Stun your protestant friend with one more verse :)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Odell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

Odell

Guest
This is for Catholic Dude who started the other thread. I have one more verse that I have not found one protestant able to adequately answer.

Romans 2: 5-10
“Of the righteous judgment of God, who will give to each man according to his works. On the one hand, to those who persist in good work, seek glory, honor and incorruption,** [he will give]** eternal life. To the others who are self-seeking and disobey the truth, who follow unrighteousness, **[he will give] **wrath and anger. Affliction and anguish on every soul of man who works evil, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. But **[he will give] **glory and honor and peace to everyone who works good, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.”

This is quite a bold statement, tantamount to saying that one can obtain eternal life by his good works. Consequently, it must also be true that “wrath and anger” in the same passages refers to eternal damnation.

I will try to answer any objection to this passage for it is quit easy to do so but first I want you to know how a Catholic would interpret this verse.

Paul does not hold that a man can “earn” in the strict sense of the word, the reward of eternal life. Paul makes that clear in Rom 4:4 that when one attempts to “earn” his salvation based on works he is in turn obligating God to “pay” him with eternal life. because of mans condition, God cannot be obliged to pay any man for anything. Hence we must conclude that the works Paul requires in Romans 2: 5-10 are not those performed with an eye to obligate God to pay the individual with eternal life. Rather, it is presumed that those who "persist in doing good."and who “seek glory, honor, and incorruption” are doing so under the auspices of God’s grace and mercy. These works are done under grace and not under debt. And can can and does reward us Heb 6: 10 “God is not unjust he will not forget your work and the love you have shown him as you have helped his people and continue to help him.”

Paul does not condemn the law as a guide to and part of faith and righteousness, for then he would be condemning the very precepts that tell one he is justified by grace threw faith. Example Rom 3:30-31 “Do we, then nullify the law by this faith? Not at all! rather, we uphold the law.” Did the law speak of faith, no law, as the means of justification?"

As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.
 
You should really join Puritan Board and put this up, in less than 10 minutes you’ll see 14 thread pages arguing over the definition of “the” in the scripture you quoth.
 
You should really join Puritan Board and put this up, in less than 10 minutes you’ll see 14 thread pages arguing over the definition of “the” in the scripture you quoth.
Is there any particular “the” you are talking about?
 
I know this is a little side note but I just checked out that Puritan board…and wowww, some of the stiff they have to say about the Catholic Church is pretty anti-Christian I would say. I could understand how people would be completely frightened of the CC.
 
It ain’t those parts of the Bible that I can’t understand that bother me, it is the parts that I do understand.
  • Mark Twain
 
This is for Catholic Dude who started the other thread. I have one more verse that I have not found one protestant able to adequately answer.

Romans 2: 5-10
“Of the righteous judgment of God, who will give to each man according to his works. On the one hand, to those who persist in good work, seek glory, honor and incorruption,** [he will give]** eternal life. To the others who are self-seeking and disobey the truth, who follow unrighteousness, **[he will give] **wrath and anger. Affliction and anguish on every soul of man who works evil, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. But **[he will give] **glory and honor and peace to everyone who works good, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.”

This is quite a bold statement, tantamount to saying that one can obtain eternal life by his good works. Consequently, it must also be true that “wrath and anger” in the same passages refers to eternal damnation.

I will try to answer any objection to this passage for it is quit easy to do so but first I want you to know how a Catholic would interpret this verse.

Paul does not hold that a man can “earn” in the strict sense of the word, the reward of eternal life. Paul makes that clear in Rom 4:4 that when one attempts to “earn” his salvation based on works he is in turn obligating God to “pay” him with eternal life. because of mans condition, God cannot be obliged to pay any man for anything. Hence we must conclude that the works Paul requires in Romans 2: 5-10 are not those performed with an eye to obligate God to pay the individual with eternal life. Rather, it is presumed that those who "persist in doing good."and who “seek glory, honor, and incorruption” are doing so under the auspices of God’s grace and mercy. These works are done under grace and not under debt. And can can and does reward us Heb 6: 10 “God is not unjust he will not forget your work and the love you have shown him as you have helped his people and continue to help him.”

Paul does not condemn the law as a guide to and part of faith and righteousness, for then he would be condemning the very precepts that tell one he is justified by grace threw faith. Example Rom 3:30-31 “Do we, then nullify the law by this faith? Not at all! rather, we uphold the law.” Did the law speak of faith, no law, as the means of justification?"

