The "personhood" argument

  • Thread starter Thread starter AFerri48
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nice tactics. 🙂 When you have no answer… evade!
Not so much evasion, it is more “setting the battle grounds”. The OP’s problem is with trying to argument his understanding against someone’s else. In his understanding, soul=human being, and that is perfectly fine. But when talking to other people, the “battle grounds” (that is, the definition) is going to differ, always.

I’ve spoken to people who defined “personhood” in different ways. Some claim on “a human being capable of independent existence” (excluding fetuses), others consider it “a productive human being acting in society” (excluding elderly or disabled), others claim that personhood “depends” (in that you can’t really define it, so it is ok to kill a “person” in some situations but not others - e.g. it is a baby when the couple wants it, but just a fetus when not)

Now you, you don’t even give us a definition: that way, there is nothing really I can rebuke 😛

Each person has a different understanding. I can’t just come up with MY understanding and expect them to throw theirs out and accept mine - that is ridiculous. So, first, I show them why **their **understanding doesn’t hold. When they finally “open their minds” to a different understanding, then I will offer mine.

Otherwise, I’d only be talking to a wall.
Since “rights” are social constructs, they do not exist independently from a given society. And you also confuse the biological dependence of the fetus with the social dependence of the “generic” caregiver.
I don’t understand your point. Even considering “rights” as a social construct, our discussion is necessarily to define who (or what) has which rights in our society.

I did not confuse one thing with the other, I only merged them. We, as biological bodies in a social environment are dependent on BOTH. A baby has both a biological and social dependence on the caregiver. We are now discussing the social dependence of a fetus: is it human enough to be deserving of social rights?

The example I used was to give grounds for a discussion, which is a point you seemed to miss on purpose, or didn’t understand my intention. That is only one of the many pro-choice arguments used, which are easy to rebuke, in that “a fetus isn’t human because it can’t live by itself”. That is the “first brick”, as the argument “can’t live by itself” is not enough to make a live being with human genes a non-person.
So there might be some argument about how to define a “person”, but there can be no argument about who does NOT qualify as a person… namely some entity, which does NOT have a functioning brain. As such the zygote and the conglomerate of the cells before the brain’s electro-chemical activity starts does not qualify as a “person”.
Only the brain counts. When you take a fully grown person, and remove the brain, it will cease to be a human (much less a human person). It will become a corpse. Death is defined as the cessation of brain activity.
That is our current definition of “death”, as in, something that was alive and now is not. While it does provide us with enough information to define when someone ceases to be alive, it does not offer enough to define what is “personhood”. The core of the problem here is not mere life - just as I can’t deny a brain dead person is just a corpse, you can’t deny a blastocyst isn’t alive, and none of us, based on biology alone, can define what makes a person deserving of rights.

“Personhood” and “rights” are not dependent solely on biology. If it were, then we’d have to go with scientists, the majority which define human life as beginning on conception. To biologists, life begins with a simple cell with enough genetic material; what biologists don’t do is attribute to these cells “personhood”. We do that based on other areas of study.
How could someone be a “person” without a brain?
As I said, that is your definition of what is not human, but you failed to present one for what IS a person. Unless you give us more information of what consists a person, how can I answer? You are not really leaving the ball in the playground for us to play with.

In other words: my game is showing where your “wall” has defects by removing the weak bricks until it falls. You, however, didn’t give me a wall to work with, you just called me to a different game :rolleyes:

But, just to humor you. By using your “remove piece by piece” strategy: when, exactly, does the fetus stops being a fetus - ie: when exactly does the brain form? Or should we wait until its fully formed (which I doubt, as it already has some neural function)? Should we allow abortion of up until 5 week fetuses, which is when the brain starts to form? How can we be sure that what we are removing isn’t a person? Is there a way to know exactly how formed that thing is, without endangering it?

I only ask because, as you probably knows, we only have approximated gestational ages. What we are calling a 4 week fetus might be a 5 week one, and by killing it we could be killing a “person”, by your definition.

Which, again, is my way of doing it. Keep going back day by day, then hour by hour: can you be completely sure it is not human yet?

Also, on an unrelated note (really, this is practically a PS): to you, does it matter if a fetus has a brain? I mean, you define something with a brain as a person - to you, is having a brain enough to protect that “something” from being removed? Is being a “person” enough to grant a fetus rights?
 
The context is that pro-choice people claim that abortion is okay because the zygote/embyro/fetus is not a person yet. I -]feel/-] think that this argument began because once most people realized that it is clearly a living human with it’s own specific DNA, they had to come up with a new reason for why abortion is okay. So, the personhood argument came about. It’s not the first time either, dehumanization has been used plenty of times to justify murder (Jew’s, blacks, slaves, women, children, etc), and the definition of personhood conveniently changes to help people feel like they did nothing wrong.
I think you are pretty much correct. I see the person-hood argument as a Nietzscheian argument, that is, the term person is arbitrary defined to fit who we want it to fit, and reject who we don’t want. In this sense it is the same argument used by slave owners and Nazis. If we are not trying to smuggle in our prejudices through the backdoor, we need to find the real definition of person (what it means to be a person), or deny the existence of the thing altogether.
This being… I DO believe that human and person are different terms. For example, the three Persons of the Trinity, angels, and potential extra-terrestrial life are all people, albeit not human.
All humans are persons, but not all person are human.
However, I just can’t seem to come up with an argument for what makes us people, and until at least one of us comes up with something good… the debate is lost before it even begins.
I tried to argue that anyone with a natural, inherent ability to perform personal acts made us people… but there’s a hole in this argument, where people can say that until you reach the ability to perform these acts, you aren’t a person.
A sleeping person doesn’t demonstrate any of the functional characteristics either. A fetus does have a natural, inherent ability to perform personal acts as much as you sleep are.
The soul argument obviously can’t be used against atheists… however I’m not sure if the spiritual soul is really what makes us people any way.
If you mean soul as in the immaterial aspect of a human, than this claim would be rejected by materialists, not by atheists per se. One can believe in the immateriality of the soul and not believe in God.

