M
mtr01
Guest
I may have been a little hasty in declaring it a sin. Like many people I struggle personally with all the nuances of this sticky issue. As I look through my thought process, I may have made the leap from “something to be discouraged” to “something that is sinful”. Personally, I tend to be against capital punishment…and I guess I’m guilty of interpreting Church teachings to fit my viewpoint (but aren’t we guilty of that to some degree?).The only problem is that the implication is that the death penalty is the sin to which you refer. That is what we are debating and you can not assume the point in discussion.
I’m sure you can tell, this is the single biggest issue for me, and I am totally in favor of the requirement Texas has. In fact, if all states that currently have the death penalty included such a provision, I would have no issue here at all.But you are right, we can not execute people just to avoid life sentences. In the state of Texas, one of the requirements for imposition of the death penalty is that the prosecutor show that a convict is likely to pose a continuing threat on society.
I agree, the Church’s position does leave some leaway in which to form our own positions…and it would be easier if it were just a black and white issue. Then again, we aren’t a Church of robots, and I like the fact that we can think for ourselves. Besides, it would eliminate interesting discussions such as this, where I have learned quite a bit from you and the others posting on this topic.The truth is I really am not convinced either way on the issue and have discussed it at length with three different priest. If the church would just come out against the death penalty in all cases, it sure would save me time. Until then, I’ll just continue to form my conscience on lump at a time.