J
Joseph_Kemp
Guest
Leonardo da Vinci was a profoundly CATHOLIC man.
Pop culture imagines Leonardo as a homosexual rebel who hated the Catholic Church. People say he was a blasphemer who almost never wrote about God in his notebooks. They say he worshiped Nature, rather than God. They claim that though Leonardo was undoubtably a great inventor and scientist, he was almost certainly not a Christian. Or so the usual argument goes.
But I believe that Leonardo da Vinci was a genuinely sincere and faithful Catholic. I believe he was an EXTRAORDINARILY religious man. He wrote about God constantly in his notebooks. He quoted the Liturgical Calender of the Church very often. He was familiar with the Feast Days of the various Saints, and he wrote about them numerous times. He even wrote stories about the clergy - one of my favorites being a short tale about two travelling Franciscan monks, who get a clever revenge on an unscrupulous merchant who tricks them out of their supper.
Here are some of Leonardo’s words about God:
“Good Report soars and rises to heaven, for virtuous things find favor with God. Evil Report should be shown inverted, for all her works are contrary to God and tend toward hell.”
“We, by our arts may be called the grandsons of God.”
“If the Lord—who is the light of all things—vouchsafe to enlighten me, I will treat of Light; wherefore I will divide the present work into 3 Parts . . . Linear Perspective, The Perspective of Colour, The Perspective of Disappearance.”
“God sells us all things at the price of labor.”
“Fame alone raises herself to Heaven, because virtuous things are in favour with God.”
And, near the end of his life, Leonardo wrote:
“I have offended God and man because my work didn’t reach the quality it should have.”
Leonardo’s paintings show a profound grasp of religious symbolism that is genuinely unusual. He studied religion carefully, and he owned a large collection of religious books in his library, over 25 volumes – technical treatises on religious knowledge, very carefully chosen.
There is even a present-day book written about the “Catholic Leonardo da Vinci”:
Quoted from Zenit: “To help put things in their right place, philosopher Giuseppe Fornari has just published a book entitled, “La bellezza e il nulla. L’antropologia cristiana di Leonardo da Vinci” (Beauty and Nothingness: The Christian Anthropology of Leonardo da Vinci), published by Marietti. In the work, Fornari argues that “far from being a heretic and blasphemer, a compiler of riddles (as pop esotericism would like) Leonardo was rather a tormented Christian, irregular by necessity but profound and impassioned.””
An interview with Fornari on Leonardo can be read at Zenit, here: zenit.org/article-15524?l=english
Incidentally, the odd belief that Leonardo was a homosexual seems (to the best of my knowledge) to have originated from a very bad essay written about him by Sigmund Freud: “Leonardo da Vinci: A Memory of His Childhood.” (A typically Freudian title.) It’s over three-hundred pages long. And it is absolutely ridiculous.
FREUD believed that Leonardo was gay. But then Freud believed that pretty much EVERYBODY was gay. I think we can discount this idea from this one view alone. It is an inbuilt bias in Freud’s work, and it is unsupportable.
Modern homosexuals find Freud’s ideas about homosexuality and “mother attachment” to be highly insulting. Present day psychology has debunked most of Freud’s ideas on homosexuality, anyway. But the odd belief that Leonardo was gay just keeps hanging on. Perhaps because nobody has directly challenged it.
And if anyone still entertains doubts that Leonardo was a Catholic, here is a quote by Leonardo that almost nobody ever reprints in ANY book. Leonardo writes about the inventions of Nature:
“Though human ingenuity may make various inventions, it will never devise any inventions more beautiful, nor more simple, nor more to the purpose than Nature does; because in her inventions nothing is wanting, and nothing is superfluous, and she needs no counterpoise when she makes limbs proper for motion in the bodies of animals."
Then, Leonardo adds something that almost no one ever talks about, anywhere:
“The definition of the soul I leave to the imaginations of the friars, those fathers of the people who know all secrets by inspiration. I leave alone the sacred books; for they are SUPREME TRUTH.” (my emphasis)
This is an absolutely extraordinary statement. Leonardo, the “blaspheming rebel,” actually declares his allegiance to the teaching authority of the clergy of the Roman Catholic Church (the friars), and to the Holy Scriptures, which are, in his words, “supreme truth.”
This pretty much removes all doubt about his religious loyalties.
Of course, I have seen at least one Leonardo expert struggle with this passage. Scholar Martin Kemp wrote of it that “researchers have been puzzled for years by this statement, and no one is clear how to make sense of it.”
Well, if you believe that Leonardo da Vinci was a “homosexual, blaspheming rebel” who hated the Catholic Church, then it would NATURALLY be very difficult to fit this passage into that paradigm. But if you view Leonardo as an actual Catholic, taking into account all of his religious writings, Church references, religious paintings and such, then this passage makes a lot more sense. It is an infinitely more acceptable understanding.
I firmly believe there is enough evidence to have Leonardo (possibly) declared a Saint. And why not? The Roman Catholic Church already HAS a patron Saint of Scientists: Saint Albert. Why not a patron Saint of Creativity, too? Saint Leonardo? That has a nice ring to it.
