I’ve been involved in vocations work for 20 years now, and I’ve seen stuff that works, and other methods that don’t.
As has already been stated on this thread, the career choice version doesn’t work.
When we lived in Missouri, Conception Abbey produced a booklet regarding parish vocation committees. How successful was it? In the parishes where there was faith, it worked. For parishes without a lot of faith, it didn’t. When the diocese held a retreat for young men interested in the priesthood, half of the attendees were from my parish.
The Conception Program used demographics. They put the parish priest and a volunteer together to work the phones. “Have you ever thought about being a priest?” they’d ask.
Essentially, if vocations are not discussed on a regular basis, the parishoners will not pay any attention to the issue. The “vocation thought” in the bulletin is a start, but more has to be done.
Other studies have shown that direct contact with the priest has resulted in more vocations. The parish priests HAVE to get involved if they wish to propagate their vocation.
I was the prez of our vocations committee, and if any member had an idea, I simply made them the coordinator of the project. Worked quite well, because the person with the idea had the zeal to carry it through to completion.
There was a vacant leaflet rack in the church vestibule, and one committee member made a sign about vocational reading to tack to it. I saw one woman reading through the brochures.
Our parish also brought back 40 Hours Devotion for the sake of vocations.
I had planned a nun-run of St. Louis, but we moved to NC before it came to pass. We would have stayed at Kendrick Seminary, would have had access to their monastic-style chapel with stalls, and had the bus and monasteries lined up.
One thing I’m finding here lately is that if one is going to discern a religious vocation, they just about have to start living as eremitical a life as possible to be able to focus on God. All the noise of the world has to be left behind–at least temporarily. You could encourage that.
HTH.
Blessings,
Cloisters