O
Odell
Guest
This is for Catholic Dude who started the other thread. I have one more verse that I have not found one protestant able to adequately answer.
Romans 2: 5-10
“Of the righteous judgment of God, who will give to each man according to his works. On the one hand, to those who persist in good work, seek glory, honor and incorruption,** [he will give]** eternal life. To the others who are self-seeking and disobey the truth, who follow unrighteousness, **[he will give] **wrath and anger. Affliction and anguish on every soul of man who works evil, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. But **[he will give] **glory and honor and peace to everyone who works good, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.”
This is quite a bold statement, tantamount to saying that one can obtain eternal life by his good works. Consequently, it must also be true that “wrath and anger” in the same passages refers to eternal damnation.
I will try to answer any objection to this passage for it is quit easy to do so but first I want you to know how a Catholic would interpret this verse.
Paul does not hold that a man can “earn” in the strict sense of the word, the reward of eternal life. Paul makes that clear in Rom 4:4 that when one attempts to “earn” his salvation based on works he is in turn obligating God to “pay” him with eternal life. because of mans condition, God cannot be obliged to pay any man for anything. Hence we must conclude that the works Paul requires in Romans 2: 5-10 are not those performed with an eye to obligate God to pay the individual with eternal life. Rather, it is presumed that those who "persist in doing good."and who “seek glory, honor, and incorruption” are doing so under the auspices of God’s grace and mercy. These works are done under grace and not under debt. And can can and does reward us Heb 6: 10 “God is not unjust he will not forget your work and the love you have shown him as you have helped his people and continue to help him.”
Paul does not condemn the law as a guide to and part of faith and righteousness, for then he would be condemning the very precepts that tell one he is justified by grace threw faith. Example Rom 3:30-31 “Do we, then nullify the law by this faith? Not at all! rather, we uphold the law.” Did the law speak of faith, no law, as the means of justification?"
As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.
Romans 2: 5-10
“Of the righteous judgment of God, who will give to each man according to his works. On the one hand, to those who persist in good work, seek glory, honor and incorruption,** [he will give]** eternal life. To the others who are self-seeking and disobey the truth, who follow unrighteousness, **[he will give] **wrath and anger. Affliction and anguish on every soul of man who works evil, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. But **[he will give] **glory and honor and peace to everyone who works good, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.”
This is quite a bold statement, tantamount to saying that one can obtain eternal life by his good works. Consequently, it must also be true that “wrath and anger” in the same passages refers to eternal damnation.
I will try to answer any objection to this passage for it is quit easy to do so but first I want you to know how a Catholic would interpret this verse.
Paul does not hold that a man can “earn” in the strict sense of the word, the reward of eternal life. Paul makes that clear in Rom 4:4 that when one attempts to “earn” his salvation based on works he is in turn obligating God to “pay” him with eternal life. because of mans condition, God cannot be obliged to pay any man for anything. Hence we must conclude that the works Paul requires in Romans 2: 5-10 are not those performed with an eye to obligate God to pay the individual with eternal life. Rather, it is presumed that those who "persist in doing good."and who “seek glory, honor, and incorruption” are doing so under the auspices of God’s grace and mercy. These works are done under grace and not under debt. And can can and does reward us Heb 6: 10 “God is not unjust he will not forget your work and the love you have shown him as you have helped his people and continue to help him.”
Paul does not condemn the law as a guide to and part of faith and righteousness, for then he would be condemning the very precepts that tell one he is justified by grace threw faith. Example Rom 3:30-31 “Do we, then nullify the law by this faith? Not at all! rather, we uphold the law.” Did the law speak of faith, no law, as the means of justification?"
As long as Protestants refuse to see a distinction between strict merit due from obligation and gracious merit provided by benevolence, there can be no resolution to this controversy. And no way to even begin to understand the passage at hand.