Struggling Catholic College Student

  • Thread starter Thread starter lemilliw3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

lemilliw3

Guest
Hi,

I don’t usually do things like this but I’ve been despairing a lot lately so I figured getting some (name removed by moderator)ut on my situation might be useful.

I am a senior in college this coming year and an RA/Student leader in the Catholic Dorm on my campus. I’ve always been practicing but like everyone have fallen in and out of various times of sin. This last year was amazing, first semester I was absolutely on fire for Christ, attending daily mass, praying regularly, joined a bible study etc. Second semester a few weeks in I started having severe doubts about faith. I was sitting in mass one day praying and was just struck by the thought “what if none of this means anything” and I just couldn’t get it out of my mind. All semester I struggled with despair and this summer it has grown even further in to confusion and I can feel myself teetering on the brink of apathy. I started dating a guy who is also catholic but much more liberal than me. He never tries to push his political opinions or opinions on the church’s teachings on me, but hearing his perspective has made me start questioning mine. Yesterday I came to the realization that I may not be 100% prolife anymore, that I’m starting toview the morning after pill and contraception as a grey area. After my last dating relationship which was unchaste for a time, I swore to myself that I wouldn’t have sex again until marriage. I broke that vow this past weekend and don’t even feel that bad about it. The only reason I feel bad is because I know the Catholic church teaches that premarital sex is wrong. I don’t know how to renew my faith in God. It has been weeks since I’ve received communion because of my constant state of sin. If I go to confession I screw up again soon enough after that I still can’t go to communion. This past semester people just told me to persevere in prayer but I’m so disconnected at this point that I don’t even know how to make myself want to try. I’m terrified of the new semester starting knowing that my heart/thoughts are not in line with my faith.

If anyone has any advice, please share it.

Thank you
 
When I was in college, I quite going to Mass and I got involved in illicit relationships like you’re describing.

At least I went to midnight Mass sometimes, with some girls from Indiana State. (I went to an engineering school Rose-Hulman, in Terre Haute.)

It continued a few years, and then I got hooked. I got married and had six kids and I have not even wanted to stray now for over 23 years. One son is an electrical engineer, one daughter is chemical eng. student, the other four undecided so far, ranging from seventh grade on up. All the kids went to Catholic school starting in kindergarten through high school thus far, and we are active in the parish.

Comparing the two times in my life, when I was young and wild I had a good “party” time. Now I have a great family, and I can’t even imagine wanting to return to the meaningless types of relationships you and I had a college problem with.

Let’s just hope it passes soon, because for sure the chaste life is the way to go. Am I a hypocrite? No, because I’m not putting on any pretenses. I’m telling you where I came from, and I’m saying that the best part about that life is that I’m not in it any more.

I write this in an attempt to encourage you to believe you can come out of this soon. I hope it came across that way. 🙂

Alan

P.S. You might ask your priest if he knows of any spiritual director who could help you. Maturity in the spirit will cause you to let go of attachment to your worldly lusts, I believe.
 
Sometimes when we are bombarded by doubts, the only way we can “bridge” over the troubled period of doubts is to just keep going to Mass, keep saying the daily Rosary.

Mother Theresa of Calcutta had a terrible time with these doubts and spiritual “dryness” … aridity.

It happens a LOT, unfortunately.

One time, I had read a book that threw a lot of doubt on the Real Presence, the Catholic Church’s teaching on Transubstatiation … that the Consecrated Host is the REAL Body and Blood of Jesus Christ. It was very persuasive.

So, there I was sitting in church waiting for daily Mass to start, and my mind began to race: “what is none of this is real?”. It was very intense, and suddenly my mind just “wore out”. My mind went completely blank. And then suddenly, two words popped into my head, “Keep coming.”

And so I did. I kept going to Daily Mass. I kept going to Confession regularly, weekly or sometimes even daily. Priests had no problem with even daily Confession.

The only comment I ever got was that Satan works hardest on those whose faith is the strongest.

Since then, there have been many other “spiritual events”. Even met Satan once.

Stay with it.

Pray constantly. When walking down the hallway or in the parking lot. At the supermarket checkout line. Ask the Holy Spirit to put the right words on your tongue, so that when you open your mouth, always the right words will come out.
 
Hi,

I don’t usually do things like this but I’ve been despairing a lot lately so I figured getting some (name removed by moderator)ut on my situation might be useful.

>>Glad to see that you are reaching out to some of your catholic friends for some valuable (name removed by moderator)ut.