As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.
I used that same approach back in 04 in response to that same passage (Rom 2:5-10 and others) here’s an example of that diologue.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=207036&postcount=218

You’re correct, it’s a problem for Protestants to reconcile given faith alone theology.
 
Is there any particular “the” you are talking about?
No, any of them. It’ll probably just happen anyways 😃

A lot of the people on there are vehemently anti-Catholic. They’ll do anything to prove us “wrong”.
 
As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.
There’s* always* an answer. I believe some Protestants claim that Rom 2:5-10 applies only to people still “under the Law”, which the Jews and those unfamiliar with the gospel at the time, so the claim goes, still were then. Or that the “good” that one is supposed to do is simply to believe in the work of Jesus, accepting His cloak of righteousness as ones’ own.
 
This is for Catholic Dude who started the other thread. I have one more verse that I have not found one protestant able to adequately answer.

Romans 2: 5-10
“Of the righteous judgment of God, who will give to each man according to his works. On the one hand, to those who persist in good work, seek glory, honor and incorruption,** [he will give]** eternal life. To the others who are self-seeking and disobey the truth, who follow unrighteousness, **[he will give] **wrath and anger. Affliction and anguish on every soul of man who works evil, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. But **[he will give] **glory and honor and peace to everyone who works good, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.”

This is quite a bold statement, tantamount to saying that one can obtain eternal life by his good works. Consequently, it must also be true that “wrath and anger” in the same passages refers to eternal damnation.

I will try to answer any objection to this passage for it is quit easy to do so but first I want you to know how a Catholic would interpret this verse.

Paul does not hold that a man can “earn” in the strict sense of the word, the reward of eternal life. Paul makes that clear in Rom 4:4 that when one attempts to “earn” his salvation based on works he is in turn obligating God to “pay” him with eternal life. because of mans condition, God cannot be obliged to pay any man for anything. Hence we must conclude that the works Paul requires in Romans 2: 5-10 are not those performed with an eye to obligate God to pay the individual with eternal life. Rather, it is presumed that those who "persist in doing good."and who “seek glory, honor, and incorruption” are doing so under the auspices of God’s grace and mercy. These works are done under grace and not under debt. And can can and does reward us Heb 6: 10 “God is not unjust he will not forget your work and the love you have shown him as you have helped his people and continue to help him.”

Paul does not condemn the law as a guide to and part of faith and righteousness, for then he would be condemning the very precepts that tell one he is justified by grace threw faith. Example Rom 3:30-31 “Do we, then nullify the law by this faith? Not at all! rather, we uphold the law.” Did the law speak of faith, no law, as the means of justification?"

As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.
Dawg…you pretty much just quoted Robert Sungenis’ Not by Faith Alone, p. 37, just split the quote up.

I think the Protestant can adequately reply to your use of these verses though. Why does God reward the ones who persist in good works, seeks glory, honor and incorruption with eternal life? The text doesn’t say. Yet, you interpret this to mean that good works congruently merit eternal life. However, all Paul says is that eternal life is rewarded to those who…, etc. he never states why. So, the text can just as well mean God rewards eternal life to those who work thus because they have saving faith. I don’t really see anything in this text which would indicate one way or another.
 
Dawg…you pretty much just quoted Robert Sungenis’ Not by Faith Alone, p. 37, just split the quote up.

I think the Protestant can adequately reply to your use of these verses though. Why does God reward the ones who persist in good works, seeks glory, honor and incorruption with eternal life? The text doesn’t say. Yet, you interpret this to mean that good works congruently merit eternal life. However, all Paul says is that eternal life is rewarded to those who…, etc. he never states why. So, the text can just as well mean God rewards eternal life to those who work thus because they have saving faith. I don’t really see anything in this text which would indicate one way or another.
There is no need to say why. All God is saying is that those who seek to do good will be rewarded. we dont need to know why God says that. saving faith? where do you get this one from?
as we know God does not make anyone do anything. we have to choose to do what God tells us to do. If God is the One making us do what is good, He did not need to come to us and suffer as He did.

He did not have to communicate with us at all. He could have done all alone… From the beginning God sends man to warn others of their sins and tell them to repent. Free will at work. how do you respond to that?
 
There is no need to say why. All God is saying is that those who seek to do good will be rewarded. we dont need to know why God says that. saving faith? where do you get this one from?
as we know God does not make anyone do anything. we have to choose to do what God tells us to do. If God is the One making us do what is good, He did not need to come to us and suffer as He did.

