Tabernacle not in the sanctuary :(

  • Thread starter Thread starter NickVA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Gary,

The first time I became Pastor, I tried to keep the Church open for private prayer and got kicked in the backside:

.
When we first came to this small town parish the Church was locked for the same reason. However, the Church secretary would open it if asked. Now the back door of the Church is unlocked during the day.
 
Alex:
It’s terrible this happened to your church. Hopefully the kids have repented. Obviously the churches cannot be unsecure.

However it doesn’t seem to me to make a difference whether a tabernacle in a “side” chapel is damaged or whether it is in the main church. Both are bad.

I just think that its movement away from the front and center position was unnecessary and part of the deconstruction and reconstruction of the Mass due to the false interpretation of VII.
 
Vocations are really starting to FLOW in my diocese. We have more men in the seminary and in formation as deacons then we have had in a very long time.

You don’t need a “church” for an EF Mass. You need a priest willing to celebrate the EF and a open MASS TIME for the celebration of the EF Mass. If I was a bishop I would look VERY CLOSELY at anyone who wanted to create a “tlm-only” parish. That would smack strongly of division to me.

Your use of “liberal” to describe a bishop who does not do what you want him to do is simply ignorant.
My term liberal is a fair statement. We have over 1,000 people who want EF form of the liturgy, his answer I will not have it in MY DIOCESE if you are unhappy take it to Rome. He is even against the new english translation! Too old of wording , he says So please don’t call me ignorant.Then what would you call bishops that will not do as the Holy Father wanted? As far as a TLM church THE ONLY REASON FOR THAT WAS IS THAT HE WILL NOT PUT ONE IN A REGULAR PARISH CHURCH ! I am so glad things FLOW in your diocese but here ours are almost EMPTY So maybe if you LOOKED at a BIGGER PICTURE YOU WOULD NOT MAKE SUCH “RASH” STATEMENTS! As I have stated in other posts "If the OF form gets you to heaven then that is your path, it’s fine with me. But PLEASE do not call people names, when you don’t live in this diocese and also the things we are asking for are being done as per instruction of our Holy Father.So if having the EF dosent bother our Holy Father, why should it bother you? God Bless
 
Do you realize just how transparent your comments like “Show it where it said to move it I have read them all” are? Did you think your little wordplay/twist would fool anyone? C’mon…

The Catholic Church does not require that a tabernacle be located at the rear center of a sanctuary in the Latin Rite.

You need to come to grips with the facts.
This is why all the papers from Vatican II (you have read them ?) Were twisted into something else! It was called "THE SPIRIT OF VATICAN II " So if mine is a "play on words " Then how did those papers turn into what we have today? if not a “play on words” So just show the quotes from them! Also no, it does not say it is to be in the center of the sanctuary, nor does it say the altar was to be a table and that the priest face the people or that communion rails ARE TO BE REMOVED , or that communion MUST be taken in the hand! TO GET my facts youALSO NEED TO GET yours. God Bless
 
Some posters have brought up the use of “name calling” which I have used in my posts. They are right and I am truly sorry. I will pray hard for the things this bishop puts us through in our town So is it fair to say here is a man who knows better then our Holy Father? I will pray I am SORRY
 
What I am suggesting is that many “traditionalists” don’t seem to have a clue about the liturgical history of the Church – yet they claim to. Their view of history is usually limited it seems to the Church in the USA from around 1920 to 1965 or 45 years. .
And the “non-traditionalist” view of history involves 1970-2010, or 40 years:)🙂
 
We also have the only 24/7 Adoration Chapel in our city, mainly because our neighborhood is still fairly safe. There is a password that is needed after 6:00 p.m.

It is a beautiful chapel with the sole purpose of Adoration of Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament. Just because it isn’t in the main church building doesn’t make it unworthy of Our Lord.

There is such a thing as stewardship. To open our main church building all night long would be expensive and foolhardy, as we would have to have security to make sure that gangs didn’t bust up the building and desecrate Jesus in repose in the Tabernacle, or hurt, rape, or kill those who stop by to adore the Lord. God expects our leaders to use wisdom and take care of the buildings and the people that He has blessed us with.
I don’t think anyone claims that a side chapel by its nature is unworthy of the Lord. Also, I don’t think anyone who says that the tabernacle should be front and center is advocating throwing church security to the winds. Church security, utilities budget, and tabernacle placement are three different issues. You can have the tabernacle in the center and still lock the church at designated hours, whatever local conditions require.

Many here have posted security as the prime reason for the side chapel. I cannot see how potential desecration of a side chapel is better than desecration of the main church, other than perhaps fewer square feet availble to be vandalized.

Any how many years of saving on electricity for lighting and heating the side chapel vs. the main church was required to offset the cost of building the side chapel, if it was not there originally?

I think these are superflous reasons given to justify a practice that was conducted unnecessarily.

Are side chapels allowed? Absolutely. Is the Mass valid with no tabernacle on the altar? Absolutely. Should the parish secure the church against vandals, either on the main altar or in a side chapel? Absolutely.

Was removal of the tabernacle from the main altar required by Vatican II? Absolutely not. Is there a danger of the faithful fixating on the tabernacle to the exclusion of the readings and the Eucharistic prayer? Absolutely not.

Did the removal of the tabernacle from the main altar confuse people about what/when/how/why they should show reverence in the church? Absolutely.

Taking the tabernacle from the main altar and builing a side chapel to put it in instead was a solution to a problem that didn’t exist, in my humble opinion. And in doing so, created more problems, confusion being just one of them.

The same can be applied to all of the other aspects of the liturgy that have been deconstructed and reconstructed; the manner and posture of taking Communion, who administers Communion, taking away the Communion rail, “active participation” ad infinitum.
 
I don’t think anyone claims that a side chapel by its nature is unworthy of the Lord. Also, I don’t think anyone who says that the tabernacle should be front and center is advocating throwing church security to the winds. Church security, utilities budget, and tabernacle placement are three different issues. You can have the tabernacle in the center and still lock the church at designated hours, whatever local conditions require.

Many here have posted security as the prime reason for the side chapel. I cannot see how potential desecration of a side chapel is better than desecration of the main church, other than perhaps fewer square feet availble to be vandalized.

Any how many years of saving on electricity for lighting and heating the side chapel vs. the main church was required to offset the cost of building the side chapel, if it was not there originally?

I think these are superflous reasons given to justify a practice that was conducted unnecessarily.

Are side chapels allowed? Absolutely. Is the Mass valid with no tabernacle on the altar? Absolutely. Should the parish secure the church against vandals, either on the main altar or in a side chapel? Absolutely.

Was removal of the tabernacle from the main altar required by Vatican II? Absolutely not. Is there a danger of the faithful fixating on the tabernacle to the exclusion of the readings and the Eucharistic prayer? Absolutely not.

Did the removal of the tabernacle from the main altar confuse people about what/when/how/why they should show reverence in the church? Absolutely.

Taking the tabernacle from the main altar and builing a side chapel to put it in instead was a solution to a problem that didn’t exist, in my humble opinion. And in doing so, created more problems, confusion being just one of them.

The same can be applied to all of the other aspects of the liturgy that have been deconstructed and reconstructed; the manner and posture of taking Communion, who administers Communion, taking away the Communion rail, “active participation” ad infinitum.
A great post you worded it much more clearly then I ever could. Thanks for a great post God Bless
 
I have just learned that our Bishop ordered our tabernacle moved to the center in order to conform to liturgical standards.

We have been holding mass in the gym for two week while the renovations took place. Tomorrow we will have mass back in the Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top