I am a senior in college this coming year and an RA/Student leader in the Catholic Dorm on my campus. I’ve always been practicing but like everyone have fallen in and out of various times of sin.

>>Like yourself, I went to a catholic university and feel in/out of my faith at various levels. As bright young adults, we can sometime over analyze the HE “double hockey sticks” out of things, including our faith. I remember just falling away from my faith and didn’t even know that I was doing it. As a college student, I think I was just too smart for my britches (spelling?), loving my self centered life, and thought that I was smarter than the rest of the world. Over the years, I came to realize the gift (my faith) that I was given and have found that I can live in a secular environment and still be a faithful catholic that has a personal relationship with Christ. A few years after graduating from university, my faith came back with a vengeance, especially in light of marriage, having a baby, and realizing that those unbelievers are really not as ‘cool’ and ‘smart’ as they appear to be at times.

This last year was amazing, first semester I was absolutely on fire for Christ, attending daily mass, praying regularly, joined a bible study etc. Second semester a few weeks in I started having severe doubts about faith.

>>What happened? Was it just too much work to be catholic? No one ever said it would be easy and God understands if you fall sometime.

I was sitting in mass one day praying and was just struck by the thought “what if none of this means anything” and I just couldn’t get it out of my mind. All semester I struggled with despair and this summer it has grown even further in to confusion and I can feel myself teetering on the brink of apathy.

>>The alternative really isn’t so great, so try not to let other people or churches “tickle your ear”. Enjoy humanity for what it is, but I think you’ll find the church to be pretty amazing if you just keep giving it a chance.

I started dating a guy who is also catholic but much more liberal than me. He never tries to push his political opinions or opinions on the church’s teachings on me, but hearing his perspective has made me start questioning mine. Yesterday I came to the realization that I may not be 100% prolife anymore, that I’m starting toview the morning after pill and contraception as a grey area. After my last dating relationship which was unchaste for a time, I swore to myself that I wouldn’t have sex again until marriage. I broke that vow this past weekend and don’t even feel that bad about it. The only reason I feel bad is because I know the Catholic church teaches that premarital sex is wrong. I don’t know how to renew my faith in God.

>>Can I suggest a few simple things…Remember PLUS…Say a Prayer once in a while and try to enjoy just one hour a week in Gods house…a few extra minutes before mass on your knees is a wonderful experience. Learn your faith better…visit sites like this and read some of the recommended books by our wonderful Apologists. Spend time time with other Catholics/Christians in Unity. You might be surprised that your peer group is really affecting you. Sacrifice a bit on a regular basis through Charity…real charity. You might be surprised that you can become stronger in your faith as easy as you find that you can grow away from your faith. If you’re being honest with yourself, you realize the power of sex, but also realize that its purpose is much more than what our society is trying to make it.

It has been weeks since I’ve received communion because of my constant state of sin. If I go to confession I screw up again soon enough after that I still can’t go to communion.

>>Don’t be so hard on yourself, but be honest with yourself. Reconciliation/Confession is a great start, but not the whole picture. You sound like an intelligent person and will make the right decisions with time. As my wife reminds me, were two people, one couple, but each on our own journey.

This past semester people just told me to persevere in prayer but I’m so disconnected at this point that I don’t even know how to make myself want to try. I’m terrified of the new semester starting knowing that my heart/thoughts are not in line with my faith.

>>Again, don’t be so hard on yourself, but don’t fall into the trap of “slamming the faith” just because your roommate or neighbor is doing it. Once you peel back the onion a bit, you’ll probably realize that they have some ghosts in the closet that need to be addressed.

If anyone has any advice, please share it.

Thank you
>>Sorry if I just rambled a bit, I really feel a connection with your story and want you to realize how awesome the faith is. I’ve been blessed in so many ways…a good career, a wonderful wife, 2 beautiful girls, and a deep love of the faith and relationship with God. I’d love to see you have the same.
 
I would suggest praying to St. Gemma Galgani. She has helped me through some difficult times for my faith and I know she continues to pray hard for me. I’m sure she would do the same for you. If you are interested, there is a website about her:

www.stgemmagalgani.com

I will pray for you too.
 
Pray to St. Michael the Archangel. I’ll write more later.
 
My advice for you is going to be difficult, but I’m pretty convinced of it, so here goes.

I think you need to give some serious thought to whether you should continue dating the guy you’re seeing. Clearly, his ideas are not in line with the truth as the Church teaches it, and, sadly, you are beginning to adopt those ideas for yourself.

