Teachers Defend Tactics in Hoax DWI Program

  • Thread starter Thread starter peregrinus_WA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
<begin sarcasm> And??? I guess that proves it then. We should always side with the majority when it comes to right and wrong, because everyone knows that a majority can’t make mistakes. Unless of course you count things like society’s opinion on contraception, some pro-life issues, the real presence, divorce,… etc… etc… etc… <end sarcasm>
It was just an observation. It does bear noting that many legal issues revolve around questions of reasonableness, meaning what an average person would deem reasonable. If 80% of the parents deemed this to be unreasonable, I wonder why at least one person planning this exercise thought, “Maybe this isn’t such a great idea.” It may also indicate how out of touch they are with what parents think.
 
See, this is why I absolutely despise discussing topics with emotionally supercharged people. First, I have said in almost every one of my posts that lying may not have been the best way to handle this situation. However, I will not “pile on” the teachers and law enforcement for trying something new in order to save lives.
Next, this issue has NOTHING to do with punishment (or in the example you gave - abuse). There was no wrongdoing on the part of the students. The teachers and law enforcement were trying to PREVENT not CORRECT. This is a case of prevention, not punishment. I can understand if you are emotional over the situation but let us not mix apples and oranges.
This is an ad hominem attack. Address the issue. Don’t call people names and put labels on them just because you are having trouble justifying your position.

Yes, it was punishment, not prevention. They smacked these kids with the death of their friends in retaliation for all the drunk drivers who have killed people, not because these kids were drunk drivers. Grief over the death of a close friend or relative is among the highest of stresses which we suffer. You dismiss the normal reaction as ‘hysteria’ when it is nothing of the sort. People have severe emotional responses to the news of the death of a loved one or close friend. Deliberately inducing this level of stress in children is far worse abuse than applying the cane when they have been misbehaving.

scribd.com/doc/453876/Understanding-Stress
Scroll down to list of top ten stress inducers

It is not apples and oranges. These are 2 methods of behaviour modification. That one seeks to modify that behaviour before commission does not change its purpose. Both induce pain and suffering in the recipient to achieve the desired behaviour.

At least with caning, one waits until someone has actually done something wrong before inflicting the suffering.

The message I get from you is that you think this was just an unfortunate lapse of judgement, no harm, no foul, we’ll know now not to do it again, and besides, those kids are just weak, snivelling, hysterical, hypochondriac, over-emotional sissies who need to toughen up, and their parents with them and anybody else who thinks the police and teachers were wrong. Police should be allowed to do whatever they want.

But the truth is - I don’t think I’ll ever look at a policeman the same way anymore.

All this harping on the police being allowed to lie just reminded me about how the police here in WA have a long history of lying on the stand to put people in jail just because they think they are guilty but have no evidence to support their suspicions. One the more famous, a retired CID chief who made a habit of ‘stitching people up’, was killed by a car bomb planted by a bikie gang. The truth about how many people were in jail on fabricated evidence came out when the he was killed, along with evidence that this is a widespread practice among the police, when his former partner blew the lid off and came clean. He was dying of cancer and wanted to make things right before he died. So far, something like 5 men have been released from prison, their murder, robbery and fraud convictions quashed. All of his convictions are now considered unsafe and at great expense to the State, all are having to be revisited, reinvestigated and retried.
Here’s one of the cases - theage.com.au/articles/2002/06/11/1022982845389.html

Lying is a poisonous method which yields poisonous fruit and corrupts whoever uses it.
 
I was really surprised to see two students being interviewed by Geraldo, one who acted out the part of victim and one who was a student witnessing the spectacle, and neither of them were upset about this. They both seemed to feel that the tactic was worth it to get the message about drinking and driving across. Geraldo commented on how he was much more upset than they ever were.
 
