Statement regarding Real Catholic TV and its name

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joe_5859
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joe_5859

Guest
From the Archdiocese of Detroit:

Issued: Dec. 15, 2011
Contact: Ned McGrath, infodesk@aod.org / (313) 237-5943

The Church encourages the Christian faithful to promote or sustain a variety of apostolic undertakings but, nevertheless, prohibits any such undertaking from claiming the name Catholic without the consent of the competent ecclesiastical authority (see canon 216 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law). For some time, the Archdiocese of Detroit has been in communication with Mr. Michael Voris and his media partner at Real Catholic TV regarding their prominent use of the word “Catholic” in identifying and promoting their public activities disseminated from the enterprise’s production facility in Ferndale, Michigan. The Archdiocese has informed Mr. Voris and Real Catholic TV, RealCatholicTV.com, that it does not regard them as being authorized to use the word “Catholic” to identify or promote their public activities. Questions about this matter may be directed to the Archdiocese of Detroit, Department of Communications.

I haven’t seen any response from RCTV on this statement so far.
 
I haven’t seen any response from RCTV on this statement so far.
I never saw any response from them before, really, but why would they respond now, the story is just the AoD saying what it already said. Nothing new in the article.

I’m waiting for Voris to own up to doing business as RealCatholicTV on his own. And I still don’t think Detroit has any authority over the e website based in another state, so I’m not sure why they even mentioned RealCatholicTV.com.
 
Hi Joe,
There was a statement added to the original one at AoD in your link, dated yesterday. It reads:

Need for Statement on Real Catholic TV

Issued: January 3, 2012
Contact: Ned McGrath, infodesk@aod.org / (313) 237-5943

About Us - Archdiocese of Detroit Print this statement

Subsequent to the release in mid-December, 2011, of a “Statement regarding Real Catholic TV and its name,” inquiries have come to the Archdiocesan Department of Communications regarding the timing and need for this particular declaration. The Director of Communications presents this response:
“The Archdiocese of Detroit has been consistent in its statements to and about Real Catholic TV since the fall of 2008. (Regarding RealCatholicTV.com) Due to continued requests made to the Detroit archdiocese for clarification concerning the use of the title Catholic by Real Catholic TV, and to avoid any confusion among the faithful, it was determined a public statement should make clear what has been told to Real Catholic TV, namely, that it does not have the authorization required under Church law to identify or promote itself as Catholic.”
 
Julia Mae:
I’m waiting for Voris to own up to doing business as RealCatholicTV on his own. And I still don’t think Detroit has any authority over the website based in another state, so I’m not sure why they even mentioned RealCatholicTV.com.
Could it be that the Indiana entity is a shill? I have seen many State documents from Indiana that looks as though this is the case.
 
Could it be that the Indiana entity is a shill? I have seen many State documents from Indiana that looks as though this is the case.
I don’t know. I never heard of this guy, to be honest, until that other thread and then I was really interested in how it works when a Bishop, or I guess an Archbishop, tries to enforce this Canon.

Who has jurisdiction on the Indiana case? Has there been any reaction from that Bishop?
I’m also confused about this. I thought I read something here on CAF about Voris having a business in Michigan that operated as RealCatholicTV. So, he also has one in Indiana with that other guy? Really, my question about the Church is: who’s in charge?
 
Julia Mae:
Who has jurisdiction on the Indiana case? Has there been any reaction from that Bishop?
I’m also confused about this. I thought I read something here on CAF about Voris having a business in Michigan that operated as RealCatholicTV. So, he also has one in Indiana with that other guy? Really, my question about the Church is: who’s in charge?
The jurisdiction applies to the base of operation (and the person producing the content), not the entity who happens to have an identical domain name. Marc Brammer’s address, as per the Indiana filings, is simply a “dwelling” - not a business with a studio in production, such as Concept Communications owned by Voris, and doing business publicly - on location - as RealCatholicTV. This application for the identical assumend name was filed two years later in Michigan by Voris, AFTER it was previously filed in Indiana by Brammer.

Sorry, it gets confusing, I realize, but documents don’t lie.
 
