Tabernacle not in the sanctuary :(

  • Thread starter Thread starter NickVA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

NickVA

Guest
The fact that many modern Catholic churches do not have the tabernacle in the sanctuary, or on a small “side altar” is quite disturbing to me. I believe that that Tabernacle should be in the center of the high altar. It shows that Christ’s body is the CENTER of attention during the mass. I went to a Church the other day and the Tabernacle was literally in another room, which was only visible to the right side of the aisle. Will the Holy Father do anything to correct this Architectural disaster?

I wouldn’t necessarily call myself an extreme traditionalist, but this is just totally inappropriate.:eek:

Do you guys agree?
 
It depends. Some parishes have configured their church as such so that the “side altar” or “side sanctuary” can actually be opened as a smaller chapel for adoration while the rest of the church is closed off. If thats the case then I think its an excellent idea.
 
The cornerstone of our Cathedral was laid in 1885, and the Cathedral was consecrated in 1889. The Tabernacle was in a side chapel until 2006.

So, as you can see, it is not something new. Our own Cathedral had the Tabernacle in “The Chapel of Our Lady”, for 117 years.

With that being said, the Tabernacle is now behind the main altar, in the sanctuary.

I’m not a big fan of modern architecture, but we can’t blame everything on it, if you know what I mean.

Our Bishop, has issued a directive to all parishes in our diocese, that all Tabernacles will be moved from side chapels, or altars, to the main sanctuary space. He has given a timeline for it to be completed, but unfortunately, I don’t remember what it is exactly
 
It is important to remember that even pre-Vatican II there were churches which did not have the tabernacle on the high altar. The next thing to understand is that Vatican II did not order the removal of tabernacles which were on the high altar, in the centre of the sanctuary.

In 1964, the Instruction on the Liturgy, Inter Oecumenici said the following regarding the tabernacle:
The Blessed Sacrament is to be reserved in a solid, burglar-proof tabernacle in the center of the high altar or of another altar if this is really outstanding and distinguished. Where there is a lawful custom, and in particular cases, to be approved by the local ordinary, the Blessed Sacrament may be reserved in some other place in the church; but it must be a very special place, having nobility about it, and it must be suitably decorated.
  • so in some places there was a custom of reserving the Blessed Sacrament somewhere else in the church, but the guidelines are clear.
Subsequent documents have caused quite a bit of confusion - even to the extent of saying one thing in one paragraph, followed by a direct contradiction in the next… I strongly suggest that you read The Catholic Sanctuary and the Second Vatican Council by Michael Davies which is available HERE. This one chapter is specifically on the placement of the tabernacle, but the rest of the short book is well worth reading.
 
The cornerstone of our Cathedral was laid in 1885, and the Cathedral was consecrated in 1889. The Tabernacle was in a side chapel until 2006.

So, as you can see, it is not something new. Our own Cathedral had the Tabernacle in “The Chapel of Our Lady”, for 117 years.

With that being said, the Tabernacle is now behind the main altar, in the sanctuary.

I’m not a big fan of modern architecture, but we can’t blame everything on it, if you know what I mean.

Our Bishop, has issued a directive to all parishes in our diocese, that all Tabernacles will be moved from side chapels, or altars, to the main sanctuary space. He has given a timeline for it to be completed, but unfortunately, I don’t remember what it is exactly
I hope this doesn’t mean there’ll be less or no adoration.
 
The tabernacle is not supposed to be the focus during Mass. The focus during Mass is the altar.

But I agree with you, moving the tabernacle out of sight is a way of taking people’s focus off the Real Presence. Some parishes do this in order to maintain adoration, however, and that’s a good thing. It isn’t always feasible to keep the main sanctuary open for adoration but a smaller area is more secure. There can be only one tabernacle so the one allowed is in the adoration chapel.
 
I hope this doesn’t mean there’ll be less or no adoration.
To be honest, I don’t know if the Cathedral has scheduled adoration.

Although, I’m not sure what I said that would indicate that there would be less adoration.

Could you clarify for me?
 
To be honest, I don’t know if the Cathedral has scheduled adoration.

Although, I’m not sure what I said that would indicate that there would be less adoration.

Could you clarify for me?
Well, the purpose of the tabernacle being in a separate chapel is that they can open that small chapel for adoration when the rest of the church is otherwise closed.

This usually is the case for parishes with either perpetual adoration or a regular adoration schedule.
 
Well, the purpose of the tabernacle being in a separate chapel is that they can open that small chapel for adoration when the rest of the church is otherwise closed.

This usually is the case for parishes with either perpetual adoration or a regular adoration schedule.
Thanks for the clarification.

In our Cathedral, (I should have made this more clear), the side chapel I spoke of is separate, and off to the side, but is not closed off or separtated by doors or railings per se. There is a set of columns which separate if from the Nave, but that is it. In cases of large events, it is used as overflow seating, and is the main access from the sacristy, to the Narthex for the celebrant(s).
 
