The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Zundrah! You love God. You love the Catholic Church, I think. Why do you think it would be good to spit at both? Honestly, to adelphi mou, to seperate yourself from Christ so willingly seems to me to be the worst apostasy you can ever perform. Please don’t do this… for your sake please!
But i want to be comfirmed! I have to be comfirmed for my church to be “my church”…
 
I am not prepaired to worship a wafer…
We do not worshi a simple wafer. Before consecration, the wafer isimply that: a wafer, nothing more, nothing less. After the consecration it becomes so much more. It retains the physical accidents of bread and wine, but truly becomes Body Blood Soul, and DIvinity of Chrst. Mass is the intersection of Heaven and Earth. We are faithful to Jesus and eat His flesh and Drink His blood. From what I get from your posts, you do not want to be CAtholic in the true sense, you just want to be in the CAtholic “club”. YOu want the label, but are unwilling to submit to the authority of the Church.
 
I want to be closer to Christ…
Of course, but growth in Christ takes time; you know that. Growth simply for the sake of growth is called cancer. And wanting to be closer to Christ, but wanting to do it your own way is called sin.
 
The Vigil Mass was about the Eucharist oddly enough.

Anyway, what is the rush for Zundrah to come to a different view than she has right now?

Nothing good happens when you rush. Unless God tells you to pack your bags, move and don’t look back, I think taking your time on these things is honorable, not despicable.
I need to be comfirmed strawberry jam! I need it! My church is apparently not my church unless I am comfirmed! :eek:
 
Of course, but growth in Christ takes time; you know that. Growth simply for the sake of growth is called cancer. And wanting to be closer to Christ, but wanting to do it your own way is called sin.
But the Eucharist is the only way that i will be catholic!
 
The Vigil Mass was about the Eucharist oddly enough.

Anyway, what is the rush for Zundrah to come to a different view than she has right now?

Nothing good happens when you rush. Unless God tells you to pack your bags, move and don’t look back, I think taking your time on these things is honorable, not despicable.
It isn’t so much a rush for her to change her beliefs. We are asking her to spend more time thinking (or at least thats what I’m doing now). Otherwise her conversion will be false, shallow and pointless.

Then again my personal opinion is that Jennifer is saying all this just to get a rise out of people.
 
The church was probably catholic still; with out any “split-offs” like protestant denominations, right?
It was Catholic, yes, although there were some serious doctrinal disputes that the Catholic Church had to reign in. The Gnostic, Docetist, and Arian groups were all major problems, since they were also claiming to be “Christian”. However, even most Protestant groups today will admit that these three groups were dangerous splinter groups.

So, you want to be Catholic, but earlier, you told me that some of the passages of the early Christian writers, like Ignatius, were false teachings, and that Revelation warned against people changing the Bible. So, are Ignatius and ALL of the other early Christians wrong in their interpretation that the Eucharist is literal? Were the Apostles such poor teachers that every single student of theirs got the message wrong?
 
But i want to be comfirmed! I have to be comfirmed for my church to be “my church”…
I don’t understand why everyone is expecting you to be on the same page with them now.

Do you feel pressured? I would.
 
If that is your answer then I can only suggest you spend a long time discerning whether the Catholic Church is for you. It seems you have a few problems with the most integral aspects of the religion. These should be worked through before you can really convert.
 
But i want to be comfirmed! I have to be comfirmed for my church to be “my church”…
To be confirmed is not just saying you want to be a member in the Church; it’s taking the responsibility for learning and carrying out the docrines of the Church. My dear, if you were living in the Holy Land in the 4th century and approached St. Cyril of Jerusalem and said you wanted to join his church, and then told him all the things you believe, he would politely show you the door. You say you want the Catholic Church to be “your church”, but really, you have to be willing to tell the Church our mother “I want to be your child”; you are the one who submits to the other, not the other way around. I think you’re taking things too fast; I agree with Strawberry Jam on this point. Take a breath.
 