Christi pax,

Lucretius
 
zzyz,

Your objective definition of person-hood is applaudable, but I see a deeper problem with your “certain amount of brain usage == person” hypothesis: why should person-hood be accepted as the criteria for determining these moral issues? You already reject someones humanity as a criteria, what make person-hood less rejectable? Can’t I just say that a person who is a ultimately a burden on a family/society has no right to be alive?

Further, what makes humans so special? No one (but Descartes, apparently :rolleyes:) would deny that pets and higher animals have some hint of personality: why are these creatures exceptions? If you reject qualitative difference between humans and the brutes (aka the 'soul"), than an adult pig seems to have more of a right to live than a vegetable.

To be more blunt, what is the broader ethical context in which you are make this claim?

Christi pax,

Lucretius
 
Now you, you don’t even give us a definition: that way, there is nothing really I can rebuke 😛
You are absolutely correct, I did not give a definition. The problem is that there is no direct definition, only a descriptive one. Just like in Forrest Gump, where he says: “Stupid is as stupid does”. The same is applicable to the question of “person”. By stipulating that the person is tied to a working brain, I tried to be as accommodating as I could be. Clearly, an embryo of 5 weeks (which is the usual age when the brain’s electro-chemical activity can be detected, is more than generous to declare a being a “person”.

Personally, I would go with the descriptive definition. If a being exhibits the traits of a person, it should be afforded the label of a “person”, regardless of the building material (biological or silicon based) regardless of the taxonomical description (human or chimpanzee or dolphin). Intelligence is what makes us “persons”, not the biological components. But this view is not something that is readily accepted by others.
I don’t understand your point. Even considering “rights” as a social construct, our discussion is necessarily to define who (or what) has which rights in our society.
Currently, in our society fetuses do not have “rights”. They do not have “rights” to inherit, for example. Laws can change that, of course.
That is only one of the many pro-choice arguments used, which are easy to rebuke, in that “a fetus isn’t human because it can’t live by itself”. That is the “first brick”, as the argument “can’t live by itself” is not enough to make a live being with human genes a non-person.
As a matter of fact, I do not use that particular argument. The relationship between the woman and the zygote/fetus is a parasitic relationship. Not a symbiotic one! In a symbiotic relationship both parties benefit from the relationship. In a symbiotic relationship only one party benefits, the other one loses.
That is our current definition of “death”, as in, something that was alive and now is not. While it does provide us with enough information to define when someone ceases to be alive, it does not offer enough to define what is “personhood”. The core of the problem here is not mere life - just as I can’t deny a brain dead person is just a corpse, you can’t deny a blastocyst isn’t alive, and none of us, based on biology alone, can define what makes a person deserving of rights.
Yes. You are right in pointing out that not all definitions are “black and white”. For example: a medical student is not a “doctor” until she receives her diploma. One second before she gets her diploma, she is still a student, one second after she becomes a doctor, who is allowed to practice. But not all situations are like this. When does an acorn become a sapling or an oak tree?
As I said, that is your definition of what is not human, but you failed to present one for what IS a person. Unless you give us more information of what consists a person, how can I answer? You are not really leaving the ball in the playground for us to play with.
Very true. But I am not interested in the fluid concept of who IS a person, only in the concept of who IS NOT a person. After all, we are talking about abortion. 😉 But as I told you, I only brought up the question of “personhood” to accommodate your side. As far as I am concerned the fetus is a parasite, which could be removed at will, preferably as soon as possible, if it is not wanted.

Let’s consider a seriously wounded person, who would die if she would not receive a necessary organ from someone else. Currently, there is no legal or “moral” requirement to provide that organ so save her life. Not even if that organ is “blood”, which will be replenished by the donor. No one can be legally forced to donate blood or bone-marrow to save the life of someone else. Think about it. 🙂
But, just to humor you. By using your “remove piece by piece” strategy: when, exactly, does the fetus stops being a fetus - ie: when exactly does the brain form? Or should we wait until its fully formed (which I doubt, as it already has some neural function)? Should we allow abortion of up until 5 week fetuses, which is when the brain starts to form? How can we be sure that what we are removing isn’t a person? Is there a way to know exactly how formed that thing is, without endangering it?

I only ask because, as you probably knows, we only have approximated gestational ages. What we are calling a 4 week fetus might be a 5 week one, and by killing it we could be killing a “person”, by your definition.

Which, again, is my way of doing it. Keep going back day by day, then hour by hour: can you be completely sure it is not human yet?
You cannot.
Also, on an unrelated note (really, this is practically a PS): to you, does it matter if a fetus has a brain? I mean, you define something with a brain as a person - to you, is having a brain enough to protect that “something” from being removed? Is being a “person” enough to grant a fetus rights?
We use the age-old adage: “Similis simili gaudet”. It is a rather irrational concept, but we “value” our own species over others. At least most people do. I am an exception.
 
