Synod of Carthage 418 Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter Latinitas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Latinitas

Guest
Hi CAF community,

I found this disturbing canon from the Synod of Carthage held in 418, by St. Aurelius:
CANON XVII
“If priests, deacons, and inferior clerics complain of a sentence of their own bishop, they shall, with the
consent of their bishop, have recourse to the neighboring bishops, who shall settle the dispute. If they desire to make
a further appeal, it must only be to their primates or to African Councils. But whoever appeals to a court on the other
side of the sea *, may not again be received into communion by any one in Africa.”
How can I explain this. I understand that it is not infallible, and there was worry that Rome under Pope St. Zosimus became Pelagian, but this seems odd, considering that the Synod of Hippo, which Augustine attended, needed confirmation from “the other side of the Sea” as well.
I know the situation needed to be adjusted, which it eventually was, but how can I defend Papal primacy against those who would use this.
Benedicat Deus,
Latinitas
 
Why are you concerned about something written about 1,600 or so years ago and only applies to Africa? Aren’t there more pressing concerns in today’s world; or is it that you just want to argue?
 
Why are you concerned about something written about 1,600 or so years ago and only applies to Africa? Aren’t there more pressing concerns in today’s world; or is it that you just want to argue?
The OP is asking how one would respond should a protestant use this as an argument against universal authority for the pope.

I do not have an answer - but I hope that some others will.

Peace
James
 
The OP is asking how one would respond should a protestant use this as an argument against universal authority for the pope.

I do not have an answer - but I hope that some others will.

Peace
James
Or more like an Eastern Orthodox Christian, but yes, this is mostly why.

I too hope that another will have an answer.

Benedicat Deus,
Latinitas
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top