The if you died today question

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholictiger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

catholictiger

Guest
i don’t know if you have heard it before but the question about if you died today would you go to heaven or Hell?

how do you as a catholic respond to this question

I think as catholics we really don’t know what we have in store for the after life, we have a general idea and we know how to live to make it to heaven and enternal life, but ulitmatly we really don’t know if we are ultimately destined for Heaven or Hell.

so if you where to answer this question how would you.
 
I’d go to Hell, have a myraid of Sins that have gone unrepentant and I’ve been feeling like God is a bad father figure at the very least…
 
i don’t know if you have heard it before but the question about if you died today would you go to heaven or Hell?

how do you as a catholic respond to this question

I think as catholics we really don’t know what we have in store for the after life, we have a general idea and we know how to live to make it to heaven and enternal life, but ulitmatly we really don’t know if we are ultimately destined for Heaven or Hell.

so if you where to answer this question how would you.
The way you respond is by saying that’s a question nobody knows.

The question is based on an emotional appeal, not a biblical one. The answer being sought is an absolute assurance of making it to Heaven, but that’s unbiblical. It’s based on the notion of Sola Fide which states as soon as you put your faith in Christ, you’re guaranteed Heaven.

Texts like Galatians 6:7-9 shows that only by living in obedience according to the guidance of the Holy Spirit will get you to Heaven, and that’s to be finally determined at the Judgment Seat of Christ (2 Cor 5:10; Rom 2:6-8, 14:9-12).

Note: you can turn this into an evangelization opportunity as well, since the last thing they’re expecting you to say is that the Bible doesn’t speak like that.
 
Hey, if St. Paul wasn’t absolutely sure of his final destination, how in the heck can I be?
 
Hey, if St. Paul wasn’t absolutely sure of his final destination, how in the heck can I be?
good answer

but where does this come from in scripture just wondering i don’t doubt you i just love to see it
 
I think St. Joan of Arc said it best:

Joan of Arc’s famous response to the trick question she was asked about whether she was in God’s grace:
“If I am not, may God put me there; and if I am, may God so keep me. I should be the saddest creature in the world if I knew I were not in His grace”

maidofheaven.com/joanofarc_quotes_autobiography.asp

God bless.
 
I ask myself that many days and i generally believe that I am not a good Catholic or a good person.I think most people think the same way.Ger:shrug:
 
i don’t know if you have heard it before but the question about if you died today would you go to heaven or Hell?

how do you as a catholic respond to this question

I think as catholics we really don’t know what we have in store for the after life, we have a general idea and we know how to live to make it to heaven and enternal life, but ulitmatly we really don’t know if we are ultimately destined for Heaven or Hell.

so if you where to answer this question how would you.
We really don’t know. But what comes with our faith is hope. We are hopeful that we have done enough to earn heaven.
 
Hey, if St. Paul wasn’t absolutely sure of his final destination, how in the heck can I be?
So then, what do we do with, for example,
And this is the testimony, that God gave us eternal life, and this life is in his Son. He who has the Son has life; he who has not the Son of God has not life. I write this to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life. (1John 5)
:confused:
 
St. Paul clearly indicates that we must persevere to the end and in 1 Cor 9, he says “26Therefore I run in such a way, as not without aim; I box in such a way, as not beating the air; 27but I discipline my body and make it my slave, so that, after I have preached to others, I myself will not be disqualified.”. So, it is clear that Paul realizes that there is a possibility of being disqualified even after accepting Jesus as Lord, repenting, and preaching the gospel. Over and over we are told to persevere and to be on guard against the enemy. So, we know we can slip into sin which is deadly (1John 5:17) in the future even if we are believers now.

However, I can’t emphasize enough how important it is to know whether or not you are in a state of grace right now. Respectfully, I disagree that we can’t know whether we would go to heaven or hell if we died today–at least right at this moment. We can know the state of our soul because God has written the law on our hearts and we know if we have violated it. Unless we have a poorly formed conscience (which is possible), we should darn well know if we are in mortal sin. If you think you are, repent now, and get to confession as soon as possible. I agree that we cannot predict the future state of our souls. Not that we doubt Jesus in any way, nor do we doubt that His Sacrifice can atone for every sin in our past, present or future. We can trust Him completely to do
everything He promised. What we can’t know is if, at some point in the future, we will reject His gift of salvation.