I don’t understand why everyone is expecting you to be on the same page with them now.

Do you feel pressured? I would.
Zundra,
We are not expecting you to be on the same page as us right now. What we are asking is that you investigate the Real Presence seriously, and if you don’t believe in it when the time comes for the Sacraments of Initiation at Easter Vigil 2010, don’t go through with it, and continue to study. You are welcome to continue RCIA in the meantime. If you change your belief, you might even be able to go through the sacraments sooner, it would depend on your diocese. If, God forbid, you were to die before you received the sacraments, you would still be considered a Catholic by virtue of your intention to study and join the church.

There is a LOT of time left before Easter of next year. There’s no need to blindly rush forward.
 
I agree with Rolltide, your intentions to join are already demonstrated! No need to rush!

You believe, that is such a big thing right there!🙂
 
My pastors are not interested; I told them that i am protestant and they didn’t even batter an eye lid…
They are not worried that you are currently Protestant, a separated sister. Not batting an eye does not mean they are not interested.
When you make your first confession, it is unlikely that you will see any reaction from the priest. All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God. When we come in a spirit of true contrition, there is no sin that cannot be forgiven.
This is my plan; I will let the priest think that I am in belief in what is going on at Easter comfirmation. I will just go along with it until I am comfirmed. That way I will be a real member at my Catholic chruch, that way I will really belong to my church! 😃 Even if i must eat the Eucharist I will!
Your “confirmation” would be a sacrilege of the Sacrament. It would merely be an act, like that on a stage with no true meaning. Both the Eucharist and Confirmation are Sacraments. Your sacrilege would not be only against the Sacrament of the Eucharist, it would be a sacrilege against the Sacrament of Confirmation.
The worst lie that you can tell is the one you tell yourself. Because you do not believe, you would still not find a home in the church that you want to be your own.
If you read the Book of Acts, you will find the story of Ananias and Sapphira. What most of us here are seeing from these recent posts is a plan to lie to the Holy Spirit. We are doing what we can to warn you against this sin.
If we did not, if we turned a blind eye, we would be accomplices.
Christ will be with me; even in darkness.
Do not cheapen the grace of Christ on the cross.
The problem is that if you lie, and then take the Eucharist unworthily, you will be in a state of mortal sin, and mortal sin can condemn us to hell. Even if you go to confession, according to what you say right now, you won’t really be sorry that you received the Eucharist and that you didn’t believe in it, and so the confession will be invalid, even if the priest grants you absolution. In order for your sins to be truly forgiven during Confession, you need to be truly sorry. You will continue to remain in a state of mortal sin unless you continue to abstain from the Eucharist voluntarily…

That said, you can’t even do that forever, because Catholics are obligated to receive the Eucharist at least once a year on Easter Sunday.

For Protestants, worship is about the sermon.
For Catholics and Orthodox, worship is about the celebration of the Eucharist.
The unrepentant confession would be one more sacrilege.
Zundrah! You love God. You love the Catholic Church, I think. Why do you think it would be good to spit at both? Honestly, to adelphi mou, to seperate yourself from Christ so willingly seems to me to be the worst apostasy you can ever perform. Please don’t do this… for your sake please!
But i want to be comfirmed! I have to be comfirmed for my church to be “my church”…
It will still not be “your church” because your membership would be a lie.
It was Catholic, yes, although there were some serious doctrinal disputes that the Catholic Church had to reign in. The Gnostic, Docetist, and Arian groups were all major problems, since they were also claiming to be “Christian”. However, even most Protestant groups today will admit that these three groups were dangerous splinter groups.

