Telling Mom you're leaving her church?

  • Thread starter Thread starter confusedgirl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

confusedgirl

Guest
I am going to be 18 soon and my mom is pentecostal and has raised me that way since I was really young. My dad’s entire side are Scottish Trinidadian catholics so naturally I was baptized in the catholic church. My mom was so angry that she forbid my dad to ever let his sister take us again. My dad was a cradle catholic but currently is not practicing. For a little be I liked pentecostal church and I even got baptized into it at a really young age. But when I hit 13 I started really questioning the pentecostal faith. So many problems came up, there were a lot of problems with the people, the messages are just so… I just felt it wasn’t for me. I was in catholic school for a couple years and although I hated the uniforms my favourite time was always mass. I think when I was 8 I went to mass for thr first time in a long time and when I turned 9 that same year I knew how the mass went and I knew all the prayers and I really wanted to be catholic. LOL (an early glimpse of my conversion story) I said a hail mary at home because that’s the one you prayed at the end of the day in my mom flipped she was all like: WE ARE CHRISTIANS WE DON’T WORSHIP MARY RAAAAAAAAWR!!! :mad: haha and you know she said all kinds of stuff to get catholicism out of my mind but every now and then I always thought of being a catholic. After so much turmoil in the church we were in when I was 16 my family decided as a family we would pick a new church. Unfortunately we didn’t choose one we all liked my mom chose one she liked and didn’t allow us to go to one we all liked. Its one of those pentecostal/gospel churches and noisy and I hated it. My mom forced me into the choir and hey my type of church music is the stuff we sang in catholic school and of course Libera. (Google of you’ve never heard) I felt like I was being forced into a church that I don’t really want to be in. Then I had a big fight with my mom for missing choir practice and I tried telling her how I felt forced to go to this church and choir that I didnt want any part in. She raged and lectured me about how she was bringing me up the right way. At that point I was going to become an atheist then at that point something in reminded me that I used to love going to mass. Become catholic. God? Are you calling me to become catholic? :confused: anyways I read up on the faith snuck out early on a sunday morning to get to 9:00 mass before I went to my moms 11:00 church service. 😃 it was easy cuz mass stayed around a time frame of 1 hour so I’d get to her church pretty early. (I hope she forgives me for going behind her back like that and taking my brother with me. My brother loves the catholic church too and wants to go with me everytime I go) I’m going to be 18 soon and like now I am looking into churches to attend as well as RCIA. I feel not telling her would make her very mad. But she most certainly doesn’t want me to convert to a church she doesn’t agree with. She thinks I’m not christian because I show no interest in her church and all sorts of untrue stuff. I want to be a full practicing catholic but well she’s really been preventing me. She’s so stubborn too like I asked if I could go to a different church from her and she raged again saying how bad it would look if I did that. There is no reasoning with her at all. How do I go about this?
 
You say that you were baptized Catholic. In that case you’re already Catholic and simply need to be confirmed.
 
If there is no reasoning with her then the only recourse is that, when you turn 18, simply inform her of your decision and then shut up…If she so chooses, you just let her to rant and rave and whatever about the Church - and you say nothing - not even if she asks you a question (during the rant). If she gets angry at your lack of response, you can simply say that you will discuss it with her once she has had time to calm down.
Depending on how things go, it might be necessary for you to simply get up and walk away.

Eventually she will simply have to deal with the facts. The more calm and loving you can be, the better. Remember that you are sitting upon a rock and cannot be moved by any “wind” blowing from her direction. But neither do you, anchored on the Rock, need to fight with that wind…for it will simply blow itself out.

Another possibility, if you wish to explain your choice rather than simply announce it would be to write your mom a letter. This allows you to express things carefully and clearly and it also allows her to read it in full before she starts talking to you (or ranting at you) about it.

hope this helps a bit.

Peace
James
 
I did the same thing when I was 16 or 17 (I’m now unsure whether it was before or after my birthday that year). I think I unintentionally softened the blow by first explaining why I no longer wanted to be Methodist, in such a way that apparently my mother thought I was announcing I would no longer be Christian, so that when I finally said I wanted to be Catholic it was a relief to her.

Of course, my family has always acknowledged that Catholics are Christians and has little or no more anti-Catholicism than is practically inevitable in Protestants. In your case I wonder if it might be best to wait until you are actually 18 and out of the house (perhaps gone off to college) to politely and respectfully inform your mother than you are preparing to commit to the Catholic Church.
 
The advice that you received from JRKH and Aelred Minor is good in my opinion. I’ve never been in your situation, but it reminded me of this question asked by a Jewish girl to a Catholic saint in this video:
youtube.com/watch?v=xSTvG_PUE9E

I hope that this helps.

