Temptation vs Sin: Confession required?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SkippingM
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SkippingM

Guest
Greetings,

I recently returned to Catholicism (a few months ago), after having thought myself a Protestant. Since my return, I’ve been pretty good concerning doubts, questions, and concerns, and I’ve been attending Mass regularly. However, this past Sunday, my family & I were feeling sick with a cold, and the weather had turned colder. The Mass we go to is further away because we’re currently in a country where we don’t speak the language, and that’s the one that’s in English.

Since we weren’t feeling all that well, we thought we would go to the one near here, in a language we don’t understand. But we weren’t ready in time, so we decided to go to the regular one, which is further away but was at a later time.

We then decided to not go at all, so as to not get even worse with the colder weather.

I started getting worried that this wasn’t sufficient reason to miss Mass, and also that I would be more prone to temptation during the week because, well… I had been relying on communion to keep me strong in mind.

By the next day (Monday) I had already spiraled into questioning whether I believed in Catholicism at all, or if I was Protestant. It was almost like a switch turning on/off. It lasted until yesterday night, after I spoke with a Protestant friend of mine about my concerns.

Seeing her reactions to my concerns, unexpectedly caused me to feel more “Catholic.” Today, I feel like I’m just lacking information and understanding, but I’m trusting that God wants me here in the Catholic Faith for now, even with all my reservations.

So now… I’m wondering what to do Sunday. Have I sinned by going down this whole Protestant vs Catholic spiral and so I should avoid taking part in communion. And even further, was it indeed sufficient reason, staying home from Mass, or should I also go to confession before HC for that reason. I ask because the next opportunity I will have for confession in English is after Sunday. So I don’t know what to do. What if missing another HC makes the whole temptation worse?

Thank you. Hopefully all of the details weren’t annoying.
 
Be at peace, we are not expected to attend Mass if unwell or the weather is an issue. This is sufficient reason to stay away from Mass. It is also a service to those of your fellow brothers and sisters because you don’t spread the germs.

Stay strong with prayer. Rely on God to help you and trust in God.
You have not sinned going down that path, it is a normal part of our Journey home.

So remember, if unwell there is no obligation to attend Mass and others will appreciate not getting a dose of your bug. Also, questioning our faith and religion is also a completely normal part of the journey home. Rely and trust in God.
 
What if missing another HC makes the whole temptation worse?
If you were baptized Catholic, you are filled with The Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is a powerful force to help fight off temptaions. There’s also prayer and if you say the Rosary, that helps with temptations.

Also maybe you can go to Mass a little early next Sunday and speak to the Father. I’m sure he’ll be able to advise you best.

But God knows your heart, yiu can confess directly to Him…ask His help to over come temptations. God loves you, He will help you.

Hope you’re feeing better.
 
Last edited:
Have I sinned by going down this whole Protestant vs Catholic spiral
No. It’s perfectly acceptable to ask questions about what you’re doing.
was it indeed sufficient reason, staying home from Mass
You shouldn’t go to Mass if you’re sick. Furthermore, it’s okay if you need to stay home to take care of someone else who is sick.
 
Welcome home!

I really like the way you put this 😁
after having thought myself a Protestant
I may need to start using that phrasing to describe myself, although for me, it would apply from birth to about age 15-16.

You probably heard amongst your Protestant friends or elsewhere - the phrase “Do not be afraid” (in other words, “don’t worry”) is in the Bible 365 times, good for each day of the year. Seems like you have a good conscience about you, so heed that advice and be at peace.
 
Last edited:
Just mention it at your next confession. You are not required to attend mass while sick. Neither are you required to make heroic effort to attend - especially not if it jeopardizes your loved ones - or those at mass.

Your intention was to attend. You did not miss out of obstinacy or disobedience. You did not willingly choose to sin. God knows your heart. Simply mention it.
 
I wish they gave the option of deleting topics. Can a moderator please delete the whole thing? Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top