This is an ad hominem attack. Address the issue. Don’t call people names and put labels on them just because you are having trouble justifying your position.
I have no trouble addressing the issue and if you took offense over my remark about being emotionally supercharged, then I beg your forgiveness.
Yes, it was punishment, not prevention. They smacked these kids with the death of their friends in retaliation for all the drunk drivers who have killed people, not because these kids were drunk drivers.
With all due respect, you are reaching on this issue. The teachers and law enforcement were not punishing the students in question for the crimes of others. On an emotional level, you may need to tell yourself that in order to justify your outrage, but that is simply not the case. The intent here was prevention, plain and simple. Those involved were attempting to demonstrate the emotional consequences involved when/if friends decide to drink and drive. Now, we can certainly debate whether the method used was right or wrong, but let’s be clear. This was NOT a punishment against the students involved.
Grief over the death of a close friend or relative is among the highest of stresses which we suffer. You dismiss the normal reaction as ‘hysteria’ when it is nothing of the sort. People have severe emotional responses to the news of the death of a loved one or close friend. Deliberately inducing this level of stress in children is far worse abuse than applying the cane when they have been misbehaving.
I’ll agree with you that the death of a friend is highly stressful. I will even go so far as to agree that perhaps lying wasn’t the best method to use in this situation. However, it WAS the method that they decided to use and it’s too late to change it now. So, we are left looking at things like intent, harmed caused, effect, and possible results. I don’t believe that most people will conclude that the intent of those involved was to cause any long-lasting emotional discomfort. Rather, it was most likely their intent to cause a rather short-term and emotionally uncomfortable experience in a controlled environment (school). The immediate “harmed caused” & “effect” was of course sadness, shock, anger, etc. All negative in nature and certainly an unpleasant feeling. Unfortunately, I doubt very seriously that we will know anytime soon what the “results” are, as this type of demonstration is meant to be realized over the course of a lifetime and not meant to be measured in a week, month or even a year.
scribd.com/doc/453876/Understanding-Stress
Scroll down to list of top ten stress inducers
No question… stress of this nature and in this situation is present and certainly uncomfortable.
It is not apples and oranges.
It is apples and oranges. We can debate over that all day and neither of us will get the other to concede, so I suggest that rather than continue saying, “it is” vs. “it isn’t” we state our individual cases which support our position. I have done so, and I’d like to hear your position minus the outrage and emotion. “Just the facts ma’am.”
These are 2 methods of behaviour modification. That one seeks to modify that behaviour before commission does not change its purpose.
{{{ See next page for my continued response }}}
 
{{{ Continued from above }}}

Please clarify here… “does not change” the purpose of the one attempting to prevent an action or “does not change” the purpose of the one who may commit the act?

If you are stating that the modifier’s (in this case the teachers and L.E.) purpose will be ineffective simply because he/she attempts to gain compliance prior to the result of the unwanted action, then I must disagree with you. If it is not possible to instruct prior to a given situation actually taking place, then parents all over the world are wasting their time telling young children to look both ways before crossing the street, don’t talk to strangers, etc. The fact is, prevention tactics do work and should be used.

