Stalin voted third-best Russian

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bendecida
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Who came in second and who came in first?

I personally have a problem with Russians. Maybe because they stole family land.🤷
 
Who came in second and who came in first?

I personally have a problem with Russians. Maybe because they stole family land.🤷
Nevsky first (a Russian grand prince from the middle ages, second Stolypin a reformist PM under the last czar Stolypin, then Stalin). However, rumour had it Stalin was actually going to win that vote apart from some last minute vote-giggling. In today’s Russia, Stalin is enjoying having his bad history whitewashed by Putin.:mad:
 
Nevsky first (a Russian grand prince from the middle ages, second Stolypin a reformist PM under the last czar Stolypin, then Stalin). However, rumour had it Stalin was actually going to win that vote apart from some last minute vote-giggling. In today’s Russia, Stalin is enjoying having his bad history whitewashed by Putin.:mad:
Oh. Thank you for letting me know that. Too bad Putin’s vacation home is on my family’s land.:mad:
 
Worst of all when the Stalins regime is basicly justified by the Church leadears.
I think that the leaders of the Rus.Orthod.Church should remember that Ukraine with its ancient Christian culture , has a right for its spiritual tradition , its culture , has the right for its Church. The Ukrainian Church which a few centuries elder than the Moscows Church.
And the Church leaders should never forget about regime which was anti-human and human-hating regime.
We should not forget that agreement in 1940-th when the Rus.Orht.Church was forced to co-work with NKVD , and that that co-work included reports about the Christians after their confessions…
We should never forget about deportations of many nationalities , about holodomor , when for two years more than 10 million people were destroyed by hunger.
The leaders of Rus.Orth.Church should always remember these , especially when they visit their Church members in the foreign and independent country like a Ukraine.
 
Worst of all when the Stalins regime is basicly justified by the Church leadears.
I think that the leaders of the Rus.Orthod.Church should remember that Ukraine with its ancient Christian culture , has a right for its spiritual tradition , its culture , has the right for its Church. The Ukrainian Church which a few centuries elder than the Moscows Church.
And the Church leaders should never forget about regime which was anti-human and human-hating regime.
We should not forget that agreement in 1940-th when the Rus.Orht.Church was forced to co-work with NKVD , and that that co-work included reports about the Christians after their confessions…
We should never forget about deportations of many nationalities , about holodomor , when for two years more than 10 million people were destroyed by hunger.
The leaders of Rus.Orth.Church should always remember these , especially when they visit their Church members in the foreign and independent country like a Ukraine.
Amen! Thanks for remembering holodomor and Rus. Orth. Church’s imperial stance towards countries like Ukraine. God Bless Athanasiy 🙂
 
15 million is quite terrifying enough to make the point.
Twice six million and half of the six to again…

Mao’s numbers are generally considered to be larger still.

And the killing fields of Cambodia are quite something too, in that wearing spectacles was enough to earn someone the label of bourgeois.

The difference between the socialist internationalists and the national socialists, aside from the bungling of the economy that leads to mass starvation, is that the international socialists kill classes of people who are deemed to be controlling the economy, and the nationalist socialists kill races of people after selling the lie that these certain races are really the ones controlling the economy.
 
Twice six million and half of the six to again…

Mao’s numbers are generally considered to be larger still.

And the killing fields of Cambodia are quite something too, in that wearing spectacles was enough to earn someone the label of bourgeois.

The difference between the socialist internationalists and the national socialists, aside from the bungling of the economy that leads to mass starvation, is that the international socialists kill classes of people who are deemed to be controlling the economy, and the nationalist socialists kill races of people after selling the lie that these certain races are really the ones controlling the economy.
I’d prefer to put it that people who really, really, really know what the answer is, tend to generate monsters quite prolifically.
 
I’d prefer to put it that people who really, really, really know what the answer is, tend to generate monsters quite prolifically.
That can turn into a recipe for leaving it up to somebody else, all because good people are unsure.

Knowing that there is a right and a wrong, and standing up for the right, is a good thing, for the most part.

Envy and resentment against the rich or those otherwise chosen is something that must be guarded against. This is the sentiment, the ressentiment, that has generated the monsters of the twentieth century.

The twentieth century was not an age of certainty, but an age of uncertainty, with people desperately grasping at straws, and no shortage of pyschopaths—beyond the good and evil as defined in more certain ages—who were more than willing to supply the answers.
 
