Tablet ignites debate on Messiah

  • Thread starter Thread starter Prayer_Warrior
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What say you?
Who cares?

It is my understanding that many young girls at the time of Christ were claiming to have the messiah within their womb. Whether the idea of a messiah first developed a few decades before the birth of Christ or several centuries is irrelevant.
 
Hmmm, a couple of billion people could also have believed the earth to be flat. I don’t see how numbers actually has anything to do with whether or not something is true, especially when it comes to how one feels about something. One might be able to say that the majority of ancient peoples believed in sacrificing their children to the gods just as easily, but the numbers will not support the notion that sacrificing children to the gods is a right belief. I think we have to go beyond herd mentality.
I think you need to provide evidence for your numbers instead of the sloppy moral equivalence you’ve demonstrated above.

I said nothing about truth being a function of majority rule. If crank scholars wish to convince 2 billion people that they are wrong, they will need to provide irrefutable evidence.

Even if the majority of people believed the world to be flat (which was a complete myth; any sailor can tell you why), one would simply need to sail beyond the horizon and then return to disprove it.

Filling in gaps in smudgy texts with what one wishes were there is doing Mad Libs—it isn’t doing scholarly work, much less proving or disproving anything.
 
I think you need to provide evidence for your numbers instead of the sloppy moral equivalence you’ve demonstrated above.

I said nothing about truth being a function of majority rule. If crank scholars wish to convince 2 billion people that they are wrong, they will need to provide irrefutable evidence.

Even if the majority of people believed the world to be flat (which was a complete myth; any sailor can tell you why), one would simply need to sail beyond the horizon and then return to disprove it.

Filling in gaps in smudgy texts with what one wishes were there is doing Mad Libs—it isn’t doing scholarly work, much less proving or disproving anything.
You’d previously said:
When 2 billion people believe the same thing, and sustain that belief over two millennia, one should require extraordinary evidence in contradiction.
I was trying to locate a parallel to the two billion. Have there consistently been two billion? I’d say that the group grew from a small base to huge numbers over seventeen centuries, and then, mainly because a group of patriarchs divided up the globe into jurisdictions. Rome not only got the boon of the western half of the empire, but the discovery of the Westeren Hemisphere after the fact. So, the numbers have an interesting meaning if a great deal of the time that’s elapsed represents a situation of this one denomination as “the only game in town”.

Even if the evidence presented by the Gabriel stone is authenticated, it is not likely to change the views of people who hold a belief in their version of messiah as being the unique one.
 
CGWEAVER over at the Reasonable Faith discussion boards has posted this about the controversy:

**LET ME PUT YOUR WORRIES ASIDE: **

**Here is the exhaustive scholarly translation of the tablet provided months ago by **“A New Dead Sea Scroll in Stone?” (Biblical Archaeology Review, January/February 2008), by scholar Ada Yardeni. Many thanks to Regenstein Library…University of Chicago.

Like I said in my earlier post…there is little reason to (a) see any messianic figure in view (b) infer form the text a death for Israel, or for others, or for sins, (c) and little reason to see YHWH in this text resurrecting anyone after three days.

See the attachment for the Hebrew version right form the tablet…if you read Hebrew you can translate it yourself…