He did not have to communicate with us at all. He could have done all alone… From the beginning God sends man to warn others of their sins and tell them to repent. Free will at work. how do you respond to that?
Well, I guess I’m not sure how what you’ve said objects to anything I’ve said. Free-will is irrelevant to my argument, so I’m not sure why you propose it as an objection?

Really, the only relevant thing you said to me was “saving faith? where do you get this one from?” But, this isn’t really a defeater.

My only point was we shouldn’t say these works congruently merit eternal life because the text doesn’t tell us why God rewards these works.

The only way this text can be a problem for Protestants is if it tells us God rewards these works with eternal life because they congruently merited it. So, how can this text be a problem for the Protestant, given the only way it could be a problem for them isn’t actually here in the text? I have no idea.
 
Well, I guess I’m not sure how what you’ve said objects to anything I’ve said. Free-will is irrelevant to my argument, so I’m not sure why you propose it as an objection?

Really, the only relevant thing you said to me was “saving faith? where do you get this one from?” But, this isn’t really a defeater.

My only point was we shouldn’t say these works congruently merit eternal life because the text doesn’t tell us why God rewards these works.

The only way this text can be a problem for Protestants is if it tells us God rewards these works with eternal life because they congruently merited it. So, how can this text be a problem for the Protestant, given the only way it could be a problem for them isn’t actually here in the text? I have no idea.
You dont say, God does it. He says.

what else is to say? He will reward those who do good. Why? why do you have the need for God to explain to you why? it does not make any sense. God doesnt have to answer to protestants woes. He built a Church to lead His people. those outside are left in confusion and seek all kind of explanation because they dont know God.
 
Dawg…you pretty much just quoted Robert Sungenis’ Not by Faith Alone, p. 37, just split the quote up.

I think the Protestant can adequately reply to your use of these verses though. Why does God reward the ones who persist in good works, seeks glory, honor and incorruption with eternal life? The text doesn’t say. Yet, you interpret this to mean that good works congruently merit eternal life. However, all Paul says is that eternal life is rewarded to those who…, etc. he never states why. So, the text can just as well mean God rewards eternal life to those who work thus because they have saving faith. I don’t really see anything in this text which would indicate one way or another.
But he does say why ** “who will give to each man according to his works.” **

And what is it that he gives according to their works; eternal life.

"On the one hand, to those who persist in good work, seek glory, honor and incorruption, [he will give] eternal life."

The moment you bring saving faith into the equation you contradict the very meaning behind faith alone and the reformers who championed that it is only Christ righteousness that justifies the individual. The “saving faith” that is required to receive Christ’s righteousness requires the individual to possess a certain quality of faith prior to justification, then the determination of whether the individual receives the justification falls squarely on your own shoulders.

Also if imputation depends on the quality and persistence of faith, then justification cannot be reduced to the “alien righteousness of Christ.” either. Christ’s atonement does not automatically impute righteousness to sinners en masse but is only appropriated by the faith disposition of the individual. So why as a protestant would you claim that justification by imputation has any ethical superiority over justification by infusion where God infuses his divine righteousness into the individual?
 
But he does say why ** “who will give to each man according** to his works.”
I’m not sure why you emphasized ‘according’ and ‘eternal life.’ The protestant will say ‘good works’ can only be performed by by the one with saving faith, so God’s decision based on works makes perfect sense.

It doesn’t say eternal life is rewarded because of their works. It just says eternal life is rewarded according to their works.
The moment you bring saving faith into the equation you contradict the very meaning behind faith alone and the reformers who championed that it is only Christ righteousness that justifies the individual. The “saving faith” that is required to receive Christ’s righteousness requires the individual to possess a certain quality of faith prior to justification, then the determination of whether the individual receives the justification falls squarely on your own shoulders.
I’m not sure I follow. Many protestants think faith is a passive recipient for Christ’s righteousness. It’s that passive receptivity, and Christ’s utilization of it that makes it saving.
Also if imputation depends on the quality and persistence of faith, then justification cannot be reduced to the “alien righteousness of Christ.” either. Christ’s atonement does not automatically impute righteousness to sinners en masse but is only appropriated by the faith disposition of the individual. So why as a protestant would you claim that justification by imputation has any ethical superiority over justification by infusion where God infuses his divine righteousness into the individual?
I’m not sure I understand this objection either. Justification can be reduced to Christ’s righteousness precisely because it depends on a certain kind of faith; namely, that passive receptor caused in the individual by God.

