St. Therese's Teaching on Purgatory

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sirach2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sirach2

Guest
God has raised up St. Therese not only to teach us her little way, but also to help us know more fully God’s infinite love and mercy. In proclaiming her Doctor of the Church, the Church validates her beautiful teachings and gives us light and assurance that when we follow them, we are not in error. I share this excerpt from her teaching on Purgatory, but the entire article is very inspirational, without the need to read her entire book.

God is Father rather than Judge

Once St. Therese had a confrontation regarding this topic with Sr. Marie Febronia, who not only was sixty-seven years old but also was sub-prioress. She had heard that St. Therese encouraged the novices to believe that they could go straight to heaven. She did not like this as she considered this kind of confidence presumptuous, and thus she reproached St Therese. St Therese tried lovingly and calmly to explainto Sr. Febronia her point of view but with no success as Sr. Febronia clung to belief. For St. Therese God was more Father than Judge, and she took the liberty of finally responding, “My sister, if you look for the justice of God you will get it. The soul will receive from God exactly what she desires.”

The year had not passed when, in January 1892, Sr. M. Febronia together with other sisters fell prey to the flu and died. Three months later Sr. Therese had a dream which she related to her Mother Prioress and which was then documented: "O my Mother, my Sr. M Febronia came to me last night and asked that we should pray for her. She is in Purgatory, *surely *because she had trusted too little in the mercy of the good Lord. Through her imploring behavior and her profound looks, it seemed she wanted to say, You were right. I am now delivered up to the full justice of God but it is my fault. If I had listened to you I would not be here now.
 
Sometimes, I think, St. Therese is so familiar to us that we almost take her for granted. We scarcely realize the type of thinking that held sway over many in the Church in her day, captured so well by your quote. The inordinate fear of an avenging God (Jansenism), combined with a great distrust of all things mystical due to the lingering effects of the heretical battles of the previous centuries (Quietism) had a devestating effect. That God would seek souls in a loving, intimate and very personal type of union was viewed with great distrust, to say the least.

And then came St. Therese and her re-introduction of the God of Mercy, seemingly lost for the prior couple hundred years, and she swept all that away . . . almost overnight. 🙂 I think it’s hard for us to realize what a truly radical departure she was from the prevailing mindset of her day and age.

Dave 🙂
 
Gee, Dave, that was right from the Holy Spirit! Such inspiring thoughts! I think some of that fear-thinking prevails even today, and if we can be secretaries of her teachings, we may lift a lot of fear from the hearts of God’s children.

As so often happens, in the second reading today, God speaks to us again very timely. I include a couple verses that were omitted from the actual reading, for they point to that excessive fear. Hebrews 12:18-24
You have not approached that which could be touched and a blazing fire and gloomy darkness and storm and a trumpet blast and a voice speaking words such that those who heard begged that no message be further addressed to them, for they could not bear to hear the command: “If even an animal touches the mountain, it shall be stoned.”
Indeed, so fearful was the spectacle that Moses said, “I am terrified and trembling.”

No, you have approached Mount Zion and the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, and countless angels in festal gathering, and the assembly of the firstborn enrolled in heaven, and God the judge of all, and the spirits of the just made perfect, and Jesus, the mediator of a new covenant, and the sprinkled blood that speaks more eloquently than that of Abel.
Thanks so much for sharing your reflection, Dave.

You, too Alan!
 
Another great revelation on God’s mercy was given to St. Faustina by our Lord himself. I wholeheartedly encourage reading of St. Faustina’s diary, “Divine Mercy in My Soul”.
 
Yes, Hawko, St. Faustina’s Diary was a pure gift to us from the heart of God. Were there any specific passages that influenced you or changed your relationship with God?
 
The soul will receive from God exactly what she desires.
A while ago in our church Bible Study group, someone brought up a question that since the Protestants don’t believe in Purgatory, does it mean they will all directly go to heaven? That question is sort of related to the above quote of St. Therese.

