R
RCCDefender
Guest
WOW!!! I don’t ever remember reading anything like that, maybe that one wasn’t in mine, I’ll have to check… I did have RCIA at the Cathedral, so I had always thought that was a plus. I remember we had to read some other books on Mary as well. And I was reading as much as I could get my hands on in my spare time, so I might have had a lot more influence from those outside sources than others in the program. I’ll have to look back over my manual. Maybe I am attributing more of my outside studies (and my bliss at becoming Catholic) to my RCIA class than I should. Thanks for pointing out your experience with this program. I haven’t heard of anyone else who used it. Maybe you could give me the reference to the one about the Holy Spirit as well. I should really reevaluate this program since you had such a bad experience.We used this last year and it will probably be used this year. I thought it sucked.
We did not use the entire binder; we have a rather condensed RCIA it seems. Anyway, when ever my team was up to lead the class I found my own materials and focused on the Catechism.
Why? Check out this Update on Mary. I wish it would be worth it to fisk this whole article but here are some highlights. It (not so) subtley calls into question the perpetual virginity of Mary.
Um…she was not pregnant out of wedlock. She was betrothed. The author of the piece (of ****), Elizabeth Johnson, C.S.J. spends a lot of filler in this Update chiding us to remember and yet she seems ignorant of Jewish customs regarding marriage.
Don’t get me started on the the Update on the Holy Spirit.
The organizers of this product really didn’t take care not to include questionable material. And since we kind of did our own thing I don’t really know how effective the whole programs approach would be. My observation was that there was a lot of feel good fluff.
I have no idea if this would work better with well-catechized facilitators but I was dealing with comments like “I learned not to pray for things more than once. Once is enough” and “I personally don’t have a problem with women priests” said to unsuspecting candidates.