Sunday instead of the Sabbath?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Boxerdog
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“I have repeatedly offered $1,000 to anyone who can prove to me from the Bible alone that I am bound to keep Sunday holy. There is no such law in the Bible.’
You may keep your $1000 as it would be morally wrong to take your money off you, knowing you had lost before you had begun. The Scriptures cannot be used against her whose scriptures they are
It is a law of the holy Catholic Church alone. The Bible says, ‘Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy.’
Actually ‘NO’. It is a nice complement but we cannot take complements when they are not due!

Catholic was not used until AD107, yet we know St John and St Paul refered to ‘the Lords Day’ which of course was a Sunday. This occured some 60 odd years before St Ignatious of Antioch put the name ‘Catholic’ to the Holy Church He founded.

Like so many before you, who have tried to use the Old Testament to substantiate their thinking: Christ said He came to ‘FULFILL’ the Old Testament. We are living now in the age of the New Covenant between God and man. 👍
 
Seventh Day Adventist ‘Praise Him’ wrote:
I have repeatedly offered $1,000 to anyone who can prove to me from the Bible alone that I am bound to keep Sunday holy. There is no such law in the Bible.’
You may keep your $1000 as it would be morally wrong to take your money off you, knowing you had lost before you had begun. The Scriptures cannot be used against her whose scriptures they are
:It is a law of the holy Catholic Church alone. The Bible says, ‘Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy.’
Actually ‘NO’. It is a nice complement but we cannot take complements when they are not due!

Catholic was not used until AD107, yet we know St John and St Paul refered to ‘the Lords Day’ which of course was a Sunday. This occured some 60 odd years before St Ignatious of Antioch put the name ‘Catholic’ to the Holy Church He founded.

Like so many before you, who have tried to use the Old Testament to substantiate their thinking: Christ said He came to ‘FULFILL’ the Old Testament. We are living now in the age of the New Covenant between God and man.
 
Well mr or miss “praise him” it is obvious that you are here proselytizing for the SDA CULT. There is no cult or fundie group that hates the Catholic Church more than the SDAs.

They like to call the Catholic Church the “*hore of Babylon” and “the Beast”, they make up lies about a hat (TRIPLE tiara) that has not even been worn since the Reign of John the 23rd. claiming that the tiara has the words “the Vicar of God” which ahs never had those words engraved on it ever, even 50 years ago when it was last worn.

Do You think you will get lots of converts, telling outregous lies about the Catholic Church? It is an old saying "you get more flies with honey than vinegar.
 
Doctrinal Catechism, p. 174
As we can see from these few quotes as well as in scripture, (there are a whole lot more just like these from catholic sources)
It really surprises me to see a catholic forum trying to defend sunday from scripture when there is an overwhelming amount of quotes through the years from catholic sources including the catechism
The Catholic forum does not have to defend anything. This forum is for those who wish to come here and discourse.

I have a copy of said catechism in front of me. On page 174 it expounds Good Friday. I would suggest you go back to those of the SDA who sent you here and tell them they gave you the wrong information 😉
 
Revelation 1:10. Most Scholars Catholic, Protestant, or whatever agree that this is not about Sabbath or Sunday but it is Johns way of saying “the Day of the Lord”, referring to the Day of judgement, or what Paul would call the “parousia” which means “coming” or the grand entrance of Christ on the scene at the end of the world. If it did apply to a specific day of the week, it would be the Sabbath because the Sabbath is the Lord’s day (Mark 2:27-28, Isaiah 58:13).

Sorry for being wordy, but I have to say something about Colossians 2:16. Paul is not here telling us not to keep the Sabbath. He is reiterating Christ’s stance on the Sabbath. Christ taught how to keep the Sabbath, not not to keep the Sabbath. If you put Colossians 2:16 in context, and start reading in chapter 2, Paul is denouncing a philosophical and mystical, syncretistic, Hellenized Jewish legaism…not the law itself. The hand written ordinances he speaks of are not the law, but the “cheirographon” (ver.14) which was a word used back then to denote an accusation in the docket at a court case. The law points out our sin, like a mirror. But the solution is not to break the mirror. The cheirographon which was “nailed to the cross” is the accusation against us. It is God’s way of telling us that the way of keeping track of the sins of His saints has been nailed to the cross. Furthermore, in verse 16 where Paul talks about “meats and drinks” right away we are into a translation problem. The translators across the board are biased against the law. The words here are “brosei” (eating) and “prosei” (drinking). But its usually translated as food and drink. If it says eating and drinking, then it refers to how we eat or drink. But if it refers to food and drink, it is referring to what we eat or drink. It is either talking about the law, or how we keep the law…the evidence shows that Colossians 2:16 concerns the latter.

Finally, arguing never gets us anywhere. But as I have learned from other threads on this subject, the Catholics usually say “just about every Catholic Church has a saturday Mass”. In fact, every Sabbath afternoon when Im on my way home from Church, I drive by a Catholic parish, and the parking lot is full. There is no reason (doctrinally) that Catholics cannot keep the Sabbath. What I challenge each of you to do is to make the Sabbath as day of rest for you. You don’t have to become Adventists. But out of respect for God’s law, I think you would benefit and be blessed by making the Sabbath a special day of blessing you yourselves and your families. Don’t work on it, take a break from shopping, etc. God did not give us the Sabbath as an arbitrary burden, but to protect us from fogetting that He made us, “and not we ourselves”.

Peace and God Bless,

alan
I would challenge you to adhere to the scriptures that you and “praise Him” profess, and stop breaking the first commandment by making the Jewish Sabbath an idol. I’ll try this one more time before I “kick the dust off.” 'So God blessed the seventh day and hallowed it, because on it God rested from all His work which He had done in creation."Gen 2:4…Jesus(God) RESTED from His work by rising to His RESTING place on the first day of the week Ps.132:8, 2Chr.6:41 Matt.28:1, Mark 16:19, Luke 24:51. "So Jesus(God) blessed the first day and hallowed it. because on it Jesus(God) RESTED from all His work(Rom.4:25) which He had done in the “new creation” (2 Cor.5:17) "…the old(Sabbath) has passed away, behold the new(First Day) has come. See also Matt.28:1. This is the biblical mandate that “praise Him” offered the $1000.00 reward for. All I ask is that he pay off his bet by sending the $1000.00 to Catholic Relief Services. He can even keep the tax deduction. How magnanimous of the “thredkiller”. I won’t hold my breath waiting for him to pay it off or for you to observe the “Lord’s Day” as mandated in holy writ. BTW. By what authority do you rewrite Rev.1:10?
 
Having answered the question, this thread is now closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top