Struggling to Remain Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheLordsSon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TheLordsSon

Guest
It’s very frustrating knowing that nobody can give me total faith in God, for weeks I’m a believer, and then the next day I think, “what if it’s just stories told by men” It’s horrible because one of you can say “pray” but how can I pray to something that at that moment I don’t think is listening, I feel like I’m a crazy person sitting in a room talking to something that may or may not be hearing me. People tell me that you just have to have faith, well it’s really hard to have faith in something so good when so many bad things are happening in my life. I understand, that you will say this life is just temporary and heaven is for eternity…Well I my life is a living hell and I just feel so detached from everything. These are just random thoughts, so excuse me if they come off undirected or whatever I just feel like I’m losing my mind.

I just feel for every question a person has about God can be refuted easily but not rationally. Like does God heal this person and not that person, ‘because it’s his will’…
Why do bad things happen to good people, ‘They’re suffering on earth, but they won’t suffer in heaven’’ and so on etc.

It just makes me feel like I’m not practicing catholicism for the right reasons, and I don’t think I’ll ever know (or believe) the truth which drives me insane…but at the same time I try to stay connected with God because I don’t want to fall for ‘Satan’s trap’ (not like I’m going to suddenly go around stealing and murdering) I want to be in heaven but I can already picture myself on my death bed thinking back of the horrible life I had growing up with such big expectations and potential being scared to death of the afterlife…Like In heaven I’ll still be bitter about my earthly life…man I wish I was ignorant, dumb, and sublime so I wouldn’t be in the positions I put myself into…while friends go out and enjoy summer, I’m hurting physically, mentally, emotionally, and spiritually to such a high degree I don’t know how I’m going to make it the rest of my life not in a psych ward or something.
 
I think what you describe is common, if people are being honest.

Why not go speak to a priest? It might help tremendously. Or you could read Come Be My Light and find out that Blessed Mother Teresa of Calcutta herself experienced similar thoughts.

You’re not alone in this.
 
I think what you describe is common, if people are being honest.

Why not go speak to a priest? It might help tremendously. Or you could read Come Be My Light and find out that Blessed Mother Teresa of Calcutta herself experienced similar thoughts.

You’re not alone in this.
That’s the thing, talking to a priest is still someone who cannot give me any answers that will remove my doubts; he’s going to refer to the bible or his own faith it’s like a never ending cycle that’s just making me so furious. Everything can be explained by catholics but it’s using faith, and if you don’t have it then you don’t have the answers. And even when I do have it…it’s like 'okay I’ve convinced myself that God exists because: 1.) I’m afraid to go to hell 2.) I want to be in heaven 3.) My life on earth sucks (trust me, no pity story it really does) so I need something to look forward to in the afterlife. 4.) I love Jesus for dying for my sins… Then all of the sudden my faith goes straight out the window and I’m hopeless again. I’m even hopeless with God in my life because deep down inside I’m praying because I have no other realistic options, I’m calling on God because there is nothing else that can save me. It’s like a kid that finds out Santa’s not real but still writes letters because he still wants to believe.

I just find it so hard to understand why God places such burdens on people and expect such blind faith back, I’m human for crying out loud. I understand he put himself on the earth and suffered like man but he’s GOD, he knew GOD exists and in that thinking it’s understandable how holy he acted. I’m just frustrated that all I have left in life is a religion that I reverted back to because I have nothing left, and I’m feeling as if I’m losing that too…what will it take for me to realize that God is the way? Sorry for the long post, just very frustrated, on top of everything else in my life crumbling around me and trying to keep a smile the spiritual problems are stacking up too…I just wish I could go back to being a kid, where I worried about cartoons and baseball…
 
TheLordsSon,

Don’t allow yourself to despair…pray and be assured that God hears you. He does allow us to have struggles, but does not abandon us when He sees that we really want Him in our lives.

It can’t hurt to talk to a priest, and perhaps even do some spiritual reading? Nothing is hopeless.

Hope springs eternal!

Talk to our Blessed Mother as well. Don’t give up…Mary cares deeply about all her Son’s children. He gave her to us as our spiritual Mother.
 
