Study: Millennials more conservative politically than past generations

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ridgerunner;
But it’s not difficult to see problems with the article even so. It cites conclusions (no facts) from a British study. “Conservatism” in Britain is not the same as in the U.S. It concludes (without evidence) that prejudice is more prevalent among persons of lower intelligence. But that’s totally without analysis. Upon what is that based, and what was the population upon which it was based? Was there a selection bias? We don’t know because the article just states opinions and no facts.
The article of course is a summation of the new study, by Gordon Hodson, a psychologist at Brock University in Ontario and commented on by Brian Nosek, a social and cognitive psychologist at the University of Virginia.

The studies you mention above were earlier studies done in The United Kingdom which looked at babies born in the 50’s and then in the 70’s. The results were the same.

In comparing his study to those, Hodson found the same.
Consider this. In the news clips from last night’s riots, we saw a black man shout that “all whites are devils”. Now, there’s prejudice with a capital “P”. Did he say that because his IQ is low (if it is) or did he say it out of a cultural bias, or did he say it out of bad experiences he or those he knows had with whites?
He said it of out ignorance of course, because even if he had bad experiences with some whites, it’s not a reflection of all whites which he was grouping his prejudice on.

I was beat up by a group of blacks when I was coming out of the enlisted men’s club in Okinawa, back in 1971. The experience at first turned me into an instant racist, for I had no experience with black people prior to entering into the Marine Corps.

However, intelligence gained through faith, made me realize painting the entire black race with the same brush was wrong. I got over racism through the grace of God, but also using intelligence.
I think I can say without too much fear of being wrong that if you tested the attitudes toward blacks among Hispanics, the antipathy level would be much more prevalent than if you tested those of white suburbanites of exactly the same IQ. Why? It’s both cultural and, for some, experiential. Did they control for that? Doubtful, but if they did, it’s not stated or explained in the article.
The studies have to go under peer review by the University before being release, so I’m sure it wasn’t just based on Hodson’s opinion alone.

Again, its a summation of the study, which I’m sure if you dig deeper, you could find.

Jim
 
It seems to me almost “ethnicist” to insist that “foreigners” are incapable of coming up with their own ambitions, based on their own cultures, beliefs and biases, and depend on the West or the U.S. for them. Would the Iranian mullahs who never hesitate to butcher their own people really be nice guys but for the CIA?
“Own people!” A phrase from anti-communist propaganda. We could also say that Pinochet, Videla, Montt, and Suharto are butchers of “their own people”.
Islam was aggressive in its very cradle, and won its empire with fire and sword. It is only in very modern times that it seemed quiescent; times when the west was so overwhelmingly powerful that Islam itself was on the retreat. Is there a really compelling reason to believe that such a history (not to mention its literature) has no reverberations in the psyche of some modern Muslims?
We seem to be forgetting about the The Crusades, Thirty Years War, the Napoleonic Wars, and World War I as examples of the Western war-mongering before the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.
 
“Own people!” A phrase from anti-communist propaganda. We could also say that Pinochet, Videla, Montt, and Suharto are butchers of “their own people”.

We seem to be forgetting about the The Crusades, Thirty Years War, the Napoleonic Wars, and World War I as examples of the Western war-mongering before the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.
Other than the Crusades, the others were not fought on religious basis.

The Crusades were fought for religious reasons, but in defense against Islam which had shut down the Holy Land and were on the verge of wiping out the Byzantines. Pope Urban hoped that the Crusades would open the Holy Land, but also reunite the Byzantines with the Rome.

1000 years of hindsight shows that they were probably a bad idea, but at the time after having suffered 100 years of Islamic aggression in Spain and France,the mindset to establish the crusade made it possible.

Anyway, its a different topic and I hope we don’t trash the thread on this.

Jim
 
Ridgerunner;

The article of course is a summation of the new study, by Gordon Hodson, a psychologist at Brock University in Ontario and commented on by Brian Nosek, a social and cognitive psychologist at the University of Virginia.

The studies you mention above were earlier studies done in The United Kingdom which looked at babies born in the 50’s and then in the 70’s. The results were the same.

In comparing his study to those, Hodson found the same.

He said it of out ignorance of course, because even if he had bad experiences with some whites, it’s not a reflection of all whites which he was grouping his prejudice on.

I was beat up by a group of blacks when I was coming out of the enlisted men’s club in Okinawa, back in 1971. The experience at first turned me into an instant racist, for I had no experience with black people prior to entering into the Marine Corps.

However, intelligence gained through faith, made me realize painting the entire black race with the same brush was wrong. I got over racism through the grace of God, but also using intelligence.

