Switching parishes. Anyone ever done this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter punisherthunder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your parish is always based on territory. You will always belong to the territorial parish in which you reside.

You can attend any parish you choose. Don’t confuse that with which parish is actually your parish and who is actually your pastor.

.
A Catholic priest posted here a while back and addressed the question.

You’re a member of a parish based on where you live.

You may of course register (and attend Mass, etc.) at any parish.

Where being a member comes in is (as the others suggested) if, for example, you’re planning a Catholic wedding or funeral. If you go to a parish where you’re not a member they may, but are not required to, provide the service for you.
That being said, then we are members of a Parish, but we don’t attend there (except for confessions). We attend a little far away Parish where we registered because we prefer the Latin responses and Gregorian Chants, plus a St. Michaels Prayer at the end of the Novus Ordo Mass. We baptized our son in the registered Parish.
A good point. Even if you move to another state, the courtesy of informing the parish office staff of the parish you leave behind that you need to be removed from the rolls is much appreciated. It would save them so much in unnecessary postage if everyone always did this!!
YES. And please be aware that while anyone is certainly welcome to attend Mass on any given day any where they find themselves…pastors build their budgets on the number of people registered.
This is the data that the Archdiocese uses when he asks can he build an addition? How much tax should the parish be charged by the Diocese to support the chancery, the men in seminaries, the school administration, the outreach and social service agencies that they offer. The registration also tells people who teach how many students in any given age they should expect to have? How many books do they need to order, how many desks are necessary? How many Bibles should we have on hand? How many people can we reasonably expect to give based on age and income? It’s not merely about “gee I love Fr. so-and so’s homily”. That’s GREAT! But people get all upset and worked up when they NEED services and the parish is not equipped to help them.
They have to know who you are, that you’re participating in the life of the parish so they can waive fees if necessary for you, that you have children that need catechesis that they can write letters of recommendation when you come in and ask for them, when people want to be Godparents and the other priest who never heard of you asks your pastor if you are good to go, and HE has heard of you.
Bottom line: does switching impact your spiritual life negatively?: Absolutely NOT.
Will you eventually have problems from hopping around? You might.
Just land somewhere you like, and make your presence known by registering.
Maybe you’ll never need anything. But somebody else will, and hopefully things have been put in place to better serve everyone. Even the destitute.
God Bless.
Oh Good to know this, because we are open to move States in 1-2 years from now.
 
We live five blocks from one parish ( our home parish I guess ) but we attend and are registered at another one 30 blocks away. Why? The parish school is better…

Make sure you’re registered and also realize that priests do move on…
 
Go to Mass wherever you want. I belong to St Joseph in Richardson TX but because of work schedule, I work for a major retail or I go to mass at The Catholic Cathedral in downtown Dallas because it is closer to work and it is easier to get there on time.
 
I know many parishes that have buried someone that wasn’t a member.
When one plans to get married in the Church, it takes 6 month to do so and that’s plenty of time to become a member. God Bless, Memaw
Some parishes do, some don’t, and some won’t. If you don’t take the trouble to find out which kind you’re going to, you are taking your chances. Believe it or not, that is the way it is. I certainly wouldn’t presume that anybody who wants to get married at a basilica or a major cathedral can do it.
 
My son and his wife were married in the same parish where her parents were married, even tho they neither lived in that parish and did not intend to after the wedding. God Bless, Memaw
It is the norm for the children of parishioners to be able to marry in the parish of the parents.
 
I do not know why a bishop would have a problem with that.
I’m 23 now myself and have thought of joining a nondenominational church when I get older. The church that my family is at right now seems kind of in some way a little rude. The people who have kids that go to the churches school seem to stick to those other people and no one just reaches out to talk really. I would be happy to make friends with others there but it seems like it would be hard to do so.