Your objective definition of person-hood is applaudable, but I see a deeper problem with your “certain amount of brain usage == person” hypothesis: why should person-hood be accepted as the criteria for determining these moral issues? You already reject someones humanity as a criteria, what make person-hood less rejectable? Can’t I just say that a person who is a ultimately a burden on a family/society has no right to be alive?
No one has the “right” to anything, unless that “right” is declared by law, and that law can be enforced.
Further, what makes humans so special? No one (but Descartes, apparently :rolleyes:) would deny that pets and higher animals have some hint of personality: why are these creatures exceptions? If you reject qualitative difference between humans and the brutes (aka the 'soul"), than an adult pig seems to have more of a right to live than a vegetable.

To be more blunt, what is the broader ethical context in which you are make this claim?
Very well presented question. I value “intelligence” and/or “sentience” over everything else. Whether it is manifested in a biologically alive entity, or not. Of course you are welcome to disagree with this approach. 🙂
 
It seems to me that you summarily discard the “personhood” argument, and concentrate solely on the “human rights” argument.
Personhood is a legal status usually given by law. E.g. juridical persons are in principle just a mere construct of law.
It does not seem right to tie the most basic protections, e.g. the right to life, to something which is usually given only due to a law saying so. Because what is given, can be taken.
What use are regulations against “human” rights abuses, if they are only against “person” rights abuses and the government/parliament/ruling class/… has the power to take personhood away?

On the other hand, while for example slaves were denied personhood and thereby had no rights, no one sane in their mind claimed they were non-humans. And that was the basis for abolishing slavery.

Even the Nazis didn’t deny that Jews were in some sense humans.
It is always the “strong” and powerful one, which (or who) grants rights to the others, and enforces those rules by the usage of force. A “right” which is not enforced is not a “right”. It is not “fun” to admit that at the bottom of it, there is no other “foundation”, but “might makes right”.
As i said above, the evaluation of history would have to be changed.

Because i think Nazis would have fully agreed to the above quoted passages. Hence, Nazis actions can only be considered to be a crime, because they lost. What the allies did, especially in the Nurembourg Trials would have to be decribed correctly with a smear word from Neo-Nazis in Germany:
“Siegerjustiz”.

No, this does not mean i equate your position with the one of the Nazis; i just claim that based on the above you cannot formulate any argument on why the Nazis were wrong except “they lost”.
(Important disclaimer: the word “right” here does not mean correct or desirable, it denotes the “legal right”.) We might wish that it would not be the case, but this wish is unfounded.
And this brings a problem. We in Germany (at least a very large majority) are convinced, the Nazis weren’t only wrong because they lost; actually, even if they had won, they would have still been wrong, still mass-murdering criminals however many laws they enacted correctly according to the then german constitution depriving Jews (and others) of rights or personhood or whatever.

The only solution to the problem, Nazis were wrong, although the correctly established laws did not say so, is that there is some law or some principle beyond the power of the state. Its either that or the Nazis (at least most of them) weren’t criminals.

This is no theoretical problem, but was actually a great problem for German federal republic, founded in 1948. Surely, a host of crimes happened between 33 and 45. But mostly in full accord with the written law. Hence, it was in doubt to what extent cimes could be punished, especially as many Nazis could correctly claim that they acted within the boundary of the law existing at that time.

The only solution was to officially recognize that there are legally binding principles beyond the reach of the state and that these principles are to some extent immutable over time and circumstances. That way it could legally argued that the Nazi laws in violation of this principles were void although correctly enacted and that therefore people acting within these laws although capable of knowing they were in violation of these fundamental principles could be guilty of crimes.

The only option seems to be, to presume that every single human has something worthy of protection, something beyond the reach of the state; the choice of words for this is “human dignity”, but thats just a lable. (Tying it to personhood, does not work, see above)

Its that or the Nazis just lost, but weren’t more right or wrong than anyone else.

As i am throughfully convinced that the second alternative is wrong, i must choose the first, although there is no rational naturalistic argument to show its true.
So the “unborn” have no “rights” unless they are afforded by the state. And if the state says that abortion is legal, then the unborn have no “right” to survive. If the state says that the unborn cannot inherit, then it cannot inherit… period. We may or may not like this approach, we may or may not wish to change it, but the fact is there. There are no “natural rights”.
And if all humans have something worthy of protection and as birth doesn’t change biologically much or anything at all about the fetus/childs body (to be disconnected and to start breathing is just a minor change or organ function, its no change about whether human or not), then unborn have something worthy of protection as well (to what extent is another question). And the state has to enter the minefield how to handle that in light of the rights of the mother.
 
You are absolutely correct, I did not give a definition. The problem is that there is no direct definition, only a descriptive one.
Again, I don’t understand your intentions here. The OP just wants to know how to argument with people. If there is or isn’t a proper definition to personhood, it doesn’t matter: as long as he can prove pro-choicers that their definition has gaping holes, our goal will be achieved on this thread.
Intelligence is what makes us “persons”, not the biological components. But this view is not something that is readily accepted by others.
They don’t accept it probably because of the implications. You’d have to consider some advanced forms of Alzheimer’s a non-person, at the same time that you’d be giving chimpanzee (and, honestly, even house cats and dogs) their due rights in society.
Currently, in our society fetuses do not have “rights”. They do not have “rights” to inherit, for example. Laws can change that, of course.
Currently, in our society, there is a polemic over the issue. In Brazil, where I hail from, fetuses have rights just like that of other people. The right to life, for example, is still protected, as abortion is illegal here. They have very basic rights, such as to life and freedom and security, because, really, there’s not much more they need to live. But, at least, in case they are people, they are protected by society.
As a matter of fact, I do not use that particular argument.
No one supposed that you do. My first post was directed to the OP, and I used common arguments presented by pro-choicers to show how my method works.
When does an acorn become a sapling or an oak tree?
Who knows? But if we want trees, we know which of those we need to protect and care for first, which is why some endangered plants (and bird eggs) enjoy better protection from government than human fetuses. Everyone wants trees and eagles, but who cares for more humans, am I right?
Very true. But I am not interested in the fluid concept of who IS a person, …]
Again, no one said you did. I was directing my first post to the OP, and then I tried to explain my first post to you.
Let’s consider a seriously wounded person, who would die if she would not receive a necessary organ from someone else. Currently, there is no legal or “moral” requirement to provide that organ so save her life. Not even if that organ is “blood”, which will be replenished by the donor. No one can be legally forced to donate blood or bone-marrow to save the life of someone else. Think about it. 🙂
Think about what?

