient view of the Church.
No, it’s not a recent invention that I can confess my sins directly to God. 1 John 1: 9. The veil in the temple guarding the holy of holies has been rent from top to bottom. I have direct access to God through Christ. I don’t see at all that I need any human “middle man” between me and God.
First of all, your failure to see what you need changes nothing. God provided that we should confess to those who had been authorized to forgive sins.

Second, the priest is not a “middle man”, but act in the person of Christ, who is our One Mediator between God and man. This is how Jesus set it up.
By the way, what gives you authority to decide which parts of Scripture are aimed at whom?
😃

Catholics read scripture from the point of view of those who wrote it, which is why we often understand what it says differently than those who are separated from the Apostolic Tradition.
I disagree that penance and repentance are the same thing. Repenence is to change your mind, be utterly sorry you’re doing something, and turn around in and go the other direction. Penance is trying to appease God for your sin when Jesus Christ has already done that.
Well, we understand these words differently. Catholics see repentance as pennance. Jesus has already "appeased’ the justice of God’s penalty for our sins in His flesh. There is no “appeasement” that we could make that would have any benefit. We can join our sufferings to his, and make up what is lacking in His body. We can make reparation for our sins (amends for wrongs done).
Not everyone who has left the Catholic Church and believes that it’s wrong and tries to reach former Catholics has a vendetta toward the CC. Or was poor catechized. Or any other number of Catholic responses that I’ve heard already over and over. You’re not saying stuff that I haven’t heard before.
You are right. since coming to CAF, I have learned that a significant number of people leave because of what goes on below the waist, rather than in the head or heart. :eek:
God didn’t give Christians a church, we ARE His church.
Do you not see that both can be true? the Church is larger than the collection of believers. He meant for the Church to be the Ark through which He is carried to the world, and from which the world be carried to HIm.
Why do you speak constantly as if the church is some separate entity apart from Christians? What do you think Christians are anyway? We are the bride of Christ, the church. And after listening to Catholics for several years online,
Because the notion that the church is comprised only of Christians is a deficient view of the Churchc. We are members of her, but she is not comprised only of us. She also contains the saints who have gone on before us, the Church suffering, and the Church triumphant. The saints who are perfected and already in heaven are the ones who are OSAS, and have ceased from their labors. The Church has as her head Christ, and as her soul, the HS, which is why the Church is infallible. Only the fallible members attached to her that still sojourn on the earth are capable of error.
I come away with the impression that many of them believe that they can control and limit God. He has to agree with them or else.
I don’t understand this statement. Perhaps you can elaborate?
 
Yes, but the question remains what kind of power?
Jesus is quite specific. He was sent with the authority to forgive sins. He tells them “as the father has sent me, so I send you” - with the power to forgive sins.
Code:
Did they sit in little booths waiting to hear long lines of people's confessions?
Actually, no, private confession was a later development. In the beginning, penitents stood up in the assembly and confessed before everyone. :bigyikes:
Or did they go about preaching the gospel?
Public confession of sins often did accompany the preaching of the gospel. This was even practiced during the baptism of John.

Matt 3:4-6
5 Then the people of Jerusalem and all Judea were going out to him, and all the region along the Jordan, 6 and they were baptized by him in the river Jordan, confessing their sins.

The preaching of the gospel does provoke the sincere repentant person to confess:

Acts 19:17-19
18 Also many of those who became believers confessed and disclosed their practices. 19 A number of those who practiced magic collected their books and burned them publicly;

But the sacrament of reconciliation was reserved for the baptized who had commited post-baptismal sin.
Is the power what you say it is or is the power to preach the gospel and tell people if they beleive it their sins are forgiven and if they don’t, they aren’t.
Certainly Jesus authorized them to teach, preach, make disciples as well as forgive sins. The problem with people “believing that their sins are forgiven” is that they may not meet the criteria for such a believe, and if they are misguided, then they will die in their sins. This is why people need an objective authority outside themselves. Human beings are capable of an appalling degree of self-deceit. The Pharisees thought they were right before God, but they were not.
Even if it is the way you say, nothing I see says that that authority is granted to Catholic priests.
Respectfully, your inablity to “see” does not change the facts. 😉
Where does it say there are elite successors to be lords over the church.
Apparently somewhere in your imagination?
There were only twelve apostles and they’re gone.
Your statement seems to indicate that you reject the Apostolic succession. Once again, your refusal to believe this does not make it untrue. Many people did not believe in the existence of germs for a long time. That did not make them cease to exist.
I don’t need a human priest. I have a Priest. His name is Christ.
Indeed! Jesus is our great high priest. Those who are called into service to Him are taken up into His priesthood.
I’m forgiven and I’ve never been in a little booth with a Catholic priest. Nor will I ever by nor do I sense any need to be.
No, it is perfectly fine for you to confess in front of the whole congregation, should you so desire, or to speak to the priest in his office, or elsewhere. The booth is more comfortable for some, and it is an option.
 
