Symbols for the Soul

  • Thread starter Thread starter in_servitude
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

in_servitude

Guest
Some say (I believe incorrectly) that the Eucharist is just a symbol.

I wonder if that happens because a person’s soul is too abstract.

A person’s feelings can be symbolized by a heart - or emicons. :mad::eek:🤷😊👍

A person’s thoughts can be expressed by a light bulb over the head - or question marks.:confused: Also, a halo can indicate holy thoughts while devil horns can indicate devilish thoughts.

What about a person’s soul? Is there something I’m missing? Do we have any symbols commonly used to represent the soul?

When people fail to see the spiritual significance of the Eucharist - and refer to it as “just a symbol”, I wonder if that is because the soul is viewed as an abstract concept rather than something that is just as real as the computer screen that you are viewing right now.
 
Some say (I believe incorrectly) that the Eucharist is just a symbol.

I wonder if that happens because a person’s soul is too abstract.

A person’s feelings can be symbolized by a heart - or emicons. :mad::eek:🤷😊👍

A person’s thoughts can be expressed by a light bulb over the head - or question marks.:confused: Also, a halo can indicate holy thoughts while devil horns can indicate devilish thoughts.

What about a person’s soul? Is there something I’m missing? Do we have any symbols commonly used to represent the soul?

When people fail to see the spiritual significance of the Eucharist - and refer to it as “just a symbol”, I wonder if that is because the soul is viewed as an abstract concept rather than something that is just as real as the computer screen that you are viewing right now.
The Eucharist is the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus… Not just His soul? What are you talking about…? What does that have to do with our souls?
 
The Eucharist is the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus… Not just His soul? What are you talking about…? What does that have to do with our souls?
Here’s what I’m saying:
  1. The Eucharist is NOT a symbol.
  2. In my life, I have lots of non-Catholics that do not get this.
  3. If I could better understand “symbols” that represent “the soul”, then I might better communicate with my friends/family about this.
  4. It recently occurred to me that there might not be a single symbol for “the soul”.
  5. If #4 is true, why in the heck would the Eucharist suddenly fall into this “symbol” classification.
 
Here’s what I’m saying:
  1. The Eucharist is NOT a symbol.
  2. In my life, I have lots of non-Catholics that do not get this.
  3. If I could better understand “symbols” that represent “the soul”, then I might better communicate with my friends/family about this.
  4. It recently occurred to me that there might not be a single symbol for “the soul”.
  5. If #4 is true, why in the heck would the Eucharist suddenly fall into this “symbol” classification.
Re your point 4.

Your mind is an element or process of your soul; and, since the mind has several symbols (a head, a brain, a lightbulb, question mark etc), ISTM that a soul would have those symbols and many more.

ICXC NIKA
 
Here’s what I’m saying:
  1. The Eucharist is NOT a symbol.
  2. In my life, I have lots of non-Catholics that do not get this.
  3. If I could better understand “symbols” that represent “the soul”, then I might better communicate with my friends/family about this.
  4. It recently occurred to me that there might not be a single symbol for “the soul”.
  5. If #4 is true, why in the heck would the Eucharist suddenly fall into this “symbol” classification.
You are making a connection between “soul” and “Eucharist” that does not exist.

Suppose there is a symbol for the soul; let’s say http://www.celticvirtue.com/wp-content/plaqueshop/symbols/Shamrock.gif.
How would this symbol help you communicate with your friends/family about the Eucharist?

The point is, when non-Catholics say the Eucharist is a symbol, they are interpreting this passage differently than we Catholics do:
John 6:51 (and other John 6 passages) :
“I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.”

We Catholics believe that at the consecration, the substance of the bread (and the substance of the wine) become the Real Presence of Jesus – Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. Non-Catholics do not believe this, but rather that the bread (and wine) serve as a symbol of the life of Christ.

There is no connection between “soul” and “Eucharist” as you are trying to make. If you want to connect Eucharist and soul, you need to say “body, blood, soul, and divinity” because that is what the Eucharist is.
 
You are making a connection between “soul” and “Eucharist” that does not exist.