The jurisdiction applies to the base of operation (and the person producing the content), not the entity who happens to have an identical domain name. Marc Brammer’s address, as per the Indiana filings, is simply a “dwelling” - not a business with a studio in production, such as Concept Communications owned by Voris, and doing business publicly - on location - as RealCatholicTV. This application for the identical assumend name was filed two years later in Michigan by Voris, AFTER it was previously filed in Indiana by Brammer…
Okay, wait. You posted this:
Subsequent to the release in mid-December, 2011, of a “Statement regarding Real Catholic TV and its name,” inquiries have come to the Archdiocesan Department of Communications regarding the timing and need for this particular declaration. The Director of Communications presents this response:
“The Archdiocese of Detroit has been consistent in its statements to and about Real Catholic TV since the fall of 2008. (Regarding RealCatholicTV.com) Due to continued requests made to the Detroit archdiocese for clarification concerning the use of the title Catholic by Real Catholic TV, and to avoid any confusion among the faithful, it was determined a public statement should make clear what has been told to Real Catholic TV, namely, that it does not have the authorization required under Church law to identify or promote itself as Catholic.”
And in a link that is in the other thread about this, doesn’t it say Voris legally attached RealCatholicTV to his business name in 2010? Do I have the date right?

If that’s what happened, then the Archdiocese told him he couldn’t use the word “Catholic” two years before he started doing it. So he already knew. So… how does the website address tie-in? When did the Indian a guy register the domain name?

I dunno. I don’t think he’s going to comply because it looks like he just did it deliberately, so why would he change now? I don’t think the Catholic Church can sue him civilly, can it? I mean, you can’t trademark the word Catholic at this point in history. Maybe the state can go after him for claiming non-profit status and taking donations under false pretenses, but I don’t see how the Church has a bit of power here.
 
Julia Mae:
And in a link that is in the other thread about this, doesn’t it say Voris legally attached RealCatholicTV to his business name in 2010? Do I have the date right?

If that’s what happened, then the Archdiocese told him he couldn’t use the word “Catholic” two years before he started doing it. So he already knew. So… how does the website address tie-in? When did the Indian a guy register the domain name?
I’m not very good at copying tables but there is a time-line in this article that says:
2008 Started RealCatholicTV.com. There’s some data connecting him to legalizing RCTV in Michigan in 2010, so you have it right. I don’t understand the time lapse of two years necessitating a second filing, except his timeline may be referring to the assumed name filed by Marc Brammer in Indiana in Oct. 2008. Lizaanne advertized in a post here on CAF that they were opening in August 2008 (if I remember correctly).

So why re-register in Michigan? A good question. It appears from the filing in Indiana that Brammer filed as a “domestic” entity, meaning that the base of operations would be in Indiana, and not as a “foreign” entity (outside Indiana). That could be why Voris refiled, since there is no business whatsoever in Indiana. Here’s the paperwork, that doesn’t reveal Voris being connected in any manner whatsoever, neither as Director, nor in the Articles of Incorporation (Select option 3 on the next page) Furthermore, there is no visible evidence of operation in any search for Greenstar Enterprises or RealCatholicTV at the 3002 Miami Street address. In fact, it is a residence.

So it leaves a lot of unanswered questions that look very odd on the surface, even to the most casual observer. Had Voris not opened up that can of worms by publicly protesting he is not the owner, perhaps people would not have pursued this information on their own to figure out whether he is being truthful. It makes little difference, except when he implies that AOD has no jurisdiction over him. I believe they absolutely do, since the Indiana entity is perhaps just an escape route.
 
Had Voris not opened up that can of worms by publicly protesting he is not the owner, perhaps people would not have pursued this information on their own to figure out whether he is being truthful. It makes little difference, except when he implies that AOD has no jurisdiction over him. I believe they absolutely do, since the Indiana entity is perhaps just an escape route.
Okay, that Canon lawyer link, that was yours. I read both of these pages and on one of them he talks about jurisdiction. I’ll see if I can find it.
 
Okay, that Canon lawyer link, that was yours. I read both of these pages and on one of them he talks about jurisdiction. I’ll see if I can find it.
Well, that didn’t get done in time to edit my last post! (Real life interrupting cyber-life again.)) Anyway, I found what he said about jurisdiction :
A) The AOD, some claim, does not have jurisdiction over Voris/RCTV.
  1. Jurisdiction is a quintessentially canonical issue (!), but I have yet to see the “lack of jurisdiction” claim being made by anyone who knows how canon law actually determines jurisdiction over persons and projects. As a blog is not the place for me to attempt a pre-emptive tutorial on canonical jurisdiction, I’ll just say that, to the extent that jurisdiction is or might be an issue in this matter, I believe the AOD to be on firm ground.
  1. I can add, though, that the “lack of jurisdiction” claim implies that the AOD needed “jurisdiction” to state that it “does not regard [Voris/RCTV] as being authorized to use the word ‘Catholic’ to identify or promote their public activities (Dec 2011)” or that “the catechetical presentations and the interpretations of Catholic teachings or positions presented by St. Michael’s Media and/or RealCatholicTV—be they audio, video, or exclusively Web-based—cannot be approved or endorsed by the archdiocese at this time (Oct 2008).”
Code:
 Since when, I ask, does the AOD need “jurisdiction” to reply to inquiries made to it by third-parties regarding Voris/RCTV or to anticipate the need to respond to more such inquiries in the future? Are the pervasive claims by Voris/RCTV that they are producing “Real Catholic TV”, and running a “Catholic Investigative Agency”, and publishing the “Catholic Critic”, etc., immune from any reply by the ecclesiastical institution headquartered just a few miles from the Voris/RCTV facilities and directly responsible for the identity and mission of the Catholic Church in this region?
With all that goes on these days, I think this is one of the more interesting questions. I don’t see any way to enforce this without the Church going through a civil procedure. In America. Where we ostensibly have freedom of speech. I’m just not seeing a practical way for the AoD to prevail. This is also interesting in light of what seem to be attacks on the Church by government. Though that’s another thread. Keep us posted, you seem to have your eye on this issue.