Comments? Feedback?
Pop culture imagines Leonardo as a homosexual rebel who hated the Catholic Church. People say he was a blasphemer who almost never wrote about God in his notebooks. They say he worshiped Nature, rather than God. They claim that though Leonardo was undoubtably a great inventor and scientist, he was almost certainly not a Christian. Or so the usual argument goes.
But I believe that Leonardo da Vinci was a genuinely sincere and faithful Catholic. I believe he was an EXTRAORDINARILY religious man. He wrote about God constantly in his notebooks. He quoted the Liturgical Calender of the Church very often. He was familiar with the Feast Days of the various Saints, and he wrote about them numerous times. He even wrote stories about the clergy - one of my favorites being a short tale about two travelling Franciscan monks, who get a clever revenge on an unscrupulous merchant who tricks them out of their supper.
Here are some of Leonardo’s words about God:
“Good Report soars and rises to heaven, for virtuous things find favor with God. Evil Report should be shown inverted, for all her works are contrary to God and tend toward hell.”
“We, by our arts may be called the grandsons of God.”
“If the Lord—who is the light of all things—vouchsafe to enlighten me, I will treat of Light; wherefore I will divide the present work into 3 Parts . . . Linear Perspective, The Perspective of Colour, The Perspective of Disappearance.”
“God sells us all things at the price of labor.”
“Fame alone raises herself to Heaven, because virtuous things are in favour with God.”
And, near the end of his life, Leonardo wrote:
“I have offended God and man because my work didn’t reach the quality it should have.”
Leonardo’s paintings show a profound grasp of religious symbolism that is genuinely unusual. He studied religion carefully, and he owned a large collection of religious books in his library, over 25 volumes – technical treatises on religious knowledge, very carefully chosen.
There is even a present-day book written about the “Catholic Leonardo da Vinci”:
Quoted from Zenit: “To help put things in their right place, philosopher Giuseppe Fornari has just published a book entitled, “La bellezza e il nulla. L’antropologia cristiana di Leonardo da Vinci” (Beauty and Nothingness: The Christian Anthropology of Leonardo da Vinci), published by Marietti. In the work, Fornari argues that “far from being a heretic and blasphemer, a compiler of riddles (as pop esotericism would like) Leonardo was rather a tormented Christian, irregular by necessity but profound and impassioned.””
An interview with Fornari on Leonardo can be read at Zenit, here: zenit.org/article-15524?l=english
Incidentally, the odd belief that Leonardo was a homosexual seems (to the best of my knowledge) to have originated from a very bad essay written about him by Sigmund Freud: “Leonardo da Vinci: A Memory of His Childhood.” (A typically Freudian title.) It’s over three-hundred pages long. And it is absolutely ridiculous.
FREUD believed that Leonardo was gay. But then Freud believed that pretty much EVERYBODY was gay. I think we can discount this idea from this one view alone. It is an inbuilt bias in Freud’s work, and it is unsupportable.
Modern homosexuals find Freud’s ideas about homosexuality and “mother attachment” to be highly insulting. Present day psychology has debunked most of Freud’s ideas on homosexuality, anyway. But the odd belief that Leonardo was gay just keeps hanging on. Perhaps because nobody has directly challenged it.
And if anyone still entertains doubts that Leonardo was a Catholic, here is a quote by Leonardo that almost nobody ever reprints in ANY book. Leonardo writes about the inventions of Nature:
“Though human ingenuity may make various inventions, it will never devise any inventions more beautiful, nor more simple, nor more to the purpose than Nature does; because in her inventions nothing is wanting, and nothing is superfluous, and she needs no counterpoise when she makes limbs proper for motion in the bodies of animals."
Then, Leonardo adds something that almost no one ever talks about, anywhere:
“The definition of the soul I leave to the imaginations of the friars, those fathers of the people who know all secrets by inspiration. I leave alone the sacred books; for they are SUPREME TRUTH.” (my emphasis)
This is an absolutely extraordinary statement. Leonardo, the “blaspheming rebel,” actually declares his allegiance to the teaching authority of the clergy of the Roman Catholic Church (the friars), and to the Holy Scriptures, which are, in his words, “supreme truth.”
This pretty much removes all doubt about his religious loyalties.
Of course, I have seen at least one Leonardo expert struggle with this passage. Scholar Martin Kemp wrote of it that “researchers have been puzzled for years by this statement, and no one is clear how to make sense of it.”
Well, if you believe that Leonardo da Vinci was a “homosexual, blaspheming rebel” who hated the Catholic Church, then it would NATURALLY be very difficult to fit this passage into that paradigm. But if you view Leonardo as an actual Catholic, taking into account all of his religious writings, Church references, religious paintings and such, then this passage makes a lot more sense. It is an infinitely more acceptable understanding.
I firmly believe there is enough evidence to have Leonardo (possibly) declared a Saint. And why not? The Roman Catholic Church already HAS a patron Saint of Scientists: Saint Albert. Why not a patron Saint of Creativity, too? Saint Leonardo? That has a nice ring to it.
Comments? Feedback?