The Early Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alegare21
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And yes you’re right (for once) that the early church fathers were not technically catholic, namely because the name didn’t stick as a label for a while. They were of the “universal” church. The Catholic Church of today is the same thing; we are the “universal” church. The catholic church is of the tradition that the apostles set in stone 2000 years ago.
 
The only historical documentation I can see him bringing up are from protestant encyclopedias based on the opinions of certain protestants. If he would research for actual historical documentation, or even open up a secular history book, he would see the truth.
Yes, my point exactly. The plain historical fact is the Church’s origins were never questioned by anyone until quite recent times. When the Orthodox went their separate way, the Church had been in existence for over 1000 years, and even they are considered in schism, not truly a “separate” church in the sense Protestants mean.

Our friend Brian isn’t going by history. What exactly he is using for a criteria only he knows, but it’s certainly not what solid, secular historians go by, that’s for sure. Two to one it’s some cut-off-from-reality interpretation of the meaning of “church” taken from his faith community’s revisionist version of history designed to make it appear they are the real Church of Christ when they’re probably an off-shoot of an off-shoot of some Protestant denomination started who knows when.

I say this in plain honesty not to be snide. I’m sure Brian is a follower of Our Lord and serves him faithfully in his faith community, but his faith community is not the Church founded by Christ and that’s all there is to it.
 
And my church, the Christian church, was founded by Jesus nearly 2000 years ago.
You claim that yours is the church of 2000 years ago. Let’s see, Can you tract your chief pastors back through 2000 years to the Apostles? You may want to make that empty claim with no proof, but you know very well none of the post reformation churches can trace their beginnings more than 500 years back.

That Christian Church that Jesus Christ founded 2000 years ago is what is today called The Catholic Church. If you want to look at the Truth, then consider this.
The earliest documents starting from the first century on, and continuing in unbroken succession deal with the sacraments, the liturgy, the orthodox doctrines and praxis as practiced down through the millennia right up through today. The chief Pastors of The Catholic Church can be traced in a direct line of succession from The Apostles right up to today.

Here is one of the many ways of discerning the Church which Christ founded.

There are a few things we know about this Church:
  1. It was built by Jesus Christ himself (Matt 16:18) which means that the “true church” must be about 2000 years old.
  2. Jesus only built ONE church (Matt 16:18).
  3. This church is the God -ordained upholder, protector and defender of the truth (1 Tim 3:15).
  4. This church is the fullness of Christ (Eph 1:22-23) which means that it is also the fullness of truth (John 14:6).
  5. The unity of this church will be proof to the world that Jesus was sent by God (John 17:21,23). In order for this unity to be seen by the world this church must be a visible church. The unity of this church must be a unity like that which exists between Jesus and the Father (John 17:21-23), therefore there can be no contradictions in doctrine. The Father and the Son do not disagree on doctrine therefore neither can the “true church”.
  6. This church can never change what it proclaims to be true. Jesus is the same yesterday, today and forever (Heb 13:8) therefore truth is the same yesterday, today and forever (John 14:6).
  7. The Church which Jesus Christ founded is the one through which He chose to declare which are the books contained in His New and Eternal Covenant.
If you would like to learn more about the teachings of Jesus Christ, please contact the folks at http://www.chnetwork.org/. I promise, if you unite yourself to Jesus Christ through His Church, you will experience the great gift the He has promised to those who follow Him. As Jesus said, “He who eats My body and drinks My blood lives in Me and I in him and I will raise him up on the last day.” And He is faithful and sure to keep His promises. Repent, turn to the Gospel and be saved and you will have everlasting life.

Grace and peace be with you.

Your servant in Christ.
 
The early writers were not Catholic; they were members of Christ’s church, which they described as being catholic (universal). They did not practices and believe the doctrines your “Catholic Church” adopted throughout the years. That makes your church something different from “His church.”
Cite some evidence please. How can you call ur’ self a student of the ECF’s … and make such a statement ?
 