Actually that quote proves quite the opposite from what you claim. WatchfulPilgrim seems to have more of an open mind so perhaps he will see where you made this error.
Take it up with WatchfulPilgrim, I was making comment that it was insightful.
 
Ginger, please read the thread “Self Gratification and Communion” on the Apologetics forum.
Set aside your disagreements with us on Scripture for a moment and really read the posts there. You will find some major benefits of the Sacrament of Reconciliation.
The young man there is struggling with sin.
He is ashamed to go to confession and admit this sin.
He decides to go, and you can tell from his posts how good he feels afterwards.
He finds the strength to fight this sin (and another).
How easy would it have been for this young man to simply pray to God and ask forgiveness in private? Very easy.
How hard is it to admit this sin to a person we believe is acting in the person of Christ? Very hard.
It is very hard and humbling to confess your sins aloud to another person. We are, in fact, actually humbling ourselves before God.
I think that’s one of the main reason that God instituted this Sacrament. He knows this is a humbling experience. He knows we are far less likely to re-offend after confession (trust me, I’m Catholic). He also knows it is one of the most liberating experiences we can have.
You may disagree with the basis and the mechanics, but I doubt you can disagree with the fruits.
 
Ginger-

I’m not ignoring them; I don’t have time to do them justice. It’s Christmas Day, and in an couple of hours, I’m loading the family into the van and driving four hours to spend several days with family.
And your excuse on December 23, was?
You and your co-religionist, WindGirl, have ignored my repeated questions about why Protestants who claim to be led by the one Spirit have come to contradictory conclusions about baptismal regeneration, infant baptism, the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist, etc.
I have answered that question many times!!!
This thread is split from another entitled “Protestants, can a Catholic priest forgive sins.”

POST #351
Cinette,

All Protestants have the same basic beliefs - anyone who deters from those fundamental beliefs that make us Christians, are Christian in name only.

These basic beliefs are also shared with Catholics, found in the Holy Scriptures and summarized in the Apostle’s Creed:

I believe in God, the Father Almighty, the Creator of heaven and earth, Gen 1:1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.
and in Jesus Christ, His only Son, our Lord: John 3:16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son,

Who was conceived of the Holy Spirit, Luk 1:35 And the angel answered and said unto her, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee: therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God.
born of the Virgin Mary, Luk 1:27 To a virgin espoused to a man whose name was Joseph, of the house of David; and the virgin’s name [was] Mary.
suffered under Pontius Pilate, Luke 23:16 I will therefore chastise him, and release [him].
was crucified, Luk 23:23 And they were instant with loud voices, requiring that he might be crucified. …24 And Pilate gave sentence that it should be as they required.
died, Luk 23:46 And when Jesus had cried with a loud voice, he said, Father, into thy hands I commend my spirit: and having said thus, he gave up the ghost.
and was buried. Luk 23:52 This [man] went unto Pilate, and begged the body of Jesus. 53 And he took it down, and wrapped it in linen, and laid it in a sepulchre that was hewn in stone, wherein never man before was laid.

He descended into hell. Psa 16:10 For thou wilt not leave my soul in hell; neither wilt thou suffer thine Holy One to see corruption.

etc.
 
My position is that Jesus promised the Spirit to the Church,
Mine too!!!
…and this never meant that each one of us would be lead individually into all truth.
The Church is made up of individual believers.

Acts 15:8 And God, who knows the heart, bore witness by granting them the holy Spirit just as he did us.

2 Corinthians 4:3 But if our gospel be hid, it is hid to them that are lost:

2 Timothy 3:16-17
All scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching, for refutation, for correction, and for training in righteousness, so that one who belongs to God may be competent, equipped for every good work.
Acts 17:11-12
…and examined the scriptures daily to determine whether these things were so. Many of them became believers, as did not a few of the influential Greek women and men.

1 Cor 2:14-15 The man without the Spirit of God does not accept the things that come from the Spirit, for they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned. We who have the Spirit of God understand these things, but others can’t understand. For who hath known the mind of the Lord, that he may instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.
 
