The good side of NFP

  • Thread starter Thread starter divinefaith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

divinefaith

Guest
Is there any non religious reason drawing you to NFP? Toni Weschler, the author of Taking Charge of your Fertility talks about its positive side, but then again, she is promoting ‘Fertility Awareness’ which actually allows the use of barrier methods during the fertile days. So I can understand why this would seem easier. But this question I ask because I wonder whether NFP is difficult, which in contrast to Fertility Awareness allows no ABC at all.
 
Is there any non religious reason drawing you to NFP? Toni Weschler, the author of Taking Charge of your Fertility talks about its positive side, but then again, she is promoting ‘Fertility Awareness’ which actually allows the use of barrier methods during the fertile days. So I can understand why this would seem easier. But this question I ask because I wonder whether NFP is difficult, which in contrast to Fertility Awareness allows no ABC at all.
NFP is difficult and the other methods are not easier.
NFP is difficult when you cannot do it. Besides you cannot do it when the woman most desires it. It is not easy. But when you can do it, it is 10 times better.
Now, the pill takes out the desire from womena and, for men, condoms are like tAKING SHOWER with an umbrella.

In the end, who gets more pleasure? I would say with NFP.

There is better food than when you are hungry. When you are belly full, you do not appreciate so much…
 
Since starting NFP I’ve learnt so much about my health, and my emotions. It’s definitely a tool for women’s health outside of marriage! I think every girl should learn how to chart so they understand their body more.
 
Since starting NFP I’ve learnt so much about my health, and my emotions. It’s definitely a tool for women’s health outside of marriage! I think every girl should learn how to chart so they understand their body more.
I’m a guy so I can’t say for myself. But my wife relates to this…that it can be useful in charting and noting health as well as fertility.
 
NFP has been a wonderful tool to help me learn about my own body. I’d have to say that another plus is that I don’t have to put harmful chemicals into my body in order to regulate births. I’ve always been against birth control pills, even even before I knew about the moral problems with using them.
 
NFP has been a wonderful tool to help me learn about my own body. I’d have to say that another plus is that I don’t have to put harmful chemicals into my body in order to regulate births. I’ve always been against birth control pills, even even before I knew about the moral problems with using them.
This. 👍

ETA: I actually initially learned NFP using Taking Charge of Your Fertility, and have since lent it to multiple non-Catholic couples who are interested in NFP. So the appeal is definitely broader than Catholic teaching, though I would argue it’s the same reason using different terminology.
 
Toni Morrison’s book promotes both NFP and FAM. The problem with FAM is that there have been no studies on it. Every contraceptive that has been tested has been done without the woman being aware of when she is pregnant. As such, Toni makes a distinction between NFP and FAM by stressing to people that using barrier methods increase your chance of getting pregnant. Why? Because if your condom breaks, you need to recognize that the failure rate of the condom includes breakages that occured when the woman was infertile. She knows her audience probably is not going to have the moral resistance against using barriers while fertile so she is stressing that such a method is increasing your risk.

Anyway, I love knowing my cycle. I fully intend on teaching my daughter about her full cycle when she’s about to hit puberty. Unlike some Catholics, I don’t think this knowledge should be withheld untill just before you get married. Chastity is a virtue that needs to be instilled. I don’t want to use fear of pregnancy or anything else to try to bully my daughter to wait for marriage. Besides, how hard is it to convince a bunch of engaged women that growing up being told they had an equal chance of getting pregnant any day of the year was a lie? Then you see these larger NFP families and you think “must be failures.”

Anyway, I’m totally sold. If I lost my Catholic faith, I’d probably just become more open to other sexual activities during my fertile period. Only way you’d ever get me on the pill is for health reasons.

But then again I tend to favor natural remedies over anything else. NFP sort of opened my eyes and helped me to find out about things like home birth as well. And I loved my homebirth experience. I just don’t like taking drugs or things like that unless I’m forced to.
 
Is there any non religious reason drawing you to NFP? Toni Weschler, the author of Taking Charge of your Fertility talks about its positive side, but then again, she is promoting ‘Fertility Awareness’ which actually allows the use of barrier methods during the fertile days. So I can understand why this would seem easier. But this question I ask because I wonder whether NFP is difficult, which in contrast to Fertility Awareness allows no ABC at all.
I don’t think NFP is a difficult method, it does require more than other methods but I wouldn’t call it difficult. It was primarily non religious reasons which drew me in the first place.
We got married in the Catholic church and took classes before marriage so I was amazed to later learn it was a Catholic teaching and thought why didn’t we know about this before?
 
I don’t think you can possibly relate FAM with using with using NFP in Catholic marriage.

Essentially FAM is just using awareness of your cycle to determine when you need to use other methods of contraception. Whereas in a Catholic marriage (where sexual activity has to be - as they say - procreative & unitive) NFP is simply learning you cycle to determine when intercourse is less likely to result in conception.

