The Mass and Protestant Services very different

  • Thread starter Thread starter Heath_K
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This statement is not true.As great as taking part in communion is it is not heaven on earth.It is something we do in rememberance of Him but Jesus Himself said that His kingdom is not of this world.It is in many other places in the Bible as well.I can understand your joy and jubilance to partake in the Holy communion but the phrase "heaven on earth "is untrue.It’s a contradiction in terms.God bless.
This is where you miss the point of the Eucharist - and this is why Catholic services are soooo much more different than protestant ones. Christ IS PRESENT in the Eucharist - Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity!

Heaven and Earth DO touch in the Mass!👍
 
I’m still sort of new to the Catholic Faith. But as I learn more about it, i find that the Mass differs greatly from protestant services in more than just liturgy/no liturgy, communion/no communion, and just stuff like that. But the main thing I find that differs between the two is that Catholics go to Mass to worship God and to only Worship God, of course there is a homily or sermon, but the Eucharist is the main reason for the Mass, to offer Jesus back to God, because it is the only thing that pleases Him because Jesus was the perfect sacrifice. But Protestants go to church to worship in a much more different way. Most of them go to feel good, to get ‘recharged’ in their faith, to get something out of the sermon, to hear the good music, to socialize and so on… So what i get is that Catholics to go church to give to God, and protestants to go church to get from God. Am I the only one that thinks this? Am I totally wrong? Please lend me your thoughts on this 🙂 Thank you!
The mere act of showing up for Sunday services is giving to God. I feel like I am giving to God with my brothers and sisters and we are there to help each other get as close to God as we can. That’s the great thing about fellowship and why I will probably NEVER leave my church. I love my church family!!! 😃
 
That may be so ,but we have Sunday School and Wednesday night Bible studies so on the whole we protestants at least Baptist hear and read a lot more Scripture in church than Catholics do.
Also we Baptist go to Church to praise and to worship God and our Lord Jesus Christ. We praise God with hynms and songs. We worship God with prayer and scripture reading and study. We also worship God by serving him where we are needed in the Church. We give back to God a portion of what he has given us and we give back to Him our whole life 100% so that He may use us in what ever way will glorfy Him. We are not about ourselfs but glorfying God. Lastly our worship is sincere and from our heart.

Proud to Be Baptist
allischalmers
Your church sounds like ours, only we don’t have weeknight Bible studies. 😦 That is something I’m pushing for, though, because it would help so many people get a better understanding of God’s Word. 😃
 
This is where you miss the point of the Eucharist - and this is why Catholic services are soooo much more different than protestant ones. Christ IS PRESENT in the Eucharist - Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity!

we do believe that Christ is present in communion as you do but we also he believe He is present in prayer,worship and fellowship with Him.This does not mean heaven is on earth though.Heaven is a totally seperate place not of this world.
 
Your church sounds like ours, only we don’t have weeknight Bible studies. 😦 That is something I’m pushing for, though, because it would help so many people get a better understanding of God’s Word. 😃
Adding more bible studies to church’s activities is really great. Unfortunately, not many people are really interested in. At my church, we have an adult bible study group though any young people can join, there are about 30 people joining at this point - out of 14,000 registered members. :eek:
 
Adding more bible studies to church’s activities is really great. Unfortunately, not many people are really interested in. At my church, we have an adult bible study group though any young people can join, there are about 30 people joining at this point - out of 14,000 registered members. :eek:
Oh at this point I’d be happy with 30 interested people. Right now, 10 have told me they’d commit to it, out of 300 members. 😦
Prayers for the start of a successful Bible study are welcomed. :o
 
The Mass is Heaven on earth… literally!! We are at the Lambs Supper and we are happy to be called to the Lambs Supper!
This statement is not true. As great as taking part in communion is it is not heaven on earth.It is something we do in rememberance of Him but Jesus Himself said that His kingdom is not of this world.It is in many other places in the Bible as well.I can understand your joy and jubilance to partake in the Holy communion but the phrase "heaven on earth "is untrue.It’s a contradiction in terms.God bless.
You obviously have no idea what the Catholic Mass is.

Have you ever been to a Catholic Mass before? If you have then you weren’t paying much attention.

Scott Hahn a Presbyterian Minister studied the book of Revelations for upteen years (can’t remember how long he said) and then he attended a Mass one day, sat in the back of the Church and totally recognized the book of Revelations in the Holy Mass. He recognized God up on the altar. He even said to himself, “my Lord and my God” when the Priest held up Jesus (the host after consecration). Btw, Scott Hahn is now a Catholic Theologian.

