The problem of "soft Catholics" and hell

  • Thread starter Thread starter justamoose89
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My point is- two claims the Bible makes (about hell and the loving of God) are perceived as contradictory by them. So they decide one is a mistake, with no supporting evidence. Why assume one is a mistake over the other?
Why assume any mistake, if someone does not want to go to Heaven do you think a Loving God would force them? if God does force people to Heaven then how could it be Heaven? If God was not Love would He have given us free will to Chose Him or not to chose Him? if the latter is true(and God isent Love) then we would not be on earth right now

as for God sending people to Hell, God is the best Judge ever and if someone had repeatedly chosen not to give up there sins and still rejected His mercy He can’t force it on them, that would be supremely ungodly, at the same time He does have Justice and Mercy upon thouse chose Him by sending them to purgatory until they are pure

So its Strange, hell is a result of free will, free will is a result of Gods unconditional Love
 
If it’s not possible that a loving God would allow us to go to Hell, why on earth did God come down from Heaven, allow Himself to be beaten and spat on, scourged, crowned with thorns, and nailed to a cross? To save us from . . . what? A destiny God would never allow us to have anyway?

Doesn’t make any sense.🤷
 
If it’s not possible that a loving God would allow us to go to Hell, why on earth did God come down from Heaven, allow Himself to be beaten and spat on, scourged, crowned with thorns, and nailed to a cross? To save us from . . . what? A destiny God would never allow us to have anyway?

Doesn’t make any sense.🤷
Thats basically exactly what I’ve been saying. If there was no hell, or if no one went to hell, why did Christ even bother coming to earth? And their response was, “Christ came to show us how to live and how to love.” And i ask why did He die on the cross then? If Christ didn’t need to die, why did He? And they just shrug and say “all I know is that a loving God wouldn’t send people to hell.”
 
In the parable of the sheep and the goats (Matthew 25), when the goats expressed surprise at being tossed into the flames, is it really correct to say they sent themselves to Hell? God is the one telling them to go there.
But they are going there by virtue of their actions. If they had not chosen their actions (or in this case I believe it was lack of actions), then they would not be headed off to hell.
 
But they are going there by virtue of their actions. If they had not chosen their actions (or in this case I believe it was lack of actions), then they would not be headed off to hell.
How can we decide what their actual lack of actions were?

What if they set up a food pantry after deconversion? Helped people no one in their place of worship was helping?
 
But they are going there by virtue of their actions. If they had not chosen their actions (or in this case I believe it was lack of actions), then they would not be headed off to hell.
I think, however, that there is a significant difference between saying we ought to go to Hell because we chose to do evil or failed to do good, and saying that we deliberately, with full consent of our will, choose to go to Hell. I would venture to suggest that the goats in the parable, despite their lack of righteous action, would generally prefer to spend eternity in paradise, rather than in a place of torment.
 
In the parable of the sheep and the goats (Matthew 25), when the goats expressed surprise at being tossed into the flames, is it really correct to say they sent themselves to Hell? God is the one telling them to go there.

I have been wondering about this lately, as I often hear Catholics and non-Catholics alike say that people choose to go to Hell. I understand why people want to say this, because it takes the blame away from God. It is very difficult to love God if He sentences those who do not love Him (or who went to the wrong church) to an eternity of torment. However, the New Testament, at least in my opinion, really seems to weigh in on the idea that God is the judge, sending people to Hell, even if they would really prefer to be elsewhere.

“Soft” Christians of any variety, who are unable to believe God sends people to Hell are certainly not expressing orthodox doctrine. However, many of them are likely experiencing a real dilemma. How can they love God and teach others to love Him, if they believe He sentences even so much as a single person to unceasing, blistering torture for ever and ever?

Some people can reconcile God’s love with the existence of Hell, and some people cannot. I suppose you could try to convince them with Lewis’s “the doors are locked from the inside” argument, but I do not know if that lines up with accepted Catholic orthodoxy.
Your perspective on God is incorrect. If you read the entire New Testament, God is certainly the Righteous Judge, but His longing is to be our “Abba”. Correctly interpreted, Abba means more than Father - it is a term of affection which is more likened to “Daddy”. He is a loving Father who doesn’t wish any person to go to Hell so He created a means by which we could avoid it through the loving and willing work of His only begotten Son, Jesus. Does this sound like a tyrannical judge? I think not.

If God is light, you can not bring darkness into the presence of Light without first dispelling the Light. God is a light that can not be extinguised. God knows this so He wishes to first illuminate and dispel our darkness so that we can be with Him.

I can’t say who will go to Hell or not, but I do believe that we will see people from many different denominations there. I don’t know exactly know how God will do it, but we are all accountable for what we know to be true.

Regardless of whether anyone can reconcile both the simultaneous existence of God and of Hell, it doesn’t change the fact that they exist. Truth is still Truth regardless if anyone believes it. Hell was also not created for us - it was created for the devil and his cohorts - they chose to separate themselves from God and that is exactly what Hell is - total separation from God. God did not intend it for us, but we choose it by our sinful actions.