Another important thing to know is that the sins against purity are one of the chief reasons people leave their faith behind. Think how many people formally leave the Church over contraception, abortion, and divorce/remarriage, and how many stay Catholic in name but whose hearts are far from God because of premarital sex, masturbation, etc.

I can think of three cases just of CAF members who have followed this unfortunate path. Their stories unfolded with every post. They started out as serious Catholics, trying their best to live a virtuous life, and when they gave in to their sexual temptations, they turned away. Interestingly, it was more than just giving in to sin; they began to doubt the faith intellectually as well, seemingly so as to discredit the Church that would not permit them to live as they wished. They went from exemplary, serious Catholics to anti-Catholics and one even an atheist in a very short time.

So, the question for you is, how important is your Catholic Faith to you? Important enough to sacrifice for? If so, you need to give up the sexual sins and draw close to Christ in the Sacraments. Frequent confession is one of your best strategies. The infusion of grace you receive there is quite real and exactly what you need to have the courage to continue. Think seriously about removing dangerous influences from your life, including the guy you are seeing. Which one is more important to you, God, or the guy? It really does come down to this.

God bless you as you struggle to come home to Him.

Betsy
 
Jesus said to his disciples:
“The Kingdom of heaven is like a treasure buried in a field,
which a person finds and hides again,
and out of joy goes and sells all that he has and buys that field.
Again, the Kingdom of heaven is like a merchant
searching for fine pearls.
When he finds a pearl of great price,
he goes and sells all that he has and buys it.”
Today’s reading tells us how precious the kingdom of heaven is. That is to say how precious our faith is. Our faith leads us to the kingdom of heaven.

Faith is a gift. Don’t take it for granted or let go of this precious gift but cultivate it. Stand up from where you fall and keep on keeping on. I agree with Betsy’s suggestion.It is a good idea to break up with the young man who wants to have sex with you. It is important to avoid the occasion near sin.

We ought to seek relationship for true love, not for temporary pleasure. Purity, chastity, and integrity are so important for long term relationship. Even you committed the sexual sin, you can stop doing it and have a recycled virginity. The fact you posted on CAF of your concern shows you care about your faith. Since faith is important to you, then make all the efforts to retain it, like the merchant sells all he has to buy the pearl. Make your efforts for Jesus.
 
I’m also a Catholic college student going to a Catholic university. And I am a senior as well. Its true what someone said earlier: Satan takes special interest in those who are strong in their faith.

It seems like you know where everything went wrong: its the guy. The purpose for dating is to find your future spouse. Our spouses are supposed to bring us closer to God, not further away. I suggest spending serious time in adoration. I dated a guy for a long time that led me away from the Church, and the longer I stayed, the further I strayed. When I finally broke up with him, I was broken myself. But God took that brokenness and completed me.

Either way, welcome to Catholic Answers! You will find so much support and information here, especially when it comes to the Church’s stance on moral issues. And to top it off, you’ll get the arguments you need to (maybe) convince your boyfriend! Who knows? 🤷
 
These Bible verses come from today’s Liturgy of the Hours:

Mid-morning reading (Terce) 1 Peter 1:13-14 ©
Free your minds, then, of encumbrances; control them, and put your trust in nothing but the grace that will be given you when Jesus Christ is revealed. Do not behave in the way that you liked to before you learnt the truth, but make a habit of obedience.

Noon reading (Sext) 1 Peter 1:15-16 ©
Be holy in all you do, since it is the Holy One who has called you, and scripture says: Be holy, for I am holy.

Afternoon reading (None) James 4:7-8,10 ©
Give in to God: resist the devil, and he will run away from you. The nearer you go to God, the nearer he will come to you. Humble yourselves before the Lord and he will lift you up.

universalis.com/-400/today.htm
 
I was sitting in mass one day praying and was just struck by the thought “what if none of this means anything” and I just couldn’t get it out of my mind.
What do you mean, “means anything”?
I swore to myself that I wouldn’t have sex again until marriage. I broke that vow this past weekend and don’t even feel that bad about it. The only reason I feel bad is because I know the Catholic church teaches that premarital sex is wrong.
Sounds like a case of Acedia, look it up. You’re starting not to care that you are drifting from the Church. There is a reason why leaving feels appealing to you or why staying feels appalling to you.

Persevere in prayer. You don’t have to feel like praying to do it, you just have to do it.
 
You don’t really say, what exactly changed between the first semester and the second. Did you stop praying, or cut back on your prayer time? Did you attend Mass with less and less frequency? What about confession?

