Hmm - imagine I’m a rational alien. (Well actually
I am as far as you are concerned
![Grinning face with big eyes :smiley: 😃](https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f603.png)
)… I meet knowledgeable and devout Catholics who explain why they believe that their faith represents the high truth. They say (smugly?) 'all religions aren’t equal because one is true (the Catholic religion - or at least my particular branch of Catholicism). But then I meet other Catholics (ultra-conservative, liberal, intellectual, Jesuitical [my personal favourite] , charismatic, liberational), Protestants (Episcopal liberal, Episcopal African, Anglo-catholic, Methodist, Baptist, white fundamentalist, black fundamentalist), Seventh Day Adventist, Mormon, Quaker, Sunni muslim, Shiite Muslim, Indian Buddhist, Nepalese Buddhist, Chinese Buddhist, Sikh, many different Jewish groups, haitian voodoo, West Indian obeah, animism, countless African and Polynesian beliefs, Chinese Confucianism, Taoism, Japanese Shinto, da-da etc etc - you get the idea). Each and every one of the people, that I as a rational alien meet, believes, with total conviction and confidence, that his religious beliefs are true. Each is utterly convnced that her belief represents the ultimate truth and that all the others are ‘superstition’, ‘error’, ‘heresy’. (Except there are a few, who whilst holding to their own faith acknowledge other paths, in charity, love and understanding, but they are few, very few).
So, here I am, a rational alien on this earth and hundreds of people have grasped me by the buttonhole of my alien cybersuit and with all conviction have said to me ‘mine is the way, the truth and the light - others are mistaken, or evil, or damned, or pitiable’.
My question is this - in all this maze of belief and disagreement, how do I as a rational alien, unburdened with the bias of being born into this faith or that, come to the conclusion that any one of these deeply held convictions should hold sway over all the others. What are the criteria that I should apply, and in applying these criteria, why should I come to the conclusion that the mainstream version of Catholic belief represents truth and all others are mistaken? Why?
Alec
homepage.ntlworld.com/macandrew/Grenada_disaster/Grenada_disaster.htm