That’s the thing, talking to a priest is still someone who cannot give me any answers that will remove my doubts; he’s going to refer to the bible or his own faith it’s like a never ending cycle that’s just making me so furious. Everything can be explained by catholics but it’s using faith, and if you don’t have it then you don’t have the answers. And even when I do have it…it’s like 'okay I’ve convinced myself that God exists because: 1.) I’m afraid to go to hell 2.) I want to be in heaven 3.) My life on earth sucks (trust me, no pity story it really does) so I need something to look forward to in the afterlife. 4.) I love Jesus for dying for my sins… Then all of the sudden my faith goes straight out the window and I’m hopeless again. I’m even hopeless with God in my life because deep down inside I’m praying because I have no other realistic options, I’m calling on God because there is nothing else that can save me. It’s like a kid that finds out Santa’s not real but still writes letters because he still wants to believe.
Trust me man, we use reason, for example look at some of these videos a preist has done on God and Christianity wordonfire.org/WOF-TV/Faith-Clips-new.aspx

I will pray for you!
 
Hello. I can kind of relate to what you’re saying, because back when I was still a Protestant, I went through a major crisis of faith from 2002 to 2008. I had doubts about God’s existence. I prayed the Our Father almost every day during that period, but I felt like I was just going through the motions. Then, back in late 2007 or early 2008, I prayed that God would help me to become interested in him again, and that he would help me believe again. It took a little while, but God set a chain of events in motion, which eventually led me to the Catholic Church.

If I were you, I would pray a sincere prayer to God, through Jesus Christ our Lord, to help you to overcome your unbelief. It sounds to me like you want to believe, but your doubts are just getting in the way. This was exactly what was happening to me during my crisis of faith. I would also take the advice of the other poster, and talk to a priest about this. It would probably also be beneficial to talk about it in Confession. The priest could give you much needed advice in this sacrament, as I am learning. If you pray for Jesus to help you overcome your unbelief, and your sincere, I don’t see why he wouldn’t help you, since he has helped me, and he is even helping me now in some areas that I’ve been struggling with.
 
TheLordsSon,

Don’t allow yourself to despair…pray and be assured that God hears you. He does allow us to have struggles, but does not abandon us when He sees that we really want Him in our lives.

It can’t hurt to talk to a priest, and perhaps even do some spiritual reading? Nothing is hopeless.

Hope springs eternal!

Talk to our Blessed Mother as well. Don’t give up…Mary cares deeply about all her Son’s children. He gave her to us as our spiritual Mother.
Pray for what though, that I regain my faith? All of the sudden will it hit me? I feel as if I’m praying to a parent that’s not in the room and hoping that they come back with what I prayed for. Like I said, everything your telling me to do stems from having faith…spiritual reading is reading man’s word, why would I believe a man’s opinion of God the same time an athiest is putting his words down on paper. Humans don’t have the answers to give me, and I can’t receive God’s answers, I’m stuck at a crossroads that really seems impossible. You suggest talking to Mary, well Mary doesn’t talk back to me…I know your guys are just trying to help but I’m just expressing how I’m feeling, a week ago I had such devout faith and today I feel like I lost everything. I won’t give up because I can’t give up since I already ruined my life on earth (long story short, I made some unfixable mistakes) I’m searching for answers and reasons but I can’t find them! I’m afraid I’ll never have true inner peace, it’s hard because I’m miserable with and without my faith.
 
Dear brother,

Sailor has it right…we all carry doubts around with us from time to time, if we are honest.

Some of the saints had it bad: take a look at the story of St. John of the Cross. So we know that Satan’s best effort is to make us doubt about G-d’s presence, and then doubt about our own capability to know Him.

Please try some positive things, and don’t despair if they “seem” not to work…that is also Satan playing with your mind.

Pray, pray, pray. Give G-d your troubles. He WILL resolve them, though not exactly as you may have planned.

If you have trouble focusing on your prayers, open your Bible…anywhere…and start to read. Take the words as if G-d is speaking directly to you…He is. The Psalms are particularly good about this communication with G-d.

Be open to opportunities to learn more about our Faith. Summer is a slack season (usually) for Parish education efforts, but even Bible study will speak to you.

Ask for prayers from others to help you understand what is happening to you. You have our prayers already…please take some comfort in that.

And, last, I would suggest a personal retreat at a nearby monastery, if that is available to you. Benedictines and Trappists are particularly welcoming, and you may speak with a monk or priest while you are there about your tortured journey. Usually, any cost is your optional donation. But the beauty of this time is joining in community prayer and Mass, and the quiet that will allow you to think about your options better.