Suppose there is a symbol for the soul; let’s say http://www.celticvirtue.com/wp-content/plaqueshop/symbols/Shamrock.gif.
How would this symbol help you communicate with your friends/family about the Eucharist?
Perhaps you are totally correct. I’ll tell you why I think there is a connection.
  1. Exodus 12 - the first exodus - the Jews HAD to eat the flesh of the lamb in order to be spared a physical death (of their first born son). They HAD to put the blood of the lamb on their door posts to be spared a physical death. This first exodus is, in my opinion, a physical model for the second exodus. The Jews, suffering in their worldly slavery were set physically free.
  2. The second exodus is something that is real. When we receive the Eucharist, something is actually happening in the spiritual world. It is not something abstract, or imagined. Our souls, suffering in our spiritual slavery (sin) are set free spiritually. That is why John 6 says what it says.
The point is, when non-Catholics say the Eucharist is a symbol, they are interpreting this passage differently than we Catholics do:
John 6:51 (and other John 6 passages) :
“I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.”
We Catholics believe that at the consecration, the substance of the bread (and the substance of the wine) become the Real Presence of Jesus – Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. Non-Catholics do not believe this, but rather that the bread (and wine) serve as a symbol of the life of Christ.
There is no connection between “soul” and “Eucharist” as you are trying to make. If you want to connect Eucharist and soul, you need to say “body, blood, soul, and divinity” because that is what the Eucharist is.
Agreed - body, blood, soul, and divinity.

My problem with the whole symbol argument is that it seems to blithely miss the spiritual component of the second exodus. It is as if “the soul” is some kind of intellectual construct - like a number line. It isn’t. Rather, the soul is just as real any physical item we can touch.

So, it seems to me that if we do not have a symbol for the soul, then we miss an opportunity to give some weight to the teaching regarding the second exodus and the reality of the spiritual freedom that we experience through the Eucharist.

But, perhaps I’m pulling two things together that should be. I’d be willing to yield that point.
 
I see now. You are talking about the soul of the reciepient, not the soul of the Eucharist.

While it was Christ’s death on the cross (the blood of the Lamb) that set us free (what you refer to as the second exodus), I don’t think it’s quite proper to say that the Eucharist sets the soul free. In fact, wouldn’t you agree that it is the sacrament of Penance that sets the soul free, from sin. Thus, the soul is already free in that we are (or should be) in a state of grace when we receive the Eucharist. It is when we are in union with Christ that we share in His resurrection. And so thus the the Church teaches us is that in receiving Communion, the Eucharist gives us life, nourishes the soul, feeds it, enables us to grow in grace.

Non-Catholics call the bread a symbol because it’s the only way they can explain John 6. If you don’t take those words in John 6 literally, which they don’t, then all you have left as a reason for breaking bread, blessing it, and eating it, is to act as a symbol.
 
I see now. You are talking about the soul of the recipient, not the soul of the Eucharist.

While it was Christ’s death on the cross (the blood of the Lamb) that set us free (what you refer to as the second exodus), I don’t think it’s quite proper to say that the Eucharist sets the soul free.
John 6:49-51
49 Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died; 50 this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die. 51 I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.
The ancestors had a physical exodus and died. The spiritual exodus that Christ teaches says that we will be set free from spiritual death. I’m not exactly sure how this happens, but my impression is that the condition of my soul changes when I receive the Eucharist. I suppose that is reinforced when we say (right before receiving the Eucharist) in Mass/Holy Communion, “Lord, I am not worthy that you should enter under my roof, but say the word and my soul shall be healed.”
In fact, wouldn’t you agree that it is the sacrament of Penance that sets the soul free, from sin.
I agree.
Thus, the soul is already free in that we are (or should be) in a state of grace when we receive the Eucharist. It is when we are in union with Christ that we share in His resurrection. And so thus the the Church teaches us is that in receiving Communion, the Eucharist gives us life, nourishes the soul, feeds it, enables us to grow in grace.
I agree with all of this.
Non-Catholics call the bread a symbol because it’s the only way they can explain John 6.
My experience: this message is given with what I perceive to be a significant lack of charity. While I have run into some honest truth seekers out there, I think some knowingly use the symbol argument to formulate an attack.
If you don’t take those words in John 6 literally, which they don’t, then all you have left as a reason for breaking bread, blessing it, and eating it, is to act as a symbol.
Yeah, and it is this comment that makes me wish we had some kind of symbol for the soul. It would probably enable a distinction to be drawn between the reality of the Eucharist and what our (real) soul experiences and what seems to be a mostly intellectual exercise in Protestant circles.
 
