Talking loudly in Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter BlueSapphire
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BlueSapphire

Guest
I attended Mass at a Parish near me recently - It was a Sunday Mass. After the final blessing and the Priest said the words, go in peace etc… All of a sudden the whole Church erupted into a loud babble of noise and chatter as the people were leaving. I have to say that there is always some talking on the way out in most churches, usually in load whispers, but in this particular church the chattering was deafening. IMHO I thought it very disrespectful of the Holy Presence in the Tabernacle. 😦 Any thoughts on this?
 
I Agree,
It is also disrespectful to those who, like myself, wish to pray after mass.

peace
James
 
Yes, I’ve seen this happen in some parishes, too. I agree that it is very disrespectful of the Real Presence of Jesus in the Tabernacle.

It’s one of those things that, once it gets started, it’s hard to stop it. The parishioners become accustomed to it as “this is the way it is.” Only a deliberate action on the part of the pastor could change it.

I have heard those in favor of such a thing argue that it is better to have the parishioners build community through this socializing than to leave without ever talking to each other. In their mind, the only alternative to this loud pre- and post-Mass socializing is for the parishoners to enter and exit silently, solemnly and sullen-faced without ever getting to know anyone else in the parish. They further argue that Jesus would rather the parishoners build these communal bonds than to be in silence. That, they would say, is really more respectful of Jesus.

Then one might counter that this socialization can easily take place in the vestibule or parish hall after Mass. But they would simply rebut that the vestibule is too small and most people won’t hang around in the parish hall: once they leave the church, they’ll be out to their car.

Of course, the real antidote is to work harder to build community in the right ways. The volume of pre-and post-Mass talking is not an accurate way to measure the true communal bonds between parishioners. True bonding and empty small talk still can have the same volume. In addition, you can’t really have true bonding without respecting and reverencing that Holy Communion which is the actual source of our unity.

Those are my thoughts, anyway. :o
 
I Agree,
It is also disrespectful to those who, like myself, wish to pray after mass.

peace
James
I’ve heard those in favor of this socialization respond that people who want to pray silently should do it on their own time. When the community is gathered, now is the time to interact with each other.

I think they’re wrong, and I agree with you, but that’s what they say.
 
Matthew 21:12-17

" 'My house will be called a house of prayer." And that is as it should be!
 
I’ve heard those in favor of this socialization respond that people who want to pray silently should do it on their own time. When the community is gathered, now is the time to interact with each other.
Such comments seem to me to be evidence of how little the mass and Eucharist has impacted such people. How sad.

I certainly have no problem with people “interacting”, however there are “gathering areas”, and parking lots for such.
I can hardly kneel before my Lord in the Tabernacle in the parking lot can I?
As said above "The Church should be a “house of prayer” and not sound like a cafeteria.
I think they’re wrong, and I agree with you, but that’s what they say.
Thanks.

Peace
James
 
The Sunday before last I went to my home parish, which I’ve been escaping to find refuge in a Traditional Mass lately. The same thing happened, and was almost more shocking than usual. I moved over to the Tabernacle (off on the side of the church :mad:) and knelt there in prayer until I was the only one left. Then I genuflected and sort of made a pact with Our Lord without words that I would rarely, if ever! :eek: come to Mass here again… It was sort of the last straw 😊

I pray that your home parish leaves you at peace and undisturbed by people’s ignorant irreverence. Check out the Fatima prayers against irreverence, the ones the angel taught the kids. These are my favorites, sometimes they bring me to tears because of all the sad things I’ve been fortunate enough to see happen at Mass. But God did say that we must suffer before we enter the Kingdom, and so suffer we will until we get there! 😛
 
I attend daily Mass as often as I can and I’ve noticed that there are two people in particular that are really distracting. They sit together and just chatter away before Mass. This is more noticeable during daily Mass because there are not THAT many people in the large church; voices totally carry. Even if I move, I still hear their conversation because of the acoustics.
 
Before, during, and after mass the Church shouldn’t be transformed into a meeting hall or a movie theater-but even the theaters are quieter than some parishes today. Very sad how our objective is here to teach the world, but sadly in some cases it’s quite the opposite.
 
I’ve heard those in favor of this socialization respond that people who want to pray silently should do it on their own time. When the community is gathered, now is the time to interact with each other.

I think they’re wrong, and I agree with you, but that’s what they say.
So in other words, my silent Rosary interrupts their yakking. Wowzers. Besides which, how can I pray silently on my own time (i.e., before and after Mass) when everybody around me is talking and laughing and carrying on?

It’s the same at my parish. When I was a kid in parochial school, we got in trouble for whispering (or even thinking about whispering). Now it’s like Animal House in church.

And the worst offenders are (a) old people and (b) the ushers.
 
I’ve heard those in favor of this socialization respond that people who want to pray silently should do it on their own time. When the community is gathered, now is the time to interact with each other.

I think they’re wrong, and I agree with you, but that’s what they say.
Yes, I agree and every so often Father or a lector will remind us to wait until we are outside of the church to converse in respect to those who are still praying and out of general respect to our Lord.

Invariably the next Sunday some have already forgotten and bad habits resume. I think we all need to participate in reminding one another. I usually whispher, I will continue the conversation outsde and point to the people still praying or just nod and smile at comments. A finger to the lips with a smile would not be rude in my book.👍
 
Before, during, and after mass the Church shouldn’t be transformed into a meeting hall or a movie theater-but even the theaters are quieter than some parishes today. Very sad how our objective is here to teach the world, but sadly in some cases it’s quite the opposite.
We keep things very quiet before mass, but after mass it’s not so quiet, not loud either. And we are VERY tiny so it empties fast, like in less than 2 minutes.

Our parish is so small that we have no meeting area, no undercroft like at my last church. Our church would probably be hard pressed to hold 120 people and often we have 20 people at mass in the summers when the snow birds are gone. But we meet in our church for meetings that need room for more than 4 people.
 
At one nearby parish, the Priest invites the congregation into a room off the church for tea/coffee and a chat, which I think is lovely! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top