Stunned!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Marie5890
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I wasn’t there but… giving this man the benefit of the doubt, I have often been in situations where I asked a question and people looked at me like I was stupid because

a-) I temporarily forgot myself
b-) Misworded the question so they didn’t realize what I was actually asking
c-) Was pointing out a different side they never though about and my question was so beyond their knowledge they brought it back to something simpler than what I meant and missed the point

With all that said and done… When I first read the post, I did not find the question so shocking and here is an example of how our early years really do form us.

I went to a catholic school which taught me VERY little about the faith. Our exercise books had the picture of the fish on it and I just thought it was to differentiate it from the other subjects. I never clued in to what it mean until in my 30s.

Somewhere when I was about 8, I heard that Jesus was jewish. And I said to my mom ‘Jesus was jewish and then became Cathocli’. I will NEVER forget the look of horror and disappointment on my mom’s face (and believe it or not, to this day I admire her knowledge of the faith) and although I don’t remember what she said, it was obvious the topic was NOT up for discussion. So as I became older and heard that Jesus was jewish, I ALWAYS cringed. It made no sense. Even today although I know he was the promised one born to a jewish family, that experience with my mom so affected me, it can seem odd.

So I guess the lesson is be very careful what you say to a kid 😉
 
I think my generation, the one that would have grown up mostly post-Vatican II, in general was very poorly catechized.😦
I’m 51. Its my generation that doesn’t know their faith very well. As a young teen in the 70’s I can tell you some of the things that were done as a matter of course that would make people cringe nowadays. Liturgical abuses all over the place. And we did them all thinking that we were worshiping God in a meaningful way.

I went to Catholic school for 12 years. I’ve learned more about my faith in the few years that I’ve been hanging out on this board than I every knew before. My husband went to CCD, made his Sacraments and was an alter server. His knowledge of our faith is pitiful.

One of the biggest lacks is the understanding of why we do certain things, and the reason behind the “rules” Without the WHY, the rules just seem burdensome and not worth the effort. I know more people than I can count who “used to be Catholic” but have moved on to other Christian churches. Without the basic knowledge of what our Church has that the others don’t, they figure church is church, and some are easier.

I think the tide has turned. We are bringing back the reverence and meaning and people are returning to the Church who have been lost for many years. But I honestly think a lot of us are the product of those years.
 
If I read the OP’s original post, she was talking to the wife who said neither she nor her Catholic school educated husband knew Christ was Jesus. For the sake of clarifying how badly he was taught, she should ask him directly. I find it odd that a kid would sit through 12 years and not ask questions because, even if he wasn’t taught, he had to have questions about something. As an altar boy, he must have heard some sermons discussing Passover etc. There is a lot to be said for an enquiring mind. Did he not have discussions with his friends?
 
I was educated in the early 60s when they still used what I presume was a French version of the Baltimore Catechism. It was all question and answer and as long as you could spit back the answer that was as far as the course went. Asking a question of a teacher who has never been to college but grew up with the same type of catechism was not going to get you anywhere.

As for Jesus being Jewish, I know many Catholics who are horrified at that notion and will argue black and blue that he was the first Catholic. I don’t quite understand that mentality now but I think I was probably in my twenties before I understood that he WAS Jewish.

I was 14 before I actually held a Bible in my hands and it was at my parish’s 40 Hours Devotion when I was left alone in the church. They had recently installed a stand to permanently have a Bible present at the front of the nave so I went to get the big white Bible, fearful that I was doing something wrong but yet compelled, as a book-addicted teen, to read this book about which I had alway been very curious, and sat down to read what? oh, Leviticus, of course. Now there’s an introduction to the Bible for you! Try going home and talking to your mother about ritual purification when she’s also the product of a question and answer program taught by her mother, who’d learned it the same way!

Unfortunately, Catholics in those days didn’t have the resources that I only discovered in my mid 40s.
 