Food For Thought.
Marking the Birth of St. John of the Cross: 24 June
Fr. Justin Avanooparambil, OCD
ewtn.com/library/SPIRIT/bdjohncross.htm
Meaning of the Sanjuanistic Spousal Symbol
The relation between God and the soul cannot be better expressed except through the “spousal symbol”. As Edith Stein observes: “The bridal union with God is seen to be the original and true bridal state, while corresponding human relationships appear as imperfect images of this original, just as the Fatherhood of God is the archetype of all earthly paternity”.8 Therefore, it is not surprising at all if our Mystical Doctor has chosen it as his most favourite symbol.
Although in The Spiritual Canticle the bridal relationship is the central theme, The Dark Night and The Living Flame too echo the same melody of The Spiritual Canticle.
St. John of the Cross could write such “love-poems” (like The Spiritual Canticle and Romance) of exquisite beauty, incomparable in any language, only because he was a man totally overtaken by God, who is the Love Supreme.
He considered God as the Beloved of his heart. To this “Beloved of his heart” he gave his total love, detaching himself from everything else that is not his Beloved.
He sought the union of love with him passing through the “dark night” of purifications, with an unwavering faith as his only guide and light.
“This guided me
More surely than the light of noon
To where He waited for me
— Him I knew so well —
In a place where no one else appeared”.9
Our Saint’s love for God was passionate and irrevocable. Thus, chastity for him was not something inhuman or a dry abstinence from something evil. Instead, it is one of the expressions of a total self-offering by the creature to its Creator in whom alone love finds its perfection and fulfilment.
The total submission to God of human sexuality is the condition of its sanctification. But there is the ultimate valid reason for chastity: that God may be free to possess to the full a virgin-soul and body, which he has prepared for his own dwelling.
The intense delight of being so possessed could probably be expressed in no other terms than that of the Spousal symbol which our Saint borrows mainly from the Canticle of Canticles.
The scenes in The Spiritual Canticle are all full of suspense and eloquence. But what matters most to us is the masterly way the Mystical Doctor presents to us a profound spiritual reality. The bride and the Bridegroom, taking the role of the soul and Christ respectively, manifest their love in mutual giving.
On the part of the soul it is a total surrender, and on the part of Christ it is a gradual manifestation of His glory:
“It must be known that many souls attain to the first cellars and enter therein, each according to the perfection of love which he possesses, but few in this life attain to this last and innermost perfection, for in this there comes to pass that perfect union with God which they call the ‘Spiritual Marriage’. And that which God communicates to the soul in this most intimate union is completely ineffable, for it is God Himself who communicates this to the soul and transforms her into Himself with marvellous glory”.10
Before arriving at this stage of “intimate union” where everything is “totally beyond words”, there are several steps through which the soul has to pass. It suffices for us here to know that the whole painful process of purification that the soul endured, as we said before, is all oriented towards this final goal: complete union with God. In this sense the “spousal symbol” is the crown of all the mystical teachings of St. John of the Cross.
Conclusion
As the entire spiritual teachings of St. John of the Cross can be explained by two key (Spanish) words Todo y Nada [All and Nothing], so also his whole mysticism can be explained, as we have already seen, through two symbols: Night and the Spousal symbol. They are like the keys of two large rooms full of treasures.
If his ascetical work The Ascent of Mount Carmel starts with guiding a soul that is desirous of spiritual perfection, his mystical work The Living Flame of Love ends with bringing the same soul to the experience of Transforming Union. This is the last stage of spiritual perfection attainable here on earth. He calls it “a foretaste of Eternal Life”.11 The next stage is called ‘Beatific Vision’ which, he says, is not meant for this life!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top