Cite some evidence please. How can you call ur’ self a student of the ECF’s … and make such a statement ?
FYI: What I know is entirely from my own research of early Christian writings (Ante-Nicene)

Q: Does the traditions you claim came from the apostles include the following (and this is just a sampling):
The perpetual virginity of Mary?
Origen tells us that belief originated with the Protoevangelium of James in the latter second century, which as I am sure you know, is not apostolic. (Commentary on Matthew 17)

Irenaeus declares as a mater of fact that Mary and Joseph had sexual relations after the birth of Jesus. (Against Heresies 3:4)

Tertullian undeniably believed Mary had other children after Jesus. (On the Flesh of Christ 7)
The assumption of Mary
The origin of this doctrine is nowhere near the Ante-Nicene era.
Confession to and absolution from priests
The closest thing I can find on this is found in an account of Dionysius of Alexandria by Eusebius in Book six of his Ecclesiastical History. Dionysius apparently issued an injunction, that those at the point of death, if they desired it, should receive absolution that they might depart this life in comfortable hope. If the apostles delivered such a doctrine, Dionysius would have had no need to issue an injunction.
Eucharistic adoration
I have found no hint of it in the early ecclesiastical works.
Transubstantiation
Many references to the Eucharist being the body and blood of Christ, but indication that it “became” the literal body and blood of Christ is absent from the early works.

The most explicit references against the doctrine is probably from Clement of Alexandria’s Paedagogus Book 1, chapter 6 where he comments on the bread of life discourse saying, “Elsewhere the Lord, in the Gospel according to John, brought this out by symbols, when He said: “Eat ye my flesh, and drink my blood; ” describing distinctly by metaphor the drinkable properties of faith and the promise.”

And Origen in his commentary on Matthew 11:14 said this:

“It is not the material of the bread but the word which is said over it which is of advantage to him who eats it not unworthily of the Lord. And these things indeed are said of the typical and symbolical body. But many things might be said about the Word Himself who became flesh, and true meat of which he that eateth shall assuredly live for ever, no worthless person being able to eat it; for if it were possible for one who continues worthless to eat of Him who became flesh. who was the Word and the living bread, it would not have been written, that ‘every one who eats of this bread shall live for ever.’”

And Irenaeus reveals his denial of your doctrine explicitly in a story he relayed:

For when the Greeks, having arrested the slaves of Christian catechumens, then used force against them, in order to learn from them some secret thing [practiced] among Christians, these slaves, having nothing to say that would meet the wishes of their tormentors, except that they had heard from their masters that the divine communion was the body and blood of Christ, and imagining that it was actually flesh and blood, gave their inquisitors answer to that effect… (Fragment 13)

I think this quote from Irenaeus, more that anything else, demonstrates how your doctrine eventually came to be accepted as truth later on in the Catholic Church.
Universal authority of the church in Rome
There can be no doubt that Rome did not possess universal authority in the Ante-Nicene church. Good references for this can be found in Ignatius’ letter to Pollycarp, where he employed Pollycarp to assemble bishops to appoint his replacement. And strong evidence is also found in Eusebius’ account of Paul of Samosata. (EH 7:27-30)

Again, these are just a few of the doctrines Catholics believe where I have found no evidence of them being handed down by the apostles.
 
In response to your post brian, I’ll show you some facts.

Rome in the early church had all the authority it does today. In Adversus Haereses Irenaeus states “But since it would be too long to enumerate in such a volume as this the succession of all the churches, we shall confound all those who, in whatever manner, whether through self-satisfaction or vainglory, or through blindness and wicked opinion, assemble other than where it is proper, by pointing out here the successions of the bishops of the greatest and most ancient church known to all, founded and organized at Rome by the two most glorious apostles. Peter and Paul, that church which has the tradition and the faith which comes down to us after having been announced to men by the apostles. With that church, because of its superior origin, all the churches must agree, that is, all the faithful in the whole world, and it is in her that the faithful everywhere have maintained the apostolic tradition” (Against Heresies 3:3:2 inter A.D. 180-190).

Tertullian writes “The Lord said to Peter, “On this rock I will build my Church, I have given you the keys of the kingdom of heaven [and] whatever you shall have bound or loosed on earth will be bound or loosed in heaven” [Matt. 16:18-19]. … Upon you, he says, I will build my Church; and I will give to you the keys, not to the Church; and whatever you shall have bound or you shall have loosed, not what they shall have bound or they shall have loosed” (Modesty 21:9-10 A.D. 220).

