See, this is why I absolutely despise discussing topics with emotionally supercharged people. First, I have said in almost every one of my posts that lying may not have been the best way to handle this situation. However, I will not “pile on” the teachers and law enforcement for trying something new in order to save lives.
Next, this issue has NOTHING to do with punishment (or in the example you gave - abuse). There was no wrongdoing on the part of the students. The teachers and law enforcement were trying to PREVENT not CORRECT. This is a case of prevention, not punishment. I can understand if you are emotional over the situation but let us not mix apples and oranges.
This is an ad hominem attack. Address the issue. Don’t call people names and put labels on them just because you are having trouble justifying your position.
Yes, it was punishment, not prevention. They smacked these kids with the death of their friends in retaliation for all the drunk drivers who have killed people, not because these kids were drunk drivers. Grief over the death of a close friend or relative is among the highest of stresses which we suffer. You dismiss the normal reaction as ‘hysteria’ when it is nothing of the sort. People have severe emotional responses to the news of the death of a loved one or close friend. Deliberately inducing this level of stress in children is far worse abuse than applying the cane when they have been misbehaving.
scribd.com/doc/453876/Understanding-Stress
Scroll down to list of top ten stress inducers
It is not apples and oranges. These are 2 methods of behaviour modification. That one seeks to modify that behaviour before commission does not change its purpose. Both induce pain and suffering in the recipient to achieve the desired behaviour.
At least with caning, one waits until someone has actually done something wrong before inflicting the suffering.
The message I get from you is that you think this was just an unfortunate lapse of judgement, no harm, no foul, we’ll know now not to do it again, and besides, those kids are just weak, snivelling, hysterical, hypochondriac, over-emotional sissies who need to toughen up, and their parents with them and anybody else who thinks the police and teachers were wrong. Police should be allowed to do whatever they want.
But the truth is - I don’t think
I’ll ever look at a policeman the same way anymore.
All this harping on the police being allowed to lie just reminded me about how the police here in WA have a long history of lying on the stand to put people in jail just because they think they are guilty but have no evidence to support their suspicions. One the more famous, a retired CID chief who made a habit of ‘stitching people up’, was killed by a car bomb planted by a bikie gang. The truth about how many people were in jail on fabricated evidence came out when the he was killed, along with evidence that this is a widespread practice among the police, when his former partner blew the lid off and came clean. He was dying of cancer and wanted to make things right before he died. So far, something like 5 men have been released from prison, their murder, robbery and fraud convictions quashed. All of his convictions are now considered unsafe and at great expense to the State, all are having to be revisited, reinvestigated and retried.
Here’s one of the cases -
theage.com.au/articles/2002/06/11/1022982845389.html
Lying is a poisonous method which yields poisonous fruit and corrupts whoever uses it.