Sadly, our society is such that we always need to blame someone and mostly anyone but ourselves. Everyone especially loves to blame God because He’s an easy target. We don’t want the onus of choosing Hell (even if it’s by not choosing God) so we blame Him. If I warn my son that touching the hot stove will burn his hand, but he does so anyway, whose fault is it?

CSJ
 
Your perspective on God is incorrect. If you read the entire New Testament, God is certainly the Righteous Judge, but His longing is to be our “Abba”. Correctly interpreted, Abba means more than Father - it is a term of affection which is more likened to “Daddy”. He is a loving Father who doesn’t wish any person to go to Hell so He created a means by which we could avoid it through the loving and willing work of His only begotten Son, Jesus. Does this sound like a tyrannical judge? I think not.

If God is light, you can not bring darkness into the presence of Light without first dispelling the Light. God is a light that can not be extinguised. God knows this so He wishes to first illuminate and dispel our darkness so that we can be with Him.

I can’t say who will go to Hell or not, but I do believe that we will see people from many different denominations there. I don’t know exactly know how God will do it, but we are all accountable for what we know to be true.

Regardless of whether anyone can reconcile both the simultaneous existence of God and of Hell, it doesn’t change the fact that they exist. Truth is still Truth regardless if anyone believes it. Hell was also not created for us - it was created for the devil and his cohorts - they chose to separate themselves from God and that is exactly what Hell is - total separation from God. God did not intend it for us, but we choose it by our sinful actions.

Sadly, our society is such that we always need to blame someone and mostly anyone but ourselves. Everyone especially loves to blame God because He’s an easy target. We don’t want the onus of choosing Hell (even if it’s by not choosing God) so we blame Him. If I warn my son that touching the hot stove will burn his hand, but he does so anyway, whose fault is it?

CSJ
Good post:thumbsup:
 
How can we decide what their actual lack of actions were?

What if they set up a food pantry after deconversion? Helped people no one in their place of worship was helping?
That’s God’s job to judge. Hence why in the parable Jesus is doing the judging (Jesus is God).
I think, however, that there is a significant difference between saying we ought to go to Hell because we chose to do evil or failed to do good, and saying that we deliberately, with full consent of our will, choose to go to Hell. I would venture to suggest that the goats in the parable, despite their lack of righteous action, would generally prefer to spend eternity in paradise, rather than in a place of torment.
I think you’d be right there. I’m sure the goats surely thought they deserved to go to Heaven. We probably get that even less in western society because we’re way too literal. People don’t understand that you choose your fate by all of your choices, not just by the ones that explicitly mention it.
 
I’m having a problem with some Catholics in authority at my university. They refuse to believe that God will send anyone to hell, because God is loving, and a loving God wouldn’t do that. I’ve tried using scripture, but I’ve met with some really lame responses that seem to satisfy them. ex: When I told them that in the Bible, Jesus said He was the Way the Truth and the Light, and no one comes to the Father except by Him, they said “Well imperfect men wrote the Bible, and translated the Bible, they made a mistake there.”

How can I respond? The answers I’ve been getting from them are irrational and nonsensical. This is just getting ridiculous.
You may not want to follow some of my advice, but as I understand your predicament the university is full of ignorant professors; true or not, notice I didn’t say your professors were stupid, or idiots, or otherwise unintelligent. However, if they were properly informed teachers they might know that it is the grace of hope that brings us to redemption. God’s redemption requires judgment – judgment consumes such wooden-headed logic which cannot withstand the fires of examination. Furthermore, without justice and the judgment it brings, our state as humans is truly hopeless as the Pope explains:

The judgment of God is hope, both because it is justice and because it is grace. If it were merely grace, making all earthly things cease to matter, God would still owe us an answer to the question about justice—the crucial question that we ask of history and of God. If it were merely justice, in the end it could bring only fear to us all. The incarnation of God in Christ has so closely linked the two together—judgment and grace—that justice is firmly established: we all work out our salvation “with fear and trembling” (Phil 2:12). Nevertheless grace allows us all to hope, and to go trustfully to meet the Judge whom we know as our “advocate”, or parakletos (cf. 1 Jn 2:1). (Encyclical Spe Salvi, His holiness Pope Benedict XVI)

Now you can respond that hope saves us and hope is rooted in God’s justice. You might point out their logic would rightly lead your godlike professors giving an ‘A’ to all – and everybody knows professors hate giving-out ‘A’s. But, such professors love their students so much we can conclude they wouldn’t allow any of them to fail – now would they? Such an act might be said to condemn students - a student’s hell. Consequently all should rise to student’s heaven by receiving ‘A’s. On the other hand, you might ask them to read 1 Cor 3:12-15 and Phil 2:12 and turn in 1,500 word report – in the morning.

Of course you do know that the better part of valor would suggest not mentioning their ignorance?

JoeT
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top