Suffered incredible abuse from Mother Superior at Roman Catholic Church in New England

  • Thread starter Thread starter Angryatgod
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Angryatgod

Guest
I had an abusive home life. My father was an active perpetrator of sexual abuse towards several women, abusive towards my mother and I, and a devout Roman Catholic.
He died when I was 9 from lung cancer. I had severe PTSD that was not being acknowledged, addressed, or treated. I was diagnosed with severe ADD and was put on twice the usual dose of stimulants. I began to go to the very small, unrecognized-by-state-education-board, unlisted school at the church.

I couldn’t do my homework because I was going through such bad dissociative episodes that several days at a time were lost from my memory. The nuns acted as the classroom teachers, and they’d often tell me that my dad would be very disappointed in me for not completing my homework.

I was targeted by the Mother Superior. She publicly insulted me, insinuating that I had an intellectual deficiency as opposed to a learning disorder, found a way to shame me if she caught me smiling about something, and finally, began to take an extremely disturbing interest in my body and how I was developing.

She said she would often see male partitioners staring at my chest (I was 13 but very developed) during Mass. She said I was tempting them away from focusing on the Mass, and that my body was my cross to bear. She took it upon herself to suggest to my mother that I should have an elective breast reduction surgery, paid in part by donations the Church received.

I began to see my body as something that was inherently evil, and that I had to maim myself to be less appealing to men. I began seriously self-mutilating, both as a way to try to show the M.S. that I was genuinely trying to be good, and as a cry for help to my mother to please get me away from those insane people.

My mother was doing the best she could and had my soul as her highest priority. She had been brainwashed by my dad into thinking that this church was the only way to reach salvation. She tried to speak to the priest at our church, who was a Bishop about it, but he was in his 90’s and out of it. It was later revealed that the M.S. was actively manipulating him in his senile state, which is considered elderly abuse.

After the M.S. suggested I get the reduction surgery to my mom, it clicked that this place was incredibly abusive and she took me out of the school. She tried to get me to come to church with her still, but I now had PTSD from my father passing AND the abuse in the school. I stopped going, and eventually stopped going to church altogether, and now I haven’t gone to church or had any kind of faith for 15 years.

I’m feeling drawn back to faith—but please don’t try to convert me, I’m already kind of going in that direction and after all of this insanity and trauma I have a right to move at a pace that won’t send me into a flashback.

I feel a need for spiritual guidance and some kind of perspective on all of this mess. I would gratefully and warmly welcome any insight into what could have been happening when I was a kid, how to understand my anger at god, how to understand my incredible distrust of religion, and how to move forward spiritually.

I really hope to hear from you guys.
 
It was a New England church, so the U.S.

I’m in the 27-35 age bracket now.
 
It was a New England church, so the U.S.

I’m in the 27-35 age bracket now.

I’d love to hear any and all help, but is it ok for me to ask how that info might be helpful for you?
 
Two quick questions:
  1. please confirm you are over 18
  2. when did this take place? What decade?
Reason I ask, while many people remember the sisters teaching at Catholic School via rose color lenses before Vatican II, there were many teaching who were not really not meant to be teachers and/or never received the training required to be good teacher.

Today, MOST sisters who are teachers are really called to be teachers and have received the training.

Also, it was not unheard of for some Mother Superiors to be overly strict. Not just with lay girls, but also the religious sisters. There are stories of female saints who had very strict or abusive superiors.

Now, none of this excuses this. But it just means that sometimes, you have people elected to leadership positions who really don’t have the proper leadership skills.

I pray this helps a little.

God Bless
 
Sure, I was born in the late 80’s/early 90’s. I’m awfully sorry to be so vague, I’m not trying to be combative. I just still have a lot of fear surrounding the church and religion, so I don’t want to give too much specific information in case someone from that church is on this site.

Thank you for your kind words, and I really hope that your prayers help. I feel like these people took away what was supposed to be the safest and most loving resource in a kid’s life.
 
It was a New England church, so the U.S.

I’m in the 27-35 age bracket now.

I’d love to hear any and all help, but is it ok for me to ask how that info might be helpful for you?
Wow… OK. I was expecting you to say this happened back in the 1950s or 1960s…

All I can really say is sometimes there are people in education (whether a religious sister or in public school) who really have no business teaching.
 
Last edited:
I learned after I left that the M.S. kidnapped the Bishop (he wasn’t very lucid by that point) and lived with him in a hotel room in Michigan for a while. I really have no idea what that was about, but it didn’t really surprise me.
 
Sure, I was born in the late 80’s/early 90’s. I’m awfully sorry to be so vague, I’m not trying to be combative. I just still have a lot of fear surrounding the church and religion, so I don’t want to give too much specific information in case someone from that church is on this site.

Thank you for your kind words, and I really hope that your prayers help. I feel like these people took away what was supposed to be the safest and most loving resource in a kid’s life.
I’m sorry you had this experience.

