"The Lord of the Rings", A Fantasy, and my Faith: Is it Healthy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mr_Friscus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mr_Friscus

Guest
There are many things one can enjoy about the Lord of the Rings Trilogy. I, myself, just finished watching the third installment, “The Return of the King”, earlier this evening once again. I find myself watching some of these series of movies at least once throughout any given year.

One thing I noticed in the past is that certain parts drummed up special, intense emotions inside of me. While there are stereotypical reasons for intense emotions at these specific parts of the movie, assigning these emotions to the true reason for their effect has escaped me, until now.

What parts? Let’s talk battle scenes. In “LOTR: Return of the King”, the forces of Mordor march on the city of Manisterith, of which the armies of men defend. They’re losing the battle, retreating inward within the city. Then, out of the blue, the assembled forces of Rohan arrive at the battlefield, and after a stoic entrance heroically charge into battle.

At first guess, one might surmise that I’m excited simply because of the violence and high-action content. However, I’ve never been one to be hypnotized by violence just for its own sake, although it’s a necessary element at times in telling a story.

So, what else is going on here that could possibly incite this emotion in me? How about the reasons for the army of Rohan’s arrival? A previously conflicted King Theodin, theoretically unwilling and wavering to assist Manisterith, much because the Steward of the city did not use his forces to assist Theodin when Rohan was in need, during the defense of Helm’s Deep. Eventually, Theodin, with heavy persuasion from Aragorn, overcomes this conflict, and answers the call for aid even though he received none in return, performing a true act of support, charity, and brotherhood! That certainly has something to do with a spike in emotion when the Riders of Rohan arrive at the battlefield, but isn’t the true cause either. That just wasn’t it.

Then, I p(name removed by moderator)ointed it. I connected a theoretical fantasy of mine to why I was so charged as the riders of Rohan sprinted into the legions of Mordor, taking it to them with the most brutal of justified force.

As I watched the entire LOTR series, it came to me how there is a certain luxury here for these men of Rohan, and all men in the trilogy; true evil is represented here in the flesh. Saron, and his armies of Mordor, are not men, and not made in God’s image. They needn’t receive any compassion or worth, and encompass only the concept of evil. In real life, even in times of war, the opponent is a human being, even if sworn to kill and defeat you. This conflict can truly question whether the right action is being made. It questions the absolute certainty of convictions to slay any human enemy or army.

Then, It hit me that evil in my own personal life is not in the flesh, or objectified whatsoever. I cannot lash out physically at evil, even if I may hate it. This yearning to pummel a physical representation of evil with every ounce of my strength is what truly spiked my emotion levels to the highs I speak of.

I wish it were that straightforward and simple in my life. However, it isn’t. I can swing my fist at “evil” as much as I want, and two outcomes can occur: I take an odd whiff at nothingness or injure my fist.

I sometimes imagine a scenario where one of the biggest forms of evil in my life, depression, were suddenly offered to me as a physical object. One object that came to mind, oddly enough, was a television set. Not only were “depression”, “lust”, “Lack of Trust in God” and “sexual impurity” encased within this mystical TV, but also written brashly on its exterior.

I approach this TV with a baseball bat, slowly, heavily breathing as I stand in front of the things that have caused me so much pain and guilt throughout my life. I see it, laying there, entirely helpless and vulnerable. One might think the urge to act instantly would win out, but this objectified nutshell of sin doesn’t get off that easy. No sir.

My face fumes, my eyes water, my nostrils flare with aggression, my breathing heavy and even restricted due to my rage as I circle this object, stalk it, and twirl the bat in my hand as I pace.

“So here you are, right in front of me” I say, and go on a tangent of charges against this cauldron of evil, Listing them one by one, and how they’ve effected my life. I lose my composure and maniacally scream at this evil*** “I HATE YOU! I… HATE YOU!” *** The screaming is a big release of exertion, and I silently gather myself, for a calm few seconds, a calm before the storm.

*“Now that I’ve said my peace, It’s time to make you pay for what you’ve done” *I decry. My hands tighten their grip on the bat. My entire life begins to flash before my eyes, and although it takes a long time, within 2 seconds I’ve charged, coordinated my approach in sync with my backswing, and delivered my first punishing blow to these vices that now are at my mercy. I scream again, “I HATE YOU!”, and deliver another blow, and another. Glass is shattered, plastic is split, Sin is being pummeled.

… continued on next post…
 
I see the wires of sin exposed from the TV. I pick the TV up by the wires and sinch my teeth, penetrating the outer rubber shell, gnarling at the inner cords until they are split in half. My grunts of savagery and rage grow as adrenaline is flowing through my body.
I slam it to the ground and stomp it repeatedly over and over.

I drop the ground just over it, and ask how “it” likes the tides being turned. * “You’ve destroyed me, and caused me so much pain, now it’s my turn to punish you”*. I pick up the bat again, and proceed to pound the fleeting pieces of it inches into the ground, over , and over, and over again until I’m unable to expend another ounce of energy. I drop to the ground on my hands and knees, catching my breath, and peering up to see this synthesization of sin completely torn apart. My sin, defeated, at my hands.

Back to “The Lord of the Rings”, after that admittedly savage description in chilling detail. As the riders of Rohan charged into the army of Mordor at the battle of Manisterith, I realized that I’ve had that fantasy myself. The opportunity to attack true evil physically, in the flesh or as an object.