Cyprian writes “With a false bishop appointed for themselves by heretics, they dare even to set sail and carry letters from schismatics and blasphemers to the Chair of Peter and to the principal church at Rome, in which sacerdotal unity has its source” (Epistle to Cornelius Bishop of Rome 59:14 A.D. 252).

Rome had the authority. The Anglicans just researched that not too long ago and a large portion of them came back to the Catholic Church.
 
FYI: What I know is entirely from my own research of early Christian writings (Ante-Nicene)

Q: Does the traditions you claim came from the apostles include the following (and this is just a sampling):
.
Dearest Brian, You were asked to substantiate your fallacious claim that your church was the early church. Once again as in the past, when asked to substantiate your claims, you have been unable to provide any evidence whatsoever. Instead have attack what you disagree with. This does not constitute evidence of your claims.

It is clear to everyone here that you are unable to provide any proof of your claim that your church is the Church founded by Jesus Christ whereas several here have provided substantial proof and evidence of the existence of The Catholic Church from the time of Christ down through time to the present.

My dear brother, How can you expect to convince anyone when you don’t provide any proof of your fallacious claims? That is a completely ineffective approach. We enjoy having you here and discussing these matters with you, but you need to come equiped to show the validity of your contentions.
I’m sure that if you go and do a little scholarship you will be able to come up with at least one or two pieces of evidence ot support your arguments.

God bless and guide you.

Your Servant in Christ.
 
In your response to Transubstantiation:

St. Justin Martyr writes “We call this food Eucharist, and no one else is permitted to partake of it, except one who believes our teaching to be true and who has been washed in the washing which is for the remission of sins and for regeneration * and is thereby living as Christ enjoined. For not as common bread nor common drink do we receive these, but since Jesus Christ our Savior was made incarnate by the word of God and had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so too, as we have been taught, the food which has been made into the Eucharist by the Eucharistic prayer set down by him, and by the change of which our blood and flesh is nurtured, is both the flesh and the blood of that incarnated Jesus.” First Apology 66 A.D. 151).

Irenaeus writes "He has declared the cup, a part of creation, to be his own blood from which he causes our blood to flow; and the bread, a part of creation, he has established as his own body, from which he gives increase unto our bodies. When, therefore, the mixed cup [wine and water] and the baked bread receive the Word of God and become the Eucharist, the body of Christ, and from these the substance of our flesh is increased and supported how can they say that the flesh is not capable of receiving the gift of God, which is eternal life — flesh which is nourished by the body and blood of the Lord and is in fact a member of him? (Against Heresies 5:2 A.D. 189).

Clement of Alexandria writes " ‘Eat my flesh’ Jesus says, ‘and drink my blood.’ The Lord supplies us with these intimate nutrients, he delivers over his flesh and pours out his blood, and nothing is lacking for the growth of his children (The Instructor of Children 1:6:43:3 A.D. 191).

The Eucharist and transubstantiation have always been the same.*
 
This is a great site for church fathers. You can also find a good list of Church Father writings at www.newadvent.com.

Just one note about any site with church father material is to be careful when reading editorial commentaries. For example, a great scholar and translator, Phillip Schaff, allows his religious bias against the Catholic Church to come through quite clearly in his analysis of some documents, for example, or Ignatius of Antioch and Eusebius’s Ecclesiastical History. Just to ilustrate, he calls Ignatius of Antioch a fanatic for writing so much on the office of bishop, and is disgusted that he did not write more on subjects near and dear to his own heart.

Now, I have no problem with someone criticising a church father, but that was a little much for such a well respected scholar.

God bless,
Ut
 
ccolley;6209307:
It is really best to look at the whole writings of the church fathers, if possible rather than bits picked ot by others.

Clement of Alexandria also said.
(The Instructor 1:6)
newadvent.org/fathers/02091.htm
If you read the full writings of the church fathers you will find that there was great diversity in the views expressed on some matters. Many if not most Protestant views find some support among the early church fathers. Even if they may not be the predominate view in some cases, they were still viewed as orthodox at the time. It was only later that diversity of views on these matters became unacceptable.