If you are saying that despite the use of preventive measures initiated by the modifier, the subject(s) (in this case the students) will ignore the measures and commit the action regardless. I have to say that this is possible; however, there are several factors in play that will either help make this true or not.
  1. The students in this case must understand in the end that the method used was intended to help them understand that the purpose was to help not hurt. (Since there is now such an outrage and the students are being made to feel victimized by much of the media and the public, I think that this is no longer a possibility).
  2. The individual students each process things differently. Those who are more “rebellious” will, in the end, likely be affected very little by this method. Those less “rebellious” and who are less “knee-jerk” reactionists, may think through the entire situation after it’s completion and conclude that the risk of drinking and driving is too emotionally discomforting. They may then make a conscience effort to not only refuse to drink and drive themselves but to insist that close friends and family not do so as well.
Both induce pain and suffering in the recipient to achieve the desired behaviour. At least with caning, one waits until someone has actually done something wrong before inflicting the suffering.
… and in this case?.. what?.. wait until one of the teens is actually killed in a drinking and driving accident before attempting to teach? Then I think you would be claiming that the teachers and L.E. weren’t proactive enough. Again, caning and other forms of abuse used to punish are not in play here. This is about PREVENTING teen deaths NOT PUNISHING past deaths.
The message I get from you is that you think this was just an unfortunate lapse of judgement, no harm, no foul, we’ll know now not to do it again, and besides, those kids are just weak, snivelling, hysterical, hypochondriac, over-emotional sissies who need to toughen up, and their parents with them and anybody else who thinks the police and teachers were wrong. Police should be allowed to do whatever they want.
Objection, your honor. Speculation on the part of the prosecution. 😃 You assume incorrectly, when you state my thoughts on the matter. Actually, quiet the contrary is true. I do NOT believe that the teens involved are “sniveling, hysterical, hypochondriac, over-emotional sissies who need to toughen up.” I rather believe that had not the media and “good-doers” stepped in and played the students up as being victims, the students may have walked away with one thought… “man, I never want to put someone through that nor do I want to ever go through that again. No drinking and driving for me.” In other words, they may have gotten it. Now however, the only thing that they will walk away with is how they were lied to and mistreated emotionally by their teacher and L.E. because that is exactly what the media and many in society want them to walk away with.

{{{ Continued below }}}
 
{{{ CONTINUED FROM ABOVE }}}
But the truth is - I don’t think I’ll ever look at a policeman the same way anymore.
How very sad for you. I hope that someday you find it in your heart to forgive those involved in this situation for letting you down. Their intentions were good, despite what you believe, and they were trying to save lives (despite the fact that they lied in order to do so).
All this harping on the police being allowed to lie just reminded me about how the police here in WA have a long history of lying on the stand to put people in jail just because they think they are guilty but have no evidence to support their suspicions. One the more famous, a retired CID chief who made a habit of ‘stitching people up’, was killed by a car bomb planted by a bikie gang. The truth about how many people were in jail on fabricated evidence came out when the he was killed, along with evidence that this is a widespread practice among the police, when his former partner blew the lid off and came clean. He was dying of cancer and wanted to make things right before he died. So far, something like 5 men have been released from prison, their murder, robbery and fraud convictions quashed. All of his convictions are now considered unsafe and at great expense to the State, all are having to be revisited, reinvestigated and retried.
Here’s one of the cases - theage.com.au/articles/2002/06/11/1022982845389.html
Ahh, I see now. This whole triad of yours has nothing to do with the teens. This is about hating cops. The “big bad police” are out to bully society. Sorry, I’m not going there. This thread is about the issue of teachers and L.E. attempting to circumvent teen fatalities by use of a method that involved lying; not about your personal agenda against law enforcement. Save it for another thread and I will GLADLY debate you on the overwhelming evidence which supports the good that L.E. officers do in the community while sacrificing everything from decent wages, to marriages, to their lives, so that you can come here and speak ill of them!
<Sorry, my turn to get a little emotional>
Lying is a poisonous method which yields poisonous fruit and corrupts whoever uses it.
Certainly, in most cases you are correct. However, there are times in which lying can be unsinful. Again, perhaps that is a subject better left for another thread. Or better yet, it has been discussed countless other times; maybe if you did a search you would encounter some of these threads.
 
{{{ CONTINUED FROM ABOVE }}}

How very sad for you. I hope that someday you find it in your heart to forgive those involved in this situation for letting you down. Their intentions were good, despite what you believe, and they were trying to save lives (despite the fact that they lied in order to do so).