Translation (Semitic sounds in caps and\or italics)
Column A


(Lines 1-6 are unintelligible)
7. … ]the sons of Israel ……]…
8. …]… …]…
9. … ]the word of yhw[h …]……]
10. …]… I\you asked …
11. yhwh, you ask me. Thus said the Lord of Hosts:
12. …]… from my(?) house, Israel, and I will tell the greatness(es?) of Jerusalem.
13. [Thus] said yhwh, the Lord of Israel: Behold, all the nations are
14. … against(?) o(?) Jerusalem and …,
15. [o]ne, two, three, fourty(?) prophets(?) and the returners(?),
16. [and] the Hasidin(?). My servant, David, asked from before Ephraim(?)
17. [to?] put the sign(?) I ask from you. Because He said, (namely,)
18. [y]hwh of Hosts, the Lord of Israel: …
19. sanctity(?)\sanctify(?) Israel! In three days you shall know,that(?)\for(?) He said,
20. (namely,) yhwh the Lord of Hosts, the Lord of Israel: The evil broke (down)
21. before justice. Ask me and I will tell you what 22this bad 21plant is,
22. lwbnsd/r/k(=? [To me? in libation?]) you are standing, the messenger\angel. He
23. … (= will ordain you?) to Torah(?). Blessed be the Glory of yhwh the Lord, from
24. his seat. “In a little while”, *qyTuT *(=a brawl?\ tiny?) it is, “and I will shake the
25. … of? heaven and the earth”. Here is the Glory of yhwh the Lord of
26. Hosts, the Lord of Israel. These are the chariots, seven,
27. [un]to(?) the gate(?) of Jerusalem, and the gates of Judah, and … for the
sake of
28. … His(?) angel, Michael, and to all the others(?) ask\asked
29. …. Thus He said, yhwh the Lord of Hosts, the Lord of
30. Israel: One, two, three, four, five, six,
31. [se]ven, these(?) are(?) His(?) angel …. ‘What is it’, said the blossom(?)\diadem(?)
32. ……]… and (the?) … (= leader?/ruler?), the second,
33. … Jerusalem…. three, in\of the greatness(es?) of
34. …]……]…
35. …]…, who saw a man … working(?) and …]…
36. that he … …]… from(?) Jerusalem(?)
37. … on(?) … the exile(?) of …,
38. the exile(?) of …, Lord …, and I will see
39. ……] Jerusalem, He will say, yhwh of
40. Hosts, …
41. …]… that will lift(?) …
42. …]… in all the
43. …]…
44. …]…
**
**
Column B

(Lines 45-50 are unintelligible)
51. Your people(?)\with you(?) ……]
52. … the [me]ssengers(?)[a]ngels(?) …]…
53. on\against His/My people. And ……]…
54. … ]three days(?). This is (that) which(?) …… ]He(?)
55. the Lord(?) hese(?) …]……]
56. see(?) ……]
57. closed(?). The blood of the slaughters(?)\sacrifices(?) of Jerusalem. For He said,
yhwh of Hos[ts],
58. the Lord of Israel: For He said, yhwh of Hosts, the Lord of
59. Israel: …
60. …]… me(?) the spirit?\wind of(?) …
61. ……]…
62. in it(?) ……]……]
63. ……]……]
64. ……]… loved(?)/… ……]
65. The three saints of the world\eternity from\of ……]
66. …]… peace he? said, to\in you we trust(?) …
67. Inform him of the blood of this chariot of them(?) ……]
68. Many lovers He has, yhwh ofHosts, the Lord of Israel …
69. Thus He said, (namely,) yhwh ofHosts, the Lord of Israel …:
70. Prophets have I sent to my people, three. And I say
71. that I have seen ……]…
72. the place for the sake of(?) David the servant of yhwh …]……]
73. the heaven and the earth. Blessed be ……]
74. men(?). “Showing mercy unto thousands”, … mercy …].
75. Three shepherds went out to?/of? Israel ……].
76. If there is a priest, if there are sons of saints ……]
77. Who am I(?), I (am?) Gabri’el the …(=angel?)… …]
78. You(?) will save them, ……]…
79. from before You, the three si[gn]s(?), three …….]
80. In three days …, I, Gabri’el …?],
81. the Prince of Princes, …, narrow holes(?) ……]…
82. to/for … …]… and the …
83. to me(?), out of three - the small one, whom(?) I took, I, Gabri’el.
84. yhwh ofHosts, the Lord of(?) Israel …]…….]
85. Then you will stand ……]…
86. …
87. in(?) … eternity(?)/…
\
 