All I can think about is that, nowadays, you can’t force a person to donate a kidney, but you could harvest one (or both) from a perfectly healthy pig if it was safe.

In the same line, we actually use horses to produce snake antivenom without asking them if they are ok with that.

And those are two highly intelligent animals, perhaps not to the level of dolphins, but still. Imagine us having to ask for their permission?
You cannot.
Which is why it is best that we not kill them. Better safe than sorry - if I can’t be sure it is human yet, then better keep it safe. 😉
We use the age-old adage: “Similis simili gaudet”. It is a rather irrational concept, but we “value” our own species over others. At least most people do. I am an exception.
Good for you, I guess?

Most animals do that, actually. You don’t get to see a lion worried about the welfare of a zebra, but he will care for the lioness and lion cubs in his pride. My cat only cares for us because she believes us to be cats, if animal psychologists are to be believed.

I don’t really see the problem in caring for your own over others - we do that with our own family over our neighbors, to our neighbors over other city’s dwellers, and to our own country over North Korea. We protect what we are familiar with, because we know it to be worth of protection.

If we could care for other as we care for our own, it would be fantastic, but you can’t be everywhere all the time.
 
No one has the “right” to anything, unless that “right” is declared by law, and that law can be enforced.
You seem to reject the Thomistic, the Lockean, as well as one of the foundational principle of American Political philosophy: the existence of “unalienable” rights.
Very well presented question. I value “intelligence” and/or “sentience” over everything else. Whether it is manifested in a biologically alive entity, or not. Of course you are welcome to disagree with this approach. 🙂
I’ve always understood “sentience” to refer to emotions. Do you mean sapience?

I think your approach is that it is backed on an arbritary claim: that (at least) humans with a fully functioning nervous system shouldn’t be killed. This claim is then not based on anything objective, but rather on humans agreeing with it themselves: a collective subjectivity of sorts.

Given what you have said above, you probably agree with this assessment, correct?

Christi pax,

Lucretius
 
Personhood is a legal status usually given by law. E.g. juridical persons are in principle just a mere construct of law.
It does not seem right to tie the most basic protections, e.g. the right to life, to something which is usually given only due to a law saying so. Because what is given, can be taken.
What use are regulations against “human” rights abuses, if they are only against “person” rights abuses and the government/parliament/ruling class/… has the power to take personhood away?

On the other hand, while for example slaves were denied personhood and thereby had no rights, no one sane in their mind claimed they were non-humans. And that was the basis for abolishing slavery.

Even the Nazis didn’t deny that Jews were in some sense humans.

As i said above, the evaluation of history would have to be changed.

Because i think Nazis would have fully agreed to the above quoted passages. Hence, Nazis actions can only be considered to be a crime, because they lost. What the allies did, especially in the Nurembourg Trials would have to be decribed correctly with a smear word from Neo-Nazis in Germany:
“Siegerjustiz”.

No, this does not mean i equate your position with the one of the Nazis; i just claim that based on the above you cannot formulate any argument on why the Nazis were wrong except “they lost”.

And this brings a problem. We in Germany (at least a very large majority) are convinced, the Nazis weren’t only wrong because they lost; actually, even if they had won, they would have still been wrong, still mass-murdering criminals however many laws they enacted correctly according to the then german constitution depriving Jews (and others) of rights or personhood or whatever.

The only solution to the problem, Nazis were wrong, although the correctly established laws did not say so, is that there is some law or some principle beyond the power of the state. Its either that or the Nazis (at least most of them) weren’t criminals.

This is no theoretical problem, but was actually a great problem for German federal republic, founded in 1948. Surely, a host of crimes happened between 33 and 45. But mostly in full accord with the written law. Hence, it was in doubt to what extent cimes could be punished, especially as many Nazis could correctly claim that they acted within the boundary of the law existing at that time.

The only solution was to officially recognize that there are legally binding principles beyond the reach of the state and that these principles are to some extent immutable over time and circumstances. That way it could legally argued that the Nazi laws in violation of this principles were void although correctly enacted and that therefore people acting within these laws although capable of knowing they were in violation of these fundamental principles could be guilty of crimes.

The only option seems to be, to presume that every single human has something worthy of protection, something beyond the reach of the state; the choice of words for this is “human dignity”, but thats just a lable. (Tying it to personhood, does not work, see above)

Its that or the Nazis just lost, but weren’t more right or wrong than anyone else.

As i am throughfully convinced that the second alternative is wrong, i must choose the first, although there is no rational naturalistic argument to show its true.

And if all humans have something worthy of protection and as birth doesn’t change biologically much or anything at all about the fetus/childs body (to be disconnected and to start breathing is just a minor change or organ function, its no change about whether human or not), then unborn have something worthy of protection as well (to what extent is another question). And the state has to enter the minefield how to handle that in light of the rights of the mother.
The basic problem with this is that conflates the “legal right” with “morally right” (whatever that might be). I explicitly excluded the meaning of “right” which would imply “good, correct, moral… etc”. I only point out that the legal “right” is the result of someone who had power (generally the nation-state) making a decision about what behavior can go unpunished, and which one cannot.