🍿
 
I read so much on the web lately, Julia Mae, that I forget where I saw this. The AOD is already exercising its authority in curtailing his efforts in other dioceses, such as speaking engagements, presenting programs, and I read one incidence of stopping his appearance on Marcus Grodi’s Journey Home TV program on EWTN.

It would behoove MV to bring himself into compliance so that these cancellations will not be a matter of routine, once the word gets around.
 
With all that goes on these days, I think this is one of the more interesting questions. I don’t see any way to enforce this without the Church going through a civil procedure. In America. Where we ostensibly have freedom of speech. I’m just not seeing a practical way for the AoD to prevail. This is also interesting in light of what seem to be attacks on the Church by government. Though that’s another thread. Keep us posted, you seem to have your eye on this issue.

🍿
This is a canon law issue, though. It has nothing to do with civil law. The AoD would not get the State involved in such a thing. Indeed, the State should not be involved with internal canonical affairs. To invite the State into the process would be bad all around.

The only thing the AoD can really do (beyond the statement they have already made) is to politely ask them to stop using the word “Catholic” in their name.
 
The only thing the AoD can really do (beyond the statement they have already made) is to politely ask them to stop using the word “Catholic” in their name.
Is it? Can they excommunicate Voris for disobedience to the Archbishop? If he is in violation not of just the AoD media protocols but the USCCB ones, can the Bishops sanction him in some way so he can’t get a speaking gig at a Catholic University or organization? Can they have the Bishops make sure none of the parishes are running his video feed on their websites?
 
Is it? Can they excommunicate Voris for disobedience to the Archbishop? If he is in violation not of just the AoD media protocols but the USCCB ones, can the Bishops sanction him in some way so he can’t get a speaking gig at a Catholic University or organization? Can they have the Bishops make sure none of the parishes are running his video feed on their websites?
I’m no canon lawyer, but I would think that excommunication would be a disproportionate response to such an infraction. The only way I can imagine that happening is if there were many more problems (such as if Voris started calling for schism or other such things). I can’t really see that happening.

A bishop could certainly send a letter to his brother bishops letting them know of Voris’ organization’s standing in his home diocese and discouraging them from allowing him to speak in Catholic venues (parishes, colleges, etc.). But, of course, each bishop has his own authority and thus is free to heed or ignore such a letter. Bishops generally don’t tell each other what to do.

Different dioceses have different standards when it comes to bringing in speakers to parish events. Some of them have protocols in place where speakers need to be vetted by the chancery before being invited to speak at a parish. Others don’t. If such a system is not in place, it might be more difficult for a bishop to enforce such a thing.
 
I’m no canon lawyer, but I would think that excommunication would be a disproportionate response to such an infraction. The only way I can imagine that happening is if there were many more problems (such as if Voris started calling for schism or other such things). I can’t really see that happening…
The thing is, we don’t know how serious the AoD thinks the infraction is. We know he was aware of the stricture about using the word “Catholic” since 2006. So the AoD can see it as blatant disobedience for him to actually create in Michigan a legal business entity located right in the AoD called “Real Catholic TV.” I read online where a Bishop somewhere else stopped a woman from using the word in a “Catholic Homeschoolers” group, somethng like that. I think they take this pretty seriously.

I don’t know. I think of it like putting nihil obstat in a book you publish without authorization. Hey, that’s pretty good! Maybe he should call it that. Nihil Obstat TV. Oh wait. That’d make it NOTV. Guess not! 😃

Anyway, I think I like that Bishops care about this and I can see them wanting to support each other as Bishops even if they, themselves, wouldn’t make the same decision.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top