Christian apologist Craig Blomberg has commented as well. Here is a post from him over at www.primetimejesus.com

no threat here!
Submitted by Craig Blomberg on Mon, 07/07/2008 - 01:59.
Thanks, Scot, for beating me to the punch on this. 🙂 I just read the wire service announcement in this morning’s Denver Post. As usual, someone finds a way to imagine that this would challenge historic Christian faith, since it would supposedly threaten the uniqueness of Jesus’ resurrection. In fact, it would do no such thing. What Christians claim is unique is that Jesus of Nazareth was bodily raised from the dead to life unending, not that the idea of a resurrected Messiah was without precedent. Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:4 actually believes that Christ was raised “according to the Scriptures.” Whichever passages he imagined deriving this idea from (Hosea 6:2? Psalm 16:10?) could have suggested themselves to other Jewish writers as well. While there are instances in which the New Testament typologically applies an Old Testament text to a New Testament event in unprecedented ways, suggested first only by the actions of Jesus himself, the more one finds evidence for other Jews thinking similarly (but independently) about their Scriptures, the more credible such an interpretation of the Old Testament becomes, and the more Christian faith is strengthened. Of course, we await the scholarly debate to determine if this tablet in fact says what is being claimed of it. I’m reminded of the claim in the early 1990s about a newly translated Dead Sea Scroll fragment that supposedly talked about a “slain Messiah” when it turned out to be about the Messiah slaying his enemies instead!
 
More from Blomberg:

By Craig Blomberg - Posted on July 8th, 2008
**Tagged: conference • Dead Sea documents • Israel • Messiah • Resurrection • stone **
Go to cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/07/07/1184950.aspx and click on the links to the Hebrew and English texts of the new stone causing the stir about possibly referring to the concept of a resurrected Messiah before the time of Jesus. Look at lines 78-85, which must be what Israel Knohl is referring to. Notice what’s actually in the text vs. what he has to supply. The text itself, reads merely :
"You(?) will save them, . . . . . .]. . .from before You, the three si[gn]s(?), three . . . . . . . ] In three days. . ., I, Gabri’el . . . ?}, the Prince of Princes, . . ., harrow holes (?) . . … . . ]. . .to/for . . … . .]. . .and the. . .to me(?), out of three-the small one, whom(?) I took, I, Gabri’el. YHWH of Hosts, the Lord of(?)[Israel. . .]. . … . . .] Then you will stand. . … . .]. . ."
The article with these links explains that Knohl “reconstructed one phrase to read, ‘In three days, you shall live’ - which would be an eerie parallel to the Christian account of Jesus’ resurrection on the third day of his entombment,” and that "he deduced that the phrase was addressed by Gabriel to a “prince of princes” who was slain by an evil king.
Does anybody else see all that in the actual text? That’s much more than “reconstruction” and “deduction;” that’s plain just making things up and adding them
 
More from Blomberg:

By Craig Blomberg - Posted on July 8th, 2008
Tagged: conference
• Dead Sea documents • Israel • Messiah • Resurrection • stone
Go to cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/07/07/1184950.aspx and click on the links to the Hebrew and English texts of the new stone causing the stir about possibly referring to the concept of a resurrected Messiah before the time of Jesus. Look at lines 78-85, which must be what Israel Knohl is referring to. Notice what’s actually in the text vs. what he has to supply. The text itself, reads merely :
"You(?) will save them, . . . . . .]. . .from before You, the three si[gn]s(?), three . . . . . . . ] In three days. . ., I, Gabri’el . . . ?}, the Prince of Princes, . . ., harrow holes (?) . . … . . ]. . .to/for . . … . .]. . .and the. . .to me(?), out of three-the small one, whom(?) I took, I, Gabri’el. YHWH of Hosts, the Lord of(?)[Israel. . .]. . … . . .] Then you will stand. . … . .]. . ."
The article with these links explains that Knohl “reconstructed one phrase to read, ‘In three days, you shall live’ - which would be an eerie parallel to the Christian account of Jesus’ resurrection on the third day of his entombment,” and that "he deduced that the phrase was addressed by Gabriel to a “prince of princes” who was slain by an evil king.
Does anybody else see all that in the actual text? That’s much more than “reconstruction” and “deduction;” that’s plain just making things up and adding them
Excellent information (in both posts). Thank you!
 
You’d previously said:

I was trying to locate a parallel to the two billion. Have there consistently been two billion? I’d say that the group grew from a small base to huge numbers over seventeen centuries, and then, mainly because a group of patriarchs divided up the globe into jurisdictions. Rome not only got the boon of the western half of the empire, but the discovery of the Westeren Hemisphere after the fact. So, the numbers have an interesting meaning if a great deal of the time that’s elapsed represents a situation of this one denomination as “the only game in town”.
Population growth being what it is, this is irrelevant.