You are absolute right (another meaning, hehe) that these “rights” can be revoked at the discretion of the ones who are in power. In the States there is the Miranda right - to protect you against self-incrimination. But it can be suspended, if the state declares a national emergency. There are explicit laws against torture, but these can be “overlooked”, when a terrorist act is suspected (see waterboarding).

There are “property rights”, which can be suspended when the government declares “eminent domain”. You may have a deed on your property, all the legal documents to support it, and the local government can declare that it will confiscate it because it will be used for the benefit of the community… which may or may not be true. But you are SOL, and must defend your “rights” in court, with all the financial burden associated with it.

I do NOT like this state of affairs, and do NOT support the concept. I merely point out the fact.
 
You seem to reject the Thomistic, the Lockean, as well as one of the foundational principle of American Political philosophy: the existence of “unalienable” rights.
I have no choice. Those are wonderful, but ultimately meaningless words. The phrase is “pie in the sky”. Though I would like them to be true.
I’ve always understood “sentience” to refer to emotions. Do you mean sapience?
Both. 🙂
I think your approach is that it is backed on an arbritary claim: that (at least) humans with a fully functioning nervous system shouldn’t be killed. This claim is then not based on anything objective, but rather on humans agreeing with it themselves: a collective subjectivity of sorts.
Well, it is based on the concept of “Do not do unto others, which you would not do others do unto you”. This is basically a “selfish” attitude. We do not want to suffer.
Given what you have said above, you probably agree with this assessment, correct?
Not one hundred percent. I don’t subscribe to “fully general” evaluations. All facets of the situation must be observed and evaluated before we can make value judgment.
 
Currently, in our society, there is a polemic over the issue. In Brazil, where I hail from, fetuses have rights just like that of other people. The right to life, for example, is still protected, as abortion is illegal here. They have very basic rights, such as to life and freedom and security, because, really, there’s not much more they need to live. But, at least, in case they are people, they are protected by society.
That is what I alluded to. These “rights” are all contingent upon the ruling body. They can be granted or be taken away.
Who knows?
I agree that there is no clear-cut dividing line. Just like in the declaration of “pornography”. As one of the Supreme Court justices said: “I cannot define what porn is, but I know it when I see it”. There is a tremendous problem with this approach. Something that cannot be defined properly, should NOT be legislated.
 
That is what I alluded to. These “rights” are all contingent upon the ruling body. They can be granted or be taken away.
And again, I have no idea what your point is. I don’t know if you want to prove that fetus have no right (our should not have rights), or if you want to prove that all this discussion won’t matter either way.

These discussions over abortion are made exactly to find if we should give or take rights, and the OP wanted good arguments to use with those who refuse a Biblical explanation. That’s it.
I agree that there is no clear-cut dividing line. Just like in the declaration of “pornography”. As one of the Supreme Court justices said: “I cannot define what porn is, but I know it when I see it”. There is a tremendous problem with this approach. Something that cannot be defined properly, should NOT be legislated.
Or we should legislate using broader characteristics? Just like we do with everything else?

Maybe Michelangelo’s David is a masterpiece, maybe its porn… we should cover it until we are sure; you know, better safe than sorry?

With medication, for example, no Agency for Sanitary Vigilance would allow even the most inconspicuous medication, such as grape seed powder, to be sold as medication without proper studies. They’d rather deprive population from something as silly and accessible as grape seed powder than let people consume something that might be hazardous to health. This is why we’ve come so far, you know: we are a paranoid bunch.

In the case of abortion it gets worse: we are risking killing thousands of people if we decide to allow it before making sure of** what**, exactly, is a human being/person.

You know, just like we did to Africans with slavery? When society decided to use physical characteristics and intellectual differences (because, really, they didn’t have the same culture or spoke the same language) to define what was a “person”, and treated them horribly for years, until someone came along to show that “hey, there are other clues that show that they are people like us, with just a different color!”.

Or like the Nazis did with Jews? The Europeans with indigenous Americans?

I’d rather treat them as “persons” now. What if in a couple years people decide universally that fetuses are “persons” - Planed Parenthood will be looked as some sort of concentration camp, and the whole pro-abortion generation will be considered the cause of a holocaust.

On the other hand, if we ever find out that babies up to 5 years old aren’t even human, at least we didn’t kill anyone who had a right to live.
 
And again, I have no idea what your point is. I don’t know if you want to prove that fetus have no right (our should not have rights), or if you want to prove that all this discussion won’t matter either way.
No special point, just showing that there are no “absolute” rights outside a specific social environment. I gave no value judgment about it.
These discussions over abortion are made exactly to find if we should give or take rights, and the OP wanted good arguments to use with those who refuse a Biblical explanation. That’s it.
Very well. Let’s start with basic biology. The zygote (when implanted in the uterus wall) starts a “hostile” (though temporary) takeover of the woman’s body. It becomes a parasitic entity, living off of the woman’s bodily resources, without “asking” for permission. The woman’s body treats the embryo as a foreign intruder, and “fights” it. Especially a male embryo.

So biologically speaking the embryo is a “disease”. To remove it serves the best interest of woman’s body. If the woman is willing to accept the status quo, that is her prerogative. But no one should be forced to act as an incubator against her wishes.

Now the best solution is prevention, just like with other diseases. If the prevention fails, then the next step is preventing the implantation of the zygote into the uterus wall - in other words - the morning after pill.