Ahh, I see now. This whole triad of yours has nothing to do with the teens. This is about hating cops. The “big bad police” are out to bully society. Sorry, I’m not going there. This thread is about the issue of teachers and L.E. attempting to circumvent teen fatalities by use of a method that involved lying; not about your personal agenda against law enforcement. Save it for another thread and I will GLADLY debate you on the overwhelming evidence which supports the good that L.E. officers do in the community while sacrificing everything from decent wages, to marriages, to their lives, so that you can come here and speak ill of them!
<Sorry, my turn to get a little emotional>

Certainly, in most cases you are correct. However, there are times in which lying can be unsinful. Again, perhaps that is a subject better left for another thread. Or better yet, it has been discussed countless other times; maybe if you did a search you would encounter some of these threads.
And again - the personal attack. If you can dismiss me as having an ulterior motive, or being ‘emotionally super-charged’ then you can dismiss what I have to say, without ever addressing the issue at hand. It is much easier for you to put a label on me (which has missed the mark entirely BTW), then you can disregard anything I have to say.

I have no personal agenda against law enforcement. None of the people involved in what I recounted had anything to do with me. Only now, as a result of their actions, I am not so trusting, not so gullible. I no longer automatically assume the best about police because I know they have lied to put innocent people in jail and if they have a problem with that, they have only themselves to blame.

Again the mantra - ‘but our intentions were good’. As if that makes up for it. Well, it doesn’t. Good intent does not make bad actions good.

Perhaps it might be effective if we were to take each of these seniors into the back room and administer 6 good hard cane strokes while telling them “Don’t Drink Drive” with each stroke. It could Save Lives so we should try it. Everything else we’ve tried before hasn’t worked so a new approach is needed. A little bit of thought will dismiss this, but they substituted inflicting emotional trauma for the cane strokes and called it acceptable because ‘It might Save Lives’.

The guidance counsellor said they were traumatised and that they wanted them traumatised. So this goes beyond the lying. The lie was merely the cane-stroke used to inflict the pain. The authorities thought it was alright to deliberately inflict one of the most severe emotional pains a person can feel on these children. And they don’t see anything wrong with it, and still don’t. These same people cry out in horror if you suggest using the cane. I submit that the cane inflicts far less pain and suffering than this stunt did yet it is banned as being cruel and excessive.

What they did was cruel, excessive and wrong. It has had far reaching effects, even on the other side of the world. There has been considerable poisonous fruit from these actions and I’ll wager, not one life saved as a result.

Far from being angry or upset with me, you should be upset with those who have done this and corroded what was left of the good reputation of police and teachers.
 
And again - the personal attack. If you can dismiss me as having an ulterior motive, or being ‘emotionally super-charged’ then you can dismiss what I have to say, without ever addressing the issue at hand. It is much easier for you to put a label on me (which has missed the mark entirely BTW), then you can disregard anything I have to say.
My dear lady. While I have been blunt, direct, and perhaps a smidgen sarcastic; I have not attacked you. As to “addressing the issue at hand,” I have done that. I apologize if you are unable to distinguish that.
I have no personal agenda against law enforcement. None of the people involved in what I recounted had anything to do with me. Only now, as a result of their actions, I am not so trusting, not so gullible. I no longer automatically assume the best about police because I know they have lied to put innocent people in jail and if they have a problem with that, they have only themselves to blame.
They do not have a problem with you not trusting them. In the end, it may be your loss. I’ll pray that someday you can stop blaming all law enforcement for what you perceive as a few bad incidents. How charitable would it be for me to say, “All Australians are emotionally super-charged” or, “All those who live in the state of Washington are left-wing liberals?” Nevertheless, me thinks we doest stay off topic too much. You and your biases are not the topic here.
Again the mantra - ‘but our intentions were good’. As if that makes up for it. Well, it doesn’t. Good intent does not make bad actions good.
No, perhaps it doesn’t but certainly it can lessen the culpability. And in the absence of any clear-cut workable answer to the dilemma of teen drinking and driving, I for one support trying new things with the “intent” of saving lives. I am sorry that you feel differently.
Perhaps it might be effective if we were to take each of these seniors into the back room and administer 6 good hard cane strokes while telling them “Don’t Drink Drive” with each stroke. It could Save Lives so we should try it. Everything else we’ve tried before hasn’t worked so a new approach is needed. A little bit of thought will dismiss this, but they substituted inflicting emotional trauma for the cane strokes and called it acceptable because ‘It might Save Lives’.
Again with the caning. What is it with you, abuse, and canes? Please, I have already addressed this argument and refuted it. Either come up with something new or put it down. No one was calling for abusing the teens by beating them with canes. That was your idea. Perhaps, you feel that if you say it repeatedly, it will become true. Reality doesn’t work that way (accept in politics of course).