Take heart, please! We will pray for you.
 
If you’re like a lot of us, when challenges to our faith arise, which they inevitably will, there’s still no where else to go. Jesus has the words of eternal life. He* knows*. And for whatever the world has to offer us, we still know inside that it’s not enough. So we’re trapped, in a way, by God, and this is good-and it gets better; it may not seem like it now but faith becomes surer, as challenges simply come and go. That’s just part of the struggle, the process.

For myself there have always been other reasons for faith than the ones you mentioned. I needed to know-to know if there really was such a thing as hope and truth and justice and love in this messed up world which is fueled mainly on human ego. And the Cross runs counter to all that-so I’m “stuck” with it, but I’m very, very glad to be-because it’s confirmed to me more often than not that Jesus’ path is the right one to follow.
 
Hello. I can kind of relate to what you’re saying, because back when I was still a Protestant, I went through a major crisis of faith from 2002 to 2008. I had doubts about God’s existence. I prayed the Our Father almost every day during that period, but I felt like I was just going through the motions. Then, back in late 2007 or early 2008, I prayed that God would help me to become interested in him again, and that he would help me believe again. It took a little while, but God set a chain of events in motion, which eventually led me to the Catholic Church.

If I were you, I would pray a sincere prayer to God, through Jesus Christ our Lord, to help you to overcome your unbelief. It sounds to me like you want to believe, but your doubts are just getting in the way. This was exactly what was happening to me during my crisis of faith. I would also take the advice of the other poster, and talk to a priest about this. It would probably also be beneficial to talk about it in Confession. The priest could give you much needed advice in this sacrament, as I am learning. If you pray for Jesus to help you overcome your unbelief, and your sincere, I don’t see why he wouldn’t help you, since he has helped me, and he is even helping me now in some areas that I’ve been struggling with.
How can you be so sure that it’s not you just helping yourself with the belief that you have spiritual backing? Like a coincidence happened and you base that on God helping you? I just don’t understand how I can ever have full faith without any doubts in my life. I want to believe wholeheartedly, I want to be blessed in life but I feel like my mind was overtime developed to not be able to fully jump into something and throw caution to the wind. I don’t possess that type of mind state to sustain that type of thinking over long amounts of time. I have such massive, horrid problems that I wouldn’t even dream of as a child…and that itself is hard enough; but I need God in my life. I need him to know how much I really do need him to care for me, because I can’t do it alone.

It’s just hard knowing that I’ll be alone for the rest of my life fighting this, I just wish I didn’t have so many burdens even though they’ve been almost self inflicted…
 
Praying for you from today’s Liturgy of the Hours:

Having suffered much, you entered into the Father’s glory:
look upon those who mourn and turn their sadness into rejoicing.
– Lord, give us peace and joy.
 
That’s the thing, talking to a priest is still someone who cannot give me any answers that will remove my doubts; he’s going to refer to the bible or his own faith it’s like a never ending cycle that’s just making me so furious. Everything can be explained by catholics but it’s using faith, and if you don’t have it then you don’t have the answers. And even when I do have it…it’s like 'okay I’ve convinced myself that God exists because: 1.) I’m afraid to go to hell 2.) I want to be in heaven 3.) My life on earth sucks (trust me, no pity story it really does) so I need something to look forward to in the afterlife. 4.) I love Jesus for dying for my sins… Then all of the sudden my faith goes straight out the window and I’m hopeless again. I’m even hopeless with God in my life because deep down inside I’m praying because I have no other realistic options, I’m calling on God because there is nothing else that can save me. It’s like a kid that finds out Santa’s not real but still writes letters because he still wants to believe.

I just find it so hard to understand why God places such burdens on people and expect such blind faith back, I’m human for crying out loud. I understand he put himself on the earth and suffered like man but he’s GOD, he knew GOD exists and in that thinking it’s understandable how holy he acted. I’m just frustrated that all I have left in life is a religion that I reverted back to because I have nothing left, and I’m feeling as if I’m losing that too…what will it take for me to realize that God is the way? Sorry for the long post, just very frustrated, on top of everything else in my life crumbling around me and trying to keep a smile the spiritual problems are stacking up too…I just wish I could go back to being a kid, where I worried about cartoons and baseball…
Why do you assume a priest will react in a certain way? They’re there to help you. I just went to one with many of those same problems and I feel much better now.