Currently, in our societies the law is that no one should be forced to supply bodily resources, even if this refusal is fatal to the requestor. Even if those resources will be replenished by the donor’s body, as in the case of blood or plasma or bone marrow.

This line of argument does not depend on the question of “personhood” or if the zygote is a “human being”. It depends on the principle that we have sole dominion over our bodies.

Now, in a hypothetical society, which has been “explored” by Larry Niven in his great science fiction books, the situation would be different. He describes a society where organ transplants are used routinely to utilize the organs of convicted criminals. Since the demand is greater than the supply, the society implements laws, where even minor misdemeanors carry a death sentence (three speeding tickets, or tax evasion for example), and the “criminals” are harvested for usable body parts. Fortunately we do not live in such a society. But it is a logical corollary of the demand that the woman should “donate” her body to the fetus.
 
Very well. Let’s start with basic biology.
Wonderful! I need to see if my graduation was worth all the time spent studying! Just forgive me if I don’t translate it well into English, as I studied English using fiction books, and not scientific literature 👍
The zygote (when implanted in the uterus wall) starts a “hostile” (though temporary) takeover of the woman’s body.
Interesting. We should take note that a woman’s body prepares itself for this “takeover”. I mean, if we didn’t go through all those hormonal fluctuations that prepares the uterus for pregnancy, which also are responsible for maturing and liberating the egg (you know, half of your “parasite”), I am pretty sure no such “parasite” would even exist.

Further more: the biggest “permission” a woman can give to such a parasite is to allow it to be created through, tah-da! Sex.
It becomes a parasitic entity, living off of the woman’s bodily resources, without “asking” for permission.
Never mind that, for something to be a parasite, it has to fill some basic characteristics.

Let’s check them off, shall we?

1) a parasite improves the chances of survival of its own species by taking resources from its host. At the same time, a parasite also reduces the chances of survival of the host species.

A fetus is of the same species of the mother - and I don’t care if you don’t think it is; ask any respected biologist. By raising its own survival chances, the fetus is making sure its species is propagated. Since the mother is of the same species, nothing is truly lost.

I mean, what world you live in? Living things live to reproduce; it is how we keep our own species alive. I may die in 50 or so years, but my offspring will keep “humans” alive. It’s how life works.

2) different from symbiosis, a parasitic relationship brings no benefits to the host.

So, here you are just showing how little you read about medical researches.

Did you know that a pregnant woman has better chances of surviving a heart attack thanks to the fetus? Yeah, apparently a fetus may send stem cells to repair its mother’s heart tissue (and other organs as well). After all, keeping the mother safe improves its own survival chances.

Women who never had children (nulliparity) are at a higher risk of developing malignant breast and reproductive (uterine and ovarian) cancer. Women have lower chances of developing breast cancer if their first pregnancy happens when they are still young (early 20s) rather than old (first birth at late 30s to 40s).

Moving along: late pregnancies (women in their 40s and over) are associated with longer lifespan of the woman. Some researches believe this association is due to the fact that a woman needs to live at least through the baby’s teen years, to make sure her offspring survives into adulthood, so a late pregnancy delays menopause into a later age (and menopause is what gives us a lot of health problems). A curious fact is that grandchildren have the same effect on grandmothers (grandmothers live longer if they have grandkids), but this is just trivia.

In sum: pregnancy = prolonged lifespan. I dig that.
The woman’s body treats the embryo as a foreign intruder, and “fights” it. Especially a male embryo.
Good grief, what are you, a radical feminist?

As was shown, a woman’s body prepares itself to receive the embryo. The placenta is an organ of both mother and embryo, which both nurtures and protects the child from the mother’s immune system.

Why would your own body create something to prevent itself from eliminating a threat? You know, like what happens with intestinal (gut) flora? (tip: it’s because said “threat” is not a threat to the host)

Not only all that, her body gives half of the embryo’s genetic material. How can something whose life started inside of you be called “foreign” or “intruder”? Aren’t all those immigrant’s children, born inside the USA, Americans as well? Sheesh, man, what is wrong with you and your use of words?

Did you know that a woman’s body is capable of miscarrying an embryo? If it finds some genetic mutation incompatible with life, or if the mother is in no condition to sustain a pregnancy (e.g.: high levels of stress, malnourished, ill health etc), the body will flush out the embryo just as easily as it was implanted. It is rather common in the first trimester, usually because of malformation of the embryo.

Now: if my body can so easily “flush out” that thing, why does it decide to “keep it” in **most **cases? And for around 40 weeks at that?

(answer: because the body doesn’t see it as an intruder :newidea:)
So biologically speaking the embryo is a “disease”.
So, biologically speaking, you have no idea what you are talking about. A baby, you like it or not, improves the survival rates of your species, even if you’d rather not have it inside of you.

Also, if pregnancies were diseases, imagine how our economy would fare with all those sick leaves? I mean, 9 months home, with paid leave?
To remove it serves the best interest of woman’s body.
Serves to the interest of the woman, but not her body. Her body will actually throw a tantrum called Menstruation, in that the body gets so pissed at your choice that it decides to flush all its own hard work, and preparing your body to receive a baby. You know, EVERY SINGLE MONTH.

The “interest of the body” is for a woman to be pregnant. I know, because my body does all this preparing all the time. If it didn’t want “the parasite”, the body wouldn’t be so hopeful for it. :rolleyes:
 
If the woman is willing to accept the status quo, that is her prerogative. But no one should be forced to act as an incubator against her wishes.
(she consented to it by having sex)

Now we are back in topic! This is what we are discussing.

