Supine Ignorance and Affected Ignorance

  • Thread starter Thread starter JM3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JM3

Guest
These terms are mentioned in Ronald Knox’s 1927 book ‘THE BELIEF OF CATHOLICS’. He quotes Pope Pius IX about invincible ignorance:

"Pius IX has enunciated the principle for us very clearly: “Those who are hampered by invincible ignorance about our Holy Religion, and, keeping the natural law, with its commands that are written by God in every human heart, and being ready to obey him, live honourably and uprightly, can, with the power of Divine light and grace helping them, attain eternal life. For God, who clearly sees, searches out, and knows the minds, hearts, thoughts, and dispositions of all, in his great goodness and mercy does not by any means suffer a man to be punished with eternal torments, who is not guilty of voluntary fault.”

and gives a good example of this. Then he says this:

“The attitude of mind–painfully common–which says, “I am not qualified to go into all these complicated credentials of the Catholic Church,” is an attitude of intellectual indolence masquerading as intellectual humility. The man who “thinks there may be something in it”, yet makes no effort to find out how much, is actuated not by invincible but by** supine ignorance. The man who (worse still) excuses himself from examining our credentials for fear lest he should find them to be true; who tells you that he is too busy to consider the Catholic claim, or too modest, or too unadventurous, when at the back of his mind he is shrinking from the injury to his prospects, the troubles with his family which submission to the Church would involve–such a man is actuated not by invincible but by affected **ignorance. And, I am sorry to say it, I believe there is much supine ignorance, much affected ignorance, among our fellow- countrymen. Let them not deceive themselves; they will have to find another title to heaven if they are to attain heaven at all.”

I know this is a pre-Vatican II book. I was curious if these terms are still used in post-Vatican II theology or philosophy and where I can find them.
 
The Catechism does not use them, but rather the general heading of “through no fault of their own.”
CCC #847:
This affirmation [no salvation outside of the Church] is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church:

Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.
That’s not to say the terms are no longer valid or relevant, but we are urged not to judge the hearts or souls of other people, so that would include trying to put their ignorance into different boxes labeled “supine” and “affected.”
 
The Catechism does not use them, but rather the general heading of “through no fault of their own.”
Quote:
Originally Posted by CCC #847
This affirmation [no salvation outside of the Church] is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church:

Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.

That’s not to say the terms are no longer valid or relevant, but we are urged not to judge the hearts or souls of other people, so that would include trying to put their ignorance into different boxes labeled “supine” and “affected.”
CCC 847 refers to invincible ignorance and saying that I’m ‘trying to put their ignorance into different boxes’ doesn’t answer the question.
 
…we are urged not to judge the hearts or souls of other people, so that would include trying to put their ignorance into different boxes labeled “supine” and “affected.”
The same Jesus who said “judge not” also said “judge a just judgment”. How do you resolve that contradiction?
 
The Catechism uses similar terms in discussing personal guilt for sin. This would seem to apply to all people, not just Catholics…
CCC #1859 Mortal sin requires full knowledge and complete consent. It presupposes knowledge of the sinful character of the act, of its opposition to God’s law. It also implies a consent sufficiently deliberate to be a personal choice. Feigned ignorance and hardness of heart do not diminish, but rather increase, the voluntary character of a sin.
Thankyou for the original quotes from Pope Pius IX. They are very interesting.
 