There’s help out there. Don’t deny yourself that help.

And a lot of people do think or wonder the same things as you.
 
Pray for what though, that I regain my faith? All of the sudden will it hit me? I feel as if I’m praying to a parent that’s not in the room and hoping that they come back with what I prayed for. Like I said, everything your telling me to do stems from having faith…spiritual reading is reading man’s word, why would I believe a man’s opinion of God the same time an athiest is putting his words down on paper. Humans don’t have the answers to give me, and I can’t receive God’s answers, I’m stuck at a crossroads that really seems impossible. You suggest talking to Mary, well Mary doesn’t talk back to me…I know your guys are just trying to help but I’m just expressing how I’m feeling, a week ago I had such devout faith and today I feel like I lost everything. I won’t give up because I can’t give up since I already ruined my life on earth (long story short, I made some unfixable mistakes) I’m searching for answers and reasons but I can’t find them! I’m afraid I’ll never have true inner peace, it’s hard because I’m miserable with and without my faith.
I will pray for you. Nothing is impossible for God.
 
Why do you assume a priest will react in a certain way? They’re there to help you. I just went to one with many of those same problems and I feel much better now.

There’s help out there. Don’t deny yourself that help.

And a lot of people do think or wonder the same things as you.
I understand but I feel like there’s nothing anybody could say to me to make me have that same faith. I’m not trying to be difficult, I’m just being realistic with my own thoughts and ideas. Trust me, more than anything in the world I want to believe but I don’t want it to be phony…I know people have felt the same way, I know priests and saints have felt the same way, but that doesn’t make me feel any more comfortable if anything it just makes me more reluctant… how could such holy people could lose their faith? Feels like I’m running in circles, I’m pursuing God again because I’m not happy but even with God I still feel unhappy. No amount of medication or therapy will cure my unhappiness I just wish God could show me a sign so I could find some comfort on this earth.

And what’s with Satan supposedly influencing people? What happened to free will? Or is any sort of questioning god’s existence just assumed to be of satan’s work.
 
Perhaps when you pray you should not be asking for worldly things. Instead try to pray for salvation. You do not have to speak out loud, because God can hear your thoughts.

Try contemplating on the life of Christ, and the mysteries of God in your prayer. You can do this by praying the Rosary. By contemplating on the life of Christ while you pray, instead of just asking for things it won’t feel so much like you are ‘talking to yourself’ since you will be meditating on something instead of just asking for stuff. Would you feel crazy if you just sat in a chair and thought about something? I doubt it since obviously you are thinking about this sort of thing and contemplating it-- you are already doing that! So meditate on the mysteries of God in prayer, and when you are done praying then ask for whatever you need. If you are not reading your bible, I would suggest you also do that.
 
How can you be so sure that it’s not you just helping yourself with the belief that you have spiritual backing? Like a coincidence happened and you base that on God helping you? I just don’t understand how I can ever have full faith without any doubts in my life. I want to believe wholeheartedly, I want to be blessed in life but I feel like my mind was overtime developed to not be able to fully jump into something and throw caution to the wind. I don’t possess that type of mind state to sustain that type of thinking over long amounts of time. I have such massive, horrid problems that I wouldn’t even dream of as a child…and that itself is hard enough; but I need God in my life. I need him to know how much I really do need him to care for me, because I can’t do it alone.

It’s just hard knowing that I’ll be alone for the rest of my life fighting this, I just wish I didn’t have so many burdens even though they’ve been almost self inflicted…
A small, but tangible miracle happened with a family member bac in 1993, when I was a teenager, and I’m convinced that God was the one who allowed me to remember it years later, and that memory is a lot of the reason I’m where I’m at today. It snapped me the rest of the way out of my crisis of faith.

When you pray, try your best to have at least a little bit of faith. If you are truely seeking God, God will come to you. Jesus says as much in Scripture.

You’re not alone in your suffering, especially if you offer it up to Jesus Christ. If you’ve been to Confession about the self inflicted part, and you’ve made a good Confession, your sins are forgiven. You could also talk to your priest about the possibility of partaking in the sacrament of Anointing of the Sick for your physical and mental suffering. That was recently suggested by my priest, and I’m considering it for myself.
 