Personally, I think St. Therese did not mean everyone would directly go to heaven as long as he so believed. It does not mean Purgatory does not exist either. It means we ought to aim for heaven, not for Purgatory. And if we earnestly do all we can to strive for holiness, God is not a severe judge but a loving and merciful Father. To me, St. Therese’s teaching means we ought to rid of God’s image as a severe judge, yet not to neglect our part of being holy. If we do so, we have nothing to fear.

As for the question about Protestants, I like to hear your answers if you will. 😃 Is it true since the Protestant has no idea of Purgatory, they all go to heaven when they die. As for Catholics, since we all believe the existence of Purgatory, most of us will go to Purgatory first. If so, :eek:
 
Interesting. Once I started a thread about purgatory, and few people would dare suggest that it is avoidable.

Personally I think the purgation in the Dark Night can do on earth what purgatory can do after death. To what extent, I don’t know.

Alan
 
Well, InLight, I don’t believe Protestants will have a free ticket straight to the pearly gates, just because they don’t believe in Purgatory. 😛 There’s a scripture in Revelations teaching us that “nothing unclean will enter [heaven]” pointing to a deeper purification. Rev. 21:27

The words Therese spoke about our Blessed Mother obtaining the grace at our death to make a perfect act of love and contrition were very special to me. Isn’t that what we pray every day, “pray for US sinners, now and at the hour of OUR death?” I also believe that these prayers to Mary are applied to the Body of Christ also, and not merely for ourselves. The wording in the prayer is *plural. *

Of course, we can neglect the grace, but if we are faithful, I am confident that God will grant us all the graces we need in order to please Him and become holy, if that is our true desire to be with Him forever.

Remember this old prayer from the Baltimore Catechism?

ACT OF HOPE

O my God, relying on Your almighty power and infinite mercy and promises, I hope to obtain pardon of my sins, the help of Your grace and life everlasting, through the merits of Jesus Christ, my Lord and Redeemer. Amen.

St. Therese proved the power of prayer for sinners when Pranzini suddenly repented, kissed the crucifix and went to his execution, though until that very last moment, he had rejected the grace and was impenitent.
 
40.png
Alan:
Interesting. Once I started a thread about purgatory, and few people would dare suggest that it is avoidable.

Personally I think the purgation in the Dark Night can do on earth what purgatory can do after death. To what extent, I don’t know.
We do well to think often about God’s love and mercy, and couple it with trust in His powerful grace. Jesus promised that no one would snatch His sheep from His hand, and if we trust Him to guard us and “deliver us from evil”, we give Him glory. The ancient Israelites had the greatest insight into God’s mercy, and the Hebrew word for it was hésed. I learned in bible study that this specific word encompasses it so greatly, that man could not find a word in English to describe it sufficiently. Psalm 135 is full of praise for God’s mercy, over and over, like a rosary.

I can appreciate that those who posted in your thread would have a problem believing that Purgatory is avoidable. I have my days, too, but I pray that I may grow in trust and confidence.
 
I don’t believe Protestants will have a free ticket straight to the pearly gates, just because they don’t believe in Purgatory. 😛 There’s a scripture in Revelations teaching us that “nothing unclean will enter [heaven]” pointing to a deeper purification. Rev. 21:27
I am glad to hear you say so. I too, don’t believe the free ticket to heaven for whoever don’t have a concept of Purgatory. Otherwise, we Catholics who know the right teaching will be the only ones go there. How can that make sense?:confused:
 
A while ago in our church Bible Study group, someone brought up a question that since the Protestants don’t believe in Purgatory, does it mean they will all directly go to heaven? That question is sort of related to the above quote of St. Therese.

Personally, I think St. Therese did not mean everyone would directly go to heaven as long as he so believed. It does not mean Purgatory does not exist either. It means we ought to aim for heaven, not for Purgatory. And if we earnestly do all we can to strive for holiness, God is not a severe judge but a loving and merciful Father. To me, St. Therese’s teaching means we ought to rid of God’s image as a severe judge, yet not to neglect our part of being holy. If we do so, we have nothing to fear.
When somebody says to me, “I don’t believe in Purgatory!” my response is: “You will when you get there!”