Scott Hahn explains part of his life as a Protestant Pastor in Virginia;
Here they were asking me to preach at least 45 minutes.
I said, “If you insist, you know, twist my arm. Sure.” And
they said, “We want you to immerse us in the Word of
God,” and so I began.
The first thing I did was to tell them about covenant. The
second thing I did was to correct their misunderstanding
of covenant as contract to show them that covenant means
family. The third thing I did was to show them that the
family of God makes more sense of who we are and what
Christ has done than anything in the Bible. God is Father,
God is Son, and God through the Holy Spirit has made us
one family with Him. And as soon as I began to preach this
and teach this, it just took off like wildfire. It spread through
the parish; you could see it affecting marriages and families.
It was exciting. The fourth thing I did, was to teach them
about liturgy and covenant and family, that in Scripture the
covenant is celebrated through liturgical worship whereby
God’s family gathers for a meal to celebrate the sacrifice of
Christ. I suggested in my preaching and teaching that
maybe we ought to have the family meal, communion. I
even used the word “Eucharist.” They never heard it before.
I said, “Maybe we ought to celebrate being God’s covenant-
family by communion each week.” “What?” I said, “Instead
of being sermon-centered, why not have the sermon be a
prelude and a preparation to enter into celebrating who we
are as God’s family?” They loved it.

This is his first Mass experience;
The second thing that happened was when I quietly slipped
into the basement chapel down at Marquette, Gesu. They
were having a noon Mass and I had never gone to Mass
before. I slipped in. I sat down in the back pew. I didn’t kneel.
I didn’t genuflect, I wouldn’t stand. I was an observer; I was
there to watch. But I was surprised when 40, 50, 60, 80, or
100 ordinary folk just walked in off the street for midday
Mass, ordinary folk who just came in, genuflected, knelt and
prayed. Then a bell rang and they all stood up and Mass
began. I had never seen it before.
The Liturgy of the Word was so rich, not only the Scripture
readings. They read more Scripture, I thought, in a weekday
Mass than we read in a Sunday service. But their prayers
were soaked with Biblical language and phrases from Isaiah
and Ezekiel. I sat there saying, "Man, stop the show, let me
explain your prayers. That’s Zechariah; that’s Ezekiel. Wow!
It’s like the Bible coming to life and dancing out on the center
stage and saying, “This is where I belong.”
Then the Liturgy of the Eucharist began. I watched and
listened as the priest pronounced the words of consecration
and elevated the host. And I confess, the last drop of doubt
drained away at that moment. I looked and said, “My Lord
and my God.” As the people began going forward to receive
communion, I literally began to drool, “Lord, I want you. I
want communion more fully with you. You’ve come into my
heart. You’re my personal Savior and Lord, but now I think
You want to come onto my tongue and into my stomach,
and into my body as well as my soul until this communion
is complete.”
And as soon as it began, it was over. People stuck around for
a minute or two for thanksgiving and then left. And eventually,
I just walked out and wondered, what have I done? But the
next day I was back, and the next, and the next. I couldn’t tell
a soul. I couldn’t tell my wife. But in two or three weeks I was
hooked. I was head over heels in love with Christ and His Real
Presence in the Blessed Sacrament. It became the source
and the summit and the climax of each day, and I still couldn’t
tell anybody.

more…
 
Here are a few sites that explain the Mass;
Revelation and the Holy Mass

The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass - Church Fathers

Since the Eucharist is the source, center and summit of the
Mass here is a webpage with Q & A about the Eucharist;
Questions and Answers on the Eucharist

Mass: Heaven on Earth
Dr. Hahn´s first presentation centered on the typology
of the Bible and how the Mass is Heaven on Earth.

Mass is revealed in the Apocalypse. In the Book of Revelation
Jesus is called the Lamb of God 28 times in 22 chapters. Dr.
Hahn enlightened us to the fact that the only thing in
Revelation on every page is the Liturgy. White robes, songs,
prayers. Every page of every chapter the Heavenly Liturgy
corresponds to the Earthly Mass. The Rite of Communion is
the Marriage feast of the Lamb. I have studied Revelation
before, but never seen it in this way until now.

He asked how many of us had read Revelation and maybe a
couple handfuls of people raised their arms. Dr. Hahn said
that in a Protestant church that number of hands would not be
raised! He told us the word Rapture does not appear at all in
Revelation. He explained that while our Protestant brothers
and sisters have the menu, we have the meal. They´re
studying the recipe while we have the main course. He further
said that the Book of Revelation is the main recipe for the
Lamb of God - for Mass and for the Eucharist. Same songs,
same sacrifice, same prayers as in Heaven.

Heavenly Liturgy and Earthly Mass are one in the same.
Liturgy in Heaven, however, is far more glorious than can be
described. But, he told us; we can go to Heaven here on
Earth. That is where we are in Mass.

Here is Scott’s own website, Salvation History, St. Paul Center for Biblical Theology. Scott has free online lessons you can take. Here is lesson number five in the course called, The Lamb’s Supper: The Bible and the Mass;
Heaven On Earth: The Liturgy of the Eucharist
 
Hi,
I would venture to say it is both.👍 My church is in the middle of no one being able to walk to it. So if the weather is bad and even the minister lives 20 min. away then church cannot go on. Im sure God is fine with this. It certainly would not be worth the lives of anyone.
It all depends on where priest or minister lives. There are some Catholic churches that don’t have a priest living there either, so bad weather possibly could keep him from getting there. And some Protestant churches have parsonage for the minister like a recctory for a priest. So Protestant churches with a parsonage on site could still have a service.
 
