I absolutely respect those of you who married others in the faith - I know how helpful it is to have someone supporting your faith, and sharing in the bond of love so strongly with Our Lord. The two most devout people I knew were my mother’s parents (may they rest in peace), followed closely by my own mother and father. On par with them are my brother and his wife - an amazing young couple with 6 kids and (hopefully soon!) more on the way.
However, that was not the path I took. I did not intentionally take that way, but I did not intentionally avoid it either. When I began dating my wife almost 5 years ago, it was very quickly on that I knew she was the person I was to marry - not from a selfish motive, but I felt God calling me to the married life with her.
That isn’t to say it was (or is) always easy. There were concerns about marrying in the Church, raising our future children in the faith, and even her non-Catholic brothers being Godparents. However, I kept feeling in my heart, especially when praying about the marriage, that maybe part of the reason she is the one for me is that I am to lead her into the faith, whether as a convert or simply the mother of Catholic children, and as we prepare to enter that next step in life, I continually feel that this is the right path for me.
I say all of this because too often, I see uncharitable words and dire threats about marrying non-Catholics. That isn’t to say the matter is not a grave one - we are told to abandon our families and follow Christ, so anyone who tries to prevent that is an agent of the Devil. Christ even refers to Peter as Satan for doubting the path they must follow. But the comments I’ve seen go beyond that. No one knows the situation that couple is in, so telling them to consider those matters is one thing, but the levels of doubt which I have seen people trying to leverage in conversations disturbs me.
Presumably, the OP is marrying in the Church, which means her and her fiance will (or have) completed Pre-Cana classes. That also means these matters are discussed, and in the interview, they both must agree to marry in the Church and raise the children Catholic. I would like to give all members here who are planning to marry (or who have married) non-Catholics the benefit of the doubt that they have weighed these matters carefully, and are confident in their decision. We must still pray for them, as we pray for all married or those in preparation of the sacrament, but let’s give them a break with some of these over-the-top comments, because I find them close to being condescending.