Our church had the tabernacle on a side alter when we first started going there and it really bothered me terribly. It just isn’t right!! We got a new priest and the first easter, THe tabernacle was right back on the altar where it should be!! 🙂
 
The fact that many modern Catholic churches do not have the tabernacle in the sanctuary, or on a small “side altar” is quite disturbing to me. I believe that that Tabernacle should be in the center of the high altar. It shows that Christ’s body is the CENTER of attention during the mass. I went to a Church the other day and the Tabernacle was literally in another room, which was only visible to the right side of the aisle. Will the Holy Father do anything to correct this Architectural disaster?

I wouldn’t necessarily call myself an extreme traditionalist, but this is just totally inappropriate.:eek:

Do you guys agree?
I certainly agree. I’m fairly new to the faith, so I don’t really know who, or how to voice my conerns. My parish is one that has a Chapel off the lobby. He’s not even in the worship space until the Holy Mass. I genuflect whenever I walk by the door of the chapel. Some people even look at me kind of odd. I think it’s odd watching lifelong Catholics genuflecting in the aisle before sitting down while facing the altar. In RCIA they taught us that you genuflect to blessed sacrament, which, in our parish isn’t even in the direction of altar. Now I feel terrible, like I’m being judgmental though. I’m guess the cradle Catholics have in their hearts the same respect and intent as when they were growing up, and the tabernacle was actully up in front of them.

You know what? We don’t even have kneelers in our parish. We’re asked by the cantor before mass to stand whenever kneeling would normally be required. I’ve thought about kneeling anyway, but Father says it’s an insurance problem. I’m confused on what to do. I heard a priest on EWTN say that we better kneel whether there are kneelers or not. Our souls aren’t an insurance issue. But then I read that we shouldn’t go too far against the grain and be submissive to our environment. To stand out in righteousness among our brothers and sisters can be hurtful. The liturgy and form of the mass are done under the current missal, and the rite is adhered to in all aspects save for the kneeling. I’m sorry. I’m getting way off topic. Just venting my confusion and frustration.
 
To be blunt about it, the tabernacle is not a necessity for Mass. We receive the Blessed Sacrament when the bread and body are offered and consecrated to become the Body and Blood of Christ.

Remember in the Jewish Temple, the tabernacle is where God resides within the temple, where the Ark of the Covenant is kept. Today, the new covenant is the Body and Blood of Christ, so in the same way we keep it in the tabernacle of our churches.

The Mass is not any less of a Mass if there is no tabernacle. Unless you think outdoor Papal Masses are any less. The focal point of Mass is the Blessed Sacrament, the Body and Blood of Christ on the altar.
 
It depends. Some parishes have configured their church as such so that the “side altar” or “side sanctuary” can actually be opened as a smaller chapel for adoration while the rest of the church is closed off. If thats the case then I think its an excellent idea.
I agree. All too often people voice concerns over things that they personally believe “aren’t right” when the simple truth is that they have a misunderstanding about the whole situation.
 
Many cathedrals, especially in Europe, have had the tabernacle in side chapel for years and years because visiting tourists create such a disturbance (or simply don’t know any better) that its impossible to keep complete reverence within the sanctuary. It also makes prayer and adoration quite difficult.
 
To be blunt about it, the tabernacle is not a necessity for Mass. We receive the Blessed Sacrament when the bread and body are offered and consecrated to become the Body and Blood of Christ.
See that, I have a typo.
Of course I mean bread and wine. I’m thinking ahead and my typing caught up and skipped some parts
 
To be blunt about it, the tabernacle is not a necessity for Mass. We receive the Blessed Sacrament when the bread and body are offered and consecrated to become the Body and Blood of Christ.

Remember in the Jewish Temple, the tabernacle is where God resides within the temple, where the Ark of the Covenant is kept. Today, the new covenant is the Body and Blood of Christ, so in the same way we keep it in the tabernacle of our churches.

The Mass is not any less of a Mass if there is no tabernacle. Unless you think outdoor Papal Masses are any less. The focal point of Mass is the Blessed Sacrament, the Body and Blood of Christ on the altar.
That’s right - the tabernacle is not a necessity for the Mass. However, going on the Vatican documents, the tabernacle is supposed to be “in nobilissimo loco”. The English translation is rather weak, saying that the tabernacle should be in a most noble place - there can be several “noble places” but there is only one “most noble place”. Obviously, as you and I have pointed out, there have always been places where the Blessed Sacrament has never been reserved in a tabernacle on the high altar; however, the Church is clear that the most noble place, where possible (which in reality, is most churches), is in the centre of the sanctuary. Positioning the tabernacle anywhere else is supposed to be the exception to the rule, with permission granted by the bishop.
 
The fact that many modern Catholic churches do not have the tabernacle in the sanctuary, or on a small “side altar” is quite disturbing to me. I believe that that Tabernacle should be in the center of the high altar. It shows that Christ’s body is the CENTER of attention during the mass. I went to a Church the other day and the Tabernacle was literally in another room, which was only visible to the right side of the aisle. Will the Holy Father do anything to correct this Architectural disaster?

I wouldn’t necessarily call myself an extreme traditionalist, but this is just totally inappropriate.:eek:

Do you guys agree?
I agree.

Point in fact.

The last Catholic Church we attended that put the Tabrnacle in a small side room. The reasoning was that we all have Christ in us and so the Eucharist and Tabernacle are not needed because we carry Jesus in us.

