St. Joseph at the Visitation

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ite_ad_Ioseph
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

Ite_ad_Ioseph

Guest
I saw a picture of the Visitation with the Blessed Virgin greeting Elizabeth. St. Zachary stood behind her in the doorway. St. Elizabeth was on the right of the picture, the BVM on the left. Behind the BVM, was St. Joseph, with his his hand to his heart bowing only a little, or something like that, it’s hard to remember.
This painting was intended to be a religious painting, and St. Joseph was represented nicely. But could he have gone to St. Zachary’s house with his holy wife? Is there any tradition for this?
Pax
 
But could he have gone to St. Zachary’s house with his holy wife?
It would have never occurred to me that Joseph would have let his young and pregnant bride travel alone to a faraway relative. What sort of man would do that??? Say it ain’t so, Joe!
 
I saw a picture of the Visitation with the Blessed Virgin greeting Elizabeth. St. Zachary stood behind her in the doorway. St. Elizabeth was on the right of the picture, the BVM on the left. Behind the BVM, was St. Joseph, with his his hand to his heart bowing only a little, or something like that, it’s hard to remember.
This painting was intended to be a religious painting, and St. Joseph was represented nicely. But could he have gone to St. Zachary’s house with his holy wife? Is there any tradition for this?
Pax
Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich says, in the Life of the Blessed Virgin Mary, that Joseph traveled with Mary on her trip to visit Elizabeth.
 
It would have never occurred to me that Joseph would have let his young and pregnant bride travel alone to a faraway relative. What sort of man would do that??? Say it ain’t so, Joe!
Joseph did not know she was pregnant, they were not living together, and there is no indication in any scripture or early writings that he accompanied here.

I doubt it. A teenage girl, less than one day pregnant, leaving with all haste might not have sent a message to her betrothed that she was going on a little trip to visit an aged relative.
 
There is no sociologically possible way that Mary as a young virginal Jewish woman would have even considered traveling unescorted much less dared to make the very dangerous trip across badlands alone. On the first hand it would have been socially improper. On the second hand thieves, marauders and miscreants of every sort frequented the roadways looking for victims of opportunity. She would have been singled out as vulnerable (but of course woe onto any man who would dare touch the Arc of The Most High even unknowingly!).

It is highly plausible that Mary was either escorted there by Joseph or by designated custodians & care-keepers. She/they may have possibly even joined up with a larger traveling caravan or traveling group for additional safety. My guess is that there were probably fairly routine intra-regional commerce caravans possibly with lightly armed escorts that the public could travel with.

James
 
Like so many of the events in scripture, the author was focusing our attention on the Event of the Visitation, the rest was not important to the message. It is kinda like a “Jack Webb” style of writting,“The Facts, Just the Facts”
 
Given the poor mute condition of one and the miraculously pregnant condition of the other, I suspect there were practically shuttles of their extended family and friends and acquaintances to go see Z and E. It wouldn’t have seemed strange even before that for Mary to announce that she thought she should go help her poor mute kinsman, or for her family to send her along to the hills with whatever groups from the area happened to be going that way.

So Mary probably traveled in a pack of folks going up to the hills, and they just dropped her off when they got to Elizabeth’s place. Joseph might or might not have also been part of that pack, although he had a business to run and would probably not have been able to drop everything as easily as Mary. (Not that it would have been easy for her.)
 
I saw a picture of the Visitation with the Blessed Virgin greeting Elizabeth. St. Zachary stood behind her in the doorway. St. Elizabeth was on the right of the picture, the BVM on the left. Behind the BVM, was St. Joseph, with his his hand to his heart bowing only a little, or something like that, it’s hard to remember.
This painting was intended to be a religious painting, and St. Joseph was represented nicely. But could he have gone to St. Zachary’s house with his holy wife? Is there any tradition for this?
Pax
It was probable that St. Joseph was with Mary. After all, they were already in the first stage of 1st-century Jewish marriage: the ‘bethrotal’, in which the marriage contracts were produced, even if Mary would have still lived with her parents for the meantime and would have to wait for a year before she and Joseph can live together.

With the betrothal, the couple are now legally “husband and wife”, even if the marriage is still not consummated, with the woman now considered as being the man’s authority instead of her father’s (a 1st-century Jewish betrothal is actually more similar to our concept of marriage: cancellation of the betrothal would be equivalent to a divorce).
 
She would have been singled out as vulnerable (but of course woe onto any man who would dare touch the Arc of The Most High even unknowingly!).
I think the Romans and Josephus would have noticed if suddenly the badlands were filled with the blasted corpses of bandits 😃
 
I think the Romans and Josephus would have noticed if suddenly the badlands were filled with the blasted corpses of bandits 😃
But, wouldn’t it be more in an Indiana-Jones style where the bandits’ faces would melt, explode and then immolated up to the heavens? 😛

…Ahem.
 
It was probable that St. Joseph was with Mary. After all, they were already in the first stage of 1st-century Jewish marriage: the ‘bethrotal’, in which the marriage contracts were produced, even if Mary would have still lived with her parents for the meantime and would have to wait for a year before she and Joseph can live together.
As I understand it, after the betrothal, Joseph was supposed to build or obtain a house and furnish it so that Mary could move in and they would set up housekeeping. As was stated before, Joe has a business to run and it would be unlikely he could leave it for 6 months to visit Liz.

Luke writes that she left in all haste. He probably would not have time to find someone to finish what he was working on and leave in all haste. It could be that there was a group leaving and Mary knew this so quickly packed and was gone before the angelic dust settled.

There is also that thing about J finding M pregnant. If he went with M do you think that is how he found out? By E’s greeting? If so, I don’t think he would be considering ‘quietly setting her aside’ since E had already made it public.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top