Consider these words of Saint Pius X on ignorance

*ACERBO NIMIS *
ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS X ON TEACHING CHRISTIAN DOCTRINE
APRIL 15, 1905
To the Patriarchs, Primates, Archbishops, Bishops and other Ordinaries in Peace and Communion with the Apostolic See.
2. It is a common complaint, unfortunately too well founded, that there are large numbers of Christians in our own time who are entirely ignorant of those truths necessary for salvation. And when we mention Christians, We refer not only to the masses or to those in the lower walks of life – for these find some excuse for their ignorance in the fact that the demands of their harsh employers hardly leave them time to take care of themselves or of their dear ones – but We refer to those especially who do not lack culture or talents and, indeed, are possessed of abundant knowledge regarding things of the world but live rashly and imprudently with regard to religion. It is hard to find words to describe how profound is the darkness in which they are engulfed and, what is most deplorable of all, how tranquilly they repose there. They rarely give thought to God, the Supreme Author and Ruler of all things, or to the teachings of the faith of Christ. They know nothing of the Incarnation of the Word of God, nothing of the perfect restoration of the human race which He accomplished. Grace, the greatest of the helps for attaining eternal things, the Holy Sacrifice and the Sacraments by which we obtain grace, are entirely unknown to them. They have no conception of the malice and baseness of sin; hence they show no anxiety to avoid sin or to renounce it. And so they arrive at life’s end in such a condition that, lest all hope of salvation be lost, the priest is obliged to give in the last few moments of life a summary teaching of religion, a time which should be devoted to stimulating the soul to greater love for God. And even this as too often happens only when the dying man is not so sinfully ignorant as to look upon the ministration of the priest as useless, and then calmly faces the fearful passage to eternity without making his peace with God. And so Our Predecessor, Benedict XIV, had just cause to write: "We declare that a great number of those who are condemned to eternal punishment suffer that everlasting calamity because of ignorance of those mysteries of faith which must be known and believed in order to be numbered among the elect."
 
Consider these words of Saint Pius X on ignorance

*ACERBO NIMIS *
ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS X ON TEACHING CHRISTIAN DOCTRINE
APRIL 15, 1905
To the Patriarchs, Primates, Archbishops, Bishops and other Ordinaries in Peace and Communion with the Apostolic See.
2. It is a common complaint, unfortunately too well founded, that there are large numbers of Christians in our own time who are entirely ignorant of those truths necessary for salvation. And when we mention Christians, We refer not only to the masses or to those in the lower walks of life – for these find some excuse for their ignorance in the fact that the demands of their harsh employers hardly leave them time to take care of themselves or of their dear ones – but We refer to those especially who do not lack culture or talents and, indeed, are possessed of abundant knowledge regarding things of the world but live rashly and imprudently with regard to religion. It is hard to find words to describe how profound is the darkness in which they are engulfed and, what is most deplorable of all, how tranquilly they repose there. They rarely give thought to God, the Supreme Author and Ruler of all things, or to the teachings of the faith of Christ. They know nothing of the Incarnation of the Word of God, nothing of the perfect restoration of the human race which He accomplished. Grace, the greatest of the helps for attaining eternal things, the Holy Sacrifice and the Sacraments by which we obtain grace, are entirely unknown to them. They have no conception of the malice and baseness of sin; hence they show no anxiety to avoid sin or to renounce it. And so they arrive at life’s end in such a condition that, lest all hope of salvation be lost, the priest is obliged to give in the last few moments of life a summary teaching of religion, a time which should be devoted to stimulating the soul to greater love for God. And even this as too often happens only when the dying man is not so sinfully ignorant as to look upon the ministration of the priest as useless, and then calmly faces the fearful passage to eternity without making his peace with God. And so Our Predecessor, Benedict XIV, had just cause to write: "We declare that a great number of those who are condemned to eternal punishment suffer that everlasting calamity because of ignorance of those mysteries of faith which must be known and believed in order to be numbered among the elect."
This is about the ignorance of Catholics about their faith, not about invicible ignorance or the ignorance of non-catholics.

Other extracts from ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS X ON TEACHING CHRISTIAN DOCTRINE :

“6. How many and how grave are the consequences of ignorance in matters of religion! And on the other hand, how necessary and how beneficial is religious instruction! It is indeed vain to expect a fulfillment of the duties of a Christian by one who does not even know them.”

