The Feast of Dedication

  • Thread starter Thread starter JED8643
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JED8643

Guest
I’m not sure if this has been discussed before but does anyone have any info on The Feast of Dedication that is mentioned in the New Testament Book of John, chapter 10, verse 22?

I’m wondering if Jesus was in Jerusalem specifically for this feast as alluded to in John’s Gospel?

The reason I ask is because I am in discussion about the Deuterocanonical Books with a Baptist friend of mine and this feast seems to be derived from the account of a revolt by a group of four Jewish brothers, led by Judah Maccabee, who cleansed the Temple after it was desecrated by the Seleucid King.

What is interesting is that the only place I can find this account is in the OT books of 1 and 2 Maccabees. (my Baptist friend does not consider these books to be canonical)
In my copy of the original 1611 King James Version, the KJ translators actually put a cross reference in the margin of John 10:22 to a verse in the book of 1 Maccabees.

If Jesus was in Jerusalem for this feast, it seems He is either observing extra-biblical Jewish tradition or could have considered the account from 1 and 2 Macabees actual scripture.

Does anyone have any addition info on this feast or am I missing something altogether?

Thanks,

Jed

.
 
I’m not sure if this has been discussed before but does anyone have any info on The Feast of Dedication that is mentioned in the New Testament Book of John, chapter 10, verse 22?
The Feast of the Dedication (Hanukkah, Festival of Lights) was instituted by Judas Machabeus in 164 BC.
I’m wondering if Jesus was in Jerusalem specifically for this feast as alluded to in John’s Gospel?
We don’t know.
If Jesus was in Jerusalem for this feast, it seems He is either observing extra-biblical Jewish tradition
So what? The Jews have lots of non-Biblical traditions. Most of their observances (such as the two “biggies” - Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur) do not clearly originate from OT sources. Judas clearly did not draw from 1Macabees when he first instituted the observance in the first place (duh, 1Mac had not yet been written).

The Jews weren’t Sola Scriptura people either.

If Jesus was celebrating Hanukkah, he wasn’t doing so because it is mentioned in 1Mac.

I don’t think this gives you anything of apologetical value.
 
Yeah, it’s the same feast - aka “Hannukah”. Here’s the wiki. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannukah
I’m not sure that that fact alone would be enough to convince them. Even “uninspired” books could accurately record the inaugeration of a feast. But it might grant the book a little more legitimacy in your friend’s mind.

Here are a few articles that I just stumbled on that are pretty interesting regarding Tobit and Wisdom and may really help you (they’re pretty short).
catholicdefense.blogspot.com/2010/11/book-of-wisdom-at-its-finest.html
catholicdefense.blogspot.com/2010/08/prophetic-book-of-tobit.html
catholicdefense.blogspot.com/2010/08/prophetic-book-of-tobit-revisited.html

Here’s a really good article by Mark Shea that I recommend you read, as well.
catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0120.html

A good question to ask any protestant (charitably) is “what criteria do you use to tell if any book of the Bible is inspired?” Ask them to give you a logical reason why they use those criteria. If he believes that the sole infallibe rule of faith is the Bible and the Bible doesn’t list a canon, it seems like there would be no sure way to know what books should be in the Bible.
 
Aren’t the Deuterocanonicals quoted elsewhere in the NT as well? I believe so. Too, perhaps even scripture is quoted in the NT which I’m not even sure is anywhere to be found in the OT or NT. The other posters have the answer down well.
 
Aren’t the Deuterocanonicals quoted elsewhere in the NT as well? I believe so. Too, perhaps even scripture is quoted in the NT which I’m not even sure is anywhere to be found in the OT or NT. The other posters have the answer down well.
Here’s a handy list:

scripturecatholic.com/deuterocanon.html

Some of them look difficult to tell if the source was really the verse he was claiming. Either the resemblance is vague or the topic is general enough that it could have any number of sources. However, with many of them the connection seems to be pretty clear. I’ll have to take a closer look when I get a chance. It’s pretty interesting.
 
The Feast of the Dedication (Hanukkah, Festival of Lights) was instituted by Judas Machabeus in 164 BC.

We don’t know.

So what? The Jews have lots of non-Biblical traditions. Most of their observances (such as the two “biggies” - Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur) do not clearly originate from OT sources. Judas clearly did not draw from 1Macabees when he first instituted the observance in the first place (duh, 1Mac had not yet been written).

The Jews weren’t Sola Scriptura people either.

If Jesus was celebrating Hanukkah, he wasn’t doing so because it is mentioned in 1Mac.

I don’t think this gives you anything of apologetical value.
I was once a Baptist, so I can tell you this would at least make me consider some things.

It seems the Jewish faith didn’t require strict adherence to scripture alone. That has some apologetical value.

I also think it bolsters the canonicity of the Deuterocanonical Books. If I was intersted in what John’s gospel was refering to in this passage, It would lead right to 1 and 2 Macabees.

Plus the original KJV included these books. I never knew that as a Baptist.

Thanks!

Jed
 
It seems the Jewish faith didn’t require strict adherence to scripture alone. That has some apologetical value.
The problem is that it could backfire on you when dealing with a protestant.

Catholics see themselves as the fulfillment of the Old Law (“think not that I have come to destroy the Law - I come not to destroy, but fulfill”). The Jewish Church BECAME the Catholic Church (but many Jews did not accept the New Covenant and were left behind). Thus, Catholics see the Old Law as basically valid but incomplete.

Many protestants think that the Old Law was completely flawed (some even imagine that the Old Law was some sort of divine teaching lesson of what NOT to do). Pointing out that the Jews were not Sola Scriptura would be counterproductive when dealing with such people.