That can turn into a recipe for leaving it up to somebody else, all because good people are unsure.
Indeed, many people are swayed by groups who say they really, really, really do know what the answer is, so history is a very important subject.
Knowing that there is a right and a wrong, and standing up for the right, is a good thing, for the most part.
Where the situation allows critical appreciation of that ‘knowing’, of course, and where mistakes made in application of that ‘knowing’ are open to acknowledgment and amelioration.
Envy and resentment against the rich or those otherwise chosen is something that must be guarded against. This is the sentiment, the ressentiment, that has generated the monsters of the twentieth century.
Revolutions aren’t just about ‘envy and resentment’ of the rich - what was notable about, say, France in 1789 and Russia in 1917 were the ‘barriers to entry’. People were, pretty much, stuck where they were born in a social sense, they were socially immobile societies. In Germany, there were a very significant number of people (farmers, shopkeepers, office workers, artisans) who felt themselves outside ‘meaning’ in the modern world, who didn’t feel they belonged in a world of dynamic capitalism, on the one hand, or the organized working class on the other - it was that group that predominated in the NSDAP and predominantly voted for the NSDAP. The groups that felt ‘meaning’ in their lives - like Catholics and the (largely socialist) ‘working class’ remained overwhelmingly non-NSDAP members and voters.
The twentieth century was not an age of certainty, but an age of uncertainty, with people desperately grasping at straws, and no shortage of pyschopaths—beyond the good and evil as defined in more certain ages—who were more than willing to supply the answers.
The period since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution has been about the generation of uncertainty by technological and economic forces beyond the ability of the old certainties to cope. In the end, societies that have learned to deal with uncertainty rather than grasping for old or new certainties have fared better.
 
Anyone who has had to live with someone with paranoia will understand life in the Soviet Union under Stalin. He managed to rig things so that he became the leader after the death of Lenin (which he may or may not have arranged). He perfected the art of saying the exact opposite of what he meant.
Sounds a lot like George W. Bush.
There was no way for anyone to know if or when they would be arrested. Under Stalin, it became a crime (punishable by 10 to 15 years in the work camps) to be SUSPECTED of crimes against the state, or to be a family member of such a person. In other words, if you were arrested (conviction is guaranteed) on suspicion of being an enemy of the state, your brothers, your sisters, your children could also all be sent to prison for 10-15 years for being related to you.
Being arrested and breaking international laws for just being “suspected” of crimes, without being tried or even accused… sounds a lot like Guantanamo.
 
This sort of irrationality among Russia’s younger generation is not surprising. The USSR suffered the largest death toll of WW II and yet there is a massive pro-Nazi movement going on in Moscow.

WW II dramatically reduced the Russian population, so afterwords, the Russians reproduced like there was no tomorrow and it’s very normal for Russian families to have 7-8 kids in it. Since so much of the Russian population died during Stalin’s reign, the vast majority of Russians do not remember Stalin. In fact, there are even fewer Russians in comparison who remember Stalin then there are Americans who remember FDR.

Furthermore, the young adult generation of Russia who massively outnumbers the older population, does not remember the pre-Gorbachev communist system, so the are actually polling on matters that they know nothing about. Pride and envy are very strong forces in Russian culture and they are held strongest and most dangerously served by older leaders of their political system, mafia or other organizations, and these people, who tend to be very aware of who and what Stalin was, play on the pride of the younger generations to get them rallied behind these ideas as a matter of devil’s advocacy.

In this respect, it is safe to say that stewed Americans understand communism and people like Stalin better then the young generation of the very city he ruled.

With them, it’s sort of like the inquisitions. It has nothing to do with knowledge and reason, and everything to do with pride, envy and hate.

Do some google video searching on Russian Skinheads, Nazis, socialist movement, raciest etc. and you will get a real eye opener on what sort of stuff is going on over there.
 
Sounds a lot like George W. Bush.

Being arrested and breaking international laws for just being “suspected” of crimes, without being tried or even accused… sounds a lot like Guantanamo.
While Russia may have some pro-Stalin nonsense going on, the Ukrainians have a very different outlook on him. These people remember the communist regime with terror and have a long lasting resentment for the USSR. I have allot of friends who are Ukrainian immigrants who remember the USSR. One of them even met Nikita Khrushchev. Funny thing with that guy, he honestly believes that liberals and communists are the same thing.

Anyway, every one of the Ukrainians I know are warning myself and everyone else they know to start storing beans and flour. Particularly the older guys who remember the Khrushchev days and similar times, they all claim to have seen what’s happening in this country happen before in their own and that we are headed for some very trying times.

Allot of people may be surprised to here this, but I am actually with you on Bush. I think it was Alex Jones who hit the nail on the head when he said to the liberals: “You should like George Bush. He is doing what you like.”

I myself supported Ron Paul and Bob Barr in the last election. Ron Paul in particular is the only living politician I have ever heard of who I have absolutely no political discrepancies with at all.
 