As I have shown that, biologically speaking, a pregnancy is desirable to one’s body, and that your argument of “parasitic relationship” is void of sound scientific claim, you are left with the burden of providing a better argument. This is how discussions work, after all.
Now the best solution is prevention, just like with other diseases.
Yeah, pretty much what we preach around here.
If the prevention fails, then the next step is preventing the implantation of the zygote into the uterus wall - in other words - the morning after pill.
This, again, is going a bit over the original topic. We have yet to decide if a zygote is “a person who deserves social protection” or not. When we do decide it, then we may discuss if inhibiting its survival is moral/socially acceptable or not. Otherwise, we are missing the point of this topic. (feel free to create another topic, though 👍)
Currently, in our societies the law is that no one should be forced to supply bodily resources, even if this refusal is fatal to the requestor. Even if those resources will be replenished by the donor’s body, as in the case of blood or plasma or bone marrow.
As I said, having sex was consent enough for the embryo to show up. I mean, it wouldn’t even BE there if you didn’t let it.

As for rape (because I know you are going to mention it), there is still the discussion we are having (“is the fetus a person?”). Even if said child was placed under my care against my will, if it is a person I have the social duty of protecting it.

I mean, think of someone throwing a kid into your living room. You may not want it, or care about it, but if you simply pick the kid and leave it on your doorstep in the cold, you are going to be held accountable if anything happens to it. (just like the criminal who left a child in your living room - the rapist). So,** if** the embryo is found to be a person (like the kid in your living room), you will have the duty of protecting it.

Also, focus on that “if”: that “if” is what we are discussing.

“Currently in our society” means very little in matter of what is right or wrong, specially when you consider that the “currently” just a few years ago meant that dark skinned people (either Africans or Indigenous Americans) weren’t even considered human, much less “persons”.
This line of argument does not depend on the question of “personhood” or if the zygote is a “human being”. It depends on the principle that we have sole dominion over our bodies.
Based on what?

Where does this right (sole dominion) over our own bodies come from? Who granted us this seemingly inherent right? How can you be sure this right supersedes that of respecting the right to life of another human being? (which is what a human zygote is; if not a “person”, at least human it is. Ask any respected biologist.)

This “line of argument” is the discussion at hand. Maybe for you the “dominion over your body” is a wonderful argument, but to most of us “caring for those under our care” takes precedence.

What? Doesn’t a father have a duty to provide for his children? Or his “dominion” means that he can take off to Disneyland and forget the rugrats?

No one is asking the mother to give her uterus to a zygote. We just want her to be patient and allow it to survive into birth. She can have her body back, just as new (and improved with “breast cancer protection 2.0” and “wizard level life span 1.0”).

It is not an organ donation. It is allowing the uterus to do his thing.

(next thing you know, people will complain that the food in their stomach has no permission to be there, never mind that they were the ones to eat it. Oh, wait, people already do that - food baby abortion! Silly me…)
Now, in a hypothetical society, which has been “explored” by Larry Niven in his great science fiction books, the situation would be different. He describes a society where organ transplants are used routinely to utilize the organs of convicted criminals. Since the demand is greater than the supply, the society implements laws, where even minor misdemeanors carry a death sentence (three speeding tickets, or tax evasion for example), and the “criminals” are harvested for usable body parts. Fortunately we do not live in such a society. But it is a logical corollary of the demand that the woman should “donate” her body to the fetus.
What the…? Are you taking cues from science fiction?

And “a logical corollary” goes a bit too far :rotfl: You go from “I had sex in my fertile week, now I need to accept responsibility for my acts” to “I jaywalked, now people will demand from me more than the harm I caused”.

Very logical indeed :yup:
 
And a little joke about a woman’s body:

Your period is like coming home one day and finding that your spouse has constructed this entire new baby bedroom inside your house and you have to tell them “Sweetie we don’t have a baby”, and then your spouse FLIPS OUT like “The MARBLES do you mean we don’t have a baby? I DID ALL THIS WORK FOR WHAT?”

And then they spend the next week tearing the whole room apart and throwing it out into the street and screaming at you and then, finally, when the room is completely gutted, they calm down and say “It’s okay, honey, we’ll have a baby next month”, and then they start building the room again AND THIS KEEPS GOING FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE UNTIL YOU HIT LIKE 50 AND THEN YOUR SPOUSE LEAVES YOU BUT NOT BEFORE SETTING THE WHOLE HOUSE ON FIRE SO IT’S NEVER THE SAME AGAIN.

Uterus wants babies; that’s the SOLE purpose of that organ, if you didn’t already know 👍
 
Interesting. We should take note that a woman’s body prepares itself for this “takeover”. I mean, if we didn’t go through all those hormonal fluctuations that prepares the uterus for pregnancy, which also are responsible for maturing and liberating the egg (you know, half of your “parasite”), I am pretty sure no such “parasite” would even exist.
And yet, once the impregnation occurs, the body attempts to get rid of it. Especially the male embryo. And that is just a simple fact, not a “radical feminist” propaganda.