I also do not think St. Therese was advocating presumption – otherwise, she would not be worthy to be declared a Doctor of the Church! Elsewhere in her writings, she refers to the sufferings of daily life as treasures strewed across our paths. Surely, if we use these properly, this is a means of avoiding Purgatory.
 
As for the question about Protestants, I like to hear your answers if you will. 😃 Is it true since the Protestant has no idea of Purgatory, they all go to heaven when they die.
And what about people who don’t believe in hell? Their belief wouldn’t be a guarantee that they avoid hell, would it? Just my two-one-hundreths of a dollar. . .

God bless,
Dan
 
Yes, Hawko, St. Faustina’s Diary was a pure gift to us from the heart of God. Were there any specific passages that influenced you or changed your relationship with God?
Well, I’m almost finished reading her diary so I can’t really say which passages influenced me the most until I’m finished the book. I can say that it has given me a greater appreciation and understanding of the depths of God’s mercy towards us, especially through the sacrament of confession.
 
:hmmm: Most fundamentalist Christians do not believe in a purifying state after death, that does not mean, however, that they will not experience it.All Christians who are not fully purified before death will have to reach perfect purification before entering heaven and we believe that state is called Purgatory.
See Matthew, The Beatitudes, “Only the pure in heart shall see the face of God.”
Peace, Carlan
 
And what about people who don’t believe in hell? Their belief wouldn’t be a guarantee that they avoid hell, would it?
To those who don’t believe in hell, I say: try believing you have $100 million in the bank, then act accordingly. Let me know how that works out for you.
 
A while ago in our church Bible Study group, someone brought up a question that since the Protestants don’t believe in Purgatory, does it mean they will all directly go to heaven? That question is sort of related to the above quote of St. Therese.
The difference is that Protestants believe they will go straight to Heaven because even though they are still committing sins, it doesn’t matter because they have faith. Whereas St. Therese believed that she would go straight to Heaven because she trusted that God’s grace and mercy would purify her soul of sin so that she would not need further purification after her death. Totally different attitude.

Actually, the Protestant view and the Jansenist view have something in common - they both hold, implicitly or explicitly, that God’s grace and mercy is NOT enough to actually purify the sinner and make him truly righteous in this life. This is exactly the attitude that St. Therese was rejecting.
 
Interesting. Once I started a thread about purgatory, and few people would dare suggest that it is avoidable.

Personally I think the purgation in the Dark Night can do on earth what purgatory can do after death. To what extent, I don’t know.

Alan
Code:
I agree Alan. It can also be said that God wants all of us to be saints and to reach the heights of contemplative-union prayer. It is up to us whether we dispose ourselves to reach such a state of perfection…the same goes with purgatory.

It iwll be either here or there…and we have so many occasions to do it here…there are so many trials and tribulations and pain that can help purify our souls as we keep our eyes on Him.
 
And what about people who don’t believe in hell? Their belief wouldn’t be a guarantee that they avoid hell, would it? Just my two-one-hundreths of a dollar. . .

God bless,
Dan
I believe it was St. Faustina who said that that the one thing that she observed in her vision of hell was that most of the people there never believed there WAS a hell.
 
The difference is that Protestants believe they will go straight to Heaven because even though they are still committing sins, it doesn’t matter because they have faith.
Agreed. Lot of Protestants I know hold that attitude.
Whereas St. Therese believed that she would go straight to Heaven because she trusted that God’s grace and mercy would purify her soul of sin so that she would not need further purification after her death. Totally different attitude.
St. Therese’s belief is based on her life time striving for holiness. God’s grace is for everyone but not everyone responds to God’s grace. One can believe in God’s grace and mercy, however, without responding to that grace and mercy ── allow God’s grace to work in one’s life, to develop virtues, to perfect the love of God and love of neighbor ── directly go to heaven is not likely to happen. St. Therese has long matured her friendship with God; therefore, her trust of directly going to heaven has a solid base and foundation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top