The predominant and orthodox view of the Church Fathers and all the Early Christians was that the bread and wine ARE the body and blood of Christ, not SYMBOLS of his body and blood. Church Fathers although they give us significant insight into the early Church…are not infallible.
CC
 
In response to your post brian, I’ll show you some facts.
Irenaeus did not say “greatest and most ancient church known to all,” he said, “…the very great, the very ancient, and universally known Church.” He prefaced his statement with, “it would be very tedious, in such a volume as this, to reckon up the successions of all the Churches” He chose to use Rome probably because that is where the heresies were prevalent.

Did you also notice as you read on that Irenaeus verifies that Peter was not a bishop in Rome? That means you cannot attach Tertullian’s comments about Peter to the bishop of Rome. There is more evidence from Tertullian that demonstrates he did not see Rome as superior over other church founded by apostles. I will have to locate those references when I’m at home and have more time. (I’m writing this at work on my lunch hour)

Can you verify your Cyprian quote please? Are you saying that came from his 59th epistle? If you are, that epistle is not to Cornelius and it does not contain your quote.

Just prior to what Justin said in the quote you provided, he said, “And when the president has given thanks, and all the people have expressed their assent, those who are called by us deacons give to each of those present to partake of the bread and wine mixed with water over which the thanksgiving was pronounced, and to those who are absent they carry away a portion.”

He said they partake of “bread and wine mixed with water,” not the flesh and blood of Christ. Think about it, he was writing this to a pagan who accused Christians of eating flesh and blood. He spent a great deal of time in his first apology defending against that accusation. He is not telling the emperor that the bread and wine turn into literal flesh and blood and then consumed by Christians, he is telling him that What Christians call the body and blood of Christ is really and physically bread and wine.

Irenaeus is more explicit in this: “Then, again, how can they [the Gnostics] say that the flesh, which is nourished with the body of the Lord and with His blood, goes to corruption, and does not partake of life? Let them, therefore, either alter their opinion, or cease from offering the things just mentioned. But our opinion is in accordance with the Eucharist, and the Eucharist in turn establishes our opinion. For we offer to Him His own, announcing consistently the fellowship and union of the flesh and Spirit. For as the bread, which is produced from the earth, when it receives the invocation of God, is no longer common bread, but the eucharist, consisting of two realities, earthly and heavenly; so also our bodies, when they receive the eucharist, are no longer corruptible, having the hope of the resurrection to eternity.”

Do you consider the glorified body of Christ to be “earthly?” Will receiving the Eucharist cause us to live forever in our flesh, or does it represent the hope we have in Christ unto eternal life? Irenaeus understood it as the latter.

Clement explicitly said that Jesus was speaking metaphorically. Quoting Clement where he is not explicit does not nullify what he said where he is explicit. You only argument can be that he was not orthodox. If you take that stance you will need to show evidence from other writers condemning his teaching.
 
Please tell me which book of the Early Church Fathers you are taking all the above information from? Is it Faith of the Early Fathers by Jurgens? If so then please tell me which reference page and number to look at.
I stated in my post that my research is my own and all the references come from primary sources, i.e. the actual writings.
 
Brian,
You will see small differences in translation of old documents, but the message is still the same. And yes I read on and found that no where in the document does Irenaeus state that Peter was not a bishop in rome. He goes on to name the line of successors to Peter in rome, starting with Linus.
Speaking of Heretics, Cyprian writes “After such things as these, moreover, they still dare—a false bishop having been appointed for them by heretics—to set sail and to bear letters from schismatic and profane persons to the throne of Peter, and to the chief church whence priestly unity takes its source; and not to consider that these were the Romans whose faith was praised in the preaching of the apostle, to whom faithlessness could have no access.” (To Cornelius, Concerning Fortunatus and Felicissimus, or Against Heretics2571-2573) I apologize for the incorrect citation before, I must have been reading something else at the same time (on top of doing hours of Calculus).
As to your response of St. Justin Martyr, he is saying that it is bread and wine mixed with water to the point of the prayer being said. The bread and wine then, and I use what text you cited from Irenaeus, "For as the bread, which is produced from the earth, when it receives the invocation of God, is no longer common bread, but the eucharist, consisting of two realities, earthly and heavenly; so also our bodies, when they receive the eucharist, are no longer corruptible, having the hope of the resurrection to eternity.”

