Well I’m a fairly new catholic* but I believe I have an experience which I hope will help you.
I went to my first Tridentine Mass last January at the very beautiful San Buenaventura mission in California. I had been wanting to pray at one since I first found the faith. When I was just a seeker the traditionalist Fisheaters site, while imperfect, helped confirm for me the faith that a spiritual experience at a local parish had started.
I was expected a great spiritual experience over and above what I regularly experienced at my own parish. My expectations were too high in a number of ways through no fault of the mission or the mass.
Given all I had read about the Latin mass and my knowledge on the structure and theology of the Mass of Paul VI I expected I would be able to follow the mass even though I knew no Latin. I went with a lapsed Catholic who only agreed to go because she was curious about the Latin mass (hopefully this same curiosity leads more people to your masses that might otherwise not go!). She speaks Italian, Spanish, and French. We figured with my research on the mass and her command of romance languages we would be able to follow what was going on.
We couldn’t really. Even with the provided missalette we both quickly became very lost. I couldn’t see the altar and didn’t “feel” the mass. My mind kept wandering. Needless to say, it didn’t rekindle my friend’s faith like I had hoped it would.
However, that’s a lot to ask from one mass. I left disappointed but want to try again (if anyone knows of a Tridentine Mass offered by a priest in communion with Rome in the Miami area please let me know.)
My advice is to manage the expectations game. Nobody is probably going to “get it” in one mass. I would focus on making sure the basics were understood first and getting people to commit to at least a few masses.
Some strong encouragement to those frustrated that they couldn’t understand it at first will
really help!
Who will be singing the responses at your masses? At the one I went to a choir (which musically did a great job) did that part. I think having the responses done by the people will produce a mass that’s easier for someone used to the new mass to follow in the long run, even if pronunciation or comprehension are lacking at first. Of course if a deacon or a choir sings the responses it will produce a smoother mass. If the people are not expected to do the responses explain how this is being “done for them” (at least audibly).
Thank you for doing this. I’ve just said a prayer asking the Lord to guide and bless your efforts.
- I’ve believed since December 2010 but won’t be baptized until the Easter vigil this Saturday. I know on some level that makes me not fully part of the church yet but I wasn’t sure what would be more appropriate to put there. I do have plenty of masses and catechesis under my belt I certainly. Won’t matter come Easter; God willing I’ll be baptized, confirmed, and in full communion.