The Church and Time

  • Thread starter Thread starter TantumErgo90
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TantumErgo90

Guest
I know someone who thinks that the Mass, doctrine, and disciplines in the Church should be updated. I tried to explain that the Church is outside of time. He didn’t get it. How do I explain that the Church doesn’t change with the world.
 
I know someone who thinks that the Mass, doctrine, and disciplines in the Church should be updated. I tried to explain that the Church is outside of time. He didn’t get it. How do I explain that the Church doesn’t change with the world.
There are temporal truths and eternal truths. Temporal truths change because temporal reality changes: I am 25 today, I will not be 25 in a year; the sky is blue on a clear sunny day, it is gray on a cloudy winter day. Eternal truths do not change because they express an unchanging eternal reality: Jesus was born of the Virgin Mary, God is One in Three Persons, the Eucharist is the Body and Blood and Soul and Divinity of our glorified Lord.

In order for temporal truths to change, the reality behind them must change; that has happened plenty. For eternal truths to change, their eternal reality must change; that cannot happen. The Eucharist can’t cease to be the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ just because it’s hard to believe or it’s not convenient to believe it is.

The Church is the repository and teacher of eternal truths; thus, her dogma and doctrines can never change. They can be defined more clearly, in more articulate language, but never so as to contradict an earlier understanding.

Disciplines can change, as they reflect temporal truths.

The liturgy of the Mass can change, as it has throughout its 2000 year history. But the Mass cannot change in purpose or function, because it is, for all earthly time, the joining of Heaven and earth at Calvary, the one all-time sacrifice of Jesus Christ.
 
Thank you for your response. I realize rites and disciplines can change…but this person doesn’t want any discipline. He wants it gotten rid of. So, it not a matter of it not changing…it’s a matter of it existing.
 
Thank you for your response. I realize rites and disciplines can change…but this person doesn’t want any discipline. He wants it gotten rid of. So, it not a matter of it not changing…it’s a matter of it existing.
That’s a real bummer for him, because Christ was a rabbi, a teacher. There are rules and laws and disciplines and regulations. The Church didn’t make them up.
 
Archbishop Fulton Sheen, in his autobiography, wrote that the Church is like the rock gushing water–she has a solid, immutable part and a dynamic part. It is wrong to reject one or the other–we need both.

The Gospel is for all men in all times. It never changes. But, the world is in constant flux and the Church must be able to adapt to those changes–not to conform to the world, but rather to present and live the unchanging Gospel in ever-different circumstances–when the wind changes, you need to change the position of the sails if you want to keep going steadily in the same direction.

For example, evangelizing a post-modern American and a citizen of ancient Greece is going to be radically different since their philosophies, experiences, and ways of thinking are quite different.

But, as I said, the truth being presented is always the same. We have faith that what God has revealed is best for all men of all times because we have faith that He loves all men of all times. We trust He, in His supreme Wisdom, knows what’s best for us. That is what faith is all about. Those who think what He has revealed is not good for some time period have no faith–and without faith it is impossible to please God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top