Sudden crying at Ash Wednesday Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter dont_lose_heart
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dont_lose_heart

Guest
My future husband, is non-catholic, and he comes to church with me every Sun, but today at Ash Wednesday mass, in church; I asked him to come to receive the Ashes with me and he said no, not only that he; sat down and said no once more, even though I pleaded. So I went up to receive the ashes and on my return to the seat, broke down in tears; I cried so much, then I felt lonely, sad and hurt, that if my future husband can refuse my wishes in the church, what am I in for, when we come to marriage. I prayed, and stayed on my knees, I came to the realisation that, what ever suffering comes my way in this relationship, it begins from now, and I really need all your prayers and support, especially from St Monica.

Thanking you all for your prayers, I can’t stop crying, even now.

God Bless
 
I’ll never understand why someone would ever want to enter into a lifetime of this kind of sadness.

You will surely be in my prayers.

😦

~Liza
 
First of all, take it from someone who knows, don’t beg and plead when it comes to religious matters. All it does is make the other party irritated and mad. This is what I do:

Today

me: Are you sure you don’t want to come? It will be pretty short.
husband: No, they’ll try to [put ash on] my head.
me: No, you don’t have to have that if you don’t want to.
husband: No, I don’t want to go.
me: OK then, see you soon!

fast forward to me in the pew at church, praying for my husband’s conversion 🙂

That’s all you can do!
 
First of all, take it from someone who knows, don’t beg and plead when it comes to religious matters. All it does is make the other party irritated and mad. This is what I do:

Today

me: Are you sure you don’t want to come? It will be pretty short.
husband: No, they’ll try to [put ash on] my head.
me: No, you don’t have to have that if you don’t want to.
husband: No, I don’t want to go.
me: OK then, see you soon!

fast forward to me in the pew at church, praying for my husband’s conversion 🙂

That’s all you can do!
Wonderful, thanks for the tip, St Monica pray for us. God Bless
 
My wife attended Mass with me this morning, and was the only person in the Church not to receive ashes. At least during Communion, the expectation is that not everyone will receive due to breaking the Eucharistic Fast or not being in a state of grace. I couldn’t read anything in her expression about it, I didn’t ask her about it, I simply prayed that she continues to support my faith, and that I may be an example of the love of Our Lord and hopefully draw her closer to the Church.

On a note of progress, we married with her saying she never saw herself as ever converting. We don’t talk about it in detail now, but she asks more questions, and is a very active participant in the Mass. Continued prayers are always helpful, though!
 
In all honesty, you should probably apologise to him. Better to respect his refusal than possibly make a scene at church. You might want to meditate on the Serenity Prayer during Lent:

“God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change;
Courage to change the things I can;
And wisdom to know the difference.”

I don’t know if there is something else happening to make you worry, but I pray that God will bless, guide and keep you.
 
My future husband, is non-catholic, and he comes to church with me every Sun, but today at Ash Wednesday mass, in church; I asked him to come to receive the Ashes with me and he said no, not only that he; sat down and said no once more, even though I pleaded. So I went up to receive the ashes and on my return to the seat, broke down in tears; I cried so much, then I felt lonely, sad and hurt, that if my future husband can refuse my wishes in the church, what am I in for, when we come to marriage. I prayed, and stayed on my knees, I came to the realisation that, what ever suffering comes my way in this relationship, it begins from now, and I really need all your prayers and support, especially from St Monica.

Thanking you all for your prayers, I can’t stop crying, even now.

God Bless
You don’t say if he’s a church goer or identifies himself with a denomination. From similar experience, I can say it’s quite possible he felt exactly the same way you did. Perhaps he was feeling sad, lonely, and hurt that you’ve asked him to turn his back on whatever religious tradition and background he has. You said he goes with you every Sunday. Have you explored (merely for better understanding of your future spouse) his religious background.
 
If there is a fight, negativity, or a bunch of nagging someone who you know is not Catholic, all you are going to do is poison the water so to speak. He will start associating Mass with negativity, a fight, or some other bad thing, and it will have the opposite effect of what you want.

If he is going to Mass with you on Sunday’s, that is more than many are willing to do, appreciate and thank God for that. You are going into your marriage with your eyes wide open, and are expecting a Catholic husband on the walk back down the isle. He isn’t Catholic, don’t expect him to be one.

I would tell him what is going on, and that he is welcome to join you, but then just drop it and go by yourself. Do not ever nag him about it.

When you marry someone not of your religion, be prepared to do your religion alone. It is what it is, and what makes St. Monica so popular.

God Bless
 
As someone that WAS the non-Catholic…married to a cradle Catholic. I can tell you that the more you force the issue or make an issue of it…the more stressful it will be for both of you.

I, in my own good time, finally converted to the Church and now I am very involved in my Parish…but it had to be my decision. The more my husband tried to make me “see” the more I resisted.

Unbeknownst to me, alot of people were praying I’d have a change of heart, so don’t discount praying for your husband. But please don’t argue with him about it…very seldom can one berate another into thinking the way you want them to.

My grandpa would say…You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him drink"

Good luck & God bless!

Prairie Rose
 
Perhaps God is giving you a glimpse of the struggles ahead. It sounds like he spoke to your soul. Maybe this is not the man God has picked out for you?