I wen’t to a Presbyterian church as part of an assignment for a Theology class. The people there have groups that organize activities and the people just seem happier. That is the kind of church I wan’t and need to be in. I need it in order to have the wan’t to keep going and my church does not offer that really. It sort of makes me sad almost because my church is a big one and I would think more people would be interested in making groups and clubs there. My mother said she knows someone who goes to the Presbyterian church and I think she is involved in a few things there. I may very well start doing some of the things they offer.
Just a word of caution about churches who appeal to worldly appetites: don’t. I understand the appeal of these modern oriented churches and how they have better music, social gatherings, food, etc. Ask yourself if this is how Jesus preached His message? Why was He born in a food trough for animals instead of an opulent palace? Why didn’t He just make it rain food when people were hungry? There’s a reason why Christ’s church has survived for over 2,000 years while many of these Protestant churches last only as long as the pastor/minister. It’s because the Catholic Church is the true Church, the one established by Jesus Christ and nourished by the Holy Spirit. You may enjoy the socials at a denominational church but you’ll still be apart from God. Is that what you choose? 🤷
 
It is the norm for the children of parishioners to be able to marry in the parish of the parents.
Certainly true enough at one time, but in a highly mobile society where it is common for people to be in their late 20’s and even early 30’s and long off on their own at the time of a marriage, going back to Mom and Dad’s parish (assuming Mom and Dad are still together, which is a very big if) – and the liklihood that the couple’s own friends are many, hundreds and thousands of miles away from Mom and Dad, this would seem to be a practice that is increasingly uncommon. Anyone sticking to a church wedding today - in whatever parish located wherever - should be congratulated to not giving-in to peer pressure for a “destination wedding” on a beach in Jamaica or Disney or on a cruise ship.
 
Just a word of caution about churches who appeal to worldly appetites: don’t. I understand the appeal of these modern oriented churches and how they have better music, social gatherings, food, etc. Ask yourself if this is how Jesus preached His message? Why was He born in a food trough for animals instead of an opulent palace? Why didn’t He just make it rain food when people were hungry? There’s a reason why Christ’s church has survived for over 2,000 years while many of these Protestant churches last only as long as the pastor/minister. It’s because the Catholic Church is the true Church, the one established by Jesus Christ and nourished by the Holy Spirit. You may enjoy the socials at a denominational church but you’ll still be apart from God. Is that what you choose? 🤷
I do not view it as being apart from God in any way. I still believe in God and nothing can change that. How would going to another church change my belief in God? They worship God in a different way from us but there is no problem with that. I know we are told ours is the true religion but others believe that about their own religions also.

I do not see it as leaving my religion but the place that I worship in because I feel that the place I currently am in is not the place it once was. Something happened in my church a year or so ago and it left me worried.

A building means little when the belief you have is held in the heart and mind of a person. We are walking and talking beings of God. A church is a place for us to gather with others of common belief. If you do not agree with me on that then it is fine but please let me live my life how I see fit and in a way that makes me comfortable.

Thank you and peace be with you always.
 
I do not view it as being apart from God in any way. I still believe in God and nothing can change that. How would going to another church change my belief in God? They worship God in a different way from us but there is no problem with that. I know we are told ours is the true religion but others believe that about their own religions also.

I do not see it as leaving my religion but the place that I worship in because I feel that the place I currently am in is not the place it once was. Something happened in my church a year or so ago and it left me worried.

A building means little when the belief you have is held in the heart and mind of a person. We are walking and talking beings of God. A church is a place for us to gather with others of common belief. If you do not agree with me on that then it is fine but please let me live my life how I see fit and in a way that makes me comfortable.

Thank you and peace be with you always.
They don’t have the Eucharist. Nothing else matters, not clubs, not activities.
 
They don’t have the Eucharist. Nothing else matters, not clubs, not activities.
The church I found the activities at is the only reason I would be going there. I’m not going to join in the faith I already have one. I am also not going to tell them that they are wrong for believing in what they do. You are allowed to believe what you choose and that is fine. My Dad is also Presbyterian so I do know a little about what they believe in.
 