So, you want to be Catholic, but earlier, you told me that some of the passages of the early Christian writers, like Ignatius, were false teachings, and that Revelation warned against people changing the Bible. So, are Ignatius and ALL of the other early Christians wrong in their interpretation that the Eucharist is literal? Were the Apostles such poor teachers that every single student of theirs got the message wrong?
To be confirmed is not just saying you want to be a member in the Church; it’s taking the responsibility for learning and carrying out the docrines of the Church. My dear, if you were living in the Holy Land in the 4th century and approached St. Cyril of Jerusalem and said you wanted to join his church, and then told him all the things you believe, he would politely show you the door. You say you want the Catholic Church to be “your church”, but really, you have to be willing to tell the Church our mother “I want to be your child”; you are the one who submits to the other, not the other way around. I think you’re taking things too fast; I agree with Strawberry Jam on this point. Take a breath.
Zundra,
We are not expecting you to be on the same page as us right now. What we are asking is that you investigate the Real Presence seriously, and if you don’t believe in it when the time comes for the Sacraments of Initiation at Easter Vigil 2010, don’t go through with it, and continue to study. You are welcome to continue RCIA in the meantime. If you change your belief, you might even be able to go through the sacraments sooner, it would depend on your diocese. If, God forbid, you were to die before you received the sacraments, you would still be considered a Catholic by virtue of your intention to study and join the church.

There is a LOT of time left before Easter of next year. There’s no need to blindly rush forward.
We do not want you to rush into something in which you do not believe.
We would be giving you the same type of warning if we thought you were rushing into a marriage before you are ready. Some people focus on the wedding without looking at the responsibility and work that is required to grow in that marriage relationship.
If you were to join the Army, you would still be required to fulfill what is required of you. The oath taken at the swearing in is only the beginning.

I am going again to repeat what Strawberry Jam, Rolltide, and I, along with others have already said. If you are not ready, if you do not yet believe what the Catholic Church teaches, then wait. Step back. Take a breath. Ask the moderator to close this thread so that you have time to reflect on what has already been said.

This last rush of two sentence long entries can easily be interpreted as a temper tantrum, and only serves to reinforce the idea that you are not ready.
 
When I was confirmed, the bishop actually slapped my face. This was a tradition meant to instill the meaning of what it means to be confirmed. We were called to be “a soldier of Christ,” willing to die for what the Church teaches. While there have been some changes in the rite of Confirmation, the essential elements, the truth of what it means remain the same. A member of the Catholic Church is called to be a witness to his/her faith even if that witness leads to martyrdom, even if it means death. Martyr actually means witness.
Confirmation binds a person to the Church. He/she is anointed to “share more completely in the mission of Jesus Christ” (CCC 1294)

The candidate for Confirmation in the Latin Church should be in the state of grace, be well prepared by prayer and catechesis, and be committed to the responsibilities entailed by the Sacrament. Quoted from the United States Catholic Catechism for Adults.

Coming back to the idea of the Eucharist being at the heart of what we as Catholics believe, the source and summit of our faith, would you be willing to die for a lie?
 
You are confusing me… Why did you come on to my thread about child abuse and say to every this; “it is probable that it is not necessary to feel you need to convince her of Catholic teachings”
It seemed quite nasty to me…
Because on this thread you are asking about a theologival matter. On the other I explained to you our answers would be colored by our catholicity . But trying to convince you a rosary in your pocket would help would only be one more thing for you to say was superstition.
It was NEVER a nasty remark.

And accepting confirmation in the Catholic Church without believing the doctrine and receiving the Eucharist would be a terrible thing to do.
It is heresy to say and believe that the Eucharsit is not the Body and Blood of Christ. And sacrilege to receive it in pretense.
Zundrah, do not do these things. They are wrong.
 
If a muslim siad to me that my faith in christ was a fake because christ was just a man, then I would not be offended, I would instead realise that he has not recieved christ himself.
And since I have not recieved the eucharist then how can you expect me to believe it? You are being a hypocritical christian, if we all just took offence to peoples lack of belief then the whole world would be at war.
The whole world IS at war. You haven’t noticed?
 
The Eucharist is just tradition, something we do in memory of him, it is now just a superstition taken very far out of its original meaning which was to remember him.
 
Would someone please use this already?

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top