I went to public school in Delaware, and I can tell you that when I was in middle school and high school during the early 1990s, there were some teachers who were pretty nasty and by today’s standards had no business in education.

From what I’ve heard over the years, I know that there were some sisters who really shouldn’t have been anywhere near kids too. Some people simply do not have what it takes to be in education or youth ministry.

Again, I’m so sorry you dealt with this. And while I know nothing will take the scars away, just know that you are in the company of several great saints who dealt with strict, difficult, and/or abusive Mother Superiors - and two of those female Saints are now Doctors of the Church.
  • St. Teresa of Avila
  • St. Therese of Lisieux
God Bless
 
Yes. I’m sorry, I’m a bit paranoid right now, I welcome your (name removed by moderator)ut but in order to help make this experience less scary, would you mind including why you feel these questions could be helpful? I really appreciate it.
 
Thank you, thank you so much for your gentle responses and kindness.
 
I can sense that you’re suffering muchly, and I don’t want to make it worse for you.
I was asking to get a better sense of the situation.
I’m simply not qualified to give advice beyond what your therapist recommends.
FWIW, I’ll remember you in my prayers, for healing and strength and uplifting. ❤️:pray:t2:
 
I don’t think that’s appropriate right now and this is a delicate situation.
 
Last edited:
OP, I’m very sorry you had bad experiences with your father, the Mother Superior, and the church. What you have described is wrong and inexcusable behavior.

However, I think this very personal and complex topic that you bring up is beyond the scope of what strangers on the Internet can properly address.

I would encourage you to please talk to a mental health counselor (maybe you already are) and, when you feel ready, to a priest.

God bless
 
OP I am really sorry you went through that. I hope you are getting the therapy that you need and take all the time you can coming to back to a place of faith.
 
I had an abusive home life. My father was an active perpetrator of sexual abuse towards several women, abusive towards my mother and I, and a devout Roman Catholic.
He died when I was 9 from lung cancer. I had severe PTSD that was not being acknowledged, addressed, or treated. I was diagnosed with severe ADD and was put on twice the usual dose of stimulants. I began to go to the very small, unrecognized-by-state-education-board, unlisted school at the church.
Am sorry for all that you went through .Jesus love you and cares for you .i would suggest you to go to another parish and meet a pious priest for your spiritual guidance ,perhaps make a good confession ,and later it would be nice if you could join a prayer group ,and meanwhile attend a holy hour Eucharist adoration.a retreat would be ideal as you need inner healing just inquire from your parishioners or your neighbor.
 
I’m sorry you had abusive experiences in your childhood.

I think you need professional counseling and therapy.

This really isn’t something we can help you with. We have no way if knowing what was going on, and are not qualified to help you with PTSD or abuse. You need someone professional to work through all this with.
 
I am very sorry to hear that you endured this terrible abuse and to hear that it was perpetrated by people who claimed to represent the Church.

Perhaps the most shocking element of your story is the mother superior’s recommendation that you have breast reduction surgery at the age of just 13. The mother superior was no doubt an intelligent woman and must have known that no reputable surgeon would perform a breast reduction on a girl that young unless the circumstances were absolutely truly exceptional, and nothing in your account suggests that they were (you say that you were ‘very developed’, but that could simply mean that your breasts developed relatively early, not that they were abnormally large, especially since the rest of your body would also have continued to grow). Although it is not entirely unheard of for girls to have breast reduction aged around 16, it is still unusual, and I think that it almost defies belief to imagine that a surgeon would risk performing the operation on a 13 year old. The mother superior must have known that at age 13 neither your breasts nor the rest of your body would have finished growing. This would have meant that you would have risked growing up with disproportionately small breasts or, more likely, that you would have required several further reductions over the following seven or eight years or so. Indeed, I should hope that no surgeon would remove healthy tissue from a patient unless she was suffering from physical or psychological distress that could not be alleviated in any other way, and in your case it seems that the only distress that you were suffering was that caused by the mother superior’s behaviour. All of this leads me to conclude that the mother superior was a very clever, very manipulative, very sadistic woman, and that she knew perfectly well that a breast reduction was almost certainly out of the question, but pushed the idea as a way of causing you mental distress.

I wonder how common it is for a parish to have a retired bishop over 90 years of age and suffering from dementia as its pastor. I know that retired bishops often do continue to carry out pastoral duties of some kind, but it seems rather strange for a bishop to be assigned as the main parish priest, especially when he was so old and mentally incapacitated. This is perhaps something to raise with the diocese in the hope that this would no longer happen today.

If this happened as recently as the 1990s, there is a good chance that the mother superior is still alive and possibly even still working in a parish or school. Personally, I think that it would be a good idea for you to consider reporting what you have told us to the police, in case criminal charges can be brought, to the Church, in case she can be disciplined by her bishop or her order, and perhaps also to civil lawyers, in case you are able to claim damages that would give you some sense of restitution, go some way to compensating for your losses, and cover the cost of psychological therapy, from which you would no doubt benefit.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top