The church I found the activities at is the only reason I would be going there. I’m not going to join in the faith I already have one. I am also not going to tell them that they are wrong for believing in what they do. You are allowed to believe what you choose and that is fine. My Dad is also Presbyterian so I do know a little about what they believe in.
From your last few posts especially the one in response to my post, I think I understand what you’re saying though I wouldn’t do what it appears you’re planning on doing. It sounds like you’re attending their services (as you know it’s not a Mass) for social activities and contact but still you intend on following the Catholic faith. Is that about it?
 
It is the norm for the children of parishioners to be able to marry in the parish of the parents.
Certainly true enough at one time, but in a highly mobile society where it is common for people to be in their late 20’s and even early 30’s and long off on their own at the time of a marriage, going back to Mom and Dad’s parish (assuming Mom and Dad are still together, which is a very big if) – and the liklihood that the couple’s own friends are many, hundreds and thousands of miles away from Mom and Dad, this would seem to be a practice that is increasingly uncommon. Anyone sticking to a church wedding today - in whatever parish located wherever - should be congratulated to not giving-in to peer pressure for a “destination wedding” on a beach in Jamaica or Disney or on a cruise ship.
I might add that in my mother’s day Catholic couples tended to marry in the wife’s parents’ parish, and the couples tended to attend the husband’s parents’ parish (again assuming that the couple still lived in the same town or the next town).
 
From what I’ve found out there isn’t typically a geographic factor, unless it’s a parochial school, then that may come into play but we don’t have any children though.

My concern is feeling like I’m leaving my past at this Church to learn and celebrate at this Basilica. For the record both are equidistant from my home.
Don’t go cold turkey. Try attending your new parish twice a month, then three times…

I made a painful decision to leave my parish recently and this is how I did it. It worked very well.
 
Certainly true enough at one time, but in a highly mobile society where it is common for people to be in their late 20’s and even early 30’s and long off on their own at the time of a marriage, going back to Mom and Dad’s parish (assuming Mom and Dad are still together, which is a very big if) – and the liklihood that the couple’s own friends are many, hundreds and thousands of miles away from Mom and Dad, this would seem to be a practice that is increasingly uncommon. Anyone sticking to a church wedding today - in whatever parish located wherever - should be congratulated to not giving-in to peer pressure for a “destination wedding” on a beach in Jamaica or Disney or on a cruise ship.
In the Archdiocese of Portland, the marriage policy states: For the purpose of celebrating marriage, children whose parents are members of a parish may be treated as having “domicile” in the parish when seeking to celebrate their marriage.

It also says this: Parish clergy should make a reasonable effort to accept the request of a couple living outside their parish to marry unless this would make it impossible to provide adequate opportunities for their own parishioners to marry in their proper parish. He may request the permission of the proper pastor of either party. When it is not possible to accommodate a couple’s request to marry in his parish, the priest/deacon should refer them to their proper parish or to a priest or church able to accommodate their request.

Note that if you marry outside your proper parish, the priest gets permission from the “proper pastor” of one of the parties marrying.

Other dioceses will have other policies. A basilica church, for instance, might have to have a policy of only accepting those for marriage who have established domicile, because otherwise they would be overwhelmed with requests. It just depends.

Most people who become regulars at a parish other than the parish they live in are not going to have a problem that affects them directly. Still, it does not take a lot of effort to head even those off. If I had a friend doing this–which our archbishop is fine with–from a practical standpoint I’d say that the most appreciated courtesy is to inform the parish that you are leaving that you are leaving as soon as you have established that you are a full member of the new parish. If everyone did that, it would save our churches a lot on postage, wasted phone calls, incorrect parish directories, and so on. (Yes, when they have a big capital campaign, they sometimes do delegate the job of calling everyone still on the parish rolls…)
 
From your last few posts especially the one in response to my post, I think I understand what you’re saying though I wouldn’t do what it appears you’re planning on doing. It sounds like you’re attending their services (as you know it’s not a Mass) for social activities and contact but still you intend on following the Catholic faith. Is that about it?
I would not be going to their church services for religious reasons. I intend on keeping my faith the way it is right now. I just wan’t a social place I can go to because my church offers little to none.
 
