The Gospel of Joel Osteen

  • Thread starter Thread starter coco2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think some people judge Joel Osteen too harshly, or else not harshly enough. Let me explain…

He’s not a bad, heretical or apostate preacher of the Gospel. Rather he isn’t a preacher of the Gospel at all. What he is is an excellent motivational speaker who occasionally uses Scripture and Christian buzz words. His message is usually terrific advice that will help those who heed it; but it’s drawn from Norman Vincent Peale, Dale Carnegie, Napoleon Hill, et al, not from anything Christian.

If you listen to Osteen as a self-help guru, he’s very good. If you listen to him as a preacher, he’s just short of completely useless… but a preacher isn’t really what he’s trying to be.
You say he isn’t a preacher, yet he starts every one of his “sermons” holding the Bible and having people repeat something like this: This is my Bible: I am what it says I am; I have what it says I have; I can do what it says I can do. …

He is exploiting the Bible?
 
You say he isn’t a preacher, yet he starts every one of his “sermons” holding the Bible and having people repeat something like this: This is my Bible: I am what it says I am; I have what it says I have; I can do what it says I can do. …
He does begin that way, but we should accept everything in the scriptures. Not just the things that cause us to feel good and lead us to think that everything will always be “mountain top”. I’m all for being positive, but sometimes God may choose to lead us through valleys if that is what is ultimately best for us.

Joel should follow “I am what is says I am; I have what it says I have” with an “IF”. Then, preach the Gospel.

I’m not trying to sound harsh. I’ve enjoyed listening to Joel Osteen. It would just be nice if he would take advantage of having a captive audience and slip in a little more salvation speak.
 
It would just be nice if he would take advantage of having a captive audience and slip in a little more salvation speak.
If he did that he’d lose a lot of his audience. They’re* not there to learn anything substantial or historic, they’re just there to get a pat on the head and then go on their way with smiles on their faces. Someone upthread commented that his sermons sound the same and why not change things up. Osteen doesn’t need to, the audience just wants to be spoon-fed the same feel-good stuff over and over and over…

*Of course I’m not talking about each individual but of the audience as a whole.

From my POV as an outsider, Osteen is a con artist. The summary of his message is: if you have enough faith then God will reward you with material riches. Oh, you’ve been faithful for years and you’re still poor? That’s just God putting you through hardship to make you a better person (as opposed to being a victim of Joel’s flawed message). But if “you” (read: Joel) does get rich and others are critical the wealth being flaunted, weeeeellll, they don’t know what you or your family (read Joel and his family) has been through. Maybe a grandmother sat with her cancer-stricken husband and God decided to reward the family by making the grandchildren rich years later. A “generational blessing” is what Joel calls it. Anyone who criticizes you (read: Joel) for flaunting riches is jus jellus.

He doesn’t outright beg for money but he certainly encourages his audience to buy his books and buy tickets to his lectures. He lets his sister be the hit man and push the idea of tithing large amounts to Joel’s church.

He’s got a tidy little racket with everything sewn up on all sides with the money going one way - into his own bank account.
 
I’ve alway considered Joel Osteen to be a motivational speaker. It bothers me that you don’t hear anything about salvation until the last few seconds of his telecast.
you wont hear much about Christ either…

Everyone really needs to pay attention to this man, simply a motivational speaker, who throws God in at the tail end to call himself a preacher…
 
If you say that he is not trying to be a preacher, then why doesn’t he say right up front that he isn’t a preacher and his congregation isn’t church but a glorified self-help group. He is leading people straight to Hell because nowhere does he say he and they are sinners in need of repentance and point to Christ on the cross. He is all theology of glory.
You say he isn’t a preacher, yet he starts every one of his “sermons” holding the Bible and having people repeat something like this: This is my Bible: I am what it says I am; I have what it says I have; I can do what it says I can do. …

He is exploiting the Bible?
Yeah, it is kind of unfortunate, him leading a church and not being a preacher. But remember, the Joel Osteen we see on TV is only a portion of his Sunday service, and the gospel message may be in the part we don’t see. His church is huge, and employs many, many pastors, some of whom may actually be real preachers. I think his wife, Victoria, is a real preacher, though definitely WoF. His flock may be, and I sure hope they are, hearing some true gospel from them.
 