Robert
 
Hi confusedgirl,

I know this will be hard, but it is so obvious that God wants you to be a part of the Catholic faith. Your heart seeks it in volumes. Keep praying for strength and courage and most of all an increase in faith. Your faith will keep you strong in what you believe. Who knows, your love of the church may bring your parents around. Pray for them too.

You and your family will be in my prayers.
LP
 
Mom is very very stubborn and really its impossible to talk to her. When im off to university i suppose that she wont care but that doesnt mean she’ll support it. Id be heartbroken if she would attend my confirmation, my wedding, or my children’s baptism because she was mad at me still. Thats what worries me the most 😦
 
Understood. Such can be very difficult. I couldn’t help but think if this passage as I read your post…
34 "Do not think that I have come to bring peace on earth; I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. 35 For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law; 36 and a man’s foes will be those of his own household. 37 He who loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; and he who loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me; 38 and he who does not take his cross and follow me is not worthy of me. (Mt 10)
If God is calling you home to His Catholic Church - how can you refuse? The best thing to be hoped is that as time goes on your example of true Love for Jesus will soften your mother’s heart.
Do you think that your dad can be of any support for you in this? I don’t necessarily mean right away, but over time.

Peace
James
 
Mom is very very stubborn and really its impossible to talk to her. When im off to university i suppose that she wont care but that doesnt mean she’ll support it. Id be heartbroken if she would attend my confirmation, my wedding, or my children’s baptism because she was mad at me still. Thats what worries me the most 😦
I would not count on you being off to college making much difference…but it would perhaps make the option of writing a letter more feasible.

Peace
James
 
God bless you on your journey. The Holy Spirit is calling you home. At some point, if she wants you and future Grandchild in her life she will have to find a way to accept your faith. At the very least she should agree to disagree and just love you.

I will be praying for you and your family.
 
The advice that you received from JRKH and Aelred Minor is good in my opinion. I’ve never been in your situation, but it reminded me of this question asked by a Jewish girl to a Catholic saint in this video:
youtube.com/watch?v=xSTvG_PUE9E
I hope that this helps.

Robert
It really did help 👍 its similar to my situation and i will be patient and pray.
Hi confusedgirl,👍

I know this will be hard, but it is so obvious that God wants you to be a part of the Catholic faith. Your heart seeks it in volumes. Keep praying for strength and courage and most of all an increase in faith. Your faith will keep you strong in what you believe. Who knows, your love of the church may bring your parents around. Pray for them too.

You and your family will be in my prayers.
LP
Thank you so much for your words 🙂 i will keep up with my prayers and i hope my mom gives in too and maybe my dad will come back to the church too. 😃
Understood. Such can be very difficult. I couldn’t help but think if this passage as I read your post…
34 "Do not think that I have come to bring peace on earth; I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. 35 For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law; 36 and a man’s foes will be those of his own household. 37 He who loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; and he who loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me; 38 and he who does not take his cross and follow me is not worthy of me. (Mt 10)
If God is calling you home to His Catholic Church - how can you refuse? The best thing to be hoped is that as time goes on your example of true Love for Jesus will soften your mother’s heart.
Do you think that your dad can be of any support for you in this? I don’t necessarily mean right away, but over time.

Peace
James
Youre right. How can i refuse? I mean when i go to a catholic church once it makes me feel like its the right place to be. Anytime i disobey her and step into one all the guilty feelings i had before melt away and i dont regret anything because i know it is where i belong. I can feel God calling me back any Sunday we drive by the church i sometimes go to it makes me feel homesick. Can dad help? No he fell away a long time ago. Eversince the split he hasnt been talking to us much either. There is a woman who is a good friend of my moms whos a devout catholic. I could speak to her and she can tell my mom about the faith more but i doubt she would listen. She would just argue her points of view more. But God has been calling me for this long i dont think it will stop. I guess being patient is the best option.
 
Youre right. How can i refuse? I mean when i go to a catholic church once it makes me feel like its the right place to be. Anytime i disobey her and step into one all the guilty feelings i had before melt away and i dont regret anything because i know it is where i belong. I can feel God calling me back any Sunday we drive by the church i sometimes go to it makes me feel homesick. Can dad help? No he fell away a long time ago. Ever since the split he hasnt been talking to us much either. There is a woman who is a good friend of my moms whos a devout catholic. I could speak to her and she can tell my mom about the faith more but i doubt she would listen. She would just argue her points of view more. But God has been calling me for this long i dont think it will stop. I guess being patient is the best option.
Yes - Do be patient a while longer.
God bless you.

Peace
James
 
Thank you everyone your words and prayers have definitely more strength and courage.
😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top