Re the Inquisition, Crusades, and other harsh measures imposed on dissenters from the medieval Church:
In those days there was no such thing as separation of Church and State. Church law and civil law were closely intertwined, and each institution relied upon the other for support and enforcement of its laws. The State also was believed to speak with the force of God just as much as the Church did, since kings were believed to rule by divine right. The concept of the divine right of kings didn’t disappear from English law until the late 17th century, and not until later in other countries.
Heresy was a crime under CIVIL law as well as church law because it was regarded as a grave threat to society, along the same lines as treason or sedition. In fact an argument could be made that it is a worse crime than “ordinary” treason or murder because the latter crimes threaten only one’s earthly existence, while heresy threatens one’s eternal soul. After the Reformation, countries that were ruled by Protestant or Anglican monarchs took the same stance against Catholics and treated THEM as an intolerable threat to society for the same reason.
Ever since 9/11 there has been a heated debate going on over whether the U.S. has the right to torture terrorist suspects. Some people argue that any kind of torture would be completely justified if it were necessary to prevent future attacks. Well, the people who ran the Inquisition used similar reasoning – what they were doing was justified because they were trying to save potentially thousands of innocent souls from being led away from the Faith and eventually going to hell.
Since then, of course, we have developed the concept of Church-State separation and freedom of religion under civil law. Also, the Church has come to realize that respectful evangelism and clear teaching rather than coercion is the best way to combat heresy. God respects our free will, and we must respect the free will of others while being clear about what we ourselves believe.
In order to understand the Inquisition you have to take into account the fact that they lived under a whole different concept of the relationship between church and state than we have today. I’m not “defending” them, just explaining where they were coming from.