Stretching Exercise Not Yoga

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bluecat63
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bluecat63

Guest
Hello everyone-
Can someone recommend an exercise routine that has the slow stretching movements of yoga? Obviously, as a Catholic I don’t want anything that does not reflect or muddles our Christian heritage.
Thanks!
 
You can find plenty of pilates programs, DVD’s, videos, etc. I like the ones I’ve found because they have more than just the stretching you get from yoga.
 
Thanks, Gordon -
I appreciate the (name removed by moderator)ut. I don’t know much about pilates but will investigate.
Thanks again!
 
I second Gordon on this one.

I used to do Pilates when I was dancing professionally. It’s outstanding and it’s only stretching exercises. You don’t need the equipment either. There are plenty of home DVDs you can use.

I used to own a DVD done by the NYC ballet company. It was hosted by Sarah Jessica Parker and was a low key workout based around ballet exercises.

It’s been awhile, I’ll have to look it up on Amazon or something. But it was very good as well.
 
Thank you, Kelfa28!
I really didn’t even consider pilates. It is funny how you can get in a rut and not even know you are there.
Peace!
 
Hello everyone-
Can someone recommend an exercise routine that has the slow stretching movements of yoga? Obviously, as a Catholic I don’t want anything that does not reflect or muddles our Christian heritage.
Thanks!
Check local gyms for yoga. My yoga class has no spiritual content, its yoga poses and stretches.
 
I have been currently trying out pilates and love it. Yoga isn’t bad. It is only bad when you get into the spiritual and hippie part of it.
 
Check local gyms for yoga. My yoga class has no spiritual content, its yoga poses and stretches.
The Church has stated that the positions of Yoga cannot be separated from the religion, whether it is part of the yoga program or not. If witchcraft had specific exercises designed to call demons I doubt we would argue that we are just doing the exercises and not part of the ritual.

Yoga is eastern mysticism. It is best to avoid it and go with a pure exercise routine.
 
The Church has stated that the positions of Yoga cannot be separated from the religion, whether it is part of the yoga program or not. If witchcraft had specific exercises designed to call demons I doubt we would argue that we are just doing the exercises and not part of the ritual.

Yoga is eastern mysticism. It is best to avoid it and go with a pure exercise routine.
The CA "Ask an Apologist area has discussed this a few times. Basically it comes down to the reason for doing the Yoga.

Having been through many yoga classes I can tell you that in any exercise/stretching routine you are almost certainly doing yoga even if you didn’t know it.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=822578&highlight=yoga
 
The Church has stated that the positions of Yoga cannot be separated from the religion, whether it is part of the yoga program or not. If witchcraft had specific exercises designed to call demons I doubt we would argue that we are just doing the exercises and not part of the ritual.

Yoga is eastern mysticism. It is best to avoid it and go with a pure exercise routine.
I respect your decision to refrain from yoga poses and stretches. However, there is no spiritual or religious aspect to the yoga class that I take. Child’s pose, down dog, chair, twist in chair - do not bring in any religion.

Listening to the Catholic Chanel on Sirius Satellite Radio one day, a caller mentioned to Timothy Cardinal Dolan that the Catholic Church was “against” yoga. The good Cardinal, who is President of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, said he never heard that the Church held a position against yoga.

In good conscience, I will continue my practice of forward fold and up plank.
 
Thanks to everyone who responded. I now have a direction to go and I appreciate everyone’s help!
 
Pilates is not really a substitute for yoga and while there is stretching the focus is on strengthening the abs and back but is can also strengthen and tone muscles in your arms and legs. Yoga does that too but is a different approach (so it’s not just stretching either). :shrug:I have pilates videos and taken classes and I like the approach especially after reading about Joseph Pilates philosophy.

I have has back problems and learning how to correct my posture to a neutral pelvis (from a Pilates instructor in-person) has been life-changing. If you are looking for a stretching program there are specific programs to focus on flexibility.
 
Doing yoga is allowed. Nowhere is yoga condemned. You can find plenty of yoga DVDs without religious content.

However, if you want to go the cheap and extremely effective way, do Pop Pilates on Youtube. Twenty minutes of Pop Pilates a day and you’ll be in excellent shape in no time. Twenty minutes doesn’t seem like a long time, but trust me, try a video and you’ll appreciate just how long thirty seconds really is.
 
The Church has stated that the positions of Yoga cannot be separated from the religion, whether it is part of the yoga program or not. If witchcraft had specific exercises designed to call demons I doubt we would argue that we are just doing the exercises and not part of the ritual.

Yoga is eastern mysticism. It is best to avoid it and go with a pure exercise routine.
Citations for those Church statements, please.
 
The Church has stated that the positions of Yoga cannot be separated from the religion,
This is flat-out false; the Church teaches no such thing. In fact, if the Church took such a position, it would basically mean you could not stretch, as basically any stretch likely has an equivalent position in that system. The stretching system was in place while people in the western world were still living in caves (okay, so I exaggerate, but you get the point). The body only moves so many ways, and they figured that out a long, long time again.
Yoga is eastern mysticism. It is best to avoid it and go with a pure exercise routine.
The average Joe that is practicing “yoga” is really just stretching and doesn’t have a clue of Hinduism. It all boils down to intent. You can take your "pure exercise routine"and do so with intent to practice Hinduism, and you would then be practicing what you refer to as “Yoga.” There is nothing inherently spiritual about the moves; you must conscientiously place the intent on the moves.

You can also practice Buddhist moving meditation with every action in your entire life, but you obviously must intend it. With the reasoning you have put forth in your post, everybody that moves is a Buddhist.

It’s all about intent, intent, and intent.
 
If you mostly want the stretching benefits, skip Yoga and go with Pilates. However, Yoga is not an antithesis to Catholicism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top