I understand but I feel like there’s nothing anybody could say to me to make me have that same faith. I’m not trying to be difficult, I’m just being realistic with my own thoughts and ideas. Trust me, more than anything in the world I want to believe but I don’t want it to be phony…I know people have felt the same way, I know priests and saints have felt the same way, but that doesn’t make me feel any more comfortable if anything it just makes me more reluctant… how could such holy people could lose their faith? Feels like I’m running in circles, I’m pursuing God again because I’m not happy but even with God I still feel unhappy. No amount of medication or therapy will cure my unhappiness I just wish God could show me a sign so I could find some comfort on this earth.

And what’s with Satan supposedly influencing people? What happened to free will? Or is any sort of questioning god’s existence just assumed to be of satan’s work.
Nothing has happened to free will. We all have it, and, with the help of the grace of God we make the right choices with it.

Please remember that satan is on a leash, so to speak. God will not allow us to be tempted beyond what we can endure. His grace is available if it is accepted.

Satan is not to be blamed for everything. There are three things: 1) the world 2)the flesh 3) the devil.

And, Christ is for us, and is there in prayer and the Sacraments of the Church.

The saints (John of the Cross was mentioned previously) did not lose their faith. Perhaps before their conversion they had such problems with faith.

On their spiritual journey to the Lord they may experience a “dark night of faith” during which they cling to faith in the Lord by an act of their will and desire, in spite of not having consolations. (Good feelings). That is how their faith is strengthened. God allows that, and when they cling to Him in this “dark night” without consolations, He then gives them the peace that only He can give. The Lord knows best what we need. Our salvation and happiness is His number one concern.
 
Nothing has happened to free will. We all have it, and, with the help of the grace of God we make the right choices with it.

Please remember that satan is on a leash, so to speak. God will not allow us to be tempted beyond what we can endure. His grace is available if it is accepted.

Satan is not to be blamed for everything. There are three things: 1) the world 2)the flesh 3) the devil.

And, Christ is for us, and is there in prayer and the Sacraments of the Church.

The saints (John of the Cross was mentioned previously) did not lose their faith. Perhaps before their conversion they had such problems with faith.

On their spiritual journey to the Lord they may experience a “dark night of faith” during which they cling to faith in the Lord by an act of their will and desire, in spite of not having consolations. (Good feelings). That is how their faith is strengthened. God allows that, and when they cling to Him in this “dark night” without consolations, He then gives them the peace that only He can give. The Lord knows best what we need. Our salvation and happiness is His number one concern.
‘God will not aloud us to be tempted beyond what we cannot endure’

That doesn’t make any sense to me, that’s basically saying that he allows Satan to continually tempt us with anything because we could actually say no to any temptation. Are we ever tempted by God to do things? Or is that just our own moral conscience? Could you understand the reasoning behind somebody saying religion is a way to control the masses? Every comment I’ve received to find God has been to pray to God, or trust in God, or talk to a priest, or read a catholic book…it’s almost beginning to feel like religions are one big answer to a never ending question. If an angel was put on this earth with no prior relocation of Heaven, the trinity, God, etc. would he still hold his same values and principles? Why does he expect mere mortals to be so intellectual to believe and have faith in something that happened over 2,000 years ago. Don’t take this as blasphemous or hatred, I’m just trying to wrap my head around it. And commenting on the ‘dark night of faith’ is the same type of rational the catholic church always uses to explain something using their own teachings. Like, yes we go through long periods of doubt but don’t worry just go back to having total faith and you’ll be soon ignoring those doubts again…what if these ‘dark nights of faith’ is the ‘light days of truth’ and were just snapping out of it? It’s like I’m stuck in religion limbo, a walking paradox.

I’m in my very early twenties and guaranteed sterile, being catholic wouldn’t be so hard as a thirty year old married man with three kids. As a a devout practicing catholic (not just the one’s that go to mass every sunday) I basically lock myself inside because there’s too many temptations in the world from lust to drinking in excess or gossiping…it’s like throwing bones in front of a dogs face and slapping him on the head when they go to eat it…I’m tired, confused, and just want to find answers not from what I’m questioning if that makes sense.
 
We are never, ever tempted by God. Just the three ways I mentioned, the world, the flesh, and the devil.

I obviously don’t have any answers that satisfy you right now, but I promise to pray for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top