The Eucharist and Non Catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter hwerks
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

hwerks

Guest
The Eucharist is important to me and I look forward to receiving communion as often as I can. Other denominations do not believe in transubstantiation but they do allow for participtation during their communion. We invite friends of other faiths to come to mass with us particulalrly during Christmas and Easter. Almost all feel the Catholic Mass is much more spiritual then their own services but they feel left out when they are not invited to partake of :confused:the Eucharist. The Gospel of John presents Jesus as saying: “Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood you have no life in you … he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me and I in him” (6:53-56).

He did not qualify this in anyway, so why does the Church?

For those that do not believe, they will feel nothing perhaps; but for those, like me, when I am focused on teh mass and the Eucharist it is opening a door and being with Christ and letting the Holy Spirit fill me. I see no downside to letting all particpate!
 
One downside you may not be considering is that you would be inviting them to lie. When presented with the host or the cup, we hear “Body (or Blood) of Christ”. Our proper response is “Amen”. The Amen means that we believe that we are receiving the body and blood of Christ. If one does not believe and recieves they would be professing a lie.
 
Try this link here, it is good info and provides Scriptual references to your questions.

And also welcome to the forums.
 
Great question hwerks,.

The Catechism explains the reasons:

1399 The Eastern churches that are not in full communion with the Catholic Church celebrate the Eucharist with great love. “These Churches, although separated from us, yet possess true sacraments, above all - by apostolic succession - the priesthood and the Eucharist, whereby they are still joined to us in closest intimacy.” A certain communion in sacris, and so in the Eucharist, “given suitable circumstances and the approval of Church authority, is not merely possible but is encouraged.”

1400 Ecclesial communities derived from the Reformation and separated from the Catholic Church, “have not preserved the proper reality of the Eucharistic mystery in its fullness, especially because of the absence of the sacrament of Holy Orders.” It is for this reason that, for the Catholic Church, Eucharistic intercommunion with these communities is not possible. However these ecclesial communities, “when they commemorate the Lord’s death and resurrection in the Holy Supper . . . profess that it signifies life in communion with Christ and await his coming in glory.”

1401 When, in the Ordinary’s judgment, a grave necessity arises, Catholic ministers may give the sacraments of Eucharist, Penance, and Anointing of the Sick to other Christians not in full communion with the Catholic Church, who ask for them of their own will, provided they give evidence of holding the Catholic faith regarding these sacraments and possess the required dispositions.
 
All protestants believe that Christ is present during communion. After all, He said He would be.

Lutherans believe that Christ is in the wine and bread but confess that they do not know how it happens. They do not believe the wine and bread changes into the blood and body of Christ. One can merely look at it and see that it doesn’t.

Baptists and many other protestants also believe Christ is present but do not believe the wine and bread makes any change.

All protestant who take communion take both the bread and wine however and are not refused the wine because Christ commanded they take both. I can’t image any reason to withold either from you.

I feel certain the Roman Catholic position is the same as the Lutheran one here. For a non-Catholic to take part in a Catholic Eucharist would be saying that they agree with what the Catholics teach about transubstantiation. Likewise a Catholic would not participate in a communion where the belief is different than theirs.

To participate in this event, no matter what you call it would mean that you agree with what that particular church teaches about it and a Christian should not do that!

Personally I wish all churches had communion at least once a week.
 
The Eucharist is the most intimate bond between Christ and His bride, the Church. If the bride shares her ring with others who, though wearing the wedding garments, did not ascent with the great Amen (I do), it seams they would be commiting an infedelity, not keeping this sacred sign.

It’s not that they cannot partake, it’s that they cannot partake yet…
 
I wanted to vote yes on the poll, but I trust enough in the fact that the Church teaches infallibly and that how it is done in the Church is not only right but also what is best for us regardless how we feel about it. Similar to how I would like to believe that nobody will ever go to Hell, but in some way beyond what my mind can comprehend there is a reason why God has made certain boundries the way they are. He has our best interest in mind.
 
All protestants believe that Christ is present during communion. After all, He said He would be.
I agree, however in the Catholic Mass He is present in a unique way that is dependent on the ministerial priesthood.
Lutherans believe that Christ is in the wine and bread but confess that they do not know how it happens. They do not believe the wine and bread changes into the blood and body of Christ. One can merely look at it and see that it doesn’t.

Baptists and many other protestants also believe Christ is present but do not believe the wine and bread makes any change.

All protestant who take communion take both the bread and wine however and are not refused the wine because Christ commanded they take both. I can’t image any reason to withold either from you.

