SSPX fined unfairly

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maximian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Maximian

Guest
At the Church of St Nicholas du Chardonnet in Paris, one of SSPX’s most important chapels, they are not saying Mass open to the public. They are broadcasting it instead.

During Saturday night and the early hours of Easter Day, they were setting up the technology for the broadcast on Sunday morning when the police arrived. The neighbours had denounced them to the police for holding a secret midnight mass.

On being informed of the facts, the police decided to fine them anyway.

Now, whatever you think of SSPX, I m sure you will agree that it is not helpful, when a community is trying to do its best to make social distancing possible while continuing the sacrifice of the Mass, to get treated like this.
 
I am not sure why they weren’t all fined.The rest of the country is made to stay home and the French government has very strict laws about who can be out and for what purpose. @Anicette has a thread and has spoken of how serious things are there.
 
No, your article is quoting a mendacious article in Le Point which is a disgrace.
 
No, your article is quoting a mendacious article in Le Point which is a disgrace.
Unfortunately I can’t understand French so I google translated the Le Point article:
That night around midnight, the police officers from the “56” police station, responsible for the 5th and 6th districts of Paris, intervened at the Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet church where many worshipers attended an Easter mass. An office that was held clandestinely despite the Covid-19 epidemic and the strict confinement rules taken by the authorities.

They noted that the doors of the religious building were closed and that a mass was in progress. A devotee leaving, told them that about forty people were inside. The police contacted the priest who was fined for non-compliance with the confinement rules.



The police had been warned by local residents because of the music emanating from the place of worship. The church is known to be attended by the most traditionalist Catholics in Paris.
Could you tell me what is mendacious about it? Or perhaps something has been missed in translation, in which case I’d appreciate it if you could point it out.

 
thanks you @Irishmon for this information that I learned through this threat.

Saint Nicolas du Chardonneret is the main SSPX parish of France. the community occupied it illegally since they hunt the local ordinary decades ago… So you can understant that this question of liturgy is much more crucial and a battle field in France than in many others countries.

The community is not afraid of doing things that can be illegal.
I am not sure why they weren’t all fined.
According to the article of Le point, the participants weren’t all fined because they were all gone when the police came.

135 € is what we paid when one person is catch as not respected the confinement rules, such as going out without a written paper with a necessity reason. This priest had the same penalty, according to what I read.
No, your article is quoting a mendacious article in Le Point which is a disgrace.
The problem is that the FPPX didn’t hide the mass. They broascast it live on “youtube”. You can watch part of the video on this TV station, BFMTV. The priests were not respected the barriers gestures that we are all mandate to have such as 1 meter betweem each other. They also gave the communion on the tongue which is very risky.


I don’t know why you said that it is not true when the FPPX apparently don’t hide the fact.

All the press speak of this event. If you prefer a catholic source, rather than Le point, here from the catholic daily newspaper La Croix:


On the contrary we have a mass all sunday on public french TV. Since the confinement, only 4 priests and two technicians paticipated in it. They keep one meter of distance between everbody and took the communion without any contact with another.

For more context, for burials we cannot be more than 20 people, only close family. And it is nearly impossible to have religious funeral. I strongly suspect that funeral officers push hard for cremation for it being easier for them. I think it is much more difficult than missing one Easter mass.

for my threat on the confinement as a Frenchwoman, it is there:
40.png
Confinement diary. For pandemic prevention Family Life
April 10, Holy Friday Today no chemin de croix! Sadly! The baccalaureate has been suppressed. The students, for the first time, would be graduated only by the evaluations they made through the school year… At first the governement had great ambitions for the confinement time: to homeschool the millions of French students. Yet, it had quickly collapsed. The new goal is only keep a link between tecahers and the children, to intectually stimulate them and to maintain what had been already lear…
 
Last edited:
to ADD more source, LCI has a photo of the twit of the préfecture of police on the mass incident.

The article said also that another mass was celebrated illegaly in Isère in March with 13 faithfull people. The people were fined, but the priest was not.


That being said, I read in my local french newspaper that some evangelical american pastors are not ashamed to want or planned Easter services… I don’t know what finally happened, but seems that it is not only us…
 
Our SSPX planned underground Masses during our lockdown. I reported them to the police and am providing ongoing reports to them of the priest’s activities. I hope they get caught in the act soon. Placing the community at risk like that is cult behaviour.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top