Yeah, it is kind of unfortunate, him leading a church and not being a preacher. But remember, the Joel Osteen we see on TV is only a portion of his Sunday service, and the gospel message may be in the part we don’t see. His church is huge, and employs many, many pastors, some of whom may actually be real preachers. I think his wife, Victoria, is a real preacher, though definitely WoF. His flock may be, and I sure hope they are, hearing some true gospel from them.
Another problem, women are not called to be preachers, pastors, or priests.
 
I’m getting concerned at the number of Catholics that I know who are regularly watching and spreading the message of Joel Osteen. Even the principal of our Catholic school was telling the teachers about how much she likes him and believes him. She has taped one of his sermons and is going to show us. It has something to do with suffering. She said and I quote " Who says we are supposed to suffer in life?" I wanted to scream out…"Jesus, the apostles, and every saint who has lived on this earth, that is who!!!

This is beginning to scare me and I think that priests FROM THE PULPIT need to refute this stuff. More and more Catholics are listening and weaving it into their faith.

Am I being too critical of this?

Perhaps this needs to be in a different thread, but I couldn’t figure out which one to put it in.
There is no other Gospel. There is only the good news preached by Jesus Christ recorded to us through the apostles.
 
Yeah, it is kind of unfortunate, him leading a church and not being a preacher. But remember, the Joel Osteen we see on TV is only a portion of his Sunday service, and the gospel message may be in the part we don’t see. His church is huge, and employs many, many pastors, some of whom may actually be real preachers. I think his wife, Victoria, is a real preacher, though definitely WoF. His flock may be, and I sure hope they are, hearing some true gospel from them.
If the gospel message about salvation was important to osteen, then I would assume that is what he would want broadcast. But no, he wants broadcast what brings in the dough.
 
If the gospel message about salvation was important to osteen, then I would assume that is what he would want broadcast. But no, he wants broadcast what brings in the dough.
Yeah, no doubt Osteen broadcasts what he considers most important. Still, it’s entirely possible, out of his huge church’s enormous resources, even though he doesn’t make it his priority, his sheep are getting fed. I’d like to hear from someone who goes there or has gone there.
 
I tried to read one of his books, I didn’t make it very far. Then I tried to watch one of his shows, same results. This is nothing new. Osteen preaches the “prosperity gospel”. If he claimed to be only a motivational speaker it might be ok. In “live your best life now” he refers to being called to preach and teach at the age of 35. It was all promises of good things and examples of success stories with little to no mention of what Christ did or said.
Osteen’s preaching negates everything Christ did regarding salvation. He resembles the Jews waiting on a Messiah to conquer the Romans with force. He is looking at things the way the world does, not through the eyes of faith.

IMHO, this is what happens when you interpret scripture without theology and history. Also, interpreting against the Church teaching leads to problems.

There is nothing wrong with calling the “prosperity gospel” heresy. Anyone who spreads this false gospel is, by definition, a heretic.
Just my opinion:shrug:
 
Your church and mine (AG) differ on that.
Hello-

Not to be rude. I think it is awesome that you want to learn Catholisim. My question is do you know that your church and the Catholic church have alot of diferences? Our view on Salvation is different, on free will, on pastors, the Body and Blood of Christ, traditions and a lot more. I am just curious on you reasons to be here. Thats all.

In Christ,
Jillian
 
No you’re not being too critical of Joel Olsteen’s prosperity doctrine. His doctrine cheapens the Christian faith by making it a means to material wealth rather than the saving grace for our sins. If you’re concerned about it taking root in your parish, I’d imagine you could ask your priest to talk about the 10th commandment in an upcoming homily. I’d imagine that those who are falling prey to Olsteen’s doctrine have either just forgotten what Jesus and the Church have commanded of them or were poorly catechized in the first place. In any place, a friendly reminder from the pulpit is not out of order.
I absolutely agree with this. No your not being critical. As a former Protestant I could not even stomach Joel Olsteen. He is NOT what even Protestantism is about. He teaches everything contrary to the Bible and is a lover of all things money. His sucess is out of pure greed and nothing more and I agree it cheapens the Christian faith a hundred times. He believes of material wealth and nothing more. He is a wolf in sheep’s clothing. He preaches of acculumating wealth but never will you hear him speak of using your money for the good of others, charity etc. He is a false prophet by every stretch of the means ( and this is the old Protestant in me speaking here).

I would discuss this with your priest immediately. There are many more reptuable pastors out there other than Joel Olsteen. Please do not fall prey to his brand and style of preaching. It is everything contrary to what Christ has ever taught, to Catholics and even to Protestants. I agree a friendly reminder of the 10th commandment is definitely in order here.

