The New Population Bomb

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The West’s destabilization of the Mideast or the so-called, “Arab Spring” helped speed the whole situation along too.
Hosni Mubarak was sentenced to three years for embezzlement of public funds. He was sentenced by an Egyptian court. Do you have reason to believe that Mubarak wasn’t actually guilty? Alternatively, do you believe that Mubarak should have been able to commit crimes with impunity because of his status?

Egypt: The trial of Hosni Mubarak
 
In general, you are right. I would just point out that importing people with the values you describe will solve part of the problem. The US benefited greatly from Catholic immigrants in the nineteenth century, and fairly recent Asian immigrants have been very successful in business and with better than average family stability. Those waves of immigrants in the past not only assimilated, but improved their new country. They did not have the choice of living off the labor of others. Despite what some people say today, those immigrants did not succeed because of a welcoming atmosphere, but they succeeded in spite of a less than welcoming atmosphere, and the values they brought with them were responsible for their success.

My parish has a sizable group of Burmese refugees who are doing just fine. They include a lot of young children born and baptized after their arrival here. The Burmese now have their own Knights of Columbus council and one of their young men just started seminary for our diocese.
I don’t know much about Burmese. But Filipinos are eager workers, and there are plenty of them. Maybe Merkel needs to hire all of Lufthansa’s planes for a year to fly people from the Philippines to Germany.

Maybe the U.S. should beat Merkel to it.🙂
 
Hosni Mubarak was sentenced to three years for embezzlement of public funds. He was sentenced by an Egyptian court. Do you have reason to believe that Mubarak wasn’t actually guilty? Alternatively, do you believe that Mubarak should have been able to commit crimes with impunity because of his status?

Egypt: The trial of Hosni Mubarak
What is embezzlement in the Arab world, and what leaders are not doing it? One recalls that Mohammed was a raider himself.
 
What is embezzlement in the Arab world, and what leaders are not doing it? One recalls that Mohammed was a raider himself.
There were Coptic Christians living in Egypt before the Prophet Muhammad was born.

Ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics have been deciphered and it is known that the language wasn’t Arabic.

Recent news suggests that there has been high-level corruption in South Korea, but I am not aware of any causal link with either the Arabic language or the religion Islam.

From the BBC:
10 March 2017

"South Korea’s President Park Geun-hye has become the country’s first democratically elected leader to be forced from office.

That dubious honour was imposed on her when, on 10 March, judges unanimously upheld parliament’s decision in December to impeach her over a corruption scandal.

…]

The impeachment verdict against Ms Park stripped her of presidential immunity. She could now face criminal charges."
 
There were Coptic Christians living in Egypt before the Prophet Muhammad was born.

Ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics have been deciphered and it is known that the language wasn’t Arabic.

Recent news suggests that there has been high-level corruption in South Korea, but I am not aware of any causal link with either the Arabic language or the religion Islam.

From the BBC:
10 March 2017

"South Korea’s President Park Geun-hye has become the country’s first democratically elected leader to be forced from office.

That dubious honour was imposed on her when, on 10 March, judges unanimously upheld parliament’s decision in December to impeach her over a corruption scandal.

…]

The impeachment verdict against Ms Park stripped her of presidential immunity. She could now face criminal charges."
What does any of this mean?

Egypt before Mohammed was pre-Arab Egyptian with both Greek and Roman overlays.
Some Egyptian copts still speak something derived from ancient Egyptian.

But Egyptians now consider themselves “Arabs”, though they really aren’t, quite, in the same way, e.g., Bedouin are.

And if a Korean president was guilty of corruption does that somehow make Arab leaders’ corruption less?
 
Given the ongoing push for and continually declining cost of automaton, it is incredibly likely that the need for immigration, at least by employers will dry up. Not even farm jobs are safe. And many service jobs are at risk too.

Consider that today there exist several varieties of tomatoes and other produce created mainly to be machine harvestable. Add to that, many task that used to invoke interacting with a person at a business are gradually being handed over to websites and software.
 
What does any of this mean?
Maybe I should have asked that question. You relied upon the word “Arab” to express your train of thought.

Are Israeli Jews who came from Egypt considered to be “Arab Israelis”?