By the way, only those who are in a state of grace should receive the Eucharist. We should examine our conscience daily, but especially before receiving Jesus. But since the line to receive the Eucharist dwarfs the line to confession, I wonder if that examination of conscience is really happening.
 
good answer

but where does this come from in scripture just wondering i don’t doubt you i just love to see it
Heb. 9:12 - Christ’s sacrifice secured our redemption, but redemption is not the same thing as salvation. We participate in and hope for salvation. Our hope in salvation is a guarantee if we are faithful to Christ to the end. But if we lose hope and fail to persevere, we can lose our salvation. Thus, by our own choosing (not by God’s doing), salvation is not a certainty. While many Protestant churches believe in the theology of “once saved, always saved,” such a novel theory is not found in Scripture and has never been taught by the Church.

Rom. 5:2 - we rejoice in the “hope” (not the presumptuous certainty) of sharing the glory of God. If salvation is absolutely assured after accepting Jesus as Savior, why would Paul hope?

Rom. 5:5 - this “hope” does not disappoint us, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit. Our hope is assured if we persevere to the end.

Rom. 8:24 - this “hope” of salvation that Paul writes about is unnecessary if salvation is guaranteed. If salvation is assured, then why hope?

Rom. 12:12 - rejoice in your “hope” (not your certainty), be patient in tribulation, and be constant in prayer.

2 Cor. 3:12 - since we have a “hope” (not a certainty), we are very bold. We can be bold when we are in God’s grace and our persevering in obedient faith.

Gal. 5:5 - for through the Spirit by faith we wait for the “hope” (not the certainty) of righteousness.

Eph. 1:18 - that you may know what is the “hope” to which He has called you, what are the riches of His glorious inheritance.

Eph. 6:10-17 – Paul instructs the Ephesians to take the whole armor of God, the breastplate of righteousness, and the helmet of salvation, in order “to stand,” lest they fall. Paul does not give any assurance that the spiritual battle is already won.

Phil. 3:11 - Paul shares Christ’s sufferings so that “if possible” he may attain resurrection. Paul does not view his own resurrection as a certainty.

Phil. 1:20 - as it is my eager expectation and “hope” (not certainty) that I shall not be at all ashamed before Christ.

Col. 1:5 - Paul refers to the “hope” (not guarantee) that Christ laid up for us in heaven.

Col. 1:23 - provided that you continue in the faith, not shifting from the “hope” of the gospel which you heard.

Col. 1:27 - to them God chose to make known His mystery, which is Christ in you, the “hope” (not the certainty) of His glory.

1 Tim. 1:1 - Paul describes Christ Jesus as our “hope” (not our guarantee). We can reject Him and He will allow this.

1 Tim. 4:10 - Paul says we toil and strive because we have our “hope” (not our assurance) on the living God. This is not because God is unfaithful, but because we can be unfaithful. We toil and strive for our salvation.

1 Tim. 5:5 - she who is a real widow, and is left all alone, has set her “hope” (not her assurance) on God. Our hope is a guarantee only if we persevere to the end.

1 Tim. 5:15 – Paul writes that some have already strayed after satan, as God Himself tells us in 1 Tim. 4:1. They were on the right path, and then strayed off of it.

2 Tim. 2:10 - Paul endures for the elect so that they “may also obtain salvation.” This verse teaches us that even the "elect,” from the standpoint of human knowledge, have no guarantee of salvation.

Titus 1:2 - Paul says that he is in the “hope” (not the certainty) of eternal life. Paul knows that his hope is a guarantee if he perseveres, but his ability to choose sin over God makes his attainment of eternal life less than an absolute certainty until it is actually achieved.

Heb. 3:6 - we are Christ’s house if we hold fast our confidence and pride in our “hope” (not our certainty).

Heb. 6:11 - we desire each one of you to show the same earnestness in realizing the full assurance of “hope” (not certainty) until the end.

Heb. 11:1 - now faith is the assurance of things “hoped” for (not guaranteed), the conviction of things not seen (heaven).

Heb. 12:1 – let us run with perseverance the race that is set before us.
 