And more from St. Justin Martyr: “And this food is called among us Εὐχαριστία19101910 [the Eucharist], of which no one is allowed to partake but the man who believes that the things which we teach are true, and who has been washed with the washing that is for the remission of sins, and unto regeneration, and who is so living as Christ has enjoined. For not as common bread and common drink do we receive these; but in like manner as Jesus Christ our Saviour, having been made flesh by the Word of God, had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so likewise have we been taught that the food which is blessed by the prayer of His word, and from which our blood and flesh by transmutation are nourished, is the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh. For the apostles, in the memoirs composed by them, which are called Gospels, have thus delivered unto us what was enjoined upon them; that Jesus took bread, and when He had given thanks, said, “This do ye in remembrance of Me,19121912 Luke xxii. 19. this is My body;” and that, after the same manner, having taken the cup and given thanks, He said, “This is My blood;” and gave it to them alone. Which the wicked devils have imitated in the mysteries of Mithras, commanding the same thing to be done. For, that bread and a cup of water are placed with certain incantations in the mystic rites of one who is being initiated, you either know or can learn.” (First Apology “The Eucharist” Chapter LXVI)

And where does Clement say that Jesus was being metaphoric? please cite the documentation and the passages.
 
Just prior to what Justin said in the quote you provided, he said, “And when the president has given thanks, and all the people have expressed their assent, those who are called by us deacons give to each of those present to partake of the bread and wine mixed with water over which the thanksgiving was pronounced, and to those who are absent they carry away a portion.”

He said they partake of “bread and wine mixed with water,” not the flesh and blood of Christ.

.
No … you didn’t finish what he said. He said “bread and wine, mixed with water OVER WHICH THE THANKSGIVING WAS PRONOUNCED”.

Once blessed … it becomes the body/blood/and spirit of Christ to ALL who partake RIGHTLY [so taught Paul].

In other words, if you were to receive the Eucharist w/o believing RIGHTLY … it would not become the Body/Blood/Spiritual grace of Christ to you. As Paul teaches, “w/o Faith it is impossible to please God”. You cannot receive Christ in the Eucharist as a believing Catholic can.
 
For as the bread, which is produced from the earth, when it receives the invocation of God, is no longer common bread, but the eucharist, consisting of two realities, earthly and heavenly; so also our bodies, when they receive the eucharist, are no longer corruptible, having the hope of the resurrection to eternity
.”

Do you consider the glorified body of Christ to be “earthly?”

.

Here again we read “WHEN IT RECEIVES THE INVOCATION OF GOD, IS NO LONGER COMMOM BREAD, BUT THE EUCHARIST”.

Christ took on an EARTHLY body … so he could suffer for your earthly Adamaic body/soul on Cross.
Having gained the victory … he was GLORIFIED by the Father.

Those who partake ‘Rightly’ of the Eucharist … receive ALL of Christ. The SON OF MAN who suffered for us AND the Glorified King who sits at right hand of the Father, and making himself present in our Eucharist, that is blessed — and received rightly in FAITH.
 
In other words, if you were to receive the Eucharist w/o believing RIGHTLY … it would not become the Body/Blood/Spiritual grace of Christ to you. As Paul teaches, “w/o Faith it is impossible to please God”. You cannot receive Christ in the Eucharist as a believing Catholic can.
This appears to be a receptionist view rather than the Catholic Church’s view. The Catholic Church teaches that the elements become Christ’s body and blood and remain so. Anyone who receives it receives the entire Christ whether they believe or not.
 
This appears to be a receptionist view rather than the Catholic Church’s view. The Catholic Church teaches that the elements become Christ’s body and blood and remain so. Anyone who receives it receives the entire Christ whether they believe or not.
Correct
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top