While Russia may have some pro-Stalin nonsense going on, the Ukrainians have a very different outlook on him. These people remember the communist regime with terror and have a long lasting resentment for the USSR. I have allot of friends who are Ukrainian immigrants who remember the USSR. One of them even met Nikita Khrushchev. Funny thing with that guy, he honestly believes that liberals and communists are the same thing.
Anyway, every one of the Ukrainians I know are warning myself and everyone else they know to start storing beans and flour. Particularly the older guys who remember the Khrushchev days and similar times, they all claim to have seen whatâs happening in this country happen before in their own and that we are headed for some very trying times.
Hmm⌠I appreciate your recognition that Ukrainians who suffered from religious, cultural, and brutal physical repression under the U.S.S.R. would never hold Stalin in the same light as the Russians. Stalin orchestrated the genocidal campaign that killed some 5-7 million in Ukraine during the âholodomorâ (English: to Murder by Hunger) and the destruction of its Ukrainian Catholic and Orthodox Churches. Ukraine has a free press now unlike Russia which continually praises the great K.G.B. tsar Putin.
However, I must with all due respect disagree with âevery one of the Ukrainiansâ you know warning of storing beans and flour as being sound advice. I am from Canada and we have a Canadian-Ukrainian community 1 million strong many of whose families, like mine, suffered horribly at the hands of communism. My father as a kid actually had to march in front of Khrushchev when he was Secretary of the Kompartiya in Ukaine in a coerced parade in Stanyslaviv (now Ivano-Frankivsk). My dad recalled the Soviets had the whole city surrounded with armoured vehicles at the time in case the Ukrainian underground had a go at Khrushchev who self-admittedly was up to his elbows in Ukrainian blood after basically killing off its entire intelligentsia in the 1930s.
Canada is a much more statist society than the United States and yet âevery one of the Ukrainiansâ I know, and, believe me, I know a lot, I mean a lot, is not warning me or I them to store beans and flour. None of our priests or bishops, Ukrainian or Roman Catholic, are suggesting this be done, and I am pretty positive no U.S. Catholic bishop or priest is warning parishioners to stock up on goods for the evil times ahead. I think what you are describing is IMHO your and many other Americansâ end times scenario (I believe you alluded to it in another thread on the AntiChrist). This, with the sheer depth of fear of some Catholic Americans towards Obama and his supposed unstobbability, IMHO, sometimes sees the situation much worse than it really is, and I as a Catholic, feel bound by the Catechism to not engage in âunhealthy speculationâ as to the end times.
In any event, I think this thread will have run its course if it moves from dealing with Stalinâs reputation into something completely different, namely U.S. domestic politics, for which a new thread perhaps could be started for this particular argument if you wish and this one closed.
Hope not to have offended or mischaracterized your views but I feel it wrong to generalize that Ukrainians are advocating the stalking of food in basements in the US based on their experiences in Ukraine. This is the first time I have ever heard this, so I am stating that most Ukrainians, in my experience, would never advocate anything like this and the U.S. is really a country of a different kind not degree to the Soviet Union of the 1930s with its Gulags and KGB militia patrolling wheatfields so no peasant could eat. Are you kidding? Canada and the USA saved us. I do not believe the U.S. is on the cusp of anything like this. God Bless!