As a Convert who grew up Baptist I might have a little different perspective…
We don’t have CCD to my knowledge at my parish until age 6 I believe but we do have preschool (a very reasonable and fantastic preschool I might add). My sons have learned a great deal there at school. The rest at this point I consider to be up to me.
Now here is what I would say about Baptist SS. We sang songs etc… but there was more too it, however as I got older the more bothered me. When I was in second grade I had a new SS teacher who actually stayed with my class (about 7 of us guys) through Jr High. Rather than using the little handouts that pull verses from multiple books to make a point, we started with the OT and worked our way through verse by verse each week. This was an experience that definitely made a HUGE impact on my life… but that is not normal Baptist type SS. That was more like adult Bible Study.
At the same time as a parent I do not want my kids being told people are going to hell or they were going to hell or anyone else at age 5. This is definitely something that they would probably experience in a Baptist type system.
I grew up Baptist but became Presbyterian in High School thus about half my life as each and I joined the Church this past Easter after years of study (Baptists are closer than many think to Catholics actually). Anyway… my former Minister who is also a good friend had his neighbor ask if their Grandchildren could come talk to him about Jesus. He said that would be great… expecting a pre-teen to come ask questions.
Rather what he got was a 4 year old and a 6 year old coming to give him the whole “if you died tonight would you be with Jesus or burning in Hell” routine.
Frankly I don’t want my kids exposed to that… I was and was lucky but I know many others who had that shoved down their throat who have now completely turned from Christianity… it’s too young to start that. Fear tactics don’t work long term, you can’t scare someone into salvation.
Remember that a child really doesn’t understand things from an abstract sense until around age 10 or older… believing that at any time they or their friends who might not believe exactly as they do could be burning in HELL if something happened to them is crazy and NOT what I believe Christ wanted us to put our children through.
As they get older we will teach them more and more about what it means to be a Christian. Salvation is not just a moment of prayer, it’s a lifetime of commitment. Thus giving children at good solid base right now is what they need.
Teach them about God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit), teach them about Mass (and how to get something out of it), sing song like Jesus Loves Me and teach them to pray (not just wrote prayers IMHO but also how to just talk to God about what is on your heart).
As they get older, expand that and continue until they are ready for confirmation. If you do, they will be much better prepared in regards to understanding what it means to give their life to Christ, to truly Follow Him.
So no, it’s not the exact same… it’s different, and better.
At least that’s my opinion…
Joe