So (I assume) a FAM couple can do what they like when they like and IF that includes intercourse they use their knowledge to avoid conception by using condoms. Whereas a Catholic couple (who want to delay / avoid) conception) has to be celibate accept when it is ‘safe’ for them to have intercourse.

Surely that is FUNDIMENTALLY differen.

I think knowledge of your cycle is a good thing for many reasons, but the two methods are completely unrelated morally - for most of us NFP is simply the only alternative to long term celibacy or continual pregnancy / child rearing.
 
Since starting NFP I’ve learnt so much about my health, and my emotions. It’s definitely a tool for women’s health outside of marriage! I think every girl should learn how to chart so they understand their body more.
100% agree! My husband and I were talking about this just last night. He was amazed even at how much even HE’S learned since NFP came in to our lives. All girls should be taught to chart, and its a real shame that this doesn’t happen. In school, they taught us about every fathomable kind of ABC and sex, but we weren’t taught anything useful about our cycles. :confused:
 
I don’t think NFP is a difficult method, it does require more than other methods but I wouldn’t call it difficult. It was primarily non religious reasons which drew me in the first place.
We got married in the Catholic church and took classes before marriage so I was amazed to later learn it was a Catholic teaching and thought why didn’t we know about this before?
I would have to agree. It does require more sacrifice, but it’s not necessarily difficult. It takes a bit longer to learn, but after that the method itself is quite easy. Practicing it might be difficult, (self-sacrifice isn’t an easy thing for most people to learn) but the method itself is pretty straightforward. I actually find it easier than most forms of ABC.
 
Since starting NFP I’ve learnt so much about my health, and my emotions. It’s definitely a tool for women’s health outside of marriage! I think every girl should learn how to chart so they understand their body more.
To add, many woman who chart tend to discover reproductive health problems (cancer and other conditions) way earlier than woman who do not. So they stand a better chance of addressing the issue while it is still manageable.

Also, NFP is organic and natural. I’m always confused by woman who go out of their way to eat healthy and organic only to pump their bodies with birth control pills.
 
I don’t think you can possibly relate FAM with using with using NFP in Catholic marriage.

Essentially FAM is just using awareness of your cycle to determine when you need to use other methods of contraception. Whereas in a Catholic marriage (where sexual activity has to be - as they say - procreative & unitive) NFP is simply learning you cycle to determine when intercourse is less likely to result in conception.

So (I assume) a FAM couple can do what they like when they like and IF that includes intercourse they use their knowledge to avoid conception by using condoms. Whereas a Catholic couple (who want to delay / avoid) conception) has to be celibate accept when it is ‘safe’ for them to have intercourse.

Surely that is FUNDIMENTALLY differen.

I think knowledge of your cycle is a good thing for many reasons, but the two methods are completely unrelated morally - for most of us NFP is simply the only alternative to long term celibacy or continual pregnancy / child rearing.
Ok I’m nitpicking but periods of abstainence in marriage is referred to as continence not celibacy. Celibacy is the vow never to marry.
 
I wonder how many married couples here are practicing continence.
 
NFP has been a wonderful tool to help me learn about my own body. I’d have to say that another plus is that I don’t have to put harmful chemicals into my body in order to regulate births.
Definitely agree with this 👍 I used ABC many years ago and it was not a pleasant experience. NFP allows such an intimate knowledge of your own body that it becomes empowering - for the woman and her partner.

I would gladly argue the case for NFP on moral/religious grounds AND those of obvious health benefits (both mentally and physically).

TCOYF has been a good reference for me, but there is a moral distinction between FAM and NFP.
 
We started learning the Sympto-Thermal Method when our youngest was 2 months old. We did not abstain completely during this time, though since I was breastfeeding things were a bit confusing (especially since we were just learning). Then, a few months before weaning, my signs were getting very confusing, and we did abstain completely for about 5 months because we had (still do) serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.

From the time we started learning to today it’s been almost 17 months and we have been successful in avoiding pregnancy. It hasn’t all been easy, but I think it’s been such a blessing. I know my body so much better, and it’s amazing to “see” it doing what it should be each month. It gives me such an appreciation for the power we have – with God of course – to create new life. It helps me appreciate the times with my husband that much more, since we do abstain for a lot of my cycle.
 
I posted an NFP testimonial on my blog a little while back.

I love NFP. I learned the good Catholic way, but I have to admit to using the TCOYF book more than my NFP book when I need something to refer to. Obviously, we don’t use any kind of barrier methods, but the rules for charting, etc are a little more straight-forward in there than the one we used for our class. I use the free software too, so it’s nice to know I’m using the correct terminology for that software and not missing anything. I think the FAM is a great way to teach non-Catholic couples about the method. I, honestly, would rather non-Catholics use condoms than the Pill. I think learning the method would open people up and might lead them to not use a condom in the future. Or realize they can relegate sexual intercourse to their non-fertile times and NOT have to use one at all!

Anyway, if you’re interested in my testimonial, you can read it here
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top