Consider a thought experiment …

Suppose that one of the 25,200 Jews in Egypt in 1898 became a Coptic Christian. Did the Coptic Christian who had previously been Jewish become an Arab at the moment of conversion?

“According to the official census published in 1898 (i., xviii.), there were in Egypt 25,200 Jews in a total population of 9,734,405.”

Link:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Egypt#Since_1919
(Scroll up to the end of the previous section after using this link to get to the beginning of the “Modern times (since 1919)” section.)
 
Maybe I should have asked that question. You relied upon the word “Arab” to express your train of thought.

Are Israeli Jews who came from Egypt considered to be “Arab Israelis”?

Consider a thought experiment …

Suppose that one of the 25,200 Jews in Egypt in 1898 became a Coptic Christian. Did the Coptic Christian who had previously been Jewish become an Arab at the moment of conversion?

“According to the official census published in 1898 (i., xviii.), there were in Egypt 25,200 Jews in a total population of 9,734,405.”

Link:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Egypt#Since_1919
(Scroll up to the end of the previous section after using this link to get to the beginning of the “Modern times (since 1919)” section.)
Wow! What a change! Isn’t the Jewish population in Egypt down to about 12 now?

“Being a Jew” isn’t the same as “being an Arab”. Arab Christians still consider themselves Arabs. So do Druze and Circassians. Jews from Arab countries are considered “Sephardim”, that is, Jews from places other than Europe. I don’t think Sephardim ever thought of themselves as Arabs. Jews who never left Palestine are also considered “Sephardim”. Only Jews from Europe (probably including Jews from the U.S.) are considered “Ashkenazim”.

So no. I don’t think a Jew in Egypt who converted to Christianity would have ever thought of himself as a Christian Arab. He would think of himself as a Christian with Jewish ancestry.
 
I think the other - totally unthinkable - option is to tell young people marriage matters, how marriage actually works, that having children is not just a personal good but also a social good, and just having contraceptive sex has the consequences we’re seeing today. That male-female relationships have a structure based on mutual respect and earned trust.

Importing people will not solve the problem.

Ed
So in other words, having children is just shy of a social obligation young adults? Like paying taxes and such?

I think the greatest obstacle to the changes you propose is the battle between the individual and society. You suggest the individual forgo their desires for that of society. Also, heavily implied is relinquishing control over certain aspects of one’s life. Both a hard sell.
 
Arab Christians still consider themselves Arabs.
That seems to be a true, but meaningless statement. You used the word “Arab” as an adjective and the plural noun “Arabs”, but both words are equally problematic. So you cannot use one to shed light on the other. You need to consider actual examples.

Coptic Christians who have Jewish ancestors – but who don’t know that they have Jewish ancestors – might consider themselves to be “Arab Christians.” The question is: if they discover that they have Jewish ancestors and share the information with others, then will they be able to continue to label themselves as “Arabs”?

If Rachel Dolezal had four grand-parents, and eight great grand-parents, and one of those eight great grant-parents had been “African American”, then she would have been able to classify herself as “African American.” However, if she had had seven great grand-parents who were “African American” and one who was White European, then she wouldn’t have been able to classify herself as “White European.”
 
The psychoanalyst Erich Fromm says that: “Love is an act of faith, and whoever is of little faith is also of little love”, Erich Fromm is interesting in some statements and advices but some of his advices are not suitable in practical application.
My faith once did not allow me to fall in love with an extremely beautiful woman.
Also I know that there is not far from me a large community of Jehovah’s Witnesses where a lot of beautiful unmarried youth, but I know that I should not step there with my foot and fall into the temptation of falling in love.
My opinion is- for nominal Christians, mixed marriage is not a problem, but sincere followers of Christ do not fall into such temptation.
by the way in Islam- Muslim women are forbidden to marry a non-Muslim unless her partner converts to Islam. Some men nominally convert to Islam in order to appease their partner’s family, but what is interesting that some European Imams are saying that - “There is no verse in the Holy Quran that bans Muslim women from marrying non-Muslim men.” Many women in interfaith relationships, have been disowned by their families, who in turn are often shamed with hate mail, threats and assault.
I think that not only in Germany, but also in the countries of the Benelux and in the United Kingdom, a new task has arisen- to be able to bless and give life advice to newlyweds - representatives of two different religions.
You can’t go away from this problem in a multicultural society, this becomes a frequent occurrence. But again, since so many nominal followers of their religions, the couples do not see problems in a variety of religions in mixed marriages.
 