I think my generation, the one that would have grown up mostly post-Vatican II, in general was very poorly catechized.
I had 12 years of Catholic schools, the bulk of which was during the 80’s, and when I really started taking my faith seriously again a few years ago I was shocked to find how truly terribly we’d been catechized back then. We had religion classes all through grade school, which were no more than 30 minutes a day, usually no more than 3 days each week (although I think the stated requirement was daily). These classes covered the most basic facts from the Bible and made sure we knew our prayers. They covered some of our beliefs, but not why we believed them. When I first heard the words consubstantial and transubstantiation, the words themselves were almost as foreign to me as the concepts. I don’t think there was a single time in my first 35-36 years on this planet that anyone had ever told me that the host was anything other than a symbol of Christ’s body. When it came to basic Catholic morality, we hit on some of the basics (we got the idea that abortion was wrong, even if they never used the A-word), but we were also given some extremely awful misinformation, such as being told that contraception and masturbation were both okay in the eyes of the Church (and this was from our priest).

In high school, we were required to take 5-6 religion classes total. This ensured that we had at least one each year. Some of these classes were religion classes in name only (a morality class that touched on topics like premarital sex and abortion and stated that they were wrong, but didn’t explain why from a Catholic point of view), while most of the others covered Church history. I was able to regurgitate facts, but they did very little to explain anything about our faith to me. We had a monthly Mass during high school, as opposed to weekly in grade school, and by senior year I was seldom even going on Sundays. I’d been taught that I should, but not that missing it was a sin.

As far as the OP’s situation goes, we were at least taught that Jesus was the messiah and fulfilled the old Jewish prophecies, although I don’t think any of my teachers would even entertain the idea that He was Jewish until late in my high school years. I can’t say that I’m surprised by any level of misunderstanding I hear from other cradle Catholics at this point, simply because, in my experience, the catechesis we received growing up was so inconsistent and faulty (my high school drew from at least 7 other Catholic grade schools, and we’d all received essentially the same level of understanding).
 
Born in mid 50’s. Basic cathechism, 10 commandments, adam and eve, noahs ark,
Joseph and Mary, Jonah and the whale, basic prayers, and a whole lot about hell, very little about Jesus.
And I’m sure my parents had nothing different if they even had cathechism.

Were all comfirmed, and were raised with morals, and fish every Friday1

Remember we didn’t ask questions back then, didn’t have the internet, or the nice libraries like now, no cable , etc.

I have to give credits to Protastants for encourment to read the Bible after listening to a few on TV around 15 years ago. I remember I felt like I had been cheated, as most of my adult life never questioned a word we were taught except I didn’t believe in limbo, and yes we were taught limbo.🙂

I would like to ask a few others on this thread about their first communion. did you really realize you were eating the flesh and blood of Jesus, I sure didn’t, I know they said the
body and blood of Christ or something like that, but never thought I was taking real flesh and blood, did yous? maybe I was just ignorant back then don’t know, but I was good in school.

do young children comprehend that now days, how can they since many adults can’t comprehend it or believe it , and do they really want to take it if they do?
 
I would like to ask a few others on this thread about their first communion. did you really realize you were eating the flesh and blood of Jesus, I sure didn’t, I know they said the
body and blood of Christ or something like that, but never thought I was taking real flesh and blood, did yous? maybe I was just ignorant back then don’t know, but I was good in school.

do young children comprehend that now days, how can they since many adults can’t comprehend it or believe it , and do they really want to take it if they do?
I certainly didn’t know at my First Communion, and didn’t have a really good understanding of it until the last couple years. My older daughters each had theirs over the last 3 years, and while their classes mentioned it, neither of them really understood it until I explained it to them. I think the schools are doing a little better with them than they did with me, but I’m working very hard to bolster their catechesis and make sure they have a much stronger grounding in our faith than I had.
 
** I don’t think there was a single time in my first 35-36 years on this planet that anyone had ever told me that the host was anything other than a symbol of Christ’s body/B

Gordon Sims- I thought I had read a post that said what you said, then I went back over the posts and couldnt find it, so I felt maybe I just thought I did.

Yes that is what I thought it was too more a symbol- thank you.

Well its good that you’ve become much more informed and can teach your children and can make sure they understand the teachings, so they didn’t understand the meaning of the host from school but from you, I think its a hard thing to comprehend at that age and maybe thats why they don’t explain it in school.

I think more and more younger people are more informed now too and probably they are teaching things better than what we got.**
 
Educated by School Sister of Notre Dame for 11 years late 40s through early 60s. Mass every morning in grade school, novena on Monday afternoon, stations of the cross during Lent, fasting from midnight on only taking water no less than an hour before communion, no meat on Fridays, no eating between meals during Lent, fast before all holidays.