The studies have to go under peer review by the University before being release, so I’m sure it wasn’t just based on Hodson’s opinion alone.

Again, its a summation of the study, which I’m sure if you dig deeper, you could find.

Jim
The fact remains, however, that the cited article is totally derivative and expresses only conclusions. No actual facts. It is the writer’s interpretation of the conclusions of another, based (we’re assured) on studies, not one fact of which is shown. Not so much as a whiff of actual proof.

It’s all conclusion, therefore the writer’s opinion. Peer review of an article (which wasn’t this one in any case) does not guarantee validity. Sometimes it’s only a reflection of a shared belief…or bias.
 
The fact remains, however, that the cited article is totally derivative and expresses only conclusions. No actual facts. It is the writer’s interpretation of the conclusions of another, based (we’re assured) on studies, not one fact of which is shown. Not so much as a whiff of actual proof.

It’s all conclusion, therefore the writer’s opinion. Peer review of an article (which wasn’t this one in any case) does not guarantee validity. Sometimes it’s only a reflection of a shared belief…or bias.
I think you just proved the study’s results. 😃

Jim
 
Quote:

Low IQ & Conservative Beliefs Linked to Prejudice

here’s no gentle way to put it: People who give in to racism and prejudice may simply be dumb, according to a new study that is bound to stir public controversy.

The research finds that children with low intelligence are more likely to hold prejudiced attitudes as adults. These findings point to a vicious cycle, according to lead researcher Gordon Hodson, a psychologist at Brock University in Ontario. Low-intelligence adults tend to gravitate toward socially conservative ideologies, the study found. Those ideologies, in turn, stress hierarchy and resistance to change, attitudes that can contribute to prejudice, Hodson wrote in an email to LiveScience.

livescience.com/18132-int…sm-racism.html

Probably explains the state of the nation today, with the current riots in SC and such.

Jim
Some of this (not the low intelligence part) has been known for a long time.

At least the “authoritarian personality type,” which is more prejudiced, paranoid, hierarchically-minded – groveling to authoritarian leaders. Seeing things in stereotypes, black & white, not in complexity.

Some Jewish sociologists who escaped Nazi Germany (incl Theodor Adorno) did a study on it, thinking it was the Germans who had this “authoritarian personality,” which is why so many supported Hitler. They thought that Americans, who favor freedom, would not have this personality type, but when they did their study they found that Americans had it to a large extent, I think as much as in Germany. They were stunned.

That low intelligence people are more likely to be prejudiced fits with what my niece experienced. She was a dark-complexioned person from India, came to the US as a small child, and got involved with her Catholic parish’s social service programs as a teen, such as the choir going to visit mental institutions where they met children with severe mental issues, very low IQs. They singled her out as the only non-white in the group and expressed racial prejudice towards her. She was stunned & very hurt, bec she went there to give aid and comfort to those institutionalized children.

So, it does seem, yes, that more low IQ people could be prejudiced compared with the general population.

OTOH, there are some very smart people who are in the conservative movement. But it does make sense that on the whole the Trump followers might be lower intelligence. I think they did find them to be less educated.
 
That is ludicrous. Asians tend to have higher average IQ’s than whites yet their societies can be quite hostile to outsiders. This is typical Liberal snobbery, “Anyone who disagrees with us is a dumb bigot.”

This is why Trump is going to win and make America great again. This shaming is no longer working, especially for the average white male who realizes that the Left despises him for who he is and no amount of virtue signaling will ever redeem him of the original sins of being white and male.
 
If intelligence brings us a self-satisfied rebellion against God’s laws, then let me be stoopid!
 
I certainly agree that people make wrong decisions. I certainly agree that corruption is real, and I’m grateful I’m not in a position where I must make such decisions, because I know I’m not qualified and simply don’t have access to all the information they have. People do indeed die from leaked intel. I just don’t agree with throwing the baby out with the bath water, and I disagree that all people around the world are content to live and let live.
Your only defense to all the dirty deeds done by US intelligence agencies is that I cannot disprove the existence of any positive effects. I do not have to. Those government employees swear an oath to the Constitution. Blatant disregard of that oath is justification for shutting them down.

Agreed, not everyone wants to live and let live, but what do you think is the reason the average guy joins a terrorist group? Because he hates nameless and faceless Americans for the freedom the NSA has taken from us or the CIA sky robots that killed his family? How about we set the example of living and letting live first?
 
That is ludicrous. Asians tend to have higher average IQ’s than whites yet their societies can be quite hostile to outsiders. This is typical Liberal snobbery, “Anyone who disagrees with us is a dumb bigot.”