True story. I got this from the DRE and the Parish Priest agrees with her.

One of the modern herecies of self worship I think…

We no longer go to that Church.
 
Looking at the G.I.R.M. usccb.org/liturgy/current/revmissalisromanien.shtml
**The Place for the Reservation of the Most Holy Eucharist Chapter V: 314-317
In accordance with the structure of each church and legitimate local customs, the Most Blessed Sacrament should be reserved in a tabernacle in a part of the church that is truly noble, prominent, readily visible, beautifully decorated, and suitable for prayer.
The one tabernacle should be immovable, be made of solid and inviolable material that is not transparent, and be locked in such a way that the danger of profanation is prevented to the greatest extent possible. Moreover, it is appropriate that, before it is put into liturgical use, it be blessed according to the rite described in the Roman Ritual,
It is more in keeping with the meaning of the sign that the tabernacle in which the Most Holy Eucharist is reserved not be on an altar on which Mass is celebrated.
Consequently, it is preferable that the tabernacle be located, according to the judgment of the Diocesan Bishop,
  1. Either in the sanctuary, apart from the altar of celebration, in a form and place more appropriate, not excluding on an old altar no longer used for celebration;
  1. Or even in some chapel suitable for the Faithfull’s private adoration and prayer and which is organically connected to the church and readily visible to the Christian faithful.
    In accordance with traditional custom, near the tabernacle a special lamp, fueled by oil or wax, should be kept alight to indicate and honor the presence of Christ.
    In no way should all the other things prescribed by law concerning the reservation of the Most Holy Eucharist be forgotten.
    **
Taking the above into consideration there has been an Amendment to the G.I.R.M. concerning optional placement of the Tabernacle that does not respect the directive of the revised General Instruction of the Roman Missal, which specifies that the tabernacle be located in the sanctuary or in a special chapel. The proposed text extends the possible location to include the body of the Church. Locating the tabernacle outside of the sanctuary, unless of course there is a special chapel which in my estimation, conveys the wrong message about the reserved Sacrament. I’m not much comforted in my concern by the amended text, which suggests placing the reserved Blessed Sacrament in a place where there was formerly a side altar, or in some other devotional space.
On a deeper level, I’m certainly confused by the suggestion in the proposed text that the placement of the tabernacle in the sanctuary in close visual relationship with the Altar of Sacrifice distracts from the Eucharistic celebration and its components. I’m referring especially to the recommendation that “distance, lighting, or some other architectural device” be used to separate the tabernacle and reservation area during Mass.

I’m having difficulty finding in our liturgical tradition, apart from the practice in some places over the past thirty years, this insistence on distancing visually the reserved Sacrament from its origin in the Eucharistic Sacrifice. Such insistence does not seem to have been the mind of the Second Vatican Council, for the post-conciliar liturgical norms on the placement of the tabernacle made every effort to keep the tabernacle on the altar of Sacrifice or very near to it.

In most churches which do not have a Eucharistic chapel, it is important to locate the place of the reserved Sacrament in proximity to the Altar of Sacrifice in order to keep clear the essential relationship of Christ’s abiding presence with us in the Blessed Sacrament after He becomes present for us through the Eucharistic Sacrifice.

The reserved Sacrament is also a constant witness to the profound reality of the Eucharistic Sacrifice through which Christ faithfully renews the outpouring of His life for us on Calvary.
Whatever the intent of the text in question, we must honestly recognize that it will be used to confirm and further the unfortunate, in my judgment, recent practice of removing the place of the reserved Blessed Sacrament outside the sanctuary.

At a time when we witness a loss of faith in the Holy Eucharist and a corollary loss of love of the Blessed Sacrament, it is especially important, I believe, to express clearly our faith by the place given to the tabernacle.

Therefore, should not the Amendment concerning Tabernacle placement state clearly that if there is not a special Eucharistic chapel, the tabernacle should be respectfully placed in the sanctuary in a place and manner which manifests the relationship of the reserved Sacrament to the Eucharistic Sacrifice represented by the altar?
 
All you need for Adoration is a sitting/kneeling area and a Monstrance with the Consecrated Host. Just because you remove the Taberncacle from an obscure room hidden away in THe Church and put it back where it belongs, doesn’t prevent people from having Adoration.

QUOTE=ConstantineTG;6946710]I hope this doesn’t mean there’ll be less or no adoration.
 
Nick,

I share your frustration and I found a way to solve my problem. I started attending Mass at a parish that offers the Traditional Latin Mass. I know many of us are not so lucky to have access to the Latin Mass. I recommend that you pray for change. Pray the Holy Rosary everyday and ask the Blessed Mother to hear your intention. Go to Confession once a week and before you receive Holy Communion focus on your sins and think about how your sins have caused the removal of the tabernacle from the Holy of Holies. What seems like a little way through the eyes of God is truly a big way. In the end Jesus Christ and the Catholic Church wins out. Holiness and reverence win at the end. Hang on to that hope and believe it everyday. Remember that during the darkest hours what seems impossible can and will happen. Truth always wins out at the end.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top