Adding more bible studies to church’s activities is really great. Unfortunately, not many people are really interested in. At my church, we have an adult bible study group though any young people can join, there are about 30 people joining at this point - out of 14,000 registered members. :eek:
I wouldn’t worry about it. Quality is better than quantity. Besides you may get more people once word of mouth gets around. Then you eventually will need to start more than one study due to too many people for one study in the room.
 
So what i get is that Catholics to go church to give to God, and protestants to go church to get from God.
Luke 10
Mary and Martha Worship and Serve
38 Now it happened as they went that He entered a certain village; and a certain woman named Martha welcomed Him into her house. 39 And she had a sister called Mary, who also sat at Jesus’ feet and heard His word. 40 But Martha was distracted with much serving, and she approached Him and said, “Lord, do You not care that my sister has left me to serve alone? Therefore tell her to help me.”
41 And Jesus answered and said to her, “Martha, Martha, you are worried and troubled about many things. 42 But one thing is needed, and Mary has chosen that good part, which will not be taken away from her.”
 
Catholic during the Mass give themselves up to God. Before receiving the Blessed Sacrament, we say, “Lord, I am not worthy to received you, but only say the word and I shall be healed. Amen.”
I love the liturgy of the Mass. In the Anglican church they say, “Lord I am not worthy that thou shouldst come under my roof, but speak the word only and my sould shall be healed.”
 
This is so true!
I put myself on that paten when the Priest (in Persona Christi) says, “through Him, with Him, in Him, in the Unity of the Holy Spirit, All Glory and Honor is Yours Almighty Father, forever and ever!” And then we say our “great amen” … “AMEN!” I gaze upon my Lord Jesus up there on the Altar and put myself right there with Him to give my life over to God!
again … love it! I feel such a peace reading that.
 
I’m still sort of new to the Catholic Faith. But as I learn more about it, i find that the Mass differs greatly from protestant services in more than just liturgy/no liturgy, communion/no communion, and just stuff like that. But the main thing I find that differs between the two is that Catholics go to Mass to worship God and to only Worship God, of course there is a homily or sermon, but the Eucharist is the main reason for the Mass, to offer Jesus back to God, because it is the only thing that pleases Him because Jesus was the perfect sacrifice. But Protestants go to church to worship in a much more different way. Most of them go to feel good, to get ‘recharged’ in their faith, to get something out of the sermon, to hear the good music, to socialize and so on… So what i get is that Catholics to go church to give to God, and protestants to go church to get from God. Am I the only one that thinks this? Am I totally wrong? Please lend me your thoughts on this 🙂 Thank you!
I was talking to my hubby about this last night. We both love the Catholic and Anglican services. And what I say (from our experience) is that some Protestant churches give you the milk. They are good for the new believer. The Catholic/Anglican churches will give you the meat a potatos of faith. They dig into the scriptures and tell you how it is whether you like it or not.
 
I was talking to my hubby about this last night. We both love the Catholic and Anglican services. And what I say (from our experience) is that some Protestant churches give you the milk. They are good for the new believer. The Catholic/Anglican churches will give you the meat a potatos of faith. They dig into the scriptures and tell you how it is whether you like it or not.
Hi,

I agree that some protestant churches only give milk, but I have to say my non-denom is the exception. They give me more meat and potatoes that I can handle right now. My minister tells it like it is and some people have walked out because they cant handle the truth.😦
 
Yes, this is true (that is why I made sure to say that some 😉 give the milk). I grew up in the church (Mennonite with traditional services meaning hymns, sermon, prayer nothing fancy) hubby went to various Baptist churches (became a christian around 96). When we married we went to a non-denom church. I thought I was at a Christian band concert with a motivational speaker. It did not at all suit us. We then started to attend an Anglican church. I tell you what, I have never felt so humbled before. The church was beautiful and seeing the altar made me want to run up there and sit in the presence of God all day. I am not a Catholic, but my heart is yearning for the communion with the rest of the Holy Catholic Church.
 
I love the liturgy of the Mass. In the Anglican church they say, “Lord I am not worthy that thou shouldst come under my roof, but speak the word only and my sould shall be healed.”
That is what I say in Latin in the Tridentine Mass. I’ve heard that they are going to bring back some of the old liturgical language and this might be one of them. Good thing they still say it in the Tridentine Mass.
Here is a webpage that has the order of the Tridentine Mass in case you’re curious. 😉

Here is the Latin for the prayer from Mt 8:8;
Domine, nom sum dignus et intres
sub tectum meum; sed tantum dic
verbo, et anabitur anima mea.
 
I agree that some protestant churches only give milk, but I have to say my non-denom is the exception. They give me more meat and potatoes that I can handle right now. My minister tells it like it is and some people have walked out because they cant handle the truth. 😦
I’m curious, my sister belongs to a non-denom church. I know it’s possible that not all non-denoms are the same but I would like to know… does your church have communion every week? if not, then how often does your church have it. I guess I should ask my sister but she doesn’t like to talk about her church and what she does there. So I’m curious. :confused:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top