“11. For this reason the Council of Trent, treating of the duties of pastors of souls, decreed that their first and most important work is the instruction of the faithful.[16] It therefore prescribes that they shall teach the truths of religion on Sundays and on the more solemn feast days; moreover during the holy seasons of Advent and Lent they are to give such instruction every day or at least three times a week. This, however, was not considered enough. The Council provided for the instruction of youth by adding that the pastors, either personally or through others, must explain the truths of religion at least on Sundays and feast days to the children of the parish, and inculcate obedience to God and to their parents. When the Sacraments are to be administered, it enjoins upon pastors the duty to explain their efficacy in plain and simple language.”

“13. The task of the catechist is to take up one or other of the truths of faith or of Christian morality and then explain it in all its parts; and since amendment of life is the chief aim of his instruction, the catechist must needs make a comparison between what God commands us to do and what is our actual conduct. After this, he will use examples appropriately taken from the Holy Scriptures, Church history, and the lives of the saints-thus moving his hearers and clearly pointing out to them how they are to regulate their own conduct. He should, in conclusion, earnestly exhort all present to dread and avoid vice and to practice virtue.”

"17. What We have said so far demonstrates the supreme importance of religious instruction. We ought, therefore, to do all that lies in our power to maintain the teaching of Christian doctrine with full vigor, and where such is neglected, to restore it; for in the words of Our Predecessor, Benedict XIV, ‘There is nothing more effective than catechetical instruction to spread the glory of God and to secure the salvation of souls.’ "
 
=JM3;7128639]This is about the ignorance of Catholics about their faith, not about invicible ignorance or the ignorance of non-catholics.
Of course this was written to Catholics but I wouldn’t limit this to only Catholics. What about those Catholics who have left the Church and have become Protestant because they never took the time to learn their Catholic faith? Isn’t their ignorance through their own fault?
People who have never been Catholic aren’t going to get a free pass. They can be ignorant of the Catholic Church through their own fault just as a poorly taught Catholic who has left the Church.
I think this encyclical can apply to anyone who is ignorant of the truth through their own fault.

“We refer to those especially who do not lack culture or talents and, indeed, are possessed of abundant knowledge regarding things of the world but live rashly and imprudently with regard to religion…They rarely give thought to God, the Supreme Author and Ruler of all things, or to the teachings of the faith of Christ. They know nothing of the Incarnation of the Word of God, nothing of the perfect restoration of the human race which He accomplished. Grace, the greatest of the helps for attaining eternal things, the Holy Sacrifice and the Sacraments by which we obtain grace, are entirely unknown to them…We declare that a great number of those who are condemned to eternal punishment suffer that everlasting calamity because of ignorance of those mysteries of faith which must be known and believed in order to be numbered among the elect.”
 
Of course this was written to Catholics but I wouldn’t limit this to only Catholics. What about those Catholics who have left the Church and have become Protestant because they never took the time to learn their Catholic faith? Isn’t their ignorance through their own fault?
People who have never been Catholic aren’t going to get a free pass. They can be ignorant of the Catholic Church through their own fault just as a poorly taught Catholic who has left the Church.
I think this encyclical can apply to anyone who is ignorant of the truth through their own fault.

“We refer to those especially who do not lack culture or talents and, indeed, are possessed of abundant knowledge regarding things of the world but live rashly and imprudently with regard to religion…They rarely give thought to God, the Supreme Author and Ruler of all things, or to the teachings of the faith of Christ. They know nothing of the Incarnation of the Word of God, nothing of the perfect restoration of the human race which He accomplished. Grace, the greatest of the helps for attaining eternal things, the Holy Sacrifice and the Sacraments by which we obtain grace, are entirely unknown to them…We declare that a great number of those who are condemned to eternal punishment suffer that everlasting calamity because of ignorance of those mysteries of faith which must be known and believed in order to be numbered among the elect.”
How nice of you to set yourself as the authority on Papal Encyclicals.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top