{{{ CONTINUED BELOW }}}
 
{{{ CONTINUED FROM ABOVE }}}
The guidance counsellor said they were traumatised and that they wanted them traumatised. So this goes beyond the lying. The lie was merely the cane-stroke used to inflict the pain. The authorities thought it was alright to deliberately inflict one of the most severe emotional pains a person can feel on these children. And they don’t see anything wrong with it, and still don’t. These same people cry out in horror if you suggest using the cane. I submit that the cane inflicts far less pain and suffering than this stunt did yet it is banned as being cruel and excessive.
Yes, there was intent to make the students feel emotionally uncomfortable. The idea is to get the students to equate the uncomfortable emotional feeling with the act of drinking and driving; thus, causing a distasteful association with the action. Remove the negative association… and umm… nothing.
What they did was cruel, excessive and wrong. It has had far reaching effects, even on the other side of the world. There has been considerable poisonous fruit from these actions and I’ll wager, not one life saved as a result.
Look, you want to know what’s REALLY cruel? Doing nothing or doing something that you know doesn’t work. Then at a not too distant time, having to go to the doorstep of a mother and tell her that her daughter is dead due to an alcohol related accident. Only in my example of “what’s cruel” there isn’t anyone coming along a few minutes later telling the parent that it isn’t true. Her daughter IS dead and it’s too late for any lessons to be learned. “Poisonous fruit” indeed!
Far from being angry or upset with me, you should be upset with those who have done this and corroded what was left of the good reputation of police and teachers.
LOL, I find it humorous that you believe that I am angry with you. I assure you that I am not. You have an opinion that differs from mine and while I point out the errors in your argument, I am certainly not taking them personally. I have become frustrated at some of the “logic” behind your arguments, especially that cops as a whole are some how less trustworthy by this and another issue which you cite. Nevertheless, I’m used to it as I work in law enforcement and meet people like you fairly often.

Now, I believe that I have contributed to this thread all that I possibly can. To continue, will be to simply repeat myself. Linda Marie and others, I thank you for the discussion. I still haven’t changed my view of “Maybe” as it relates to the question associated with this thread and I am sure that my arguments have not changed the minds of any here. However, I do enjoy trying. 😃 Take care all and God bless.

PS – Lisa Marie, should you wish to start a thread dealing with your opinions of cops or the legalization of caning, PM me and I’ll be there.
 
This is one of the reasons I love homeschooling. I don’t have to worry about the school system deciding what they think my child should learn and how they should learn it.

As each decade passes it seems the school system takes over more of what used to be parental responsibilities, and they do it without bothering to consult the parents. So many of us have grown up in the system that has trained us to give up control over our kids to school authorities.

I have a friend who was told she could not walk her diabetic child who said he wasn’t feeling well to his classroom after a high blood sugar incident where she was called to the school to administer insulin. Being a home schooling mom I was like “You’ve got to be kidding me?” If my child isn’t feeling well you think you have the right to tell me he has to walk alone to his classroom?

We really need to take our kids back. School is supposed to be about education -reading, writing, arithmetic remember? Not a social experiment to teach about homosexual sex, how to put on a condom, or putting our kids through emotional trauma by fabricating a story in the name of preventing drunk driving.

In this case we have law enforcement and school officials lying to minors, causing a traumatic experience without consulting or obtaining permission from the parents. Have we handed our children over to the government? :banghead:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top