The Hunger Games

  • Thread starter Thread starter empther
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Haven’t seen the movie, but I did read a self-proclaimed feminist’s review who said Katniss is a feminist character, although she insisted it wasn’t because she shoots arrows and beats up boys. Does this movie have a feminist undertone of some kind? If you Google “katniss feminist” it auto-completes and there’s lots on it.
Whats wrong with being a feminist?
 
Haven’t seen the movie, but I did read a self-proclaimed feminist’s review who said Katniss is a feminist character, although she insisted it wasn’t because she shoots arrows and beats up boys. Does this movie have a feminist undertone of some kind?
The book is written in Katniss’s first person voice. Naturally, the whole story must be told from her viewpoint.

But in the book, at least, it is Peeta who saves her life, who uses the Alliance to help him find Katniss before she’s killed, and whose one sided love for her leads to both of them surviving. Doesn’t sound like a heroine Gloria Steinman would gush over.
 
The book is written in Katniss’s first person voice. Naturally, the whole story must be told from her viewpoint.

But in the book, at least, it is Peeta who saves her life, who uses the Alliance to help him find Katniss before she’s killed, and whose one sided love for her leads to both of them surviving. Doesn’t sound like a heroine Gloria Steinman would gush over.
Ok, I was just curious why so many feminists were praising the movie.
 
Ok, I was just curious why so many feminists were praising the movie.
They are also probably praising the movie because Katniss manages to define herself. She is independent, yet makes the choice to engage in positive (for the most part) relationships with others (e.g. her sister).
 
Ok, I was just curious why so many feminists were praising the movie.
Maybe it is because she ended up really being the head and provider of her family after her dad was killed? She is a strong character who is female. IF I were to compare her to the character in the other movie big with kids. Bella, I could see calling Katniss a feminist. She was more than just falling in love.(To be fair I haven’t seen a Twilight movie and only could get through a third of the first book)
 
Concerning female roles, I thought it was nice that Katniss wasn’t some kind of irritating karate chick whose dialogue consists of demeaning comments about men, flirty sallies, and machismo like “go ahead punk, make my day”. (which, oddly enough, I liked well enough from Clint.)

(I use the word “chick” as part of a phrase, not that I think women ought to be called “chicks”.)
 
Whats wrong with being a feminist?
Seconding this, as a feminist. 🙂

I’m going to see the movie tomorrow, but I have read all three books, and I think Katniss could be seen as “feminist” even though the books themselves are not explicitly feminist. Katniss and Peeta’s relationship, in particular, is the inverse of the traditional “men hunt, women cook” arrangement (Gale is a bit more traditional, in that respect).
 
Seconding this, as a feminist. 🙂

I’m going to see the movie tomorrow, but I have read all three books, and I think Katniss could be seen as “feminist” even though the books themselves are not explicitly feminist. Katniss and Peeta’s relationship, in particular, is the inverse of the traditional “men hunt, women cook” arrangement (Gale is a bit more traditional, in that respect).
That is a good point. I don’t at all see her as a radical “hate men” type of feminist but if we compare her to other movie heroines she is a strong (ends up being a leader not by choice) character who doesn’t wait for her prince to save her
 
Originally Posted by child_of_God85
forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons_khaki/viewpost.gif
Whats wrong with being a feminist?

Depends on how one means it. The man-hating kind is not good.


Interesting that I’ve never seen the word “masculinist” used to describe a woman-hating male.

UPDATE:
Hmm. Apparently the word did exist…

merriam-webster.com/dictionary/masculinist

but I’ve never seen it before and just “invented” it a few minutes ago.
 
Interesting that I’ve never seen the word “masculinist” used to describe a woman-hating male.

UPDATE:
Hmm. Apparently the word did exist…

merriam-webster.com/dictionary/masculinist

but I’ve never seen it before and just “invented” it a few minutes ago.
That’s because “misogynist” works perfectly well to describe a woman-hater. (The equivalent, presumably, would be misandrist, but I don’t think that word exists…yet.)
 
That’s because “misogynist” works perfectly well to describe a woman-hater.
That’s what I thought! Also, there’s really been no “masculine” rights movement so the name never stuck. Men have mysoginist, chauvinist, pig, etc…
 
Don’t jam all feministis in the same boat. A true feminist is a woman (or a man) who just wants equal rights to men. They don’t hate men, but they think it"s wrong that they aren"t treated equal. That is what I would consider myself to be, and am proud of it.
 
That’s what I thought! Also, there’s really been no “masculine” rights movement so the name never stuck. Men have mysoginist, chauvinist, pig, etc…
So what is the term for a women who seems to hate the fact that she is a woman and not a man?
 
So what is the term for a women who seems to hate the fact that she is a woman and not a man?
Someone who suffers from penis envy?

I honestly don’t know anyone who thinks like that, though. (Unless they have very low self-esteem.) I’ve thought about what it would be like to be a man (no painful cramps every month, for one thing, plus all the benefits men get from living in a patriarchal society) but I like who I am.

I do have an intersex friend who has expressed the wish that sie was “just born a man and be done with it” but hir’s is a special case.
 
Don’t jam all feministis in the same boat. A true feminist is a woman (or a man) who just wants equal rights to men. They don’t hate men, but they think it"s wrong that they aren"t treated equal. That is what I would consider myself to be, and am proud of it.
I hear you. Even Father Corapi in his heyday said he was a true feminist in the true sense of the term. I’m with you there. :o
 
But getting back to Hunger Games, a while back, there was a thread (here it is) in which numerous women lamented about movies where small female characters beat up otherwise athletic or large men in an implausible way. How does Hunger Games square with that? I don’t know how old the women in that thread were, if it was a generational thing or what. But I ask since one of the “feminist” sites I saw talked about that happening in Hunger Games.
 
But getting back to Hunger Games, a while back, there was a thread (here it is) in which numerous women lamented about movies where small female characters beat up otherwise athletic or large men in an implausible way. How does Hunger Games square with that? I don’t know how old the women in that thread were, if it was a generational thing or what. But I ask since one of the “feminist” sites I saw talked about that happening in Hunger Games.
That is not an issue in the Hunger Games. There is surprisingly little hand-to-hand combat in the book (i.e., Katniss does not engage in it). She is a huntress, and arrows can be deadly regardless of who shoots them. 😉
 
That is not an issue in the Hunger Games. There is surprisingly little hand-to-hand combat in the book (i.e., Katniss does not engage in it). She is a huntress, and arrows can be deadly regardless of who shoots them. 😉
Weird then, because the headline of the blog article I read says: “Why Katniss is a Feminist Character (And It’s Not Because She Wields a Bow and Beats Boys Up)” :o
 
Weird then, because the headline of the blog article I read says: “Why Katniss is a Feminist Character (And It’s Not Because She Wields a Bow and Beats Boys Up)” :o
At least in the first book, she does not “beat boys up.” She does, however, wield a bow.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top