That reminds me of the joke about “mixed feelings”: “A fixed feeling happens when you see your mother-in-law driving your brand new Mercedes over the cliff”. There are very few clear-cut events in life. Some things carry positive and negative repercussions. And there is nothing wrong with attempting to minimize the negative consequences, while keeping the positive ones.
Further more: the biggest “permission” a woman can give to such a parasite is to allow it to be created through, tah-da! Sex.
This is the usual nonsense presented all the time. Why don’t you assert that we consented to have an accident, after all we voluntarily got into the car - even if we wear a seat belt (condom, anyone?) and drive defensively (coitus interruptus)? Accepting the risk of an accident is not consenting to an accident. Or translating: “accepting the risk to a pregnancy is NOT consenting to a pregnancy”.
I mean, what world you live in? Living things live to reproduce; it is how we keep our own species alive. I may die in 50 or so years, but my offspring will keep “humans” alive. It’s how life works.
As far as nature is “concerned” the propagation of species is “important”. But that does not translate into the individual. The individual might have a different set of priorities, which does not include the propagation of the species. And she should not be forced to do it.
Now: if my body can so easily “flush out” that thing, why does it decide to “keep it” in **most **cases? And for around 40 weeks at that?
Actually, in MOST cases (estimated: 90 some percent) the zygote is flushed out.
Serves to the interest of the woman, but not her body.
As if the woman could be separated from her body?
Yeah, pretty much what we preach around here.
Not really. You preach abstinence, not prevention. Prevention is much better than abstinence. As another old joke goes: “Of all the sexual perversions the most unnatural one is chastity”.
Uterus wants babies; that’s the SOLE purpose of that organ, if you didn’t already know 👍
Just like the “appendix” has one purpose only: to collect material which will result in appendicitis. Just because something happens naturally, it is no reason to accept it uncritically.
As I said, having sex was consent enough for the embryo to show up.
No matter how frequently you repeat it, it will not be true. The point is that if the woman does not wish to be a “breeding sack”, she should not be forced to be one. And the reason is: “we ALL prefer to be the owners of our life and body”. And the variant of the golden rule is accepted by everyone: “Do not do unto others, what you would not want others to do unto you”. This is not a universal LAW, but a universal PRINCIPLE.

The whole problem on the side of SOME Christians (fortunately a small minority) comes from one misconception (and that is not an “immaculate misconception” :D): namely that sex is “sacred”, that it is not something natural, which can be enjoyed for its own sake, that one must be ready for accepting procreation. And that misconception is as unnatural as they come.

But let me present an olive branch: as soon as the church will start a worldwide campaign to advertise and endorse ALL the different prevention methods, we shall shut up. After all no one considers abortion to be a preferred course of action. It is definitely detrimental to the woman’s health… even though it is LESS detrimental than carrying the pregnancy to term. And that is also not a radical feminist propaganda, it is simple fact (especially in the first weeks of pregnancy).
 
I am actually getting embarrassed. You have no idea what you are talking about, but you keep spouting nonsense. 😦

If you undergo surgery, you kind of have to consent that if you die due to the procedure, it was with your full consent. Undertaking any activity with full knowledge of what MIGHT come out of it is giving your consent to take responsibility for those “side effects”.

If “most cases” of pregnancy were terminated on the first trimester, how come when healthy women are trying for a baby they get it on the first try? Or why just one small hole in a condom is enough for a pregnancy to occur? If 90% of those cases terminated on the first semester, I’m pretty sure we wouldn’t be having this talk: only those who wanted a baby would have one.

You compare the appendix (a vestigial structure*) to the uterus (an evolutionary feature of mammals) - full stop. I can’t even comment on this without being mean to you, and I feel sorry for both of us that you even said such a thing :banghead:

Why you don’t think abstinence is prevention??

Why do you add Christianity to the discussion, if the most important request of the OP was to not use religious talk?

Why do I insist? You obviously have no understanding of biology OR medicine (thinking abortion is preferable to bringing pregnancy to term? You probably never saw an abortion and its after-effects).

Good night, good sir/ma’am. I’m done with you.

*(side note) Some researchers have proposed an utility for the appendix. Just so you learn a bit more today.
 
If you undergo surgery, you kind of have to consent that if you die due to the procedure, it was with your full consent.
Nonsense. Do you really think that getting out onto the traffic is “consenting” to be involved in an accident? Especially when you try to defend against it?
If “most cases” of pregnancy were terminated on the first trimester, how come when healthy women are trying for a baby they get it on the first try?
That is NOT what I said. The majority of the zygotes get flushed out from the woman’s body, without being attached to the wall of the uterus. As such there is no “pregnancy” at all.
You compare the appendix (a vestigial structure*) to the uterus (an evolutionary feature of mammals) - full stop. I can’t even comment on this without being mean to you, and I feel sorry for both of us that you even said such a thing :banghead:
Chill off. I merely pointed out that the natural presence of something does not mean that it must be accepted.
Why you don’t think abstinence is prevention??
Of course it is a version of abstinence. And if someone wishes to limit their activity to it, I have no quarrel with that.
Why do you add Christianity to the discussion, if the most important request of the OP was to not use religious talk?
Just to present an olive branch. 🙂 If you choose to neglect it, that is fine by me.
Good night, good sir/ma’am. I’m done with you.
Thank you for your contribution. Best wishes to you.
 
And a little joke about a woman’s body:

Your period is like coming home one day and finding that your spouse has constructed this entire new baby bedroom inside your house and you have to tell them “Sweetie we don’t have a baby”, and then your spouse FLIPS OUT like “The MARBLES do you mean we don’t have a baby? I DID ALL THIS WORK FOR WHAT?”

And then they spend the next week tearing the whole room apart and throwing it out into the street and screaming at you and then, finally, when the room is completely gutted, they calm down and say “It’s okay, honey, we’ll have a baby next month”, and then they start building the room again AND THIS KEEPS GOING FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE UNTIL YOU HIT LIKE 50 AND THEN YOUR SPOUSE LEAVES YOU BUT NOT BEFORE SETTING THE WHOLE HOUSE ON FIRE SO IT’S NEVER THE SAME AGAIN.

Uterus wants babies; that’s the SOLE purpose of that organ, if you didn’t already know 👍
Thank you for responding to the garbage presented in post #32 in a much more thorough and charitable way than I would have.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top