But, I’m not sure how your last few points are relevant. I’ve never claimed my soteriology is ethically superior etc. This seems more like a buck shot fire at a general protestant soteriology than a response to my points.
 
I am stunned that you took that out of context and created a strawman argument. ROFL

Romans 2
1Therefore thou art inexcusable, O man, whosoever thou art that judgest: for wherein thou judgest another, thou condemnest thyself; for thou that judgest doest the same things.

2But we are sure that the judgment of God is according to truth against them which commit such things.

3And thinkest thou this, O man, that judgest them which do such things, and doest the same, that thou shalt escape the judgment of God?

4Or despisest thou the riches of his goodness and forbearance and longsuffering; not knowing that the goodness of God leadeth thee to repentance?

5But after **thy hardness and impenitent heart treasurest up unto thyself **wrath against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God;

In context the text addresses a non-believer. :rolleyes:
 
I’m not sure why you emphasized ‘according’ and ‘eternal life.’ The protestant will say ‘good works’ can only be performed by by the one with saving faith, so God’s decision based on works makes perfect sense
according: To grant, especially as being due or appropriate
I’m not sure I follow. Many protestants think faith is a passive recipient for Christ’s righteousness. It’s that passive receptivity, and Christ’s utilization of it that makes it saving.
Im not following you. Are you saying that saving faith passively apprehends the righteousness of Christ? If so does this saving faith still depend on the intrinsic quality of faith in order to even be a saving faith? Or are you saying saving faith IS the righteousness of Christ working threw us as saving faith? The latter would be more along the line of what Catholics believe in that our works and our faith is Christ righteousness acting threw us in that we are truly doing and being righteous. We believe our faith results in our righteousness in the sense that God and us are working together.
I’m not sure I understand this objection either. Justification can be reduced to Christ’s righteousness precisely because it depends on a certain kind of faith; namely, that passive receptor caused in the individual by God.
And how does this not qualify faith? And how can a qualified faith be alone?
But, I’m not sure how your last few points are relevant. I’ve never claimed my soteriology is ethically superior etc. This seems more like a buck shot fire at a general protestant soteriology than a response to my points.
It was in response to you claiming good works come from one who has saving faith.
 
I am stunned that you took that out of context and created a strawman argument. ROFL

Romans 2
1Therefore thou art inexcusable, O man, whosoever thou art that judgest: for wherein thou judgest another, thou condemnest thyself; for thou that judgest doest the same things.

2But we are sure that the judgment of God is according to truth against them which commit such things.

3And thinkest thou this, O man, that judgest them which do such things, and doest the same, that thou shalt escape the judgment of God?

4Or despisest thou the riches of his goodness and forbearance and longsuffering; not knowing that the goodness of God leadeth thee to repentance?

5But after **thy hardness and impenitent heart treasurest up unto thyself **wrath against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God;

In context the text addresses a non-believer. :rolleyes:
9: “Tribulation and anguish upon every soul for man that doeth evil, of the Jew first and also of the Gentile.”

According to protestants the believer who does evil the sin is covered and there will be no Tribulation and anguish. But according to Paul every soul who does evil will have anguish.

Also in verse 9 if the Jews and Gentiles who do evil are not believers than who are the Jews and Gentiles in verse 10 who are granted eternal life?

10: “But glory, honor and peace to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile.”

The context has nothing to do with believe and non believe but who worketh and who does evil weather Jew or Gentile :rolleyes:
 
This is for Catholic Dude who started the other thread. I have one more verse that I have not found one protestant able to adequately answer.

As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.
I think most Protestants would make the distinction between salvation (which is a free gift, can’t be earned) and rewards given for obedience after salvation. The works and perseverence are evidence that someone has saving faith, and they will still be judged for rewards in heaven based on their life.

v. 6 - everyone will be judged based on what they’ve done. (those who are saved will be judged by their obedience for their rewards, not whether or not they are saved, and those who reject the gospel will punished in hell)
v. 7 - those whose life proved that they have been saved, will inherit eternal life.
v.8 - unbelievers get wrath.
 
according: To grant, especially as being due or appropriate
Right…
Im not following you. Are you saying that saving faith passively apprehends the righteousness of Christ? If so does this saving faith still depend on the intrinsic quality of faith in order to even be a saving faith?
Sure, I have no problem saying that faith is saving which has the property of passively receiving Christ’s righteousness.
And how does this not qualify faith? And how can a qualified faith be alone?
hmm, I don’t think I’ve ever claimed this faith is alone?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top