Struggling With the Inquisition

  • Thread starter Thread starter patricius79
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The question is this, is it possible for that human mediator to have been mistaken?
No. It was not possible for the authors of sacred scripture to have been mistaken about what they wrote. They were protected from error by the Holy Spirit.
 
Interestng.

Why then do you suppose that people frequently bring up the Crusades and the Inquisition when they are listing their grievances against the Catholic Church?
Because many people (Catholic and Protestant) simply parrot back that which they’ve been spoon-fed and never take a serious look at it with an adult intellect to attempt a determination of it’s validity for themselves. Of course, many people also do and that’s why some of us can have a reasonable discourse about these things (be the individual Protestant or Catholic) while others simply insist on mud slinging at one another.
 
Perhaps…if the Church really did anything wrong. Perhaps some reading will help you decide.

Articles on the Crusades

THE CRUSADES 101

by James Akin
catholic.net/rcc/Periodicals/Dossier/2002-02/article3.html

The Real History of the Crusades
By Thomas F. Madden
oldarchive.godspy.com/issues/Real-History-of-Crusades-by-Thomas-Madden.cfm.html

Crusade Myths
By Thomas F. Madden
ignatiusinsight.com/features2005/tmadden_crusademyths_feb05.asp

CRUSADING FOR THE TRUTH
By Robert P. Lockwood
catholic.com/thisrock/2006/0603tbt.asp
I read the four articles linked on the first page, if you’ve read those and these could you summarize the information from these that’s not in those if any please?
 
No. It was not possible for the authors of sacred scripture to have been mistaken about what they wrote. They were protected from error by the Holy Spirit.
I would agree with that, but apparently many do not.
 
I read the four articles linked on the first page, if you’ve read those and these could you summarize the information from these that’s not in those if any please?
The first batch were on the Inquisition. These are on the Crusades.
 
This isn’t a problem for those of us who don’t believe the RCC is infallible… just sayin’
Sin and infallibility have nothing to do with each other.

What, if anything, do you think the inquisition (or a sinful act of any Catholic) proves about the Catholic Church?

Chuck
 
Do a search here on CAF for the Inquisition and also for the Crusades (they are linked).

There is also, somewhere, a list of books and other related references to the Inquisition and the Crusades.
 
It cracks me up to hear some catholics say “What did the church do wrong?” when defending the inquisition.

:rotfl:
 
It cracks me up to hear some catholics say “What did the church do wrong?” when defending the inquisition.

:rotfl:
Out of curiosity, did you read the articles linked to earlier in the thread?
 
It cracks me up to hear some catholics say “What did the church do wrong?” when defending the inquisition.

:rotfl:
As I wrote earlier, we have an obligation to be serious about serious things.

Let me ask you a question, and I really expect you to give a thoughtful answer. What would you say to an atheist who said “it really cracks me up to hear some Christians say ‘What did God do wrong?’ when defending this:”

While the people of Israel were in the wilderness, they found a man gathering sticks on the sabbath day.
And those who found him gathering sticks brought him to Moses and Aaron, and to all the congregation.
They put him in custody, because it had not been made plain what should be done to him.
And the LORD said to Moses, "The man shall be put to death; all the congregation shall stone him with stones outside the camp.
And all the congregation brought him outside the camp, and stoned him to death with stones, as the LORD commanded Moses.

Or would you also be too busy cracking up to offer a defense?
 
Re the Inquisition, Crusades, and other harsh measures imposed on dissenters from the medieval Church:

In those days there was no such thing as separation of Church and State. Church law and civil law were closely intertwined, and each institution relied upon the other for support and enforcement of its laws. The State also was believed to speak with the force of God just as much as the Church did, since kings were believed to rule by divine right. The concept of the divine right of kings didn’t disappear from English law until the late 17th century, and not until later in other countries.

Heresy was a crime under CIVIL law as well as church law because it was regarded as a grave threat to society, along the same lines as treason or sedition. In fact an argument could be made that it is a worse crime than “ordinary” treason or murder because the latter crimes threaten only one’s earthly existence, while heresy threatens one’s eternal soul. After the Reformation, countries that were ruled by Protestant or Anglican monarchs took the same stance against Catholics and treated THEM as an intolerable threat to society for the same reason.

Ever since 9/11 there has been a heated debate going on over whether the U.S. has the right to torture terrorist suspects. Some people argue that any kind of torture would be completely justified if it were necessary to prevent future attacks. Well, the people who ran the Inquisition used similar reasoning – what they were doing was justified because they were trying to save potentially thousands of innocent souls from being led away from the Faith and eventually going to hell.

Since then, of course, we have developed the concept of Church-State separation and freedom of religion under civil law. Also, the Church has come to realize that respectful evangelism and clear teaching rather than coercion is the best way to combat heresy. God respects our free will, and we must respect the free will of others while being clear about what we ourselves believe.

In order to understand the Inquisition you have to take into account the fact that they lived under a whole different concept of the relationship between church and state than we have today. I’m not “defending” them, just explaining where they were coming from.
 
I just want to say that this is an awesome thread. I recommend that everyone, who hasn’t done so, go read those articles on the inquisition and the crusades. Thank you to those who linked them.
 
It cracks me up to hear some catholics say “What did the church do wrong?” when defending the inquisition.
Would you mind sharing a few thoughts about what you believe the Church’s culpability is/was?

Is this one of those cultural things that everybody just “knows” to be factual? Like, everybody just “knows” that Oswald acted alone? Or is it that everybody just “knows” that there was a second gunman on the grassy knoll?

What is it about the Catholic Church’s connection to the Inquisition that you just “know” to be true?

Thanks.
 
It cracks me up to hear some catholics say “What did the church do wrong?” when defending the inquisition.

:rotfl:
Thats it? Thats your sole contribtution to a discussion on the Inquisition?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top