Sadly, as addressed before, fighting one’s sin, and evil itself, doesn’t work that way in my world, or in anyone’s to such a degree. It would be so simple if it was possible, but the tangling of sin within the sinful human mind is the true battle field of this equation. No muscle or adrenalines are assets. No one goal or aspect to focus on. A smorgasbord of complexity and frustration, provided by our sinful human nature, mixed with the will and desire to be good.

Even though facing certain death, I found myself envying these Riders of Rohan, even if it’s easy to say while sitting on my coach, in no real danger, and a remote in my hand. I wish I could have it out with evil, my evil, face to face one day, but that day will never come. However, it’s nice to at least lose myself in this movie enough to get the slightest taste of what It would be like. And who knows, maybe one day I’ll be strong enough to truly bash my sins into pulp mentally, and not physically. I’m admittedly not there yet, but where there’s a will, there’s a way, so they say. The thought of charging into Satan’s “army” of sin designated to attack my soul, downhill, upon horse, with the sun gleaming at my back and my own army charging with me makes me chuckle, because it’s something I can metaphorically achieve.

I can take it to him…

Can’t I?
 
Literature, perhaps especially fantasy, can be a good way to inspire a person to confront their own struggles, but it can also be a form of escapism in its radical sense, where the world of the fantasy carries more meaning to the person than the material universe around them, with all its real evils, and all its real glories, and all its real devils, angels, saints, and dragons. A person can spend years absorbing themselves in a fantasy of quests and adventure without realizing they’re actually living in one. They dream of courage, but never acquire it themselves.

I think your fascination with LotR has perhaps become unhealthy. I also think it’s interesting that your favorite scene is a lopsided one, where the Riders are basically massacring a bunch of terrified & fleeing orcs. If sin were such a feeble thing, mankind wouldn’t need prayer.
 
Have you read the Lord of the Rings? I highly recommend it. Yes, a lot of the story is imbued with spiritual metaphors. God bless you. We all have our battles; but rejoice, because Christ has won the war.
 
Wow, Mr.Friscus,
Unless you’ve got a book coming out soon, your talents are being wasted.

As far as your comments, yes it would be great to be able to fight the forces of evil in the flesh, but as you say it’s not often possible. (Well, we have Planned Parenthood, but we’re not fighting the people who work there, but against principalities, against the rulers of the darkness of this world). But prayer can be battle.

As for being healthy, Mr. Tolkien wrote those books inspired by God, I am convinced, and they have nudged many people toward the faith. They are great adventures written in the Catholic spirit.

.
 
lol man I love it when you get creative. You really had that down. Well done sir! Well done!

I so much wish it were like that too. I so much wish I could drive it from me and beat it out of existence. I mean imagine if it was like a shadow. It’s always stalking you. It’s always close by. And then you suddenly spring into action. You take it by surprise. You give it what-for with your bat. And bang, it’s on the ground and you are beating it to a pulp.

Hey! This is pretty catchy! This might be a fun thread. Everyone come and fight evil in this thread!

Peace, and good fighting!

-Trident
 
Have you read the Lord of the Rings? I highly recommend it. Yes, a lot of the story is imbued with spiritual metaphors. God bless you. We all have our battles; but rejoice, because Christ has won the war.
Yes, read the book. The films did a great job capturing the “look” IMO (partly thanks to Tolkien’s thorough descriptive prose) but the narrative itself is really where the story shines, and features some prominent Christian and specifically Catholic themes that are mostly glossed over in the films.
 
There is no substitute for reading the LOTH itself, along with the Hobbit. His book The Silmarillion is great also. The best explanation, from a Christian view, is a book by Peter Kreeft, The Philosophy of Tolkein.

I recorded the movies yesterday, will watch them again!
 
Yes, read the book. The films did a great job capturing the “look” IMO (partly thanks to Tolkien’s thorough descriptive prose) but the narrative itself is really where the story shines, and features some prominent Christian and specifically Catholic themes that are mostly glossed over in the films.
Exactly. Tolkien himself, being Catholic, was asked about this, and he stated (paraphrase) that the Catholic themes were unconcious in the first draft of the story, but very much conscious during the editing process. And it’s quite in depth how the themes come into play - including Jesus carrying the cross (Frodo carrying the ring), needing help from Simon of Cyrene (Samwise Gamgee), going through the depths of Hell (Mordor), the disciples scattering (the fellowship being broken) etc., etc., etc.
 
Peter Kreeft’s book draws heavily from Tolkein’s letters to shed further light on his intentions. The supernatural element is just below the surface in the LOTR, but explicit in the Silmarillion. I don’t share the opinion of the purists that the films ruined the book, but I do agree there is far more in the books than in the films. Interestingly, Kreeft concludes the movie makers do pretty well in depicting the various kinds of evil, but not so well depicting the good. Maybe that is a sad commentary on our times, that we lack the template for “Good” so we use feeble templates.

Anyway, I enjoy the films! My hope is that people who enjoy the films will be led to the books.
 
There’s a murky line when it comes to using literature for escapism, where we do it in order to draw strength & inspiration, but then we also start doing it purely as a total retreat from reality and start caring more about the fantasy than the world around us.

You have to pray & discern which side of the line you fall on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top