Memorized the Baltimore Catechism, memorized all the prayers, prayed before class and at end of day.Church bells rang for the Angelus. Read from children’s Bible in grade school. Encouraged to watch Archbishop Fulton Sheen on TV (wish I had), discouraged from watching anything not recommended by Legion of Decency (e.g. Peyton Place, and the movies The Moon is Blue, and Baby Doll). Class trips were to the nuns’ mother house, or to see the epics TEN COMMANDMENTS etc. Wore uniforms to lessen envy, encourage modesty, and to lessen distactions from learning.

Yes, Christ was in the tabernacle. You will go down and touch your knee to the floor before you enter the pew. You will cover your head. This is the Body and Blood. And if you needed more confimation, the nuns had many stories on hand regarding miracles and tests of faith. Evil existed in the form of communism and the nuns and priests used those countries as examples of what happens when religion is outlawed and people are persecuted. We knew the histoy behind the scapulars, and religious objects.

Yes, there were discussions with the nuns regarding limbo, indulgences, abortion etc.
We were taught the faith and we lived it. We did it as a matter of course.
 
That seems like a good school and catholic environment to grow up in.

I attended catholic grade school and high school in southern indiana from the late 60’s to 1981. I remember daily mass was dropped after 1st grade. The whole diocese was being overrun by the liberal movement. I did not know this at the time but now it is clear. While I attended school there, I learned only a little about the faith.

I went back to my home parish for a mass after Thanksgiving weekend last month. I was deeply saddened to see lay women pouring consecrated wine from the main chalice into the separate cups. Much of the mass contained liturgical abuse.

As a catechist in the chicago area, I discovered the teaching material was quite “watered down.” Pointing this out got me ejected from the role. However, I discovered the Faith and Life series available at Ignatius Press. We use this at home now and it is quite good.

This is the key I believe. You have to teach the faith at home, and live it too.
 
This is the key I believe. You have to teach the faith at home, and live it too.
I thought it was on CAF a while back where I found a link to a study that showed that the biggest indicator of whether kids will stay strong in their faith when they grow up is if their father leads them by example. That strengthened my conviction to be the guiding hand in my kids’ Catholic upbringing more than anything else I’ve read or have been told. Since reading that, I make sure that we pray together and talk about religious topics regularly (anything from saints, to the Bible, to our beliefs and whatever it is they’re learning in school). We say the Rosary together, and I ask the girls what they’ll be praying for before they go to bed each night. And the only time I’ve missed Mass since reading that was because the local “last chance” Mass was canceled (it was the only day my wife & I had to do Christmas shopping together, and the plan all along had been to hit the 7:00 pm Mass).
 
their father leads them by example

I agee with that.

Seems we were all raised different and had different educations, I think a good balance is appropriate, not too extreme one way or another way.

and yes parents need to take a more active role (and they are today-well more than use to be ) in the education their kids are receiving, and that includes in regular school.🙂
 
I thought it was on CAF a while back where I found a link to a study that showed that the biggest indicator of whether kids will stay strong in their faith when they grow up is if their father leads them by example. That strengthened my conviction to be the guiding hand in my kids’ Catholic upbringing more than anything else I’ve read or have been told. Since reading that, I make sure that we pray together and talk about religious topics regularly (anything from saints, to the Bible, to our beliefs and whatever it is they’re learning in school). We say the Rosary together, and I ask the girls what they’ll be praying for before they go to bed each night. And the only time I’ve missed Mass since reading that was because the local “last chance” Mass was canceled (it was the only day my wife & I had to do Christmas shopping together, and the plan all along had been to hit the 7:00 pm Mass).
That is definitely the case. It is the father’s faith (or lack thereof) that transfers to the children most strongly. If the father has no faith, it is much more likely that the children will follow him into unbelief. God set it up so that the father is the spiritual leader of the family. Even if the father does not want that role, it is one ordained by God.
 
I attended Catholic school k-8 then public for high school (I’m still in HS actually).