Respectfully, I disagree that we can’t know whether we would go to heaven or hell if we died today–at least right at this moment. We can know the state of our soul because God has written the law on our hearts and we know if we have violated it. Unless we have a poorly formed conscience (which is possible), we should darn well know if we are in mortal sin. If you think you are, repent now, and get to confession as soon as possible.
I agree to a point with what you say here. However, we are called to do more than go to confession in order to get to Heaven. Faith AND works are a factor in the equation as well.
 
good answer

but where does this come from in scripture just wondering i don’t doubt you i just love to see it
Philippians 3:10-14
I want to know Christ and the power of his resurrection and the fellowship of sharing in his sufferings, becoming like him in his death, 11and so, somehow, to attain to the resurrection from the dead.
12Not that I have already obtained all this, or have already been made perfect, but I press on to take hold of that for which Christ Jesus took hold of me. 13Brothers, I do not consider myself yet to have taken hold of it. But one thing I do: Forgetting what is behind and straining toward what is ahead, 14I press on toward the goal to win the prize for which God has called me heavenward in Christ Jesus.

I Corinthians 9:25-27
25Everyone who competes in the games goes into strict training. They do it to get a crown that will not last; but we do it to get a crown that will last forever. 26Therefore I do not run like a man running aimlessly; I do not fight like a man beating the air. 27No, I beat my body and make it my slave so that after I have preached to others, I myself will not be disqualified for the prize.

I hope that was helpful.
 
I agree to a point with what you say here. However, we are called to do more than go to confession in order to get to Heaven. Faith AND works are a factor in the equation as well.
I didn’t mean to imply that confession ensures salvation or is the only factor in salvation, merely that through the Sacrament, God restores us to a state of grace. Though we do not know our soul as thoroughly as God, I feel that a person should have a firm grasp on whether they are in state of grace or not.

To clarify my earlier post, if we feel we are not in a state of grace our first step should be repenting and going to confession. But once we are restored to a state of grace, by all means we must continue to persevere in faith and walk in His way.
 
My brothers and sisters. As Catholics all we NEED to say is YES…By the grace of God.

I find this works when taking to folks who are not Catholic. Yes, if needed you can put flesh on the bones of that statement. Yet sometimes we need to keep it simple.

So repeat after me.Yes by the grace of God.👍
 
i don’t know if you have heard it before but the question about if you died today would you go to heaven or Hell?

how do you as a catholic respond to this question

I think as catholics we really don’t know what we have in store for the after life, we have a general idea and we know how to live to make it to heaven and enternal life, but ulitmatly we really don’t know if we are ultimately destined for Heaven or Hell.

so if you where to answer this question how would you.
Objectively we can say with certainty that if a Catholic dies in a state of unrepented mortal sin then Hell is the destination, irrespective of whether up until that point such a person has lived a holy life doing good things, but if a Catholic dies in a state of grace then they are saved (either straight to Heaven or more like Purgatory first).

The state of your soul at death determines your destination.
 
We are hopeful that we have done enough to earn heaven.
Umm… Earn heaven? This is certainly no way to speak to a protestant.

Is in not more like “we are hopeful that we have accepted God’s grace enough (which would help us to do good works, love others, and be holy) and will continue to do so until I die,”?
 
Umm… Earn heaven? This is certainly no way to speak to a protestant.

Is in not more like “we are hopeful that we have accepted God’s grace enough (which would help us to do good works, love others, and be holy) and will continue to do so until I die,”?
Yeah, I’m sure he just misspoke. The correct theological term is “merit” - not that anyone can merit salvation by themselves, but by cooperating with God’s graces after receiving the free gift of salvation in Baptism. But of course, when talking to Protestants it’s best to just quote the Scriptures!

“anyone who does not take his cross and follow me is not worthy of me.” (Matthew 10:38)

“But those who are considered worthy of taking part in that age and in the resurrection from the dead…” (Luke 20:35)

“All this is evidence that God’s judgment is right, and as a result you will be counted worthy of the kingdom of God, for which you are suffering.” (2 Thessalonians 1:5)
 
The only thing that jeopardizes a baptized person’s soul is mortal sin. By definition, you can’t be in mortal sin and not know it. So I can say that if I die right now, I will go to heaven (probably by way of purgatory). I certainly could fall into mortal sin in the future, but I know I’m not there now.
 
i don’t know if you have heard it before but the question about if you died today would you go to heaven or Hell?

how do you as a catholic respond to this question

I think as catholics we really don’t know what we have in store for the after life, we have a general idea and we know how to live to make it to heaven and enternal life, but ulitmatly we really don’t know if we are ultimately destined for Heaven or Hell.

so if you where to answer this question how would you.
If you want a non catholic point of view on this, clarify that so those who are not can reply.
I find it odd you would ask this the way you did, in “apologetics”

As your CCD should be enough to answer this. You do realize that your faith does NOT claim that all those who are not catholic will be in Hell?

Or have you never asked your priest about this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top