While Russia may have some pro-Stalin nonsense going on, the Ukrainians have a very different outlook on him. These people remember the communist regime with terror and have a long lasting resentment for the USSR. I have allot of friends who are Ukrainian immigrants who remember the USSR. One of them even met Nikita Khrushchev. Funny thing with that guy, he honestly believes that liberals and communists are the same thing.

Anyway, every one of the Ukrainians I know are warning myself and everyone else they know to start storing beans and flour. Particularly the older guys who remember the Khrushchev days and similar times, they all claim to have seen what’s happening in this country happen before in their own and that we are headed for some very trying times.
Hmm… I appreciate your recognition that Ukrainians who suffered from religious, cultural, and brutal physical repression under the U.S.S.R. would never hold Stalin in the same light as the Russians. Stalin orchestrated the genocidal campaign that killed some 5-7 million in Ukraine during the “holodomor” (English: to Murder by Hunger) and the destruction of its Ukrainian Catholic and Orthodox Churches. Ukraine has a free press now unlike Russia which continually praises the great K.G.B. tsar Putin.

However, I must with all due respect disagree with “every one of the Ukrainians” you know warning of storing beans and flour as being sound advice. I am from Canada and we have a Canadian-Ukrainian community 1 million strong many of whose families, like mine, suffered horribly at the hands of communism. My father as a kid actually had to march in front of Khrushchev when he was Secretary of the Kompartiya in Ukaine in a coerced parade in Stanyslaviv (now Ivano-Frankivsk). My dad recalled the Soviets had the whole city surrounded with armoured vehicles at the time in case the Ukrainian underground had a go at Khrushchev who self-admittedly was up to his elbows in Ukrainian blood after basically killing off its entire intelligentsia in the 1930s.

Canada is a much more statist society than the United States and yet “every one of the Ukrainians” I know, and, believe me, I know a lot, I mean a lot, is not warning me or I them to store beans and flour. None of our priests or bishops, Ukrainian or Roman Catholic, are suggesting this be done, and I am pretty positive no U.S. Catholic bishop or priest is warning parishioners to stock up on goods for the evil times ahead. I think what you are describing is IMHO your and many other Americans’ end times scenario (I believe you alluded to it in another thread on the AntiChrist). This, with the sheer depth of fear of some Catholic Americans towards Obama and his supposed unstobbability, IMHO, sometimes sees the situation much worse than it really is, and I as a Catholic, feel bound by the Catechism to not engage in “unhealthy speculation” as to the end times.

In any event, I think this thread will have run its course if it moves from dealing with Stalin’s reputation into something completely different, namely U.S. domestic politics, for which a new thread perhaps could be started for this particular argument if you wish and this one closed.

Hope not to have offended or mischaracterized your views but I feel it wrong to generalize that Ukrainians are advocating the stalking of food in basements in the US based on their experiences in Ukraine. This is the first time I have ever heard this, so I am stating that most Ukrainians, in my experience, would never advocate anything like this and the U.S. is really a country of a different kind not degree to the Soviet Union of the 1930s with its Gulags and KGB militia patrolling wheatfields so no peasant could eat. Are you kidding? Canada and the USA saved us. I do not believe the U.S. is on the cusp of anything like this. God Bless!
 
Just for fun:
Isambard Kingdom Brunel
Winston Churchill
Oliver Cromwell
Charles Darwin
Diana, Princess of Wales
Queen Elizabeth I
John Lennon
Horatio Nelson
Isaac Newton
William Shakespeare
Well, look who #3 on the Brit list is. I’d say Cromwell is at least as evil as Stalin or Hitler. Of course, I’m of Irish descent o I’m not entirely unbiased.

[

Reagan voted 'greatest American’1 Ronald Reagan
2 Abraham Lincoln
3 Martin Luther King
4 George Washington
5 Benjamin Franklin
6 George W Bush
7 Bill Clinton
8 Elvis Presley
9 Oprah Winfrey
10 Franklin D Roosevelt

](BBC NEWS | Americas | Reagan voted 'greatest American')

[sigh!]
Why do I get the feeling that a lot of my fellow Americans voted for recent presidents or pop stars because they don’t know any history?
 
Why do I get the feeling that a lot of my fellow Americans voted for recent presidents or pop stars because they don’t know any history?
Scary, eh?

I love music more than the average person… but Elvis Presley?!? I could name so many more influential and “greater” American musicians than Elvis.

Oprah? I’d like to think this one doesn’t even need to be commented on to be considered unbelievably ridiculous.

Bill Clinton perfectly fits your comment re: not knowing history.

Reagan was well liked, but geez… there have been better presidents than him. He traded weapons to Iran for hostages and bombed Libya against international laws. That’s the greatest American of all time?!?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top