The point remains that there are 2 billion people today—and GROWING—who believe Jesus Christ to be Lord. It is they who will need to be persuaded that he is not Lord. This will require compelling evidence. This tablet, as we have seen, is far from compelling evidence of any such thing, for the reasons I’ve noted above. You have completely ignored my argument and retreat to trivial concerns.
Even if the evidence presented by the Gabriel stone is authenticated, it is not likely to change the views of people who hold a belief in their version of messiah as being the unique one.
“Not likely” is a probabilistic term requiring evidence if taken at face value. Otherwise, this is simply your opinion.

Given that Christianity did not exist before 2,000 years ago, and mushroomed since on the basis of evidence Christians provided, I’d have to say that were evidence to be presented proving that a) Christ was not God or b) Christ did not die for the sins of mankind and our redemption or c) Christ did not rise from the dead, Christianity would collapse, being not true.

This is why the media and certain academics invest their lives into such efforts to find and present compelling evidence contra Christianity. That they have failed continually is a testament to the impossibility of the task; that they continue to try is testimony to their dogmatic atheism; neither says anything about Christians.

Indeed, the fact that some Christians get nervous about such news stories is an indication that many of us would indeed be open to such evidence and would respond accordingly to it. For those of us who continue to review each of these claims of “smoking gun” evidence against Christianity, and invariably discover them to be ridiculously paltry and without merit despite all the hype lavished upon them by those who desperately wish Christianity to go away, we find our faith confirmed yet again.

It certainly helps that those pushing such claims seem unacquainted with the basics of their craft, as the crank scholar who’s played “Mad Libs” with the tablet text to ---- surprise, surprise! — “discover” evidence supporting what he believed absent any evidence.

“Seek and ye shall find” apparently applies not only to Christians, but to militant secularists. The difference is that only the former are condemned for holding faith against reason.
 
Population growth being what it is, this is irrelevant.

The point remains that there are 2 billion people today—and GROWING—who believe Jesus Christ to be Lord. It is they who will need to be persuaded that he is not Lord. This will require compelling evidence. This tablet, as we have seen, is far from compelling evidence of any such thing, for the reasons I’ve noted above. You have completely ignored my argument and retreat to trivial concerns.
You may assess as you wish, but the fact of the two billion is not strong one in light of the billions who believe somethig else or nothing at all.

Even if it turned out that Paul had cobbled the Last Supper dialog from the Mithraic practices of Tarsus and inserted it into a Jewish savior from the oppression of Rome theme, what matters is whether or not the subsequent result of that supposed melding becomes an operative mechanism for unity with the divine. The end result is a viable liturgical practice.
“Not likely” is a probabilistic term requiring evidence if taken at face value. Otherwise, this is simply your opinion.
I wasn’t speaking ex cathedra. forums.catholic-questions.org/images/smilies/shrug.gif
Given that Christianity did not exist before 2,000 years ago, and mushroomed since on the basis of evidence Christians provided, I’d have to say that were evidence to be presented proving that a) Christ was not God or b) Christ did not die for the sins of mankind and our redemption or c) Christ did not rise from the dead, Christianity would collapse, being not true.
Suppose only ‘b’ is at stake because the tablet did not denounce the savior as divine and couldn’t (prior to his birth) say that he had not risen. The viable item that is left is the difference between a Jewish understanding of their own messianic traditions and what the Christian movement subsequently made of it. Then what?
Indeed, the fact that some Christians get nervous about such news stories is an indication that many of us would indeed be open to such evidence and would respond accordingly to it. For those of us who continue to review each of these claims of “smoking gun” evidence against Christianity, and invariably discover them to be ridiculously paltry and without merit despite all the hype lavished upon them by those who desperately wish Christianity to go away, we find our faith confirmed yet again.
At some point, a piece of evidence could potentially turn up that either confirms or denies. In the long run, articles of faith rarely fall to factual evidence.