I feel certain the Roman Catholic position is the same as the Lutheran one here.
You may feel that way, but the teachings are clearly different. Again it depends on the validity of the priest and his capacity to perform the Sacrament validly.
For a non-Catholic to take part in a Catholic Eucharist would be saying that they agree with what the Catholics teach about transubstantiation. Likewise a Catholic would not participate in a communion where the belief is different than theirs.

To participate in this event, no matter what you call it would mean that you agree with what that particular church teaches about it and a Christian should not do that!
Amen to that.
Personally I wish all churches had communion at least once a week.
 
What would the disciples say if a person who had left following Jesus as was noted in John 6:66 wanted to partake of Mass in say 40AD and told them that they believed in Jesus but didn’t think that the bread and wine were truely the body and blood of Jesus.

Do you think they would have let them partake?

The answer is no!
 
What would the disciples say if a person who had left following Jesus as was noted in John 6:66 wanted to partake of Mass in say 40AD and told them that they believed in Jesus but didn’t think that the bread and wine were truely the body and blood of Jesus.

Do you think they would have let them partake?

The answer is no!
Great point!
 
This is the problem I have with the Catholic Church. One of the very few I do. The Eucharist is something that is very important to me and something that I feel that I need to carry on. (That is why I am joining the Episcopal Church).I believe in the real presence of Christ I don’t know how to explain it our how he does it but he does it :). But as a baptized believer in Christ and one who tries to follow his will daily I believe that one should be able to take the Eucharist in good faith where ever they are. I do not believe that Christ put any barriers to his fellowship or his table and I don’t believe we should either. We are united by the death of Christ and we should be united at his table!
 
This is the problem I have with the Catholic Church. One of the very few I do. The Eucharist is something that is very important to me and something that I feel that I need to carry on. (That is why I am joining the Episcopal Church).I believe in the real presence of Christ I don’t know how to explain it our how he does it but he does it :). But as a baptized believer in Christ and one who tries to follow his will daily I believe that one should be able to take the Eucharist in good faith where ever they are. I do not believe that Christ put any barriers to his fellowship or his table and I don’t believe we should either. We are united by the death of Christ and we should be united at his table!
Hello!

Glad to hear this is one of the few problems you have with the Catholic Church. Usually, people have many issues;)

Please understand that even baptized Catholics who haven’t yet received proper education about what the Eucharist really is and what reception truly entails may not receive the sacrament of First Holy Communion. This also includes receiving the sacrament of First Reconciliation prior to receiving First Communion.

Also, baptized Catholics who have received First Communion but who are not in a state of grace may not/should not receive the Eucharist without going to reconcilation lest they “eat and drink judgement upon themselves.”

If we, as Catholics, put these types of restrictions on reception of communion in order to protect not only the sanctity of the sacrament but also our very souls, would we not extend the same courtesy to our non-Catholic brothers and sisters?

God bless you on your journey!
Teri
 
This is the problem I have with the Catholic Church. One of the very few I do. The Eucharist is something that is very important to me and something that I feel that I need to carry on. (That is why I am joining the Episcopal Church).I believe in the real presence of Christ I don’t know how to explain it our how he does it but he does it :). But as a baptized believer in Christ and one who tries to follow his will daily I believe that one should be able to take the Eucharist in good faith where ever they are. I do not believe that Christ put any barriers to his fellowship or his table and I don’t believe we should either. We are united by the death of Christ and we should be united at his table!
The Episcopal ecclesial community (not an authentic Church in the proper sense) does not have an authentic Eucharist, because the Episcopal community is deprived of the constitutive element of sacrametal priesthood. The Episcopal “priest” has the same sacramental orders as a Justice of the Peace. Both can marry and Baptize, but that’s it for the Sacraments.

If you are not Catholic, in communion with the Catholic Church, buying into everything, then please do not receive God in the valid Eucharist in His Catholic Church. Additionally, the Episcopal ecclesial community has no Sacrament of Reconciliation, so if you need confession and don’t have it… If you receive unworthily, St. Paul tells us that we eat and drink judgement on ourselves, making ourselves guilty of Christ’s death, rather than being saved by His death. I don’t see how that would be good for anyone, do you?

The only good reason to leave the Catholic Church is so you can come back. Let me explain… sadly, many in God’s Church have left His one true faith already in their hearts, as you may have already done. Leaving God’s Church physically can be a step in realizing how one has already left the Church in their heart. Hopefully, this realization will help one to start coming back in the heart, and then come back physically.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top