Your Catholic school can bring the Bible and some evanglisim in, but in a MUCH better way. I would find out who the Catholic ‘evengelists’ are and listen to them. I would recommend people like Michael Vorris, and Fr Corapi. Heck , you can even find You Tube vidoes of ArchBishop Fulton Sheen. These people are way more worthy of your time to listen too, and I’m not saying this because I’m Catholic now. Any Catholic school that brings Joel Olesteen into it has a VERY serious problem.
I did not like anything about him as a Protestant, nor do I like anything about him as a Catholic.

Any Catholic who believes that he isn’t that bad. Really needs to do some serious soul searching and pray. Because he does NOT represent Christ or God.
 
Also forgot to mention : Yes, he is a pastor. He is the senior pastor of the Lakewood Church in Huston Texas.
I actually have a friend that lives in Huston that goes to his church. I know this because she’s mentioned it. I don’t say a thing to her because I value our friendship. But yes, he IS a pastor. Which makes him a false prophet.
And the only person that benefits from his ministry is himself. I can tell you my friend isn’t any better off. Actually she mentions being broke quite a bit. I wonder if her money is going towards this ‘church’.
 
Also forgot to mention : Yes, he is a pastor. He is the senior pastor of the Lakewood Church in Huston Texas.
I actually have a friend that lives in Huston that goes to his church. I know this because she’s mentioned it. I don’t say a thing to her because I value our friendship. But yes, he IS a pastor. Which makes him a false prophet.
And the only person that benefits from his ministry is himself. I can tell you my friend isn’t any better off. Actually she mentions being broke quite a bit. I wonder if her money is going towards this ‘church’.
Yes your right. In an appearance on Piers Morgan Tonight in January, 2011, Osteen mentioned that he had never attended seminary. In an earlier interview on Fox News in 2008 during the U.S. Presidential primary race, when discussing whether he thought that a Mormon was a Christian, Osteen indicated that he believed that they were, but further noted that he had not studied the religion.

On the December 23, 2007, edition of Fox News Sunday, host Chris Wallace on Fox News Sunday brought up Osteen’s lack of Scripture reference in his sermons, as well as his hesitancy to discuss sin as an integral part of life. Osteen responded: “And I am ultimately trying to do that, but I’m trying to teach people how to live their everyday lives, and so I do focus on it, probably not as much as some people would like.”[17] Osteen says that he chooses to focus on the goodness of God rather than sin.[18] Osteen explains that he tries to teach Biblical principles in a simple way, emphasizing the power of love and a positive attitude.

So I guess it goes to show you anyone can be a pastor now a days.
 
TracyR;7844370) said:
If you value your friend’s soul you MUST try to reach her. Only you know how to approach it, but I would suggest asking her if she’s ever compared Osteen’s message to one of the four Gospels. Tell her Jesus warned about being led astray. Try to introduce some doubt on her part as to Osteen’s teaching. Be patient. St. Augustine’s mother once went to a priest when he was a Manichean, and the priest advised her against pushing as Augustine was still smitten with the cult’s teachings. Just keep trying to introduce doubt on your friend’s part. Maybe she’s already questioning. And when she’s ready lead her home to the Eternal City. That way she can be at peace too!
 
Hello-

Not to be rude. I think it is awesome that you want to learn Catholisim. My question is do you know that your church and the Catholic church have alot of diferences? Our view on Salvation is different, on free will, on pastors, the Body and Blood of Christ, traditions and a lot more. I am just curious on you reasons to be here. Thats all.

In Christ,
Jillian
I post on a variety of Christian forums, from Baptist Fundamentalist, to Catholic (this one), to Calvinist, to Emergent and liberal. I’m here, and on those others, both to learn what I don’t know, and to teach what I do know. I think all those different forms of Christianity have valuable lessons for us, and no one church or school of thought has a monopoly on truth.

I am pretty well aware of the Catholic positions on most things, and I have a CCC and several Catholic Bibles in my collection. Some of my favorite Christian writers are Catholic, including J.R.R. Tolkien, Peter Kreeft, G.K. Chesterton, Hans Küng, Garry Wills and a certain Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, whom you may have heard of. 😉

Though I am an Assemblies of God member, doctrinally I’m just as much Anglican and Lutheran as Pentecostal. And truth be told, if I were to convert from Protestantism, most likely I would go to Orthodoxy rather than Catholicism.
 
Yes, I know. I’m not seriously considering converting. That was just a hypothetical. But there is a lot of Orthodox doctrine that appeals to me… just not that particular bit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top