This is why Trump is going to win and make America great again. This shaming is no longer working, especially for the average white male who realizes that the Left despises him for who he is and no amount of virtue signaling will ever redeem him of the original sins of being white and male.
You have to understand that there are tremendous complexities in human behavior and thought. Aside from IQ, there are cultural and social influences, experiential influences (maybe someone was attacked by a minority person and struggles without success against being prejudice against all in that group).

There is also the issue of “marked” v. “unmarked” status. Those who are “mainstream” in our society (white, male) have an “unmarked” status, so any bad thing a person in that category does is usually not attributed to his category or all white males. Those who are minorities have “marked” statuses, so any bad thing a single person in that marked category does is more likely to be attributed to all in that category.

I’ve done my own studies re the Dalits (Untouchables) in India and that’s what I found, with a lot of supporting studies based on race relations and prejudice in America.

As mentioned, based on the experience my niece had at the mental institution, it would not surprise me if they found that lower IQ persons were more racist and prejudice in general. Think about it. We all use stereotypes and schema; life would be difficult if we did not and had to think out everything at all times in all life’s complexities. Stereotyping is a huge factor in being prejudice. It is logical that those with lower IQs would rely on stereotypes more than others and therefore be more prone to prejudice.

Having said that, my experience in seeing how racist the supposedly progressive academic world has been toward my husband (a dark-complexioned East Indian) over the decades, and having experiences of how uneducated people have been more quickly able to overcome their racism, while many highly educated people do not, I’m thinking it can work in reverse: Those thinking at a more complex level have convoluted and complex ways of sustaining their racism, while simple folk are often able to overcome their racism just by being exposed to minorities who are good and decent. I offered this hypothesis in a Q&A session at a conference, and a few minority persons spoke of similar experiences.

We cannot deny, however, that Trump does appeal to persons who happen to be racist, as well as appealing to people (who may not be racist) in many other ways. One way being that he’s much more charismatic than Hillary (which does not count with me one iota, in fact it’s a turn off, makes me uneasy that I might go along with showiness rather than good sense).
 
Your only defense to all the dirty deeds done by US intelligence agencies is that I cannot disprove the existence of any positive effects. I do not have to. Those government employees swear an oath to the Constitution. Blatant disregard of that oath is justification for shutting them down.

Agreed, not everyone wants to live and let live, but what do you think is the reason the average guy joins a terrorist group? Because he hates nameless and faceless Americans for the freedom the NSA has taken from us or the CIA sky robots that killed his family? How about we set the example of living and letting live first?
My defense is people I know. They have character. That is enough for me.
 
OK, so I presented the article on this issue, but really didn’t give my own opinion, which varies from the study, but aligns more with Nosek’s opinion of the study, stated in the article.

My opinion is that people desire to be part of a group and through the course of their life, will often end up with an ego-identity attachment to a particular group. It doesn’t matter if the group is political, religious, liberal or conservative. As long as they have a feeling of attachment to that group, they will defend the group’s positions.

However, it’s not the group’s position or religions beliefs which are actually defended, but the person’s own ego, which has attached the false self to the group.

Read down the article.
Simple viewpoints
Hodson and Busseri’s explanation of their findings is reasonable, Nosek said, but it is correlational. That means the researchers didn’t conclusively prove that the low intelligence caused the later prejudice. To do that, you’d have to somehow randomly assign otherwise identical people to be smart or dumb, liberal or conservative. Those sorts of studies obviously aren’t possible.
The researchers controlled for factors such as education and socioeconomic status, making their case stronger, Nosek said. But there are other possible explanations that fit the data. For example, Nosek said, a study of left-wing liberals with stereotypically naïve views like “every kid is a genius in his or her own way,” might find that people who hold these attitudes are also less bright. In other words, it might not be a particular ideology that is linked to stupidity, but extremist views in general.
“My speculation is that it’s not as simple as their model presents it,” Nosek said. “I think that lower cognitive capacity can lead to multiple simple ways to represent the world, and one of those can be embodied in a right-wing ideology where ‘People I don’t know are threats’ and ‘The world is a dangerous place’. … Another simple way would be to just assume everybody is wonderful.”
I’ve participated in various political and religious forums before the internet came to us and I have found prejudice and ignorance among all political and religious groups… I had my own ego-identity attachments, which through God’s grace, I’ve managed to let go of.

It has nothing to do with IQ, other than being able to know and accept our true selves, and to detach from the ego drive masks that we develop. God is the source for the knowledge of the true self, and without a humble submission to Him, we will never come to know ourselves, but more importantly, accept ourselves.

Jim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top