The prodigal son's brother

  • Thread starter Thread starter jritenour
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jritenour

Guest
“I have always been a great Catholic, attended mass, went to confession and defended the faith for many years now. Now, we are bringing in these people who were relapsed Catholics, blatant sinners and blasphemers and heretics. Sure they’ve converted and repented but now the attention, praise and good will appears to be all for them. I’ve even been asked to move to a row of pews in the back to accommodate these people. How is this fair!!!”

Does anyone feel like this sometimes? I know I have in certain ways. And I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone.
 
“I have always been a great Catholic, attended mass, went to confession and defended the faith for many years now. Now, we are bringing in these people who were relapsed Catholics, blatant sinners and blasphemers and heretics. Sure they’ve converted and repented but now the attention, praise and good will appears to be all for them. I’ve even been asked to move to a row of pews in the back to accommodate these people. How is this fair!!!”

Does anyone feel like this sometimes? I know I have in certain ways. And I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone.
No offense here. I think your response is a natural reaction from your conscience. We have a rule in our minds that says “everything must be fair”. Jesus calls us to look beyond the workings of our conscience in the parable of the workers in the vineyard, to join Him in loving and forgiving those who have violated the rules of our conscience.

Now, as far as being asked to move pews, that is a little bizarre. Why should you not be included in the front? We are all sinners. Maybe you should talk to your priest, I am not understanding the picture here.
 
“I have always been a great Catholic, attended mass, went to confession and defended the faith for many years now. Now, we are bringing in these people who were relapsed Catholics, blatant sinners and blasphemers and heretics. Sure they’ve converted and repented but now the attention, praise and good will appears to be all for them. I’ve even been asked to move to a row of pews in the back to accommodate these people. How is this fair!!!”

Does anyone feel like this sometimes? I know I have in certain ways. And I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone.
Truthfully, I do sometimes feel the same way as the prodigal son’s brother.

If I do feel this way I try to focus on the positive.
I’m not suggesting that this is easy. It isn’t.
But we can but try.
 
Yes I relate to the prodigal son’s brother. Except I have that idea concerning marriage: I was good, have remained a virgin, try to please God, treat others with respect, etc and the girls who slept around are married with kids while I remain alone. I know It’s an ugly attitude and I ask God to remove my pride. It’s pride and presumptious to think we deserve anything. Like Jesus said in the Gospel, take the lowest seat and allow the host to move you to a place of honor.
 
I do, especially under Pope Francis. 🙂
For a great treatment of this parable I just have to recommend “The Return of the Prodigal Son” by Fr. Henri Nouwen. Wonderful,thought provoking book!
 
When I think about the prodigal son’s brother, I wonder: Did he have a great burning desire to squander his inheritance and live an immoral life? Was it only a great heroic effort which kept him from doing these things? Maybe, but it seems to me that living a life of virtue just came easier for him. It was a blessing, a blessing his brother did not come by so easily. And if it was a blessing, why should he begrudge his brother who had to struggle and made mistakes? Anyway, that’s how I see it.
 
“I have always been a great Catholic, attended mass, went to confession and defended the faith for many years now. Now, we are bringing in these people who were relapsed Catholics, blatant sinners and blasphemers and heretics. Sure they’ve converted and repented but now the attention, praise and good will appears to be all for them. I’ve even been asked to move to a row of pews in the back to accommodate these people. How is this fair!!!”

Does anyone feel like this sometimes? I know I have in certain ways. And I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone.
It’s then ego which is offended and a example of belonging to the Church as if it’s a club of like minded egos alone. When outsides come in, the egos are threatened and take issue on how they’re treated.

This is not Christianity, which demands detachment from such things.

Prayer and medication are the answers for humility must replace ego.

Jim
 
It is important to remember that this parable was directed at the Pharisees. The prodigal son’s brother is lost too. Unfortunately, he doesn’t realize it. Although he has been obedient, he isn’t really grateful for what the Father has given him. He thinks he has earned the Father’s gifts through his obedience. And, he doesn’t really love the Father or realize all that HE has done for him. Rather, his heart is like that of the Pharisees, and he is full of pride. Both brothers have sinned against the Father, but in different ways. Still, the Father loves them both despite their failings and inability to love him as they should. And, he wants them to love each other.
 
Here is an example from my own life, involving my mom and Frank Sinatra (at least, what we know of Frank’s public persona). When Mr. Sinatra died and had a Catholic funeral and burial, my mom was upset, sort of like the prodigal son’s brother. “Its not fair!” she said (and she loved Frank’s music). “He had numerous wives, and carousing and all, and then its all right when he dies.” So I ask my mom, “Has it been such a struggle for you stay with one man? Was it your great desire to have 5 husbands?” “Of course not!” “Then how can you judge Frank? You never walked in his shoes. Just be glad for the Faith you have, and at least give Frank the benefit of the doubt.”
 
