N
NovusFidem
Guest
Not so much evasion, it is more âsetting the battle groundsâ. The OPâs problem is with trying to argument his understanding against someoneâs else. In his understanding, soul=human being, and that is perfectly fine. But when talking to other people, the âbattle groundsâ (that is, the definition) is going to differ, always.Nice tactics.When you have no answer⌠evade!
Iâve spoken to people who defined âpersonhoodâ in different ways. Some claim on âa human being capable of independent existenceâ (excluding fetuses), others consider it âa productive human being acting in societyâ (excluding elderly or disabled), others claim that personhood âdependsâ (in that you canât really define it, so it is ok to kill a âpersonâ in some situations but not others - e.g. it is a baby when the couple wants it, but just a fetus when not)
Now you, you donât even give us a definition: that way, there is nothing really I can rebuke
Each person has a different understanding. I canât just come up with MY understanding and expect them to throw theirs out and accept mine - that is ridiculous. So, first, I show them why **their **understanding doesnât hold. When they finally âopen their mindsâ to a different understanding, then I will offer mine.
Otherwise, Iâd only be talking to a wall.
I donât understand your point. Even considering ârightsâ as a social construct, our discussion is necessarily to define who (or what) has which rights in our society.Since ârightsâ are social constructs, they do not exist independently from a given society. And you also confuse the biological dependence of the fetus with the social dependence of the âgenericâ caregiver.
I did not confuse one thing with the other, I only merged them. We, as biological bodies in a social environment are dependent on BOTH. A baby has both a biological and social dependence on the caregiver. We are now discussing the social dependence of a fetus: is it human enough to be deserving of social rights?
The example I used was to give grounds for a discussion, which is a point you seemed to miss on purpose, or didnât understand my intention. That is only one of the many pro-choice arguments used, which are easy to rebuke, in that âa fetus isnât human because it canât live by itselfâ. That is the âfirst brickâ, as the argument âcanât live by itselfâ is not enough to make a live being with human genes a non-person.
So there might be some argument about how to define a âpersonâ, but there can be no argument about who does NOT qualify as a person⌠namely some entity, which does NOT have a functioning brain. As such the zygote and the conglomerate of the cells before the brainâs electro-chemical activity starts does not qualify as a âpersonâ.
That is our current definition of âdeathâ, as in, something that was alive and now is not. While it does provide us with enough information to define when someone ceases to be alive, it does not offer enough to define what is âpersonhoodâ. The core of the problem here is not mere life - just as I canât deny a brain dead person is just a corpse, you canât deny a blastocyst isnât alive, and none of us, based on biology alone, can define what makes a person deserving of rights.Only the brain counts. When you take a fully grown person, and remove the brain, it will cease to be a human (much less a human person). It will become a corpse. Death is defined as the cessation of brain activity.
âPersonhoodâ and ârightsâ are not dependent solely on biology. If it were, then weâd have to go with scientists, the majority which define human life as beginning on conception. To biologists, life begins with a simple cell with enough genetic material; what biologists donât do is attribute to these cells âpersonhoodâ. We do that based on other areas of study.
As I said, that is your definition of what is not human, but you failed to present one for what IS a person. Unless you give us more information of what consists a person, how can I answer? You are not really leaving the ball in the playground for us to play with.How could someone be a âpersonâ without a brain?
In other words: my game is showing where your âwallâ has defects by removing the weak bricks until it falls. You, however, didnât give me a wall to work with, you just called me to a different game
But, just to humor you. By using your âremove piece by pieceâ strategy: when, exactly, does the fetus stops being a fetus - ie: when exactly does the brain form? Or should we wait until its fully formed (which I doubt, as it already has some neural function)? Should we allow abortion of up until 5 week fetuses, which is when the brain starts to form? How can we be sure that what we are removing isnât a person? Is there a way to know exactly how formed that thing is, without endangering it?
I only ask because, as you probably knows, we only have approximated gestational ages. What we are calling a 4 week fetus might be a 5 week one, and by killing it we could be killing a âpersonâ, by your definition.
Which, again, is my way of doing it. Keep going back day by day, then hour by hour: can you be completely sure it is not human yet?
Also, on an unrelated note (really, this is practically a PS): to you, does it matter if a fetus has a brain? I mean, you define something with a brain as a person - to you, is having a brain enough to protect that âsomethingâ from being removed? Is being a âpersonâ enough to grant a fetus rights?