It was an awakening to switch to a public school and meet kids who had never gone to a religious school and knew so much about religion. These kids were mostly Protestants and how much they knew about the Bible blew me away. Not to mention, most of them were better educated on Catholicism than me! It was almost embaressing to have gone to a Catholic school for so long and for them to know so much and me so little! Growing up, I attended church each week and was involved with numerous faith groups but even with that, I still didn’t know nearly anything about the Bible, saints, or Catholic teachings. Once I saw how much my Protestant friends new, I began reading and educating myself on the CC. That was actually how I found CAF.

Looking back, it is a shame that my Catholic school/other Catholic schools didn’t better educate students on Catholic teachings. I’m not talking about anything obscure, but even the basics were overlooked. I know that some might say that the responsibility is that of the parents, but I feel it should at least be mentioned in school.

Additionally, this past summer I had to explain to my friend what Catholics believed in regards to the Eucharist! She had never heard the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation and she was going into her senior year at a Catholic HS and had been in Catholic schools since kindergarten!

I just wish schools would teach better. Sometimes, that’s the only way kids are going to hear what the CC teaches.
 
She had never heard the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation and she was going into her senior year at a Catholic HS and had been in Catholic schools since kindergarten!

so like me and a few others we were never really allowed to receive communion,

I mean isn’t that a necessity to receive communion is to believe in transubstantiation??

I need to be honest here as I still don’t. I believe the way I was taught to believe it.
 
Wow, the arrogance is pretty strong on this thread. I hope I have misunderstood the question and the thread, but I don’t think so. As you stated his question, I realized I had that same question just a few years ago. I realized I did not understand how Jesus was Jewish, and I was Catholic, and what that all meant. It has been mind-boggling to me the last few years how little I really know. I have been a firm Catholic all of my life, but once I realized how little I really knew, it started me on a journey, one of which is a very slow process.

As an adult, its not easy to learn these things and I would be horribly embarrassed to have been treated the way you treated this man and his wife. I definitely would never talk to you again about religion and would be careful in the future to bring up my supposed “stupidity” with other people. And that is exactly how you, and many others have come across. You think he and his wife are stupid. Instead of taking the time to just talk about it and give some helpful information which was obvious that they did not have (and in their shoes I would have greatly appreciated), you just stared at them dumbfounded and showed your shock at what you though was their “stupidity.” How can you hold it against them that they don’t know, as if it is their fault for not understanding?? Do you honestly think that most people have a really clear understanding? You sound like you treated them like idiots.

I have to say, I never understood most of our teachings until more recently when I have learned the same thing my children are learning. It wasn’t my fault that I wasn’t taught properly. Until recently, not only did I not know much, but I did not have a true desire to learn. So even if I had been taught (which I wasn’t taught much) then I’m not sure I would have really paid too much attention until I actually wanted to learn it.

Now I hope I misunderstood the entire concept of this thread and please correct me if so. Hopefully I’m having a bad day and just not reading carefully enough. But if not, then its no wonder why people are so judgmental of the Catholic Church … especially considering the arrogant attitudes of some of the members 😦
 
I’m not picking up on any arrogance or self-comgratulatory posts. I’m getting a vibe of concern and also of aggravation that Catholics have not been better taught. 🤷
 
One has a responsibility to educate one’s self if a person identifies with a specific religious group or political party. When I taught religion to third graders, I told them to pick a statue in the church and come back the next week and tell the class about his/her life.
If one hears something about and aspect of the church and doesn’t understand, google it.

We have a friend who is an agnostic. His daughter converted 15 yrs ago. He recently stated, “Did you know that Catholics believe that communion is the Body and Blood of Christ?” All in the room were Catholics. If my child announced she was interested in the Church, I’d be reading up on what Catholics believe. Obviously, it meant so little to him that he didn’t bother but is now shocked to learn this.
 
Goggle it,
Ok for now days, we didn’t always have google. When ones been taught what they feel they need to know , and comfirmed why would they think they don’t know?🙂

**Did you know that Catholics believe that communion is the Body and Blood of Christ?" **

Well I believe all Catholics believe we receive the Body and Blood of Christ,

but actually we are to believe the hosts actually changes into the flesh and blood of Christ

right?
 
She had never heard the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation and she was going into her senior year at a Catholic HS and had been in Catholic schools since kindergarten!
Actually, she probably heard it. In the 2nd grade. When First Communion is done at Catholic school, in my day anyway. Those are some HUGE words for a 2nd grader don’t you think?