What happens when he gets tired of pretending he supports your faith. What happens when he refuses to use Natural Family Planning? What happens when he scoffs your religion in front of the kids? Or refuses to go to Mass, so they do too. If he works against you on the most important thing in your life, your relationship with God, how can your family live in unity? You should not marry some one you want to change.

I wanted my husband to share my faith, so I refused to date men that weren’t serious Catholics. I met my husband at a Catholic Bible study. What a joy, and support he has been to me over the years. We both are Readers at Mass together. We will be celebrating our 28th anniversary this February. 👍

I would encourage you not to settle for less. 🙂
 
This may be God’s way of telling you that you REALLY need to pray heavily about this man and whether or not this is the person you truly want to marry. I can totally understand being in love with someone and wanting to “stick it out” because of that, but if I had listened to what God was telling me (and ALL the signs!) before I got married, I could have spared myself a divorce and many years of unhappiness. I will pray for you, for sure. Please, carefully examine this relationship and even though you may love him now, make sure this is the person you want to spend the rest of your life with.
 
Two words before you do get married: Retreat and discernment.

That’s all I’m going to say on the subject.
 
I absolutely respect those of you who married others in the faith - I know how helpful it is to have someone supporting your faith, and sharing in the bond of love so strongly with Our Lord. The two most devout people I knew were my mother’s parents (may they rest in peace), followed closely by my own mother and father. On par with them are my brother and his wife - an amazing young couple with 6 kids and (hopefully soon!) more on the way.

However, that was not the path I took. I did not intentionally take that way, but I did not intentionally avoid it either. When I began dating my wife almost 5 years ago, it was very quickly on that I knew she was the person I was to marry - not from a selfish motive, but I felt God calling me to the married life with her.

That isn’t to say it was (or is) always easy. There were concerns about marrying in the Church, raising our future children in the faith, and even her non-Catholic brothers being Godparents. However, I kept feeling in my heart, especially when praying about the marriage, that maybe part of the reason she is the one for me is that I am to lead her into the faith, whether as a convert or simply the mother of Catholic children, and as we prepare to enter that next step in life, I continually feel that this is the right path for me.

I say all of this because too often, I see uncharitable words and dire threats about marrying non-Catholics. That isn’t to say the matter is not a grave one - we are told to abandon our families and follow Christ, so anyone who tries to prevent that is an agent of the Devil. Christ even refers to Peter as Satan for doubting the path they must follow. But the comments I’ve seen go beyond that. No one knows the situation that couple is in, so telling them to consider those matters is one thing, but the levels of doubt which I have seen people trying to leverage in conversations disturbs me.

Presumably, the OP is marrying in the Church, which means her and her fiance will (or have) completed Pre-Cana classes. That also means these matters are discussed, and in the interview, they both must agree to marry in the Church and raise the children Catholic. I would like to give all members here who are planning to marry (or who have married) non-Catholics the benefit of the doubt that they have weighed these matters carefully, and are confident in their decision. We must still pray for them, as we pray for all married or those in preparation of the sacrament, but let’s give them a break with some of these over-the-top comments, because I find them close to being condescending.
 
I pray for you! :gopray:

Pater noster qui es in caelis:
sanctificetur Nomen Tuum;
adveniat Regnum Tuum;
fiat voluntas Tua,
sicut in caelo, et in terra.
Panem nostrum cotidianum da nobis hodie;
et dimitte nobis debita nostra,
sicut et nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris;
et ne nos inducas in tentationem;
sed libera nos a Malo. Amen
 
I absolutely respect those of you who married others in the faith - I know how helpful it is to have someone supporting your faith, and sharing in the bond of love so strongly with Our Lord. The two most devout people I knew were my mother’s parents (may they rest in peace), followed closely by my own mother and father. On par with them are my brother and his wife - an amazing young couple with 6 kids and (hopefully soon!) more on the way.

However, that was not the path I took. I did not intentionally take that way, but I did not intentionally avoid it either. When I began dating my wife almost 5 years ago, it was very quickly on that I knew she was the person I was to marry - not from a selfish motive, but I felt God calling me to the married life with her.

That isn’t to say it was (or is) always easy. There were concerns about marrying in the Church, raising our future children in the faith, and even her non-Catholic brothers being Godparents. However, I kept feeling in my heart, especially when praying about the marriage, that maybe part of the reason she is the one for me is that I am to lead her into the faith, whether as a convert or simply the mother of Catholic children, and as we prepare to enter that next step in life, I continually feel that this is the right path for me.

I say all of this because too often, I see uncharitable words and dire threats about marrying non-Catholics. That isn’t to say the matter is not a grave one - we are told to abandon our families and follow Christ, so anyone who tries to prevent that is an agent of the Devil. Christ even refers to Peter as Satan for doubting the path they must follow. But the comments I’ve seen go beyond that. No one knows the situation that couple is in, so telling them to consider those matters is one thing, but the levels of doubt which I have seen people trying to leverage in conversations disturbs me.

Presumably, the OP is marrying in the Church, which means her and her fiance will (or have) completed Pre-Cana classes. That also means these matters are discussed, and in the interview, they both must agree to marry in the Church and raise the children Catholic. I would like to give all members here who are planning to marry (or who have married) non-Catholics the benefit of the doubt that they have weighed these matters carefully, and are confident in their decision. We must still pray for them, as we pray for all married or those in preparation of the sacrament, but let’s give them a break with some of these over-the-top comments, because I find them close to being condescending.
Lovely post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top