I would not be going to their church services for religious reasons. I intend on keeping my faith the way it is right now. I just wan’t a social place I can go to because my church offers little to none.
Have you asked the priest about starting one yourself? Perhaps there is a group of people waiting for someone like you to get the ball rolling. Maybe the priest will let you put something in the bulletin to see if there’s interest.
 
I would not be going to their church services for religious reasons…
My mind is still trying to wrap around this concept. Are you saying that it doesn’t matter to you whether or not the church you attend believes what you know to be the truth? (You do believe that the Real Presence is true, correct? That the absolution offered in the Sacrament of Penance is actual? Do you see what I’m getting at?)
 
My mind is still trying to wrap around this concept. Are you saying that it doesn’t matter to you whether or not the church you attend believes what you know to be the truth? (You do believe that the Real Presence is true, correct? That the absolution offered in the Sacrament of Penance is actual? Do you see what I’m getting at?)
Yes and I see what you are getting at.

What I believe to be the truth is different from the truth they believe in. I do not see a reason why I should limit myself to one group just because of this one thing.

For example lets say someone believes in another God like being. I do not care about that and the fact they believe in them would not stop me from talking to them or doing activities that would help benefit others. Would I agree with them that they exist or are real? No I would not but they are entitled to believe that if they wan’t.

I know they are not in the same faith as me and I may try to tell them what I believe but I will not push my beliefs on them because that can in some cases be rude. The thing here is I have views they do not agree with perhaps and that is fine with me. They do not have to like me if they do not wan’t to but I think more goes into liking a person other then asking “Oh what religion do you follow and what views do you have?” I respect what they believe and I would just ask for the same in return.
 
Yes and I see what you are getting at.

What I believe to be the truth is different from the truth they believe in. I do not see a reason why I should limit myself to one group just because of this one thing.

For example lets say someone believes in another God like being. I do not care about that and the fact they believe in them would not stop me from talking to them or doing activities that would help benefit others. Would I agree with them that they exist or are real? No I would not but they are entitled to believe that if they wan’t.

I know they are not in the same faith as me and I may try to tell them what I believe but I will not push my beliefs on them because that can in some cases be rude. The thing here is I have views they do not agree with perhaps and that is fine with me. They do not have to like me if they do not wan’t to but I think more goes into liking a person other then asking “Oh what religion do you follow and what views do you have?” I respect what they believe and I would just ask for the same in return.
We’re not talking about “activities.” We’re talking about worship, shared convictions, and the substance of faith. When you go to any church, faith tends to make a difference. I don’t know anyone who think it is rude for that to be so.

As you point out, they and the Catholic Church have very different ideas of the nature of the worship we each offer on Sundays. We believe in the True Presence. They don’t, and they don’t say that they do. My concern is that you seem to be saying that you could leave the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass behind and not give it a second thought. That is not a “fine” point. That is a major point of difference.

Back to the original point of the thread–when it comes to what is substantial, the Mass is the same at one parish as it is at another. The Sacrifice being offered is exactly the same, and the Church offering the Mass is the same.
 
We’re not talking about “activities.” We’re talking about worship, shared convictions, and the substance of faith. When you go to any church, faith tends to make a difference. I don’t know anyone who think it is rude for that to be so.

As you point out, they and the Catholic Church have very different ideas of the nature of the worship we each offer on Sundays. We believe in the True Presence. They don’t, and they don’t say that they do. My concern is that you seem to be saying that you could leave the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass behind and not give it a second thought. That is not a “fine” point. That is a major point of difference.

Back to the original point of the thread–when it comes to what is substantial, the Mass is the same at one parish as it is at another. The Sacrifice being offered is exactly the same, and the Church offering the Mass is the same.
Faith making a difference is not rude at all. I believe I said something along the lines of pushing faith on others is.To be honest right now I’m not sure what I believe in anymore these days. If this is more about me talking about joining a nondenominational church then that has not even happened yet. It may but it is not set in stone. I kind of in some way like that there is variety in religion. A world with one religion would be very boring and bland for me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top