I recall meeting a couple who hoped to sail around the world. They bought a boat, fitted it out, and were working for the funds to take a couple of years off. The problem is, they failed to learn how to sail the boat and knew nothing about navigation. In their shop they had placed a banner, which read:
“If the Dream is big enough the facts don’t matter”.
I’d say that matters of faith as similar to that message.
It certainly helps that those pushing such claims seem unacquainted with the basics of their craft, as the crank scholar who’s played “Mad Libs” with the tablet text to ---- surprise, surprise! — “discover” evidence supporting what he believed absent any evidence.
(This seems to be a repeat of something I’d read on this forum previously.) I see such media reports as occasions for my faith to operate, not necessarily forcing it to dominate every discussion concerning the information though.
 
You may assess as you wish, but the fact of the two billion is not strong one in light of the billions who believe somethig else or nothing at all.
And how many Russians and Buddhists do the people forwarding these claims care about addressing? They are aimed at the West, which remains Christian and the driver of world culture. You continue to forcefully miss the point.
Even if it turned out that Paul had cobbled the Last Supper dialog from the Mithraic practices of Tarsus and inserted it into a Jewish savior from the oppression of Rome theme, what matters is whether or not the subsequent result of that supposed melding becomes an operative mechanism for unity with the divine. The end result is a viable liturgical practice.
This paragraph’s information content asymptotically approaches zero. If there’s an argument in here, I can’t find it.
Good, because you could not.
Suppose only ‘b’ is at stake because the tablet did not denounce the savior as divine and couldn’t (prior to his birth) say that he had not risen. The viable item that is left is the difference between a Jewish understanding of their own messianic traditions and what the Christian movement subsequently made of it. Then what?
This may shock you, but Christians have understood the Jewish interpretation of the Messiah to be lacking for 2,000 years now. We do not look to them for enlightenment as to the nature of Christ for good reason.

Either way, this tablet doesn’t say anything of it.
At some point, a piece of evidence could potentially turn up that either confirms or denies. In the long run, articles of faith rarely fall to factual evidence.
Really? Where might I find my local temple to Artemis today?
I recall meeting a couple who hoped to sail around the world. They bought a boat, fitted it out, and were working for the funds to take a couple of years off. The problem is, they failed to learn how to sail the boat and knew nothing about navigation. In their shop they had placed a banner, which read:
“If the Dream is big enough the facts don’t matter”.
I’d say that matters of faith as similar to that message.
And you’d be quite wrong. The practice of the Christian faith is far too difficult and contrary to human nature to be analagous to the anecdote you offer in absence of evidence.
(This seems to be a repeat of something I’d read on this forum previously.) I see such media reports as occasions for my faith to operate, not necessarily forcing it to dominate every discussion concerning the information though.
I live my faith.
 
I live my faith.
Perhaps you are using faith as a weapon. It comes off as ‘support mental health or I’ll kill you’. Are you generally as combative and derrogatory as you seem to be in response to my posts, or is there a particular reason why you feel you need to be seen as ‘right’ in this forum? I don’t see Christianity in operation in the way you are carrying out ‘conversation’ here.
 
Perhaps you are using faith as a weapon. It comes off as ‘support mental health or I’ll kill you’. Are you generally as combative and derrogatory as you seem to be in response to my posts, or is there a particular reason why you feel you need to be seen as ‘right’ in this forum? I don’t see Christianity in operation in the way you are carrying out ‘conversation’ here.
You haven’t read enough Paul in that case.

I defend the Truth. Sometimes that requires combativeness; it never requires indifference.

Truth being objective, there is no pride in being “right” by stating it, anymore than noting the sunrise implies having caused it.

I have attacked, and continue to attack, the weaknesses in your argument. You are taking it personally. I obviously do not know you, nor do I have any personal stake in the debate.

I do note the irony that the appeals to emotion and sentiment are on the other side of this debate. We have a crank scholar inserting words into the spaces of a fragmented text and breathlessly spouting his findings, while those who wish they were true parrot them. Such lemminglike silliness is what the faithful are constantly accused by the secularist of embracing, and yet time and again it is the secularist who takes such flights of fancy as we see here.

Make your argument.

Produce your evidence.

It’s really that simple.

So why do the secularists keep failing?
 
You haven’t read enough Paul in that case.