I do, especially under Pope Francis. 🙂
For a great treatment of this parable I just have to recommend “The Return of the Prodigal Son” by Fr. Henri Nouwen. Wonderful,thought provoking book!
Excellent Book!👍
 
It is important to remember that this parable was directed at the Pharisees. The prodigal son’s brother is lost too. Unfortunately, he doesn’t realize it. Although he has been obedient, he isn’t really grateful for what the Father has given him. He thinks he has earned the Father’s gifts through his obedience. And, he doesn’t really love the Father or realize all that HE has done for him. Rather, his heart is like that of the Pharisees, and he is full of pride. Both brothers have sinned against the Father, but in different ways. Still, the Father loves them both despite their failings and inability to love him as they should. And, he wants them to love each other.
Absolutely. And recall where the parable ends: before we see the older brother’s response. It is left open-ended. The choice is left for all of us who identify with the older brother to either remain outside feeling indignant or join the celebration. I recommend the latter. 🙂
 
“I have always been a great Catholic, attended mass, went to confession and defended the faith for many years now. Now, we are bringing in these people who were relapsed Catholics, blatant sinners and blasphemers and heretics. Sure they’ve converted and repented but now the attention, praise and good will appears to be all for them. I’ve even been asked to move to a row of pews in the back to accommodate these people. How is this fair!!!”

Does anyone feel like this sometimes? I know I have in certain ways. And I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone.
Well - being a revert myself - I guess I’m on the opposite side of this…
Do you resent me??? I’ll gladly give you your pew back…🙂

Yet still - I guess I do tend to feel this way sometimes. I find I have trouble in mass when I see someone not acting (IMO) reverential enough…but then how reverential am I being if I’m worrying about them???
It might seem funny but this is one of the things I like about the EF…I’m so busy reading along in my missal that I don’t look around and become distracted by others.
But then - because I sometimes attend the EF I start feeling “special” and that can aggravate the problems I have with others at the OF…🤷

The evil one has so many snares for us…and we sometimes step right into them without realizing it…

Lord help us all…

Peace
James
 
“…I’ve even been asked to move to a row of pews in the back to accommodate these people. How is this fair!!!”

Does anyone feel like this sometimes? I know I have in certain ways. And I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone.
This bit about being asked to move reminds me of something that happened to me this Sunday. Bear with me as I tell this story. I was sitting in the third row on the far left side of the pew, which is right behind the lectors. I am also a lector, and at our annual meeting a few days earlier, one of the lectors complained about the ushers seating people in the front of the church after mass has begun. Our pastor said it was fine, but that they really should only come up the side aisles after mass has begun rather than the center.

Apparently, the ushers were duly corrected. After mass began, the usher brought some people up to where I was sitting with a friend of mine and asked us to move over. We moved down to the right side of the pew…although I did not go quite all the way because the end spot there, which is along the center aisle, is behind a shorter pew and thus doesn’t have a kneeler. The person who sits there must remain seated or kneel on the stone floor during consecration and communion. Initially, I did not realize that the usher wanted to seat a large family with us, but he caught my attention again and asked me to move over all the way. I was thinking “I really don’t want to sit in that spot”! He must have known what I was thinking, because he gave me a pleading look and mouthed “please”. I begrudgingly moved all the way over.

Needless to say I was not happy. I was annoyed with T, the lector who had complained. I was annoyed with these people who came to mass late. And, I was annoyed with the usher, who had crammed us into the pew like rats! Also, I don’t really consider myself old enough to just stay seated during communion. Yet, I do have bad knees, and the surface of my kneecaps is quite uneven. So, kneeling on a hard surface, even on carpet, is painful. I was thinking, “this just isn’t fair! These people came late, and now I am stuck in this crummy seat”. I was sitting with a young friend, D. I am sure he would have gladly switched places. But, he is schizophrenic, and isn’t always cognizant of what is going on around him to do what is needed without prompting. I wasn’t sure what to do. I asked God to please have D. notice and offer to help me. Well, he didn’t…

At first, I just bowed my head during the consecration, but then I really started feeling like I needed to kneel. So, I did and yes it hurt, but not as much as I expected. During the sign of peace, the Mother of the family sitting next to us thanked me for moving over so they could do this. After that I asked the Lord to please help me kneel all the way through communion. As I came back to my seat after communion, I noticed that only the children had gone forward while the parents remained behind. I used to be in that boat…and it is hard. I knew it was good they were there. Needless to say, the prayer after communion was not exactly peaceful as that was a long period on the knees, but I kept asking the Lord to help and he did make it bearable. I was able to kneel like that for at least 10 minutes. I was quite surprised.

I recently started asking for more of my sins of pride to be revealed to me. Surely HE did! But HE also gave me what I needed to endure the resulting minor sufferings. And, maybe I am too vain because I could have asked D to help, but didn’t…more pride. Well after thinking about all of that I am reminded of Luke 14:10-11.

Anyway, thanks for sharing your frustration. You aren’t alone…
 
Frankly I have to agree with the OP. I’m going to mass Friday for the first time in a long while and I would be wholly embarrassed if a standing member of the church was displaced or inconvenienced in some way because of me especially if it wasn’t by choice.

I’m walking into that church fully realizing that it was my own mistakes and issues that put me where I am. Walking into that church will be the first step in reviving my beaten spirit and I wouldn’t expect nor want a parade (however encouragement will be welcome). Honestly, I’d much rather ease into this 🙂
 
It rather shocks me that there would be assigned seating in church. I can see a protocol for weddings and funerals, but not for Mass. The people up front should be whoever desires to get to church early enough to find vacant seating in front.
 
I thought the OP meant the part about moving to the back pews figuratively, not literally.
 
I thought the OP meant the part about moving to the back pews figuratively, not literally.
That’s how I read it, too. I took the entire OP as being a figurative representation of how he feels sometimes rather than as being literally descriptive of something that actually happened.
 
That’s how I read it, too. I took the entire OP as being a figurative representation of how he feels sometimes rather than as being literally descriptive of something that actually happened.
Me too…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top