FWIW, I did print out and read the article which attempted to offer explanations …
What article? :confused:

I never provided an article. I reason from the Scriptures, and when dialoging with Catholics, I refer mostly to Catholic sources.

I don’t hold scholars and preachers above other men.
…as to why Christians have so many different interpretations of scripture.
I’m beginning to feel like a broken record. Please See Post # 253 all believers share the same basic Christian doctrines. If not, they are Christian in name only.

Not everyone who claims to be Christian, is a Christian.

If I claim to be an vegetarian, does that make me an vegetarian? Or is it what I believe and what I eat and don’t eat that make me a vegetarian?

If I say I am I a vegetarian but I eat meat, am I a vegetarian?

If I say I am a Jew, but talk and behave like a Buddhist, am I a Jew?

If I say I am a Christian, but talk and behave like a humanist, am I a Christian?

Not everyone who claims the title Christian, is a Christian.

The Bible tells us there will be those among us who are not believers.

Mat 7:15 Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
 
Ginger, please read the thread “Self Gratification and Communion” on the Apologetics forum.
If I were you, I would notify the moderators and suggest locking the thread. It is a good place to end right where it is and I wouldn’t risk spoiling it with others coming in to argue.

Just my opinion.

But sometimes the basic points get lost in all the debate…
 
I agree it ended on a good note.
I wanted your opinion, though, as to whether or not you feel (based on that thread), that oral confession is at least in fact beneficial.
Windgirl may want to share her thoughts too.
As I said before, it’s just one of those “fullness of the faith” things that you don’t know how much you are missing.
It makes me feel all :extrahappy: after!
 
What article? :confused:

I never provided an article. I reason from the Scriptures, and when dialoging with Catholics, I refer mostly to Catholic sources.

I don’t hold scholars and preachers above other men.
If you have been following this thread closely, you would recall that WindGirl, you tag-team partner, tried to explain the glaring disunity among Protestants by means of an article.

I will provide one also:

Disunity on Essentials
By Jimmy Akin
catholic.com/thisrock/2003/0312bt.asp
I’m beginning to feel like a broken record. Please See Post # 253 all believers share the same basic Christian doctrines. If not, they are Christian in name only.
Could you please point me to the scripture which outlines the doctrines which are essential? Or would it be easier for you to tell me which verses I can ignore since they are NOT essential?

Or is the whole idea of “essentials” simply a smoke-screen to hide the fact that non-Catholics really have no doctrinal unity and that this is why the number of Protestant denominations now numbers well into the tens of thousands?

For example, could Martin Luther pastor your church, given his beliefs in things like baptismal regeneration, infant baptism, high predestination, and the Real Presence? The problem is much more general than Luther, however. Pastors from one Protestant tradition typically are not allowed to serve as pastors in Protestant churches of other traditions. A Lutheran’s belief in baptismal regeneration will prevent him from pastoring a Calvinist church, a Calvinist’s belief in high predestination will prevent him from pastoring a Methodist church, a Methodist’s belief in infant baptism will prevent him from pastoring a Baptist church, and so on.

Just two more questions (and I have asked them before in this thread without answer):
  1. Baptism…is it necessary for regeneration or not? Some Protestants who claim to be led by the Spirit say “yes” while others who also claim to be led by the same Spirit say “no”. What is your position and why do you think other Christians disagree with you?
  2. Infant baptism…is this correct or not? Some Protestants who claim to be led by the Spirit say “yes” while others who also claim to be led by the same Spirit say “no”. What is your position and why do you think other Christians disagree with you?
 
The Church is made up of individual believers.
Such a statement reflects a deficient view of the Church. Yes, individual believers are members of the One Body, but Jesus built His church upon Himself as the Head, and the Apostles as shepherds and teachers. It was only them to whom He gave the authority to cathect the sacraments.

He gave the task of equipping the saints to people, Ginger, not to the book. Yes, scripture is valuable for this task, but scripture does not accomplish it. Teaching requires a person, as does shepherding. Expecting a book to exercise discerment is a misunderstanding of it’s qualities, and God’s intentions.

Eph 4:10-14
11 The gifts he gave were that some would be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, some pastors and teachers, 12 to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, 13 until all of us come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to maturity, to the measure of the full stature of Christ.

Notice that these tasks belong to people. Scripture us USEFUL in accomplishing these tasks, but that is not the purpose of the Scripture.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top