I defend the Truth. Sometimes that requires combativeness; it never requires indifference.
Oh, I see… You feel you are here in a defensive position! Now it makes sense. The problem is, you are defensive against people of your own ilk! Oooops! :o
Truth being objective, there is no pride in being “right” by stating it, anymore than noting the sunrise implies having caused it.
I have attacked, and continue to attack, the weaknesses in your argument. You are taking it personally. I obviously do not know you, nor do I have any personal stake in the debate.
You are making an assumption that you are in “debate”, which is a guardian of the gate stance.
I do note the irony that the appeals to emotion and sentiment are on the other side of this debate. We have a crank scholar inserting words into the spaces of a fragmented text and breathlessly spouting his findings, while those who wish they were true parrot them. Such lemminglike silliness is what the faithful are constantly accused by the secularist of embracing, and yet time and again it is the secularist who takes such flights of fancy as we see here.
We are in argeement that the article lacked scholarship, so what is your axe to grind?
Make your argument.
Produce your evidence.
It’s really that simple.
So why do the secularists keep failing?
How did you come to believe everything was an argument? It is really a tiresome mode.
 
Oh, I see… You feel you are here in a defensive position! Now it makes sense. The problem is, you are defensive against people of your own ilk! Oooops! :o
It depends on the definition of “ilk”, doesn’t it?
You are making an assumption that you are in “debate”, which is a guardian of the gate stance.
Well, the title of the thread may have misled me that this was a debate. Or that this is an apologetics forum. 🤷
We are in argeement that the article lacked scholarship, so what is your axe to grind?
My “axe to grind”, as it were, is the notion that “having scholarship” would somehow fix the problem with this article. It wouldn’t. It isn’t true, which is the whole trouble with it. It is tarted-up propaganda of the sort we expect whenever the media, dominated by atheists and agnostics, undertakes to cover any aspect of religion. Academia is by and large in the same boat. The problem, therefore, is not that the article lacked scholarship, but that scholars lack a comprehension of the Christian faith.
How did you come to believe everything was an argument? It is really a tiresome mode.
Perhaps it is because you continue to toss out unfounded assertions requiring correction.

While such practices are certainly tiresome, Truth must be defended tirelessly.
 
It depends on the definition of “ilk”, doesn’t it?

Well, the title of the thread may have misled me that this was a debate. Or that this is an apologetics forum. 🤷

My “axe to grind”, as it were, is the notion that “having scholarship” would somehow fix the problem with this article.
It wouldn’t.
I think you’ve made a leap of assumption.
And if this is an “apologetics forum”, I see no reason to continue, especially if that precludes real conversation. Would the list owner please confirm that this list is primarily concerned with apologetics? That would be helpful. I may have inadvertently stumbled upon Alfa-type deutero-apologists bent on winning at all cost.

God grant us grace!
 
I think you’ve made a leap of assumption.
And if this is an “apologetics forum”, I see no reason to continue, especially if that precludes real conversation. Would the list owner please confirm that this list is primarily concerned with apologetics? That would be helpful. I may have inadvertently stumbled upon Alfa-type deutero-apologists bent on winning at all cost.

God grant us grace!
Thank you for the flurry of emotional language.

If you look at the top of this window, you will find that this thread is under the Apologetics Forum.

You’re welcome.
 
Well thanks to the person who posted the essential text of “the tablet”. I don’t see enough signal to noise ratio in the source to convince anyone in science nor religion that what is written in stone could not be anything more profound than random scribbles etched by carpenter ants leaving uric acid droppings as they meandered about foraging for dead wood and termite eggs for dinner. 😃

This topic is much ado about nothing. So I am withdrawing…

James
 
Well thanks to the person who posted the essential text of “the tablet”. I don’t see enough signal to noise ratio in the source to convince anyone in science nor religion that what is written in stone could not be anything more profound than random scribbles etched by carpenter ants leaving uric acid droppings as they meandered about foraging for dead wood and termite eggs for dinner. 😃

This topic is much ado about nothing. So I am withdrawing…

James
It is however quite useful in exposing once again how far the media and academia are willing to go in dishonestly pursuing their secularist agenda.

It is a reminder to all of us that whenever these breathless reports come up there is not only nothing to be worried about, but that the desperation of the secularist to find something----ANYTHING!----to debunk Christianity is indicative that they’re on a fool’s errand.

Until next time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top