As The Questioner mentioned, what you’ve described sounds like a case of acedia or slothfulness. This is not the same as laziness - Americans in general are the busiest people and also the most spiritual slothful. Spiritual sloth robs us of our joy. Slothful people find God joyless. This is a sin against charity. Sloth stops us from seeking God and consequently, we do not find Him. As St. Thomas Aquinas said of sloth, it in “an oppressive sorrow which so weighs upon a man’s mind that he wants to do nothing.” It is a symptom or effect of boredom.

St. Thomas Aquinas also explains that lust is a cover-up for sloth. In the Summa he states, “something arises from sorrow in two ways: first, that man shuns whatever causes sorrow, secondly, that he turns to other things that give him pleasure: thus those who find no joy in spiritual pleasures turn to pleasures of the body.”

The cure for sloth: faith. Affirmation of the God who is here, acceptance of God’s offer of Himself. Seek God, for God promises that all who seek Him will find Him. And how do we seek Him? Turn away from sin and seek His face. If your boyfriend is pulling you from God (whether through direct influence or just providing a temptation for you to compromise your faith), you face a choice: continue down the path you’re on or break it off with him and turn back to God. If you stopped praying, going to Mass, and regular confession, turn back and renew your participation in prayer and the sacraments. Ask the Holy Spirit to help you know and understand the teachings of the Church and study them. Even if you don’t feel like it. The feelings won’t always be there - there will be times of testing and dryness. But stick with it. God wants us to love Him for Him, not for the consolations He gives us. Those times of dryness are meant to purify us as we draw closer to Him.

Remember this beatitude: “Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they shall be filled.” If righteousness is what you really want and what you seek, you will be filled in God’s way and in God’s time. Pray for the grace to have faith and persevere - He will be faithful to give it to you.
 
While you consider this, keep in mind that the Church has often been wrong. There is a 2,000 year record of this.

I don’t encourage you to reject the Church. Obviously, many in this forum embrace it. However, be real and fulfill your potential. Be realistic, and understand that the Church was essentially a political institution during most of its growth. If this were not true, then the Vatican would not exist.

Today, it is difficult to discover what moral role the Church should play. The prosaic issues are generally agreed on. With the modern issues, the Church appears to prefer an anachronistic and non-leadership role.

I once asked a friend of mine (who had 4 full professorships at Hopkins) what her definition of mental health was. Her short response was, “the ability to adapt to change.” In this context, the Church is pathological.

There is a power greater than yourself, but beware of the man in the dress and gold lame hat who protected child molesters for political reasons. Children were molested, and they suffered so that he could feel comfortable in his denial. Now he leads the Church. Consider that carefully, when you consider the purity of the Church’s teachings.
 
Pray to St. Maria Goretti. This young girl loved God so much that she sacrificed her life in resisting a rape. Before her death days later she forgave her attacker. She was pure and I love her so much. Its also never a bad idea to remind yourself of the fires of hell form time to time as revealed by the saints and Our Lady of Fatima, in order to motivate you and put the fear of God and his just punishments. Think about the adultress that Christ forgave but also said “go and sin no more.” In order for us to be forgiven, we must show genuine repentance and purpose of amendment.
 
Take heart! We are all tempted by sin and sometimes feel we are failing God. I have certainly struggled with sin in my relationship with God, but I have learned 2 things recently that help to remind me of God’s love for us:
  1. There is no sin bad enough that shame will not make worse - just ask Adam and Eve.
  2. We are not called to the Catholic life to make God like us - He already believes we are irresistible - our failures and shame only affect our own hearts capacity to return His love.
Therefore, during this time of trial, remember that God loves you more than you can ever image and continue to run to Him - no matter how much you feel like running away. After all, it was Paul who tells us to run the race to win and continue to fight the good fight - both examples are invitations to continue to love God deeply and passionately through the Sacraments and service to our neighbors, especially during times of failure.
 
It seems our OP has not seen any of our responses, or at least not logged it. Her “last activity” time is the same as her first and only post. Maybe she’ll come back…

Alan
 
I’m sorry I haven’t replied, I have been reading all of the posts when I get email updates about them, I’ve been pretty busy with work and RA training but I really appreciate all the advice and responses!
 
I’m sorry I haven’t replied, I have been reading all of the posts when I get email updates about them, I’ve been pretty busy with work and RA training but I really appreciate all the advice and responses!
Oh good! I’m glad you are getting a chance to see these. My daughter is in RA training, too … can be hectic.

Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top