It occurs to me there is SOOOOOO much to learn that often subjects are only covered once or twice. And they are often forgotten. Not necessarily the jist of the topic. But perhaps many specific details.

For example, once upon a time I could run the statistical significance on a string of numbers, calculate the DW, and offer an answer to the projected hypothesis. I’ll be danged if I can remember a single formula. Which does not take away from my general knowledge of how stats work, can be maniuplated, and what makes the results valid or not. I can look at scientific data/results and figure out what I’m reading. My forgetfullness about appropriate formulas and such does not negate the work. I KNOW that.

Also, I think there were some teachers among my Catholic education that seriously had some alternative motives. I had one teacher that seemed to know her stuff. But she’d get off on weird tangents. For example I can remember dedicating about 2 weeks to the Tortures used on people within the bible. Now, we were about 13 at the time. WE were quite intrigued. But was that EVER appropriate?

Then there’s the random non Catholic teacher that is CLUELESS to the topics at hand. Good luck with that.
Wow, the arrogance is pretty strong on this thread.
I actually picked up on this also. Although I agree there are many here are in fact frustrated with the quality of eduation offered throughout the country, I do find SOME converts have a tendancy to try to belittle us “cradle Catholics”… Those of that HAVE TO BE Cradle Catholics if we don’t know an answer. It seems many converts fail to realize we learned certain material when we were young. We never questioned it. We didn’t dive deeply into certain topics. Most converts are adults. With much better study skills. And since they are converting, they have a tendancy to really DIVE in. I should hope they know what they are getting into SOLIDLY.

Who here has converted on a WHIM? Without much understanding of what they are doing? It seems to me many converts have an advantage in some ways. They rec’d their first communion as an adult. RIGHT? Do we really think your average 2nd grader has the same ability to process the information they do? I don’t think so.

For example. How many converts here were told “Mary is the mother of God. She is and was always a virgin.” And they say… Oh, ok. Good to know. Next?

First of all. Most of us cradle Catholics learned Mary was a virgin when we were kids. WAAAAYYYYYY before we really KNEW what a virgin was. By the time we figured that out, it was so second nature, many of us don’t feel the need to hit the bible and find every single verse that could prove or disprove this. I mean, WHY couldn’t Mary be a virgin? We ARE talking about God, right? The most powerful force in existance. WHY couldn’t Mary be a virgin if that’s what God wanted?

I was FLOORED, and DISGUSTED when a certain family member just blatently announced one day… “You know Mary was not a virgin.” WHAT??? How could he even think so. Well, needless to say, I had to figure out what all the converts had to just to pose an arguement. The fact that I just KNOW that didn’t win the debate.

To converts and Catholics that are now realizing there is SO MUCH MORE to know… I really like the book: The Faith Explained - Leo Trese - Has the IMPRIMATUR. Which I also learned about as an adult. This book will hit on topics that make you say out loud… “I don’t remember learning that.” And then the studies begin. AGAIN!

You know, the whole Jesus was a Jew is actually a very interesting conversation. Of course he’s of Jewish decent. Can you seperate nationality from religion? It seems so, as there are now many “Jews” by faith that are not “Jewish”.

Another question that will throw MANY for a loop. Who was conceived at the Immaculate Conception. Most people I know think it’s Christ. Catholics and Non Catholics. I was an adult before I got this straight. As we know, Christ wasn’t CONCEIVED.

And so… in the end, it’s not terribly STUNNING that many cradle Catholics have not given much thought to Jesus being a Jew. In the end, the most important pc. is that WE ARE CHRISTIANS… We need to learn our Christianty! It’s the extended education that starts to go into things more deeply. And in reality, this probably should be done with an adult brain.

Kind of like. Perhaps one learns the rules of the road, then how to drive, and then perhaps how in the world the car actually works.And THEN, how all other kinds of cars work.

There is in fact a reason that mechanics specialize. But you know what? Having this route to knowledge will not stop a mechanic or two from looking at you crosseyed when he learns you didn’t know the oil light comes on only after it’s too late to do anything about it! WHO PLANS THAT WAY? LOL! I mean SERIOUSLY, that’s like the gas light coming on AFTER you car comes to a complete stop!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top