I think the other - totally unthinkable - option is to tell young people marriage matters, how marriage actually works, that having children is not just a personal good but also a social good, and just having contraceptive sex has the consequences we’re seeing today. That male-female relationships have a structure based on mutual respect and earned trust.

Importing people will not solve the problem.

Ed
The first thing would be to bring Christianity back to Europe. After that the effort to convince young people about marriage and openness to life can be possibly fruitful.

Without the belief in God and an all pervading nihilism present, the task of convincing young people to take up the sacrifice of marriage and parenthood will be futile.
 
The first thing would be to bring Christianity back to Europe. After that the effort to convince young people about marriage and openness to life can be possibly fruitful.

Without the belief in God and an all pervading nihilism present, the task of convincing young people to take up the sacrifice of marriage and parenthood will be futile.
That’s why all of this pro-gay “marriage” pro-abortion variety of nationalism is a losing battle.
 
the task of convincing young people to take up the sacrifice of marriage
From the novel 1984 by George Orwell:

“I could have stood it if it hadn’t been for one thing,” he said. He toId her about the frigid little ceremony that Katharine had forced him to go through on the same night every week. “She hated it, but nothing would make her stop doing it. She used to call it – but you’ll never guess.”

“Our duty to the Party,” said Julia promptly.

“How did you know that?”

“I’ve been at school too, dear. Sex talks once a month for the over-sixteens. And in the Youth Movement. They rub it into you for years. I dare say it works in a lot of cases. But of course you can never tell; people are such hypocrites.”

She began to enlarge upon the subject. With Julia, everything came back to her own sexuality. As soon as this was touched upon in any way she was capable of great acuteness. Unlike Winston, she had grasped the inner meaning of the Party’s sexual puritanism. It was not merely that the sex instinct created a world of its own which was outside the Party’s control and which therefore had to be destroyed if possible. What was more important was that sexual privation induced hysteria, which was desirable because it could be transformed into war-fever and leader-worship. The way she put it was:

“When you make love you’re using up energy; and afterwards you feel happy and don’t give a damn for anything. They can’t bear you to feel like that. They want you to be bursting with energy all the time. All this marching up and down and cheering and waving flags is simpIy sex gone sour. If you’re happy inside yourself, why should you get excited about Big Brother and the Three-Year Plans and the Two Minutes Hate and all the rest of their bloody rot?”
 
“Or. We could have just followed Humanae Vitae.”

1968 was the turning point for the West, and for social anarchists. Like the old Opium trade, which led to two wars, porn became the opiate of the masses, and the contraception mentality was sold as gospel by young men who came into our neighborhoods, preaching their gospel. I was there to hear: “You know you want to live with and have sex with your girlfriend.” and using illegal drugs was cool. Christianity is useless, fill that void with Eastern mysticism. We’ll flood college towns with bookstores selling a ton of books about it. We’ll print underground newspapers preaching non-conformity, corporations are evil and “do your own thing.” Mom and dad could have it their way but we will do what we want and YOU - meaning all you conformist squares - better quit bothering us. Call them Hippies, Anarchists and Radicals - they decided to create a great big “lasting to this day” series of social experiments. And besides, the cost in lives didn’t matter. And your money was funding all this anyway. And there’s no such thing as too much money for the wealthy elite.

Corruption is fun. Mundane normal living? Not so much.

Ed
Ah yes, those dirty rotten hippies. Nevermind that the Pill went on the market in 1962, divorce was normalized a long time before that, Playboy was founded in 1954 and was a big seller many years before 1968, and the James Bond books and movies with its female characters named after female genitalia were big sellers in the 50s and early 60s.
 
More affordable delivery expenses would also help. It’s inconceivable (no pun intended) that it’s most expensive to have a baby in a country that claims to be “pro-life.” Having children is only a social good if married couples can afford it: simply being married doesn’t make it any more convenient.
In Europe though, maternity care is usually covered and they have maternity leave.

Italy has a low birth rate. Part of it is unemployment. Some of it is the age of marriage being higher. Some of it is lack of housing. Some of it is the mammone syndrome, where men prefer to live at home being catered to by their moms.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top