Pointing out theological similarities between Catholicism and Judaism is a risky apologetical approach - it could derail your entire discussion. Your correspondent might feel you have conceded evidence to support his position, and you might thus find yourself defending the whole idea that there are valid similarities in the first place - which is surely not the point you were trying to make by introducing this evidence.
 
The problem is that it could backfire on you when dealing with a protestant.

Catholics see themselves as the fulfillment of the Old Law (“think not that I have come to destroy the Law - I come not to destroy, but fulfill”). The Jewish Church BECAME the Catholic Church (but many Jews did not accept the New Covenant and were left behind). Thus, Catholics see the Old Law as basically valid but incomplete.

Many protestants think that the Old Law was completely flawed (some even imagine that the Old Law was some sort of divine teaching lesson of what NOT to do). Pointing out that the Jews were not Sola Scriptura would be counterproductive when dealing with such people.

Pointing out theological similarities between Catholicism and Judaism is a risky apologetical approach - it could derail your entire discussion. Your correspondent might feel you have conceded evidence to support his position, and you might thus find yourself defending the whole idea that there are valid similarities in the first place - which is surely not the point you were trying to make by introducing this evidence.
Not to mention that on the historical level, Judaism at the time of Jesus was so fluid and diverse (some authors even use the plural term ‘Judaisms’ for the various expressions of Jewish faith that existed then) that speaking about 1st century Judaism as if it is a homogeneous, singular entity is pretty much pointless most of the time.
 
The problem is that it could backfire on you when dealing with a protestant.

Catholics see themselves as the fulfillment of the Old Law (“think not that I have come to destroy the Law - I come not to destroy, but fulfill”). The Jewish Church BECAME the Catholic Church (but many Jews did not accept the New Covenant and were left behind). Thus, Catholics see the Old Law as basically valid but incomplete.

Many protestants think that the Old Law was completely flawed (some even imagine that the Old Law was some sort of divine teaching lesson of what NOT to do). Pointing out that the Jews were not Sola Scriptura would be counterproductive when dealing with such people.

Pointing out theological similarities between Catholicism and Judaism is a risky apologetical approach - it could derail your entire discussion. Your correspondent might feel you have conceded evidence to support his position, and you might thus find yourself defending the whole idea that there are valid similarities in the first place - which is surely not the point you were trying to make by introducing this evidence.
Your right. I can see your point on this.

Ironically, your statement about the Old Law being what not to do seems to be a good observation,
up to the point of having to “tithe” correctly or face God’s curse on your life. (taken from the book of Malachi) 🤷

Sorry, I remember that from my past as a Baptist.

Anyway, I asked the question about the verse in John to a Protestant question and answer website and got this response;

What is The Feast of Dedication that is mentioned in John 10:22?

The Feast of Dedication was a national Jewish holiday – but not one instituted by God. Just like Americans have Veteran’s Day, Independence Day, etc., the Jews had several holidays that they regularly observed that had nothing to do with Old Testament law. Judas Maccabee, a famous Jewish warrior (his nickname was Judas the Hammer), instituted the Feast of Dedication in 164 BC in commemoration of the day when they cleansed the temple after it had been defiled by Antiochus Epiphanes. The feast began on the 18th of December and lasted eight days.

To me, this only begs the question; Why would John, under inspiration of the Holy Spirit, point out this feast happening in Jerusalem if this is something not ordained by God? Did the miracle surrounding the feast (enough oil to keep the menorah in the Temple lit for a single day, yet it burned for eight days) actually occur? The Jewish people still celebrate this feast to this day. It seems to be more significant than just a commemoration of a past historical event.

Did Jesus celebrate Hanukkah ?!?!?

Anyway, thanks for all the help…

Jed
 
To me, this only begs the question; Why would John, under inspiration of the Holy Spirit, point out this feast happening in Jerusalem if this is something not ordained by God? Did the miracle surrounding the feast (enough oil to keep the menorah in the Temple lit for a single day, yet it burned for eight days) actually occur? The Jewish people still celebrate this feast to this day. It seems to be more significant than just a commemoration of a past historical event.

Did Jesus celebrate Hanukkah ?!?!?
Yes,

There is more in this passage than just the reference to the Feast of Dedication. (But while you’re at it, browse John’s Gospel and note how many times he tells us what the Jewish calendar was at the time of various episodes in Jesus’ ministry. Jesus was an observant Jew and it is not insignificant that He chose various feasts of the Old Covenant to introduce Truths of the New Covenant. . . .

v. 22 - “Solomon’s Porch” - this part of the Temple ground is mentioned often in the Gospels and the book of Acts; it was directly associated with the Coming of the Messiah. After the Dedication of the cleansed Temple described in Maccabees (when the oil miraculously lasted for 8 days) the stones of the desecrated altar, which could not be discarded because they’d been consecrated, and could not be used because they had been desecrated, were stacked in this area. The rabbis said, “When Messiah comes, he will tell us what to do with them.” When the Jews (and in John, “the Jews” always means “the leadership”) ask him in v. 24 “if thou be the Christ” this is significant! Jesus takes this opportunity to begin to introduce the Truth that the Messiah would not only be God’s Anointed but, in fact, God Incarnate “I and my father are one” (v. 30). Later Solomon’s Porch would be the place where the Apostles would gather the Church around them and proclaim the Gospel (Acts 5:12).

As *Dei Verbum *reminds